CS Paper Radar

Value-level data provenance in an electronic laboratory notebook used by humans and language-model agents: An experience report

Oleksiy V. Penkov, Boyang Shen

cs.SE physics.app-ph ·submitted 2026-10-20 08:41 UTC · v1

Abstract

A published laboratory number can be verified only when its raw file and extraction method are known. This paper presents the value-level provenance architecture of APS ELN, an electronic laboratory notebook used by both researchers and language-model agents. The architecture was motivated by a production audit in a materials laboratory covering projects performed over almost 5 years. Tracing eight baseline studies from sample to stored value showed that the initial ELN structure preserved the link from sample to raw file. Still, the link from raw file to stored value was lost, mainly due to human factors: manual entries carried no file reference or extractor version. To close this gap, the database design and workflow were reworked so that every stored value records its source file, the data file reader/viewer (DFR) plugin and version, any interactive analysis selection, or the server-side formula for derived quantities. An automated drift check re-runs each DFR on the stored files. In two end-to-end validation studies recorded by agents in X-ray reflectivity and tribology, all stored values retained verifiable provenance with zero drift. A comparison with five other platforms shows that none binds individual stored numbers to both their source files and extractor versions.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Workflow Cards: Structured Summaries of Workflow Executions Using Provenance Data

cs.DC cs.AI ·2026-08-11 ·Nicola Giuseppe Marchioro, Gabriele Padovani, Amal Gueroudji, Rafael Ferreira da Silva, Wesley Brewer +3 more
published similarity 0.65
Abstract · Accepted at eScience2026

Model Cards and Data Cards have demonstrated the value of structured, human-readable documentation for machine learning artifacts, capturing their context, parameters, limitations, and intended use. However, these practices remain focused on static artifacts (the datasets and trained models themselves) while overlooking the workflow executions that produce, transform, and evaluate them. Such executions hold critical details about data preparation, parameter choice, runtime behavior, resource use, and intermediate transformations, precisely where bias, performance variation, and reproducibility gaps tend to originate. To close this gap, we introduce Workflow Cards: structured summaries that condense the machine-readable provenance data of a workflow execution into a form both humans and large language models (LLMs) can read and analyze. This paper has two main parts. First, it defines a Workflow Card template informed by a representative set of provenance questions that surface from the execution-level data missing from Model and Data Cards. Second, it evaluates how effectively LLMs use Workflow Cards to understand workflow executions compared with querying provenance databases through a schema-based interface. Results show that Workflow Cards provide execution-level information absent from existing card types, such as Model Cards and Data Cards, thereby filling an important documentation gap; and that Workflow Cards nearly double answer quality compared with schema-based querying, consistently across LLM-as-a-Judge and human assessments.

0.19

UnespDataLens-RM: A Reference Model for Analytical Data Engineering with Governance, Quality, Provenance, and Reproducibility

cs.DB ·2026-09-08 ·Ronaldo Celso Messias Correia, Douglas Francisquini Toledo, Camila Tolin Santos da Silva
similarity 0.61
Abstract

The growing reliance on data in analytical processes and evidence-based decision-making has reinforced the importance of Data Engineering in building pipelines capable of integrating, transforming, validating, and delivering data from heterogeneous sources. However, the reliability of analytical assets depends not only on data processing capabilities but also on mechanisms for governance, quality assurance, provenance, traceability, versioning, and reproducibility throughout their lifecycle. These responsibilities are commonly addressed by different models, frameworks, and operational practices, resulting in methodological fragmentation across the analytical data lifecycle. To address this gap, this article proposes UnespDataLens-RM, a technology-independent reference model that integrates technical-operational processes and cross-cutting capabilities within a unified structure for Analytical Data Engineering. The model aims to support the specification, organization, and evolution of analytical pipelines by incorporating governance, quality, provenance, traceability, and reproducibility from the design stage. Developed following the Design Science Research approach, UnespDataLens-RM comprises eight technical-operational modules, eight cross-cutting modules, complementary dimensions, and a formalized set of artifacts, metrics, and validation criteria. The resulting specification offers a conceptual and methodological framework for future instantiations and empirical evaluations of analytical pipelines designed to be more governable, documented, traceable, auditable, and reproducible.

0.29

Review Before Trust: Source-Grounded Integrity Gates for AI-Assisted Personal Health Records

cs.AI ·2026-08-30 ·Nora Girda, Adrian Groza
similarity 0.61
Abstract

Large language models can convert medical documents into structured data, but plausible output may still be unsupported by the source. Persisting such output in a longitudinal health record, a record that accumulates patient information over time, therefore creates an integrity risk: unverified data may influence later summaries, trends, or preventive-care computations. We introduce an evidence-gated trust-promotion model that keeps generated data provisional until a deterministic monitor verifies it against the source document. The monitor admits a candidate for a specified downstream use only when the source contains a unique supporting quotation, the relevant fields occur within the same laboratory row, and the required provenance is preserved. The generator cannot approve its own output, missing or ambiguous evidence causes refusal, and refused candidates remain available for human review rather than being silently discarded. We implement the model in Medical DataCloud, a personal health-record application, and evaluate it through automated tests and a replay of saved extraction outputs. All 22 conformance and mutation tests pass. The replay covers nine historical laboratory PDF reports containing 102 manually labelled rows. The reports produce 97 numeric candidates: schema validation accepts all 97, an earlier packet-level evidence check accepts 94, and the hardened quotation- and row-level policy admits 72 while retaining 25 for review. The study evaluates system integrity rather than clinical correctness or clinical safety. The results demonstrate the technical feasibility of an enforceable boundary that prevents generated claims from authorizing their own reuse in a longitudinal health record.

0.21

CompProv Produces Machine Readable Graphs Encoding Microscopic Algebraic Provenance for Reproducible Computation

cs.SE cs.CE ·2026-10-01 ·Minas Abramyan, Mohammed Alaa Ala'anzy, Nasir Saeed
similarity 0.61
Abstract

The reliability of computational results in scientific research and financial modeling increasingly depends on verifiable traceability, not merely on trust in a reported output. Existing provenance systems operate at the granularity of files, datasets, or pipeline stages, leaving the internal sequence of algebraic transformations connecting an algorithm's inputs to its outputs unrecorded; a rounding error, an undocumented substitution, or a missing intermediate value can propagate to a final result with no recoverable trace. This work presents CompProv, a Java-based, audit-oriented provenance framework that captures lineage at the atomic level of individual algebraic operations by encapsulating numerical values in high-precision wrapper objects, producing a serializable Calculation Provenance Graph (CPG) that persists as a self-contained artifact rather than a discarded byproduct. The framework is evaluated through three heterogeneous case studies: a decentralized-finance NAV calculation, a reconstruction of an interferometric gauge-block calibration in metrology under explicitly documented input assumptions, and a hydrological model performance evaluation. Deterministic replay reproduced each result exactly in a fresh environment, and CPG-based input substitution supported sensitivity analysis without exposing the underlying source code. These results indicate that, provided the CompProv runtime and wrapper classes are available in the replay environment, a CPG allows numerical integrity to be audited without disclosing proprietary business logic, and that its self-contained structure supports temporal auditability once an execution environment has become deprecated. This framework establishes an operation-level foundation for auditable-by-design computational systems, with scaling to high-throughput computing identified as a direction for future work.

0.27

Reading the Data Back: Enriching Variable-Level Metadata for Model-Data Consistency Checks

cs.DL cs.DB ·2026-09-20 ·Eryk Kulikowski
code/data similarity 0.60
Abstract · 21 pages, 8 tables, 2 figures. Submitted to the International Journal on Digital Libraries. Code, metadata profile and census artifacts: htt…

Purpose: Research data repositories often lack variable-level metadata. Model-choice screening, checking whether a reported model suits the values of its outcome variable, also requires summaries of those values and links to the analyses that use them. We ask how repositories can represent and acquire them as metadata with evidence and review histories. Methods: We propose a metadata application profile compatible with the Data Documentation Initiative Cross-Domain Integration (DDI-CDI) model, linking versioned variables and empirical profiles to reported analyses, estimators, and analysis roles. Extraction provenance and review decisions are recorded separately. We evaluate streaming data profiling, deterministic extraction from Stata and R code, and language-model extraction of analysis records from papers. Results: A worked export of one replication package illustrates the profile: it passes shape and interchange checks and answers four queries, one of which returns the analyses that raise no alert. Screening 4,868 replication datasets from six political-science journals links outcomes to profiled columns in 1,440 deposits and flags 965, including 14 of the 21 deposits with a hand-verified linear model on a count, proportion, binary, or ordinal outcome. AI-assisted adjudication yields 55% precision on a near-balanced sample of 119 count and proportion candidates; screening rules were developed on the same corpus. Conclusion: The profile makes analysis-variable relationships queryable while preserving evidence and review history; screening yields review candidates with context. Code, metadata, and measurements are released.

0.23

AIPOCH Open-Science: An Open-Source AI Research Workbench with Reproducible .science Packages

cs.SE cs.AI ·2026-10-12 ·Wen Ouyang, Bocheng Huang, Qianyu Yao, Fei Sun, Minying Deng +74 more
code/data similarity 0.60
Abstract · 23 pages; 2 main figures, 3 tables, a graphical abstract and Supplementary Figure S1

AI-assisted research leaves instructions, computations, artifact revisions and checks whose relationships matter when another researcher receives the work. We present AIPOCH Open-Science, an open-source research workbench with portable .science session packages, and specify an exchange contract for these recorded relationships. Version and assessment targets remain attributable while receiving-workspace identifiers can be remapped, eligible contents can be omitted explicitly, and imported history remains separate from a writable fork. A controlled session tested an incorrect first version, a reviewed correction, an unreviewed revision and a planned but unexecuted step. We compared complete and partial exports with source records extracted independently of the exporter, then inspected imports into separate projects within the same installation. Both conditions retained the tested version and review associations, kept the unreviewed revision distinct from earlier assessments and represented excluded content as unavailable. A documentation-rich ordinary directory also supplied evidence for all seven static inspection questions. A separate registry case connected a table to its recorded task, execution and review; offline execution of its retained script and fixed input reproduced two saved CSV tables byte for byte. The study contributes an implemented exchange contract and a controlled examination of its preservation rules, content-selection constraints and interpretation boundaries.

0.35

Agentic Data Cleaning Without a Clean Reference: An Experimental Study of Capabilities and Trade-offs

cs.AI cs.DB ·2026-08-14 ·Hadi Fadlallah
similarity 0.59
Abstract · 21 pages, 3 figures, Submitted to New Generation Computing

Data cleaning without a trusted clean reference is challenging because unusual values may represent either genuine errors or valid observations. This paper studies how different agent capabilities affect reference-free data cleaning and proposes an evidence-grounded framework that combines structured context, profiling, LLM reasoning, executable checks, controlled evidence retrieval, source ranking, citation alignment, conservative repair, reversible scripts, and provenance logging. Seven configurations are evaluated across financial, clinical, and environmental-monitoring datasets using controlled synthetic corruption and original-data descriptive analysis, resulting in 126 completed runs. The evaluation includes two comparison baselines and a progressive LLM-based sequence that adds executable tools, evidence retrieval, evidence controls, and conservative repair. In the synthetic evaluation, the deterministic profiling baseline achieved the highest detection F1-score of 0.561. Among the LLM-based configurations, the full conservative configuration achieved the highest F1-score of 0.421, but no configuration performed best across all evaluation criteria. The source-ranked configurations achieved the lowest unsupported-rule rates, while decision-level citation alignment remained weak. The full conservative configuration produced no unsafe or unnecessary modifications, although these rates were already zero before the conservative policy was added, and it performed no direct repairs. Overall, the results show that additional capabilities introduce trade-offs among detection, repair, evidence grounding, conservative behaviour, reproducibility, and operational cost rather than producing consistent improvements. The study provides a structured framework and empirical methodology for evaluating these trade-offs in reference-free agentic data cleaning.

0.12

ProvCards: Artifact-Oriented Provenance for Heterogeneous Scientific Workflows

cs.DB ·2026-11-18 ·Tanja Auge, Marinus Holitschke, Meike Klettke
similarity 0.59
Abstract · 11 pages, 5 figures, 2 tables

Reproducibility in scientific workflows is hindered by heterogeneous components and execution environments, as well as fragmented provenance capture. Although existing approaches offer established semantics and workflow-specific solutions, provenance remains difficult to capture, exchange, and compose across workflow boundaries. We present ProvCards, an artifact-oriented approach that treats provenance as a first-class artifact grounded in the W3C PROV Data Model. Individual workflow components can generate cards that are stored, exchanged, reused, and composed independently of any workflow system or centralized execution context. ProvDecks group related cards into portable scopes while preserving their identities. ProvGraphs provide derived views for provenance reconstruction, querying, visualization, and analysis. Together, these representations support coherent, task-specific provenance views across heterogeneous components, facilitating traceability, reuse, and reproducibility. We implement ProvCards using a graph-based infrastructure and evaluate them in a scientific data-processing workflow. The results demonstrate independent provenance capture at the component level, composition across component boundaries, and reconstruction for querying and analysis. ProvCards provide a portable, composable, and incrementally extensible foundation for provenance management in heterogeneous scientific workflows.

0.11