CS Paper Radar

Evaluating Predictor-Corrector Dependence in Hard-Constrained Climate Emulators

Tianyu Zhang, Xinyu Wang, Zhenghan Tai, Xiao-Wen Chang, Yoshua Bengio

cs.CY cs.CE ·submitted 2026-10-16 14:49 UTC · v1

Abstract

Climate emulators often enforce physical constraints by correcting each state predicted by a neural network, but evaluating only the corrected forecast conflates predictor skill with the effect of the correction. We introduce an evaluation framework that separates these contributions by comparing corrected forecasts, pre-correction predictions along corrected trajectories, and autonomous rollouts with correction disabled. We further cross correction during training and inference to distinguish its immediate effect from how it shapes the learned predictor, and use matched nonphysical controls to test whether improvements are specific to the physical correction. In ACE2, correction substantially improves physical consistency. In a three-seed ACE2 pilot, models trained with correction produce less accurate uncorrected precipitation forecasts at short horizons than models trained without correction, but more accurate forecasts at 10 and 30 days. This contradicts our preregistered hypothesis that the deficit would grow with forecast horizon. In a separate nine-seed experiment, directly supervising the uncorrected output reverses its precipitation forecast deficit at 72 hours while maintaining the accuracy of corrected forecasts at 24 hours. In ConCerNet's heat-equation system, projection-trained models have higher uncorrected trajectory-based vector-field RMSE than models trained without projection, while restoring the physical projection recovers accuracy far more effectively than a matched nonphysical control. Together, these results show that hard corrections can reshape the predictors trained alongside them, creating dependencies that are not visible from corrected forecasts alone. Hard-constrained emulators should therefore be evaluated by separately measuring predictor accuracy, correction effects, and their interaction during training.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Sensitivity Fidelity Reveals Physical Dependencies Beyond Forecast Accuracy in Deep-Learning Earth-System Models

cs.LG physics.ao-phphysics.geo-ph ·2026-10-11 ·Qi Chen, Peng Zhan, Hongxing Cui, Wenqing Cui, Ibrahim Hoteit
benchmark similarity 0.69
Abstract

Deep-learning models increasingly rival numerical simulation in Earth-system forecasting, yet forecast error alone cannot determine whether their learned input-output dependencies are physically consistent. Here we introduce sensitivity fidelity as an additional criterion: alongside prediction error, model responses to input perturbations should be examined against a trusted reference or established physical knowledge. In an idealized Rayleigh-Bénard convection benchmark, four surrogate architectures achieved low forecast errors yet encoded markedly different sensitivities. Quantitative comparison with a matched adjoint distinguished the models far more sharply than forecast accuracy and showed that predictive skill and sensitivity fidelity need not coincide, while finite-perturbation experiments further linked these differences to the propagation of initial-condition uncertainty. We then applied this strategy to El Niño-Southern Oscillation prediction, where no adjoint reference exists and learned sensitivities showed event-wise robustness, validity under finite perturbations, and consistency with established precursors. These results identify gradient-based evaluation as a discriminating complement to forecast-error metrics, providing a practical test of whether data-driven Earth-system models learn physically credible dependencies.

0.09

Artificial intelligence pathways from weather to climate

cs.AI physics.ao-phcs.LG ·2026-10-07 ·Tom Beucler, J. David Neelin, Hui Su, Shivanshi Asthana, Chris Bretherton +8 more
similarity 0.68
Abstract · 33 pages, 10 figures. Submitted to "Science Advances"

Deep learning has made rapid advances in weather forecasting: autoregressive models trained on atmospheric reanalyses now rival dynamical models across nowcasting, medium-range, and subseasonal-to-seasonal lead times, producing well-calibrated ensemble forecasts at reduced cost. We review these advances and consider their extension to climate horizons, where the challenge shifts from initial-condition skill to producing reliable statistical responses under altered forcings. AI-powered climate prediction systems must produce credible forced responses to drivers (e.g., greenhouse gases, land-use change) typically outside the observed record. We propose two minimum requirements for AI in climate modeling: (i) external forcing agents must enter explicitly enough to support interventions in which they vary independently; and (ii) robustness must be stress-tested in out-of-distribution regimes, including extremes and counterfactual trajectories. Using leading AI autoregressive emulators and hybrid physics-AI models, we identify development and coupling challenges. Comparing the reported throughput of these models with that of GPU-ported dynamical models highlights how AI can reduce time-to-solution by advancing only the target variables at the required resolution and using longer time steps, rather than integrating a full high-frequency, multivariate state. Diverse AI downscaling strategies can partially substitute for explicit fine-scale resolution, paving the way toward inexpensive local hazard assessment across prediction horizons.

0.10

Missing the Butterfly and Predicting the Past: Features or Bugs of Accurate AI Weather Models?

cs.AI physics.ao-ph ·2026-08-26 ·Pedram Hassanzadeh, Weidong Li, Y. Qiang Sun, Jiangdi Wang, Alexander Wikner +2 more
similarity 0.67
Abstract

AI weather prediction (AIWP) models rival physics-based models, yet the sources of their unexpected forecast accuracy and the degree of their physical fidelity remain unclear. Here, across a hierarchy spanning observation-based reanalysis, a general circulation model, and the multi-scale Lorenz system, we show that AI models can be trained to skillfully predict the past (backcast), though backcasts are systematically less accurate than forecasts. However, skillful backcasting appears to violate the second law of thermodynamics, and all these forecasting and backcasting models miss the butterfly effect. We trace the surprising forecast accuracy, missing butterfly, and skillful backcasting to a single cause: inevitable coarse-graining of training data, which removes fast, small scales and/or some variables. From the Lorenz system to official Pangu-Weather models, reducing coarse-graining makes AI predictions more physics-like (arrow of time and butterfly-like effects emerge), but forecast accuracy declines. Results offer an explanation for AIWP models' forecast skill: unlike physics-based models, they implicitly learn how fast, small scales affect large scales without inheriting their rapid error growth. Broader implications are that AI models' proliferation calls for revisiting predictability theories and long-term climate emulation strategies, and backcasting offers a useful, new lens for such analyses.

0.48

WeatherBridge: Forecast-Aware Multi-Source Input Adaptation for Pretrained Weather Forecasting Models

cs.AI ·2026-10-10 ·Mutian Xi, Xinyu Su, Xiaohui Zhong, Hao Li
similarity 0.67
Abstract

Data-driven weather forecasting models are commonly trained on ERA5, yet operational deployment must use timely initial states from physics-based numerical weather prediction (NWP) systems whose distributions differ substantially from ERA5. Direct initialization with these states can degrade autoregressive forecasts, motivating input adaptation that keeps the pretrained forecasting model unchanged. Here, we introduce WeatherBridge, a unified, source-conditioned adapter that maps heterogeneous operational NWP initial states to ERA5 reference states without updating the pretrained forecasting model. WeatherBridge predicts the structured residual corrections with a Swin-UNet and injects source embeddings across multiple spatial scales, allowing the model to capture shared atmospheric structure and source-specific discrepancies. Its training objective combines latitude-weighted ERA5 reconstruction with One-step Rollout Alignment (ORA), which backpropagates one-step forecast error through a frozen FuXi model to optimize the adapted states for both initial state fidelity and downstream forecast compatibility. We evaluate WeatherBridge using daily GFS, HRES, and CMA initializations from 1 January to 22 November 2025 across six variables and lead times up to 240 hours. Relative to raw source initialization of FuXi, WeatherBridge reduces the mean RMSE of FuXi over the 6- 240-hour rollout for 17 of 18 source-variable combinations, with a median reduction of 10.2% and a maximum reduction of 46.3%. The adapter trained with frozen FuXi also improves FengWu forecasts on GFS inputs without retraining either the adapter or FengWu. These results demonstrate that forecast-aware input adaptation can improve forecasts from heterogeneous operational NWP inputs and transfer across pretrained ERA5-based forecasting models.

0.18

Guiding future global temperature distributions with simulations and observations

cs.LG physics.ao-ph ·2026-11-07 ·Francesco Immorlano, Elijah Tavares, Felix Draxler, Juan Nathaniel, Violette Launeau +4 more
benchmark similarity 0.67
Abstract

Assessing climate risks requires projections of daily temperature distributions, including rare and spatially widespread extremes. Climate simulations are costly and biased, while correcting them toward observations risks suppressing inter-model differences. We train a single machine-learning emulator, a conditional diffusion model, on seventeen CMIP6 models and ERA5 reanalysis to generate spatially coherent daily temperature fields conditioned on model identity, date, and CO2-equivalent concentration. At sampling time, diffusion guidance reduces model biases by steering each emulated climate-model distribution toward observations, with its strength selected through perfect-model experiments using withheld simulated futures. Observational influence decreases with projection horizon and forcing. Across seventeen synthetic targets, guidance more than halves median biases in the 1st and 99th percentiles of daily temperature, improves probabilistic scores and reliability, and reduces median annual global-mean temperature RMSE by 32-57% across three emission scenarios. In a detailed benchmark, guidance also outperforms established bias corrections on daily-field probabilistic scores. Efficient sampling generates large ensembles without further climate simulations. For example, our framework corrects CMIP6's roughly threefold historical overestimate of extreme-heat coverage, yet projects that concurrent extremes will affect nearly half of global land on a typical day in the 2080s under SSP3-7.0.

0.15

Strategic Governance of AI Models in Earth Science

cs.AI physics.soc-phcs.LGphysics.ao-ph ·2026-10-01 ·Makoto Kelp, Amirhossein Arzani, Patricia Castellanos, Paul Griffiths, Ivan Higuera-Mendieta +4 more
benchmark similarity 0.66
Abstract

AI foundation models pretrained on weather and climate data are increasingly fine-tuned to Earth science tasks well beyond weather forecasting. Their development and adoption are outpacing the scientific community's ability to evaluate them. These models are judged almost entirely by benchmark skill metrics, which measure how closely a forecast reproduces a reference product but not whether a model represents the physical processes governing the system it predicts. Forecast skill and physical reliability are therefore distinct properties. The distinction is most consequential under the nonstationary conditions of a changing climate for which these models were never trained. We identify five priorities for the physical evaluation of AI models in Earth science from task-specific emulators to foundation models, spanning training data, fine-tuning, behavioral testing, mechanistic interpretability, and output validation. We recommend three activities for the coming decade: 1) open AI-ready evaluation datasets, 2) a shared reporting standard for physics-based evaluation, and 3) a dedicated research program on the safety of these models.

0.38

Analysis increments for model bias diagnosis and correction: Theoretical foundations

eess.SY physics.ao-phstat.ME ·2026-11-08 ·Eviatar Bach
similarity 0.65
Abstract · 15 pages, 5 figures

A common method for diagnosing and correcting model bias in weather and climate prediction is based on analysis increments: the difference between the analysis and the forecast at each data assimilation cycle. Their time average is used to estimate and correct the bias, and machine learning is increasingly used to map the forecast state to the increments, giving a state-dependent correction. Despite its widespread use, the method lacks theoretical foundations. We first analyse a Kalman filter whose forecast model has a constant bias. We show what the averaged increment measures, and prove that iterating the correction removes all of the bias seen through the observations; for linear dynamics, no method can identify the rest. We then extend the analysis to state-dependent biases. For linear dynamics, each increment records the model error over the filter's memory, as seen through the observations. We use this to determine what the increments measure when averaged over a long period, averaged over periods with similar slowly varying conditions, and used without averaging, as in machine-learned corrections. Numerical experiments confirm the theory for a linear model and suggest that its main conclusions carry over to the nonlinear Lorenz '96 model, including for a correction learned by a neural network.

0.34

Domain-Adaptive Data Assimilation for Global AI Weather Forecasting

cs.CE ·2026-10-02 ·Minseok Seo, Noah Brenowitz, Doyi Kim, Hyesook Lee, Changick Kim
code/data similarity 0.65
Abstract · 27 pages, [This project is open source.]

AI weather forecasting models are commonly trained on the ERA5 reanalysis, which is unavailable in real time. Operational deployment therefore relies on initial conditions produced by numerical or AI analysis systems that differ from those encountered during training. This mismatch can degrade forecast skill, while retraining for every analysis system is costly. Here, we present Domain-Adaptive Data Assimilation (DADA), an observation-guided framework that adapts external analyses to pretrained AI weather models. Starting from a background state, DADA optimizes only an initial-state perturbation while keeping the forecast model frozen. The perturbed state is propagated through the model, and its short-range trajectory is constrained by real-world observations through a learned observation operator. The resulting initial condition is shaped jointly by observational constraints and the dynamics learned by the target model. We evaluate DADA across five global AI weather models using backgrounds from the Global Forecast System and the AI-based HealDA. Across deterministic and probabilistic forecasts, DADA substantially reduces short-range skill loss caused by changes in the initial-condition source. More broadly, DADA turns observations into a common interface between independently developed analysis and forecasting systems, enabling pretrained AI weather models to accommodate evolving operational initial conditions without reconstructing ERA5 or retraining the forecast model.

0.33