CS Paper Radar

The Logic of Emergence

David H. Wolpert, David C. Krakauer

cs.LO math.LOphysics.hist-ph ·submitted 2026-11-04 15:20 UTC · v2

Abstract

``Emergence'' refers to the fact that different mathematical languages and theories seem to be required to describe scientific theories that operate at different spatial and temporal scales. Highly circumscribed, special cases of emergence have been investigated using many different formal tools, including coarse-graining (over space and / or time), renormalization, dimension reduction, broken symmetry, and various formulations of causality. Here we extend the mathematics of model theory to unify and extend these earlier investigations. As a preliminary application of our framework, we investigate canonical examples of emergence, including the emergence of genetics from chemistry, of psychology from neurobiology, and of different forms of collective behavior from the laws governing their constituent parts. By exploiting the power of model theory we also uncover many aspects of emergence that were previously obscured. In particular, we uncover some of the rich hierarchical structure that relates different scientific fields. For example, we show that scientific fields can be related via a collection of multiple partial orders, all defined over the same set. On the other hand, under an alternative relation among scientific fields, one which allows cycles, we show that it is possible that the set of all of scientific fields must collapse into a single scientific field. Going forward, these investigations point to the formal tools that might need to be developed in order to arrive at a deeper understanding of this emergent hierarchy of scientific reality.

Comment
52 pages, 44 pages main text, 3 figures

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Emergence in Network Systems is Bounded by Boundary-Crossing Paths

cs.SI physics.soc-phnlin.AO ·2026-09-29 ·Johnny Jingze Li, Gabriel A. Silva
similarity 0.59
Abstract

Emergence, features of a whole that no part shows alone, is central to complex systems but rarely measured so as to locate its source. Viewing a system structurally, as a network of interacting parts, we evaluate emergence as what observing the coupled whole reveals beyond, or erases from, the combined observations of the parts. For observations that build what they see route by route, we show that every emergent feature is produced by its own route across the interface between parts, a route that traces it to the components and interactions responsible. We show the number of all such boundary-crossing paths bounds the total emergence discrepancy, and equals the emergence of measures that count routes. The bound is computed locally around the interface, validated through network examples, and in a nervous system the routes show that interneurons relay most of the emergence. Our work associates emergence with path structure in the network system that can be anticipated, attributed, and engineered.

0.33

Can Network Models of Science Do Without Pluralist Agents?

cs.MA cs.AI ·2026-11-03 ·Jonas Hallgren, David Hyland, Mahault Albarracin
similarity 0.56
Abstract · 21 pages, 6 figures, 1 table. Accepted at IWAI 2026 (International Workshop on Active Inference)

Science is a process of useful models being proven wrong time and again, but despite its many flaws, it somehow works. Why is this? Paul Feyerabend argued that it works because people dare to hold and defend incompatible rival theories against the accepted one, since a theory's failures often lead to its abandonment in the presence of a more accurate or simpler alternative. He called this view theoretical pluralism. We introduce a theoretical and experimental model in which this can be examined. It compares communities of pluralist agents, which can hold rival theories side by side and maintain beliefs within and between those theories, with communities of monist agents, which can only incorporate what they hear or observe into a single model of their own. In a multi-agent variational inference setting, our experimental demonstrations illustrate how communities with rival theories can go through periods of uncertainty followed by a shift in the theories they hold true, how the information that is communicated between communities affects beliefs when those communities make different observations about the world, and how sharing support for theories and sharing beliefs within them contribute differently to collective belief dynamics.

0.35

From Maps to Metabolism: Historical Precedents and a Unified Critique of Computationalism

cs.AI q-bio.NC ·2026-10-23 ·J. Mark Bishop, Slawomir J. Nasuto
similarity 0.54
Abstract

Alexander Lerchner's recent work on the 'abstraction fallacy' argues that computational functionalism confuses physical processes with abstract descriptions, and that symbolic computation alone cannot instantiate consciousness. Yet these claims were anticipated by Korzybski's map-territory distinction, Searle's critique of strong artificial intelligence, Floridi's levels of abstraction, Spencer et al.'s observer-relativity arguments, Winograd and Flores's account of computation as socially grounded practice, and Nasuto and Bishop's biological arguments. Synthesizing these contributions, this paper advances a form of non-computational physicalism: consciousness depends upon intrinsically organized, metabolically grounded physical dynamics rather than abstract computation, whilst leaving open the possibility of artificial consciousness. An objection is that this critique targets an outdated computationalism. Mechanistic computationalism, associated with Milkowski, Piccinini, Craver, Bechtel, and Kaplan, treats computation as a property of physically realized mechanisms rather than substrate-independent formalism. Although this represents an important advance, it does not dissolve the abstraction fallacy. Computational attributions remain dependent upon choices of state individuation, system boundaries, and interpretive mapping that are not determined by physical facts alone. Kaplan and Craver's 'model-to-mechanism mapping' constrains computational descriptions without eliminating their dependence upon an external observer. Grounding computation in neural mechanisms does not confer intrinsic significance or the normativity explored by Bickhard and Nasuto and Bishop. The abstraction fallacy persists wherever computational descriptions are treated as constitutive of, rather than descriptive of, physical reality.

0.24

Statistical Dark Matter: Synergy is everywhere but is hard to capture

cs.IT physics.data-an ·2026-09-27 ·Alberto Liardi, Fernando E. Rosas, Daniele Marinazzo, Thomas F. Varley, Michael Gastpar +1 more
unusual similarity 0.53
Abstract

The information-theoretic construct of synergy refers to the statistical structure that is contained in three or more variables, but not in any subset of them. Here we leverage recent advances in multivariate information theory to show that synergy is far more prevalent in complex systems than previously thought. In particular, we show that many-body systems tend to become strongly dominated by synergy as the number of subcomponents grows. At the same time, our results also reveal that commonly used tools for statistical modelling severely underestimate synergistic structures. These findings imply that synergy constitutes a prevalent, yet often invisible, informational component of complex systems. With a certain poetic licence, we interpret these results as suggesting that synergy is the dark matter of statistics - interdependencies that we know exist, but standard instruments fail to detect.

0.48

Physical Law Ecology: mapping multi-mechanism ecologies as the zeroth step of data-driven scientific discovery

cs.SC astro-ph.GAphysics.comp-ph ·2026-09-08 ·Xiongheng Bian, Xiangyu Cui, Ma Feng, Xiaoyan Shen
similarity 0.52
Abstract

Every data-driven equation discovery method assumes (implicitly and without verification) that the target system obeys a single governing law ($K{=}1$). Here we show that this assumption is the primary bottleneck limiting scientific discovery in multi-mechanism systems, and introduce Physical Law Ecology, a framework that makes $K^*$ (the number of coexisting independent mechanisms) itself the first quantity to be determined from data. The framework automatically mines a pool of topologically distinct candidate equations, constructs a continuous dominance weight field across parameter space, and discovers analytic evolution laws governing mechanism succession---with optional monotonicity constraints encoding irreversible physics. Across four unrelated systems (elastomer mechanics, pool boiling, galactic dynamics, and droplet evaporation), BIC consistently identifies $K^*{=}3$ independent governing topologies. Applied to 163 SPARC galaxies (3,269 spatially resolved measurements), the framework autonomously recovers three gravitational laws whose coexistence provides evidence against the single-universal-acceleration hypothesis of MOND ($p<10^{-34}$). In engineering applications, multi-law weighted prediction reduces error by 67-72\% over single-equation baselines while retaining full interpretability. By establishing the determination of $K^*$ as the zeroth step of scientific discovery-prior to and independent of equation search---this work opens a direction orthogonal to existing symbolic regression: not finding better equations, but mapping the ecology of mechanisms that govern complex systems.

0.26

Causal-fate dynamics of unrealized influence

eess.SY cs.LG ·2026-10-08 ·Yiwei Liu, Luwei Yang, Shunbo Lei
code/data similarity 0.52
Abstract · 39 pages (20-page main text and 19-page Supplementary Information), 6 figures, 14 supplementary tables. Code: https://github.com/Hotaru366/c…

Many dynamical systems generate influences whose consequences are not fully exhausted in the realized trajectory at the moment they arise. Such consequences are often treated as absent, delayed or statically stored, leaving unclear how unrealized influence retains future relevance as the system evolves. Here we formulate causal-fate dynamics, in which generated influence may be realized, remain latent, or be transformed by subsequent dynamics, and give an exact finite-transport representation when the relevant maps are specified. A connectome-constrained Caenorhabditis elegans model first motivates the biological hypothesis that unresolved inter-neuronal influence may persist and contribute to later propagation; it does not establish such a mechanism in living animals. We next examine operational Internet routing, where a dynamically updated cross-observer history retains predictive information beyond the current local route state. We then use the representation to construct a Transformer architecture that explicitly transports and selectively realizes latent contextual influence while retaining language-modeling function. The three studies distinguish a model-motivated scientific hypothesis, an observational phenomenon compatible with future-relevant history and an executable construction for carrying unrealized influence through subsequent computation.

0.39

Latent geometry organizes higher-order interactions

cs.SI physics.soc-ph ·2026-09-07 ·Berné L. Nortier, Jasper van der Kolk, Robert Jankowski, Simon Dobson, M. Ángeles Serrano +2 more
similarity 0.51
Abstract · Main: 11 pages, 4 figures. Supplemental material: 18 pages, 6 figures

Higher-order structures offer a natural representation of complex systems that involve interactions between groups of different sizes. A widespread feature of their higher-order structure is nestedness, whereby interactions involving smaller groups are contained within larger ones. Yet, why interactions of different orders organise into nested structures remains largely unexplained. Here, we introduce an analytically tractable geometric model of higher-order networks in which a single latent geometric space couples interactions across orders, leading to the spontaneous emergence of nestedness. We show analytically and numerically that nestedness undergoes a transition between a nested geometric regime, where it remains finite in the thermodynamic limit, and a regime where it vanishes with system size. In this regime, we uncover a weakly geometric range characterized by an anomalously slow finite-size decay, allowing substantial nestedness to persist in finite systems even when its asymptotic value vanishes. Finally, with a single geometric coupling parameter, the model reproduces the nestedness profiles observed in real-world hypergraphs across different domains. Our results reveal latent geometry as a simple organising principle underlying the nested organisation of higher-order interactions.

0.30

A Human-AI Theorem Connecting Spontaneous and Field-Induced Mechanisms of Collective Behavior in One Dimension

cs.AI cond-mat.stat-mechcs.HCmath-ph ·2026-08-31 ·Weiguo Yin
theory similarity 0.51
Abstract · 17 pages (extended from 12 pages), 3 figures, 2 tables; added the link and message-level citations to the human-AI conversation transcript […

Can an artificial intelligence (AI) generate a scientific hypothesis outside a human collaborator's active hypothesis space (AHS), and can human-AI research be organized to make such breakthroughs more likely? We document such a case while proving a theorem that connects two basic organizing mechanisms of statistical physics: collective behavior arising in zero field from competing interactions and that induced or controlled by an external field. A zero-field $O(n)$-vector open chain with arbitrary inhomogeneous nearest- and next-nearest-neighbor interaction functions $U_i(S_i\cdot{S}_{i+1})$ and $V_i(S_i\cdot{S}_{i+2})$ is microscopically, via a temperature-independent mapping at the Hamiltonian level, equivalent to a simpler $O(n)$ open chain with nearest-neighbor interaction $V_i(\boldsymbolσ_i\cdot\boldsymbolσ_{i+1})$ and axial single-spin potential $U_i(σ_i^z)$ for every integer $n\ge1$ and every system size $L\ge1$. The homogeneous linear specialization maps the foundational frustrated $J_1$-$J_2$ model onto the canonical $J$-$h$ field model---with $n=1,2,3$ being the Ising, XY, and Heisenberg classical spin models, respectively; the theorem resolved a longstanding challenge for $n=3$ published in 1990. Its proof was done with an AI-synthesized recursive Householder moving frame and understood via a human-recognized hidden reciprocity. An analogous theorem holds when the continuous $O(n)$ spins are replaced by the $q$-state Potts spins, implying a closed-form exact solution of the $J_1$-$J_2$ standard Potts open chain for every $q\ge2$ and every $L\ge1$. The emergence of these theorems from a human-AI co-development framework suggests that sustained AI involvement throughout a systematic research program may incubate autonomous scientific breakthroughs and make aspects of the discovery process experimentally testable.

0.29