CS Paper Radar

Multichoice Modeling: Exploring Decision Configuration Space under Uncertainty

Mariia Kozlova, Roman Stepanov, Alexander Walzer, Andrea Saltelli

cs.AI q-fin.RMstat.CO ·submitted 2026-10-22 10:16 UTC · v1
unusual

Abstract

Decision support has become sophisticated at exploring uncertainty, but much less so at representing the architecture of the decision itself. As a result, the decision space is often narrowed before uncertainty is analyzed, leaving interactions among choices and the effects of alternatives they imply largely invisible. This paper introduces multichoice modeling, a framework for making large decision configuration spaces explicit and computationally explorable under uncertainty. Drawing on the logic of rugged landscapes, we conceptualize such problems as contingent performance landscapes, where interdependent choices generate configuration-specific outcomes whose value changes across uncertain futures. The computational framework combines multidimensional decision and uncertainty spaces in a single simulation. Further, variance-based sensitivity analysis is used for identifying influential choices, and conditional distribution analysis for comparing configuration-specific performance profiles. We demonstrate the framework through three case studies: a manufacturing process upgrade, M&A strategy, and mortgage design. By contrasting conventional uncertainty-only analysis with multichoice modeling, the cases show how opening the decision configuration space can reveal unexpected complementarities, near-best configurations with different risk profiles, and strategies that were not apparent as alternatives at the outset.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Risk-Aware Goal-Oriented Bayesian Optimal Experimental Design

cs.CE stat.MEstat.CO ·2026-09-07 ·John D. Jakeman, Rebekah White, Bart van Bloemen Waanders, Drew P. Kouri, Alen Alexanderian
similarity 0.55
Abstract

Traditional Bayesian optimal experimental design (OED) selects measurements that best inform a model's parameters. However, such measurements can be suboptimal for downstream predictions. Goal-oriented OED targets the prediction directly. However, the existing goal-oriented criteria value all reductions in predictive uncertainty equally, with no way to prioritize rare, high-consequence outcomes. In this article, we develop a risk-aware framework that composes risk at three levels, each generalizing an ingredient of classical $I$- and $G$-optimal design: a deviation measure of the posterior predictive uncertainty (generalizing the predictive variance), a risk measure across the prediction domain (interpolating $I$-optimal averaging and $G$-optimal worst-case selection), and a risk measure over datasets (generalizing the expectation). We generate each level from a regret function in the risk quadrangle, so that one triple specifies a practitioner's risk preference. We relax the design to continuous weights on the unit simplex and construct a nested-quadrature estimator that is differentiable in the design variable. This enables solving the optimal design problem with gradient-based methods, avoiding a combinatorial search over candidate designs. For a linear-Gaussian lognormal model and a nonlinear extension, we derive closed-form objectives. These give exact references against which we verify that the estimator converges. We demonstrate this framework for finding optimal sensor placements in an inverse problem governed by an advection-diffusion equation. We find that the risk-aware designs substantially outperform the expected-information-gain baseline, which is statistically indistinguishable from a random allocation.

0.28

Enhancing Interpretability of Stochastic Programming Solutions: A Multiparametric Approach

eess.SY math.OC ·2026-08-31 ·Parth Brahmbhatt, Styliani Avraamidou
published similarity 0.53
Abstract

Stochastic programming (SP) is a powerful framework for decision-making under uncertainty, but its practical adoption in industry is often hindered by the difficulty in understanding the causal relationships that drive optimal solutions. In the two-stage SP, strategic first-stage decisions are coupled with operational second-stage recourse decisions. When the number of scenarios under consideration is large, understanding the direct link between the uncertainty realization and optimal recourse strategy becomes computationally and cognitively demanding. Common approaches to improve interpretability include trained classification trees or scenario reduction, replacing the large scenario set with a representative subset. This is often achieved through post-hoc clustering (e.g., k-means) based on uncertainty realizations or optimal recourse decisions. While useful, these methods only provide a statistical approximation of the solution space and may fail to reveal the underlying structural properties of the recourse problem that drive optimal first-stage decisions. This work introduces a novel, deterministic approach to explainability using multiparametric programming (mp) within a Benders decomposition framework. We reformulate the recourse subproblem as a multiparametric linear program, generating an explicit map of Critical Regions (CRs), which are polyhedral partitions of the uncertainty space. This allows us to cluster scenarios analytically rather than statistically. We demonstrate this methodology on a supply chain planning under demand uncertainty. Our results show that 100 stochastic scenarios map to exactly six critical region clusters. This mapping allows us to explain optimal capacity planning decisions as a precise trade-off between specific operational modes, providing a fully transparent interpretation of the stochastic solution.

0.36

Multifidelity Operator Inference for Non-intrusive Model Reduction under Data Scarcity

cs.LG math.NAstat.CO ·2026-11-10 ·Vivian Zhang, Tomoki Koike, Atticus Rex, Elizabeth Qian
similarity 0.52
Abstract · 21 pages, AIAA SciTech Forum 2027

Many-query analyses, in which a computational model is repeatedly evaluated, play an important role in uncertainty quantification and optimization for engineering design. However, many-query analyses can be prohibitively expensive when considering high-fidelity numerical models, especially those governed by partial differential equations (PDEs). Surrogate modeling replaces costly simulations with cheap approximations, enabling practical uncertainty quantification and design workflows. Machine learning (ML) approaches to surrogate modeling have gained significant traction in the development of surrogate models due to their non-intrusive nature; they do not require access to the underlying simulation code. The Operator Inference (OpInf) approach, in particular, fits reduced operators to state and corresponding time derivative data. However, high-fidelity training data is scarce due to limited computational budgets, and OpInf models trained on such scarce data often exhibit high variance, a critical liability in high-risk engineering design. We propose Multifidelity Operator Inference (MF-OpInf), which reduces this variance by supplementing scarce high-fidelity snapshots with abundant low-fidelity data drawn from coarser discretizations of the same problem. MF-OpInf handles data across varying fidelity levels by utilizing a multifidelity linear regression framework to estimate the reduced operators. Numerical experiments on model PDE problems demonstrate that MF-OpInf predicts PDE solution fields with higher accuracy compared to the high-fidelity-only OpInf with the same computational budget.

0.37

Calibrating Ambiguity Set via Diagnostic Transport for Distributionally Robust Optimization

cs.LG stat.MLmath.OC ·2026-10-07 ·Wenbin Zhou, Elizabeth Cucuzzella, Shixiang Zhu
similarity 0.52
Abstract

Distributionally robust optimization (DRO) protects decisions against distributional uncertainty by optimizing over an ambiguity set, but poorly aligned set geometry can require large radii and yield overly conservative decisions. We introduce diagnostic-transport DRO (DT-DRO), which uses held-out calibration data to adapt the ambiguity-set geometry to observed predictive errors. DT-DRO uses the conditional probability integral transform cumulative distribution function to diagnose systematic probability misallocation and translates this information into an outcome-level transport that jointly adjusts the ambiguity-set center and ground cost. The resulting formulation admits a computationally tractable dual reformulation. Theoretically, we derive valid ambiguity radii and decision-risk guarantees that tighten as estimation and approximation errors vanish, and show that DT-DRO can eliminate the nonvanishing robustness floor caused by model misspecification. Synthetic experiments and a power-outage application demonstrate improved decision quality, particularly under structural and tail misspecification.

0.22

TPO: Tri-level Distributionally Robust Learning for OOD Direct Preference Optimization

cs.LG cs.AI ·2026-10-20 ·Chengtao Jian, Kai Yang
top venue similarity 0.50
Abstract · Accepted at NeurIPS 2026

Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) minimizes empirical risk over observed preference comparisons, implicitly assuming that the training preference distribution matches the deployment preference distribution. In practice, this distributional assumption often fails, as preference distribution shifts can arise at three levels: group-level shift, prompt-level shift, and preference-level shift. Such multi-level distributional mismatch poses a critical challenge for safe LLM deployment, yet existing robust DPO methods typically either model uncertainty over the joint preference distribution or focus on individual sources of shift, leaving the hierarchical structure of OOD preference shifts underexplored. We propose TPO, a tri-level distributionally robust framework for OOD preference alignment, which jointly models all three levels of distributional uncertainty through a hierarchically structured rectangular ambiguity set. By instantiating it with Wasserstein distance, we derive a tractable and interpretable objective that combines a preference-level margin penalty, prompt-level adversarial embedding perturbation, and worst-case group reweighting, each governed by an independent radius. We establish finite-sample convergence guarantees and empirically validate the effectiveness of TPO across diverse OOD environments.

0.33

Strategic Investment Decision Making for Value Creation in Energy Transition: A Reinforcement Learning Approach

cs.CE cs.LGeess.SY ·2026-10-07 ·Yasaman Cheraghi, Reidar B. Bratvold, Aojie Hong, Ressi B. Muhammad, Sergey Alyaev
benchmark similarity 0.49
Abstract

The global challenge of climate change has driven significant steps to reduce CO2 emissions, guided by international agreements like the Paris Agreement of 2015. Acting too slowly could result in future losses and reputational damage, while moving too quickly could jeopardize shareholder value due to the marginal profitability or potential losses due to technology immaturity of many renewable projects. To navigate this complex transition, energy companies must adopt Sequential Decision Making (SDM) strategies to maximize value creation from decision flexibility under uncertainties. To support this, we developed a custom simulation environment to model the dynamic energy landscape up to 2050. Building on this, we designed a multi-criteria SDM framework that explores various decision strategies related to different portfolios for allocating funds across three sectors: oil & gas, renewables, and CO2 reduction. It aims to maximize value during the transition while accounting for uncertainties in productions, energy prices, and costs. This framework has three objectives: maximizing profit, minimizing CO2 social costs, and enhancing competitive advantage in the renewable energy sector. This research evaluates the use of Reinforcement Learning (RL) to identify optimal investment policies within the defined SDM framework. The agent's sequential decisions shape a virtual dynamic environment by influencing key variables such as oil and gas production, renewable energy output, CO2 emissions, and revenues. Through repeated interaction, the RL algorithm explores the state space and learns an optimal policy under uncertainty. We benchmark the RL strategy against a set of manually defined baseline policies and find it consistently outperforms them in adaptability and long-term value creation.

0.17

Decision-Gated Surrogate-Assisted Stochastic Optimization with Independent High-Fidelity Certification for Photovoltaic Hosting-Capacity Planning

eess.SY ·2026-09-25 ·Ali Abubakar, Samuel Essamuah Assabil, Akhtar Hussain, Van-Hai Bui
similarity 0.49
Abstract · 17 pages

High photovoltaic (PV) penetration planning requires repeated nonlinear PV and power-flow evaluations under uncertain irradiance and demand, particularly when two competing objectives, penetration and total electrical loss, are optimized simultaneously subject to reliability constraints. This paper develops a decision-focused, surrogate-assisted stochastic multiobjective framework in which a calibrated PV model coupled with a distribution-network simulator provides the high-fidelity reference, while matched data-only and physics-informed surrogates accelerate optimization and are evaluated empirically for decision reliability across the loss-penetration tradeoff. Although the two surrogates exhibit nearly identical held-out errors, optimizer-realistic screening yields markedly different operational validity rates of 44.4% and 93.4%, respectively, motivating selection of the physics-informed model on decision performance rather than test accuracy. Surrogate inference cuts the cost of a 60-scenario design evaluation from 286.0 to 0.46 ms, an approximately 620 time speedup. A decision-gated enrichment strategy further targets Pareto-critical, constraint boundary, and surrogate-disagreement regions, reducing prediction error by 39.1%. Independent 500 scenario certification verifies all 80 screened candidates and identifies 46 non-dominated designs; the selected compromise attains 70.74% expected penetration with 297.9 kW expected total electrical loss. Cross-feeder transfer eliminates baseline voltage violations on the 85- and 69-bus systems, but produces overvoltage and a 62.7% increase in feeder-network loss on the 33-bus system, demonstrating that certified penetration is topology-specific and demands decision-level auditing, independent certification, and feeder-specific validation.

0.24

Probability-Layer Clustering for Bound-and-Budget Calibration in Multi-Bound Robust Bidding of Renewable-Based Virtual Power Plants

eess.SY ·2026-10-30 ·Hadi Nemati, Álvaro Ortega, Enrique Lobato, Luis Rouco
benchmark similarity 0.49
Abstract

RVPPs that aggregate dispatchable and non-dispatchable renewable energy sources, storage, and flexible demand that bid in the day-ahead and secondary reserve markets must cope with uncertainties in market prices, renewable generation, and demand. MBRO is well suited to this setting because it hedges adverse realizations through several deviation layers while keeping the final bidding problem as a tractable, scenario-free MILP. Its performance, however, depends on how the deviation bounds and uncertainty budgets are calibrated. Existing MBRO implementations commonly rely on fixed percentile-based bounds and externally specified budget vectors, usually examined through sensitivity analysis. This paper proposes PL-MBRO, that constructs parameter-specific deviation bounds from historical data conditional on selected risk-attitude quantiles and automatically derives the corresponding uncertainty budgets from empirical cluster probabilities. For each uncertain parameter, k-medians clustering partitions the historical daily profiles into representative probability layers; the cluster median defines the balanced representative, while favorable and adverse within-cluster percentiles define the optimistic and pessimistic representatives. The empirical cluster probabilities are mapped to integer full-horizon uncertainty budgets over the 96 quarter-hourly periods, while the robust inner problem determines the periods in which the corresponding deviation layers are most adverse to the schedule. Compared with a percentilebased MBRO benchmark, in-sample and out-of-sample tests on an RVPP bidding in both markets show that PL-MBRO consistently achieves better realized economic outcomes across the optimistic, balanced, and pessimistic strategies, with improvements of up to 92.7% in-sample and 57.3% out-of-sample, measured relative to the absolute value of the corresponding benchmark realized profit.

0.30