CS Paper Radar

How large an effect would we have seen? Positive controls, detection floors and dataset pitfalls in scalp-EEG speech decoding

Blessing Isoyiza Adeika, Onyema Osuagwu

eess.SP q-bio.NCq-bio.QM ·submitted 2026-10-14 21:08 UTC · v1

Abstract

Objective. Studies that decode imagined speech from scalp electroencephalography (EEG) commonly validate their pipelines with a positive control, usually overt speech, and report null results without stating what effect size the pipeline could have detected. Approach. Using ds003626 ("Thinking out loud"), KaraOne and Track 3 of the 2020 International Brain-Computer Interface Competition, we audited decoding of overt speech, articulator preparation and imagined speech with artifact-channel subsets, band-limited decoding and trial selection, under a protocol that enforces split integrity by assertion. We injected class-dependent effects of known amplitude into the real recordings to measure the detection floor of five decoder families, and we checked the ds003626 labels against the dataset's acquisition protocol. Main results. On ds003626, two lip electrodes decoded overt speech at 0.7430 and the eight external channels at 0.7068, against 0.4231 for the 128-channel scalp montage, and no decodable signal survived in the 8-30 Hz band. On the other two corpora, within-subject accuracy rose monotonically with frequency into the range dominated by muscle activity. Band-power logistic regression detected an injected 8-30 Hz desynchronization of 0.54 uV under a criterion fixed in advance, whereas a compact convolutional network (EEGNet) detected nothing within subject up to 4.31 uV. In ds003626, the condition codes are the reverse of the intuitive reading, the class encoding changed between public releases, and condition is a deterministic function of time within each session. Significance. In these corpora the overt-speech positive control is dominated by myogenic signal and cannot validate a decoding pipeline. We recommend that speech-decoding studies report band-limited and artifact-channel accuracy, the direction of accuracy across frequency, and a measured detection floor.

Comment
22 pages, 4 figures, 8 tables plus supplementary tables. To be submitted to Journal of Neural Engineering

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Cross-subject decoding of imagined speech from scalp EEG: a leakage-controlled evaluation on three public corpora

eess.SP cs.LGq-bio.NC ·2026-10-14 ·Blessing Isoyiza Adeika, Onyema Osuagwu
similarity 0.74
Abstract · 23 pages, 5 figures, 10 tables plus supplementary tables. To be submitted to Journal of Neural Engineering

Objective. A decoder of imagined speech that works for a new user without calibration would make a non-invasive speech interface practical. We tested whether imagined-speech content recorded with scalp electroencephalography (EEG) transfers across people, and examined why accuracy within a single person remains low. Approach. We analyzed three public corpora, ds003626, KaraOne and Track 3 of the 2020 International Brain-Computer Interface Competition, under a protocol that enforces split integrity by assertion and reports exact binomial thresholds, group tests and bootstrap confidence intervals. We trained decoders on each participant and tested them on every other, compared representational geometry across participants without a classifier, applied subject-level alignment, and tested five explanations for the within-subject ceiling. Main results. Across 482 ordered pairs of participants, no pair survived correction for multiple comparisons; mean pair-transfer accuracy lay within 0.006 of chance on every corpus, while every within-subject reference lay above it. Imagery against pre-stimulus rest generalized at about 0.61 after artifact and elapsed-time controls, but its decoder labelled the interval preceding imagery as imagery as often as imagery itself, so the contrast reflects a post-stimulus state, not imagery. Within subject, only the competition corpus decoded above threshold for every participant (0.3147; chance 0.200); syllable count explained little of this, but its frequency profile failed an artifact audit. Significance. In these corpora, imagined-speech content did not transfer between people through any representation we examined. Trial count per class was the only variable that ordered the corpora, which favors larger single-condition datasets over further model development.

0.34

Streaming P300 Acquisition and Statistical Signal Validation Across Five EEG Platforms: A Hardware-Agnostic BrainFlow/LSL Pipeline

cs.HC ·2026-09-09 ·Isabella Guan, Rui Liu, Fusheng Wang
similarity 0.64
Abstract

P300 spellers offer people with severe motor impairment, such as ALS, an effective communication channel and remain one of the most established surgery-free alternatives to intracortical interfaces. Advanced language models have made spellers faster and more robust, yet the hardware beneath them is under-studied. We present a hardware-agnostic, real-time P300 acquisition pipeline built on BrainFlow and Lab Streaming Layer (LSL) that runs unchanged across consumer- and research-grade EEG headsets, with permutation tests of signal separability. Using a standard 6 x 6 row/column paradigm, we piloted five configurations: a custom dry system, a custom wet/gel system, Emotiv Flex, Emotiv EPOC X, and Muse 2. The custom systems and EPOC X showed weak or inconsistent signal separability, Muse 2 had the highest acquisition reliability despite limited centro-parietal coverage, and Flex showed the most promising signal. In 20 further Flex sessions varying subject, timing, and phrase length (131 target characters), a peak-amplitude permutation test and a cross-validated xDAWN decoder both detected a significant target response under two channel-exclusion policies, with decoder AUC reaching about 0.72 after 15 repetitions. Character accuracy depended heavily on evaluation methodology: in-sample majority voting reached 94.7%, whereas character-held-out accuracy was 31.3% with evidence accumulated across repetitions, about three times that of held-out majority voting. These analyses indicate that Flex captured a detectable, if still weak, P300 under the studied conditions, while broader participant-level validation and improved decoding remain necessary.

0.32

Decoding Imagined Speech: A Strictly Subject-Independent Approach Using EEG

cs.AI ·2026-09-24 ·Frederik Møllskov Trier, Xiaopeng Mao, Sadasivan Puthusserypady
similarity 0.63
Abstract

Imagined speech decoding from electroencephalography (EEG) has gained increasing attention as a potential communication pathway for individuals with severe motor impairments, yet reported performance often relies on evaluation protocols that do not clearly reflect cross-subject generalization. This study presents a transparent baseline investigation of a multi-class imagined speech EEG dataset under a strictly subject-independent evaluation framework. Two preprocessing and feature extraction pipelines were compared: a time-domain statistical feature approach and a frequency-domain spectral bandpower approach, evaluated using subject-wise cross-validation and trial-level majority voting with a random forest classifier. The spectral pipeline achieved a significantly higher mean trial-wise accuracy than the statistical pipeline (49.03 $\pm$ 4.18% vs. 37.97 $\pm$ 3.79%) for coarse-level classification across subjects. Forward feature selection further indicated that a limited subset of frequency bands captured most of the discriminative information. Overall, this work provides a strong basis for future brain-computer interface studies targeting improved cross-subject generalization in EEG-based imagined speech decoding.

0.23

Inner-Speech Decoding from EEG Across Three Corpora Under a Fixed Architecture and Protocol

cs.AI cs.LGeess.SP ·2026-11-01 ·Md Wahiduzzaman Suva, Md Imtiaj Alam Sajin, Esm E Moula Chowdhury Abha, Susham Moula Choudhury Akash, Md Tauhidul Islam +3 more
benchmarkdataset similarity 0.62
Abstract

Inner-speech decoding from electroencephalography could support non-invasive communication for people with severe motor impairment, but comparison across studies is hindered by dataset- and protocol-specific evaluation. We present a controlled cross-dataset study using one preprocessing pipeline, one within-subject five-fold cross-validation protocol, and a compact dual-attention Transformer (VC-DATNet; approximately 131,000 parameters) across three public corpora: Thinking Out Loud (10 participants), BISpeech (4), and SyncSpeech (3). VC-DATNet achieved per-participant sensor/source hybrid accuracies of 39.48% on the four-class Thinking Out Loud task, 20.60% on the eight-word BISpeech task, and 25.53% on the eight-word SyncSpeech task, for which we report the first decoding result. Sensor-space and cortical source-space representations were complementary, with each performing better for different participants; this pattern replicated across all three corpora and nine architectures. Moreover, ten decoders spanning convolutional, recurrent, temporal-convolutional, hybrid Transformer, and pretrained foundation-model families converged within a narrow accuracy range on every dataset. These findings indicate that representation choice should be individualized and suggest that performance on these public corpora is constrained more by signal quality and dataset scale than by model capacity. The released pipeline provides a reproducible benchmark for future inner-speech decoding studies

0.07

SURE-Voice: A Front-End Baseline for Speech-Evidence Filtering in Speech LLMs

eess.AS cs.CLcs.SD ·2026-08-27 ·Mengzhe Geng
benchmark similarity 0.62
Abstract

Speech language models (speech LLMs) can generate plausible outputs from audio that contains no usable speech evidence. We study this failure as a pre-generation support-estimation problem and present SURE-Voice, a training-free front end that decides whether an audio prompt contains intelligible speech evidence before calling a speech LLM. We build SURE-Challenge with a 640-example SURE-Core split and a 1,920-example SURE-Extended split derived from 120 LibriSpeech source utterances. Using one fixed operating point, an energy screen plus Whisper token confidence raises unsupported accuracy on the held-out Extended test from 0.000--0.133 to 0.919 for six non-degenerate speech LLM backbones, while supported accuracy remains 0.919--0.970 and downstream calls fall from 480 to 287. A 500-clip ESC-50 sanity set shows the same pattern on real environmental audio, with vocal non-speech as a residual failure mode. An overlap diagnostic shows that source attribution remains separate from speech-evidence filtering. The evidence supports a controlled benchmark baseline and a deployment-oriented analysis; it does not establish universal robustness to semantic answerability, gain variation or natural conversations.

0.17

Logit Averaging During Training Sets a New State of the Art for Non-Invasive Speech BCI

cs.LG ·2026-10-19 ·Miran Özdogan, Gereon Elvers, Michael Bronstein, Oiwi Parker Jones
similarity 0.61
Abstract

Non-invasive brain-computer interfaces are in practice limited by signal-to-noise ratio, and recent state-of-the-art methods address this limitation by aggregating over repeated trials of the same stimulus. Yet multi-trial aggregation has been treated inconsistently across the literature: some work averages brain signals at the model's input, other work averages predictions at the model's output, and neither treats aggregation as an architectural choice in its own right. We provide the first systematic comparison of aggregation strategies for non-invasive neural decoding, evaluating six paradigms (including logit averaging during training and three attention-based variants we introduce) across three datasets, four tasks, and two group sizes. We find that aggregation choice matters substantially: training-time logit averaging, the simplest method we propose, outperforms all others in 6 of 7 settings. On the phoneme classification setting of the 2025 PNPL competition, it sets a new state of the art, significantly outperforming the competition winner by 17.4 absolute percentage points in balanced accuracy. We further draw a theoretical connection between logit averaging and joint ensemble training, which has been shown to underperform independent ensembling in the deep learning literature; our results call into question recent explanations of why joint ensemble training fails. Together, these findings establish multi-trial aggregation as a key design choice for non-invasive neural decoding and identify training-time logit averaging as a simple, effective default.

0.13

Concentrated Causal Influence, Distributed Diagnostic Information: Cognitive Impairment Decisions in Large Audio-Language Models

eess.AS cs.CL ·2026-10-23 ·Xiutian Zhao, Luqi Sun, Björn Schuller, Berrak Sisman
hot direction similarity 0.61
Abstract

Large audio-language models (LALMs) can assess cognitive impairment (CI) from speech, yet their answers reveal neither which internal components control the decision nor how much CI information is accessible in their representations. We investigate both questions through CI-contrast neurons (CICNs), selected by class-contrastive activation frequency in decoder MLPs. Across eight open LALMs and two corpora (Pitt and PROCESS-2), we causally test CICNs against size- and layer-matched random masks and activity-matched controls. In three of the five models that meet our eligibility criteria, ablation of small CICN sets causes large, class-directed prediction shifts; speech-identified masks also control transcript-only decisions, and three of four primary Pitt masks retain specificity on PROCESS-2. Position-restricted interventions locate the influence before the final answer position, most strongly after the speech or transcript evidence under letter-labeled options, largely as a decision-direction shift. Beyond causal localization, supervised linear readouts of frozen CICN activations achieve 0.92--0.97 AUC within Pitt, versus 0.67--0.84 for the models' direct answers. Matched random and all-neuron readouts reach comparable performance; top-ranked CICNs show only an exploratory advantage at very small unit budgets. These results distinguish concentrated causal control over output decisions from broadly distributed diagnostic information for CI detection in LALMs.

0.35

AESSI: An Around-Ear Silent Speech Interface for Cross-Day Online Reuse without Test-Day Calibration

cs.HC ·2026-09-18 ·Xiran Xu, Mochu Dong, Yujie Yan, Chenxi Wang, Yu Jiao +1 more
similarity 0.60
Abstract

Silent speech interfaces (SSIs) enable private communication without audible speech and may support people with post-stroke dysarthria. Everyday reuse requires articulation-related representations that generalize across days despite sensor repositioning and physiological changes. We present AESSI, an around-ear SSI using masked-context representation pretraining (MCRP): a student predicts teacher representations from masked time-frequency inputs to encourage robustness to recording variability. We collected 44 electrophysiological recordings from 24 participants for 25 everyday Mandarin sentences. With six participants' complete final recordings held out, AESSI achieved 92.24 percent mean accuracy without test-day calibration. AESSI exceeded the best adapted baseline by 50.57 percentage points. At least 21 days after each participant's last recording, five participants each completed 50 independently randomized online tests without calibration, achieving 98.0 percent overall accuracy. Median preprocessing and inference time in CPU replay was 31.70 ms. These results demonstrate end-to-end system operation and support online reuse without test-day calibration. Demo is included with the paper.

0.30