CS Paper Radar

Speculative Imbalance Positions by Non-Physical Traders: Impacts on Electricity System Balancing in Great Britain

Joseph Cary, Thomas Morstyn

eess.SY econ.GNq-fin.TR ·submitted 2026-10-20 11:54 UTC · v1

Abstract

The electricity system in Great Britain (GB) allows participants to deliberately produce or consume a different volume to their traded position and has incentivised this practice with a single imbalance price since 2015. In particular, non-physical traders (NPTs) often take an open position to imbalance without any intention to produce or consume power. However, new government proposals could restrict this practice due to concerns over supply-demand balancing feasibility and costs. This article presents the first empirical analysis of speculative imbalance positioning (SIP) by NPTs in the GB electricity system through its effects on imbalance volumes, balancing costs, the imbalance price, and associated settlement costs over the period 2021-2024. Our research uses party-level imbalance data in each settlement period to run counterfactual simulations of the electricity balancing mechanism without the aggregate NPT imbalance. Our results indicate that SIP by NPTs reduced the total net balancing volume required by 3.1-3.9 TWh (16-20%), reduced system imbalance standard deviation by 48-65 MWh (13-17%), reduced balancing costs by £347-396m (5.9-6.7%), and reduced supplier imbalance costs by £193-325m (65-75%) over the analysis period. These results suggest that consumer bills would have been higher without SIP by NPTs, since the extra costs would likely have been passed on to consumers through levies, although the potential for effects in the wholesale (primarily late-stage intraday) markets complicates this picture.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

From Intraday Orderbook to Imbalance Price: Understanding Cross-Market Interaction

cs.CE q-fin.CP ·2026-09-29 ·Runyao Yu, Jochen L. Cremer, Pierre Pinson, Jalal Kazempour, Leo Semmelmann +2 more
similarity 0.67
Abstract · 10 pages, 11 figures, 5 tables

Power systems with increasing variable renewable generation face greater uncertainty in scheduling and balancing. Intraday and balancing electricity markets facilitate position adjustments and real-time balancing close to delivery. As delivery approaches, continuous intraday market participants exposed to imbalance settlement adjust their positions by trading additional volumes to reduce their imbalance exposure. We conjecture that positions remaining open after intraday trading, together with demand and supply uncertainties affecting physical market participants, influence price formation in the balancing market. This cross-market interaction is, however, rarely studied. To understand this interaction, this paper uses probabilistic modeling to examine how intraday orderbook information reflects subsequent imbalance price formation in Germany and Austria. We compare orderbook representations based on open, high, low, close, and volume, Volume-Weighted Average Price (VWAP), and last mid price across multiple horizons. Each representation is evaluated using the self product, neighboring products, and the product from the neighboring country. We then compare the best orderbook setting with fundamental feature sets and their combinations, followed by an ablation study of the available training history. We show that VWAP with neighboring products provides the best performance in both countries. Combining orderbook and fundamental information reduces testing loss in Germany but increases it in Austria. Using all available observations provides the best overall performance, while excluding 2022 can reduce loss for extreme price samples. These results reveal and help explain country-dependent interactions between the intraday and balancing markets.

0.33

Sharing the Gains of Aggregation: Cooperative Imbalance Cost Allocation

eess.SY ·2026-09-30 ·Asmus Winther Eriksen, Jalal Kazempour
benchmark similarity 0.58
Abstract

A facilitator is an intermediary that offers renewable producers and consumers fixed-price contracts and, acting as their balance responsible party, manages the residual imbalances in the market. Pooling imperfectly correlated residuals nets consumers' imbalances and reduces the portfolio's total imbalance cost, but raises an allocation question: how should these savings be divided among heterogeneous consumers? We formulate this as a cooperative game, the imbalance netting game, and compare six allocation mechanisms under a two-price imbalance settlement in terms of computational requirements, budget balance, group rationality, and additivity. We establish three analytical results: a necessary and sufficient condition for budget balance of the marginal cost contribution mechanism, group rationality of the marginal cost contribution and Vickrey-Clarke-Groves mechanisms, and a necessary and sufficient condition for when the Gately point is well-defined. On Danish 2024 data for 19 consumers, aggregation reduces imbalance cost by 10%, but how these savings are shared depends strongly on the allocation rule. A flat-rate allocation proportional to consumption, used as a benchmark for socialized imbalance pricing, charges some consumers more than twice their standalone cost, whereas all the game-theoretic mechanisms studied produce stable allocations in practice.

0.45

On BESS-Backed Trading on the Continuous Intraday Electricity Market

eess.SY ·2026-10-02 ·Leo Semmelmann, Runyao Yu, Joseph Cary, Derek Bunn
benchmark similarity 0.53
Abstract

Battery energy storage systems (BESS) on the continuous intraday market (IDC) often trade according to a rolling intrinsic algorithm, a myopic strategy which repeatedly opens and unwinds positions according to current prices throughout the trading session, before dispatching as delivery approaches. This paper introduces a novel trading strategy for storage, in which forecast-driven round trip trading takes priority and the BESS supplies a second route for closing out positions that the market would otherwise close at a distressed price. The agent uses price quantile forecasts to open positions on the IDC, and closes these positions closer to delivery. The market can move against these trades, and the BESS intervenes only when a position would have to be settled at a price that the forecast predicts to be highly improbable, absorbing or serving that volume physically and restoring its state of charge at ordinary prices afterwards. The position itself remains loss-making; what the asset changes is the price at which it is closed, by transferring the terminal settlement price through time. Four quantile forecasting models of increasing complexity supply the thresholds, and all strategies are backtested on realised EPEX SPOT transactions for the German market area in 2024. A 40 MWh BESS in this role earns EUR 2.06m against EUR 1.77m for a rolling intrinsic benchmark and EUR 1.37m for a perfect-foresight day-ahead benchmark, while consuming 167 instead of 365 available equivalent full cycles. Hence, the novel backstop strategy yields higher profits, while using the underlying BESS less, leaving capacity for other trading opportunities.

0.17

Fuji: The Shape, Composition, and Spread of Demand Bursts on Robinhood Chain

cs.SI econ.EMq-fin.TR ·2026-10-26 ·Pranay Anchuri
similarity 0.52
Abstract · 25 pages, 8 figures

Demand on blockchain-based marketplaces arrives in bursts and at a high rate. On these platforms the data are completely visible, which makes it feasible to compare the bursty demand against the usual load. The congestion manifests as an increased demand for gas, the primary resource a blockchain sells. Existing studies consider how to price the gas. The demand itself, and what it is made of during bursts, has not been measured. We measure it on Robinhood Chain, a layer-2 blockchain that quickly became a venue for trading tokenized equities and memecoins. We collected the data from every block of its first three active months and more than 50 million Uniswap swaps that occurred during bursty periods. We find that a burst trades about as many pools as a quiet period, mostly different ones, and trades them harder, on top of elevated demand that accumulated for hours. With the bursts aligned on their peaks, the median peak is 2.5 times the usual load. Both the rise and the fall of the demand are described by the sum of two exponential functions with different timescales, a slow one of hours and a fast one of minutes. Against a matched quiet period, a burst has 1.05 times the pools, 1.40 times the trades, and 1.21 times the senders. We use two models to explain the arrival of bursts: externally triggered cascades and self-excitation. The former fits the data relatively better. Inside a burst, the entry of each trader into a pool is followed for about 24 seconds by more entries than the existing traders predict. Whether this is because of imitation or because of a shared signal is left open.

0.29

Strategic Arbitrage in Electricity Markets: A Multi-Agent Policy Optimization Framework

eess.SY ·2026-10-21 ·Eli Brock, Srikar Babu Gadipudi, Somayeh Sojoudi, Javad Lavaei
publishedbenchmark similarity 0.51
Abstract · Accepted to the 65th IEEE Conference on Decision and Control (CDC 2026). 8 pages, 6 figures

Grid-scale storage and load aggregators are growing quickly in wholesale electricity markets. If highly consolidated, these new participants may distort the competitive market equilibrium through strategic withholding behavior. Traditional market power mitigation techniques are ill-suited to arbitrage-based participants. We provide a multi-agent policy optimization model to study game-theoretic equilibria for real-time markets with consolidated storage and/or aggregators. The model is designed to facilitate natural first-order equilibrium-seeking update rules. We analyze the theoretical properties of different supply functions and their implications on the convergence of the gradient dynamics. Finally, we train equilibrium policies for a modified version of the IEEE RTS-GMLC benchmark across different levels of storage fleet consolidation, to demonstrate the potential of the framework as a tool to characterize and quantify strategic arbitrage.

0.33

Verifiable Settlement and Pricing for Local Energy Markets: Architecture and Deployment on Hyperledger Besu

cs.CR cs.GTq-fin.TR ·2026-11-12 ·Michele Fabi, Baptiste Leloup
similarity 0.51
Abstract

We implement privacy-preserving local electricity exchanges using an automated market maker on the Hyperledger Besu network under QBFT consensus. The proposed protocol operator collects individual electricity positions off-chain and publishes aggregate supply and demand on the blockchain, where smart contracts compute market prices every fifteen minutes. Individual positions remain off-chain; Poseidon2 commitments and UltraHonk zeroknowledge proofs, generated from Noir circuits, verify aggregation, payments, and daily balance updates. The architecture retains community coordination while making financial execution independently auditable. Signed receipts and member-triggered recourse prevent unverified or partial settlement. In a ten-household experiment using simulated US residential profiles, daily settlement uses approximately 19 million gas and produces eight-member proofs in 2.4 seconds. Over four simulated days, local trading covers 34.4% of demand and reduces grid-only costs by 30.5% under assumed tariffs. Numerically computed __-Nash Equilibrium electricity profiles capture 83-88% of the social planner surplus.

0.30

A Power-Trajectory Framework for Data Center Participation in Day-Ahead Markets

eess.SY ·2026-10-12 ·Menghan Zhang, Caisheng Wang
similarity 0.50
Abstract · 10 Pages, 7 Figures, 4 Tables

The rapid expansion of artificial intelligence (AI) is driving substantial growth in data center electricity demand. Interval-based energy blocks in day-ahead markets do not explicitly retain predictable intra-interval demand evolution, potentially creating mismatches with ramp-feasible generation trajectories and affecting settlement. This paper proposes a power-trajectory framework in which data centers declare predictable aggregate demand evolution through continuous demand-side power trajectories before market clearing. The declared trajectories are treated as exogenous inputs for constructing generation trajectories and the corresponding price trajectory. For feasible market-clearing outcomes, physical temporal consistency is established through continuous-time power balance and satisfaction of the modeled generation operating constraints, while economic temporal consistency is established by preserving the dispatch-price correspondence in energy settlement on a common temporal basis. Under the adopted settlement definitions, a trajectory-based settlement analysis separately quantifies the monetary magnitude of representation-induced power imbalances and the supply-side compensation that may remain under temporally consistent clearing and settlement. An illustrative 5-bus case demonstrates the elimination of representation-induced power imbalance and identifies the timing and physical sources of supply-side compensation. A modified IEEE RTS-GMLC case further illustrates these compensation effects across multiple generating units under workload-driven data center demand variations.

0.17

Every minute counts: Wind farm power control during imbalance settlement using distributional soft actor-critic

eess.SY ·2026-10-19 ·Max Bruninx, Seyed Soroush Karimi Madahi, Timothy Verstraeten, Jan Decuyper, Chris Develder +2 more
similarity 0.50
Abstract

Wind farms can provide flexibility by curtailing their output during periods of excess generation in the power grid. This can be done through implicit balancing, where the power setpoints of the farm are adapted to anticipate the imbalance price. By doing so, the wind farm helps reduce the resulting system imbalance while also lowering its own costs. However, implicit balancing is challenging since the imbalance prices are unknown in advance and hard to predict. Furthermore, the control strategy of the wind farm can affect the imbalance price formation. To address both challenges, we develop a control policy with 1-minute setpoints using distributional soft actor-critic. Evaluated on real data of the Belgian grid and an offshore wind farm, we show that our method outperforms a price threshold controller, often used in industry, by 88% and performs on par with soft actor-critic. Furthermore, unlike soft actor-critic, our approach can learn a risk-averse policy by optimizing a risk measure, such as conditional value at risk. The risk-averse policy was found to better account for its own impact on the price, showing a reduction in overshoots, while achieving a similar degree of imbalance cost savings. Last, we find that using 1-minute instead of 15-minute setpoints further reduces imbalance costs for all evaluated control policies.

0.32