CS Paper Radar

Solving Distributed Flexible Job Shop Scheduling Problem Using SAT

Phuong Dang Anh, Duc Nguyen Kim Trung, To Van Khanh

cs.LO ·submitted 2026-10-10 09:13 UTC · v2
benchmark

Abstract

The Distributed Flexible Job Shop Scheduling Problem (DFJSP) requires the joint determination of factory assignment, machine selection, and operation sequencing to minimize the makespan. This paper presents an exact SAT-based approach built on an efficient SAT formulation that exploits problem structure through propagation, symmetry breaking, and incremental SAT solving to effectively address these coupled decisions. The proposed method is evaluated on 76 standard benchmark instances from the Fattahi, Brandimarte, and rdata datasets under two- and three-factory configurations. Together with previously established results, the new SAT optimality certificates bring the total number of proven-optimal instances to 72 out of 76, including three newly certified instances; for two of these instances, SAT also improves the previous best-known makespans. Across the benchmark configurations, SAT achieves the best results on four of the five configurations and remains competitive with strong exact approaches such as CP and LBBD1_CPIL, as well as existing metaheuristic methods. These results demonstrate that the proposed SAT framework is an effective exact approach for the DFJSP, combining strong solution quality with rigorous optimality certification and offering a complementary exact method for future DFJSP studies and evaluations on additional benchmark instances.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Exact SAT and Constraint Programming for Job Shop Scheduling with Time-Varying Peak Power Constraints

cs.LO ·2026-08-26 ·Huy Tuan Nguyen, Duc Trung Kim Nguyen, Khanh To Van
benchmark similarity 0.72
Abstract

The Job Shop Scheduling Problem with Power Requirements (JSPPR) extends the classical job shop scheduling problem by imposing time-varying limits on instantaneous power consumption. Previous studies have used a mixed-integer linear programming formulation and the GRASP x ELS metaheuristic, but no SAT-based exact approach or constraint programming model has been reported. This paper develops the first exact SAT and constraint programming (CP) formulations for the JSPPR. On the 35 published benchmark instances, both SAT and CP prove global optimality for all instances and obtain identical optimal makespans, substantially improving upon the best previously reported results. They also establish four improved makespan values over the GRASP x ELS results reported in the original study. CP proves optimality faster than SAT, while both exact approaches substantially improve the optimality coverage of the MILP formulations, which prove optimality on only 6 and 10 instances using CPLEX and Gurobi, respectively. The certified optimal solutions also reveal inconsistencies in several previously reported benchmark results, including makespans below the proven optimum. We provide corrected optimal makespans and a complete set of certified optimal results for the JSPPR benchmark, establishing a reliable reference for future studies.

0.26

Minimizing the makespan in job shop scheduling under conflict graph constraints

cs.DM math.OC ·2026-09-03 ·Nour Elhouda Tellache, Abdenour Azerine
similarity 0.58
Abstract

We study the job shop scheduling problem with a conflict graph, in which adjacent jobs cannot be processed simultaneously on different machines, with the objective of minimizing the makespan. We establish a polynomial equivalence with a resource-constrained job shop problem having unit-capacity resources and binary resource requirements The problem is strongly NP-hard even on two machines with unit-time operations. For this setting, we derive an optimal-makespan formula and a linear-time algorithm when the conflict graph is a cluster graph, given the clique partition. We also develop a polynomial-time $4/3$-approximation algorithm for arbitrary conflict graphs on two machines when each job has exactly two unit-time operations. For the general problem, we propose four mixed-integer linear formulations, lower bounds, and a genetic algorithm with active, non-delay, and hybrid decoding procedures. Computational experiments on instances derived from the Lawrence and Taillard benchmarks and on randomly generated generalized job shop instances evaluate the proposed methods and show that the genetic algorithm generally improves on constructive heuristics.

0.33

Matching with Multiple Bottlenecks: Parameterized Complexity and Approximation

cs.DS cs.CCcs.DM ·2026-10-05 ·Jonas Friemel, Tilo Hoitz, Phillip Keldenich, Arne Schmidt
similarity 0.56
Abstract

We consider a matching problem in which the cost of each edge is a vector with $k$ components. The cost of a matching is the sum of the bottlenecks over all components, and we ask whether there is a perfect matching of cost at most some value $Z$. This type of matching has applications in heavily synchronized job-shop scheduling problems and in reconfiguration problems, where movement is restricted to a single direction per step. In this paper, we analyze the problem from a parameterized complexity perspective and provide various results including FPT-membership for parameters $k$ and $Z$ combined, as well as W[P]-membership and W[SAT]-hardness for each of the two parameters individually. The reduction also implies para-NP-hardness parameterized by either maximum degree or treewidth. We further show hardness of approximation within a super-logarithmic factor for the optimization variant and provide a $k/d$-approximation algorithm for any constant $d \leq k$ as well as an efficient approximation scheme parameterized by $k$. With parameter $Z$, we show that no FPT-time $F(Z)$-approximation algorithm is possible for any computable function $F$, unless W[1] = FPT.

0.20

Cycle time minimization for the simple assembly line balancing problem under peak power constraints

cs.LO ·2026-08-25 ·Bao Gia Hoang, Tuyen Van Kieu, Khanh Van To
similarity 0.55
Abstract · Submitted to Engineering Optimization. This preprint has not yet undergone peer review

Peak power limits restrict concurrent tasks and may increase assembly-line cycle time. To the best of our knowledge, this study is the first to minimize cycle time for the simple assembly line balancing problem type 2 (SALBP-2) with a fixed number of workstations and a fixed limit on total instantaneous power. An exact satisfiability (SAT) method finds feasible schedules, searches systematically for shorter cycles, and proves optimality when possible. Two reproducible formulas define looser and tighter power limits for 72 cases based on the standard SALBP library, with Gurobi and CPLEX providing commercial MIP and CP comparisons. Relative to standard SALBP-2 optima, the two limits increase the best-known cycle time by 16.49% and 61.02% on average. The best-performing SAT configurations find a feasible solution for every case, solve more cases to optimality than each commercial solver, and when both prove optimality, are almost always faster under the reported settings.

0.33

Minimizing the Makespan Approximately on Two Identical Parallel Machines with a Loading--Unloading Server

cs.DS math.OC ·2026-08-19 ·Keramat Hasani, Frank Werner
theory similarity 0.53
Abstract · 29 pages, 1 appendix

We study makespan minimisation on two identical parallel machines that share a single server for both loading and unloading. Each job must be loaded, processed without interruption on its assigned machine, and unloaded immediately after processing, with a common positive integer duration for all loading and unloading operations. We prove that the decision problem is NP-complete for every fixed server-operation duration and strongly NP-complete when this duration is part of the input. We then analyse ordinary list scheduling and the longest-processing-time rule in the non-unit setting. List scheduling has a tight supremum ratio of two. For the longest-processing-time rule, we obtain the exact worst-case ratio when all processing times are at least the server-operation duration, and derive new parameter-dependent lower and upper bounds for unrestricted instances. The results show that both processing-time granularity and blocking generated by short jobs shape the approximation behaviour of the common-server problem.

0.08

Parallel Machine Scheduling with a Singler Server and Loading-Unloading Operations

cs.DS math.OC ·2026-08-12 ·Keramat Hasani, Frank Werner
theory similarity 0.52
Abstract · 20 pages, 3 figures

This paper investigates a parallel machine scheduling problem featuring a single common server responsible for both loading and unloading operations. Each job consists of a unit-time loading operation, non-preemptive processing on one of \(m\) identical machines, and a unit-time unloading operation executed by the same server. The objective is to minimize the makespan. Unlike classical loading-only common-server models, our setting requires the server to handle an unloading operation immediately after a job's processing phase concludes. We prove that the corresponding decision problem is strongly NP-complete when the number of machines is given as part of the input. Furthermore, we analyse the worst-case performance of the List Scheduling (LS) and Longest Processing Time (LPT) heuristics. For three machines, we establish that Algorithm LS achieves an approximation ratio of at most \(5/2\). For an arbitrary fixed \(m \ge 3\), we show that the general LS bound approaches \(4-3/m\) as the number of jobs grows, whereas for Algorithm LPT, we prove the finite-instance ratio $3-\frac{2}{m}+\frac{(m-1)(m-2)}{mn}.$ Thus, for each fixed \(m\), the LPT bound approaches \(3-2/m\) as the number of jobs grows.

0.38

Agent-written heuristics versus commercial solvers on unsolved job-shop benchmark instances

cs.AI math.OC ·2026-11-13 ·Andre Albrecht, Enzo Morosini Frazzon, Leandro C. Coelho, Bruno Vieira
benchmarktheorycode/data similarity 0.52
Abstract · 27 pages, 4 figures, 14 tables. Submitted to International Transactions in Operational Research. Data, schedules, checkers and code: https:/…

Commercial solvers are the standard tool for difficult scheduling problems. We study whether a frontier large language model, used as a coding agent with open-source tools only, can match them in quality and speed. We report every run, and independent checkers verify every schedule. On the 100,000-operation job shop tai_100_1000_1, an agent-written solver reached 525,515, below OptalCP, Hexaly, and CP Optimizer. Unchanged, it improved all ten instances of the family and closed two. With equal budgets on the same workstation, it ended 0.0-1.8% above the lower bound, against 2.6-5.8% for CP Optimizer and 2.4-4.4% for Hexaly. On the Behnke-Geiger flexible job shops, an agent-written tabu search improved 11 of 32 open instances. With two transport robots, an agent-written solver improved seven of ten MKT instances. New lower bounds show that four published MKT values cannot be attained on the distributed instance files. Agent-run improvement campaigns closed eight further instances.

0.37

Hard Instances on Demand

cs.DS cs.AImath.OC ·2026-10-15 ·Jamie Fravel, Martin Koutecký, Pavlo Tsitsei
publishedbenchmark similarity 0.51
Abstract · Full version of a paper accepted to ALENEX 2027

The conclusions of an experimental study of algorithms are only as good as the instances they are run on. Benchmark libraries for well-studied problems took decades to curate, while evaluations of new problems often fall back on random instances, which are known to be misleading: they may say more about the random generator than about the algorithmic question at hand. We treat instance generation as an optimization problem: parameterize the instance space, take the solver's running time as the objective, and let a black-box optimizer search for hard instances. We develop a widely applicable workflow built on the Nevergrad optimization platform and demonstrate it on four NP-hard problems: satisfiability, traveling salesperson, Hamiltonian cycle, and non-permutation flow-shop scheduling. The search needs only the solver, an instance encoder, and a compute budget. Our evolved instances beat the hardest instance of a budget-matched random draw in all four case studies, by an order of magnitude or more in three. They are often competitive with long-curated benchmark sets: our SAT champion is harder (for a three-solver portfolio) than 78% of the 498 SAT Competition formulas in its size class; our 20-city TSP champions take several times longer than the hardest measured classical TSPLIB instance (229 cities); and our flow-shop champion takes 238.6 seconds of CP Optimizer time to solve to proven optimality (versus 4.5 seconds for the hardest of 100,000 random draws) while denying CP-SAT an optimality proof. The optimizer even recovers known structure from running time alone: it locates a SAT clause/variable ratio near the phase transition and finds structurally different champions for the two scheduling engines.

0.36