CS Paper Radar

From Maps to Metabolism: Historical Precedents and a Unified Critique of Computationalism

J. Mark Bishop, Slawomir J. Nasuto

cs.AI q-bio.NC ·submitted 2026-10-23 16:49 UTC · v1

Abstract

Alexander Lerchner's recent work on the 'abstraction fallacy' argues that computational functionalism confuses physical processes with abstract descriptions, and that symbolic computation alone cannot instantiate consciousness. Yet these claims were anticipated by Korzybski's map-territory distinction, Searle's critique of strong artificial intelligence, Floridi's levels of abstraction, Spencer et al.'s observer-relativity arguments, Winograd and Flores's account of computation as socially grounded practice, and Nasuto and Bishop's biological arguments. Synthesizing these contributions, this paper advances a form of non-computational physicalism: consciousness depends upon intrinsically organized, metabolically grounded physical dynamics rather than abstract computation, whilst leaving open the possibility of artificial consciousness. An objection is that this critique targets an outdated computationalism. Mechanistic computationalism, associated with Milkowski, Piccinini, Craver, Bechtel, and Kaplan, treats computation as a property of physically realized mechanisms rather than substrate-independent formalism. Although this represents an important advance, it does not dissolve the abstraction fallacy. Computational attributions remain dependent upon choices of state individuation, system boundaries, and interpretive mapping that are not determined by physical facts alone. Kaplan and Craver's 'model-to-mechanism mapping' constrains computational descriptions without eliminating their dependence upon an external observer. Grounding computation in neural mechanisms does not confer intrinsic significance or the normativity explored by Bickhard and Nasuto and Bishop. The abstraction fallacy persists wherever computational descriptions are treated as constitutive of, rather than descriptive of, physical reality.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

From cacophony to hierarchy: a principled framework for assessing AI consciousness

cs.AI cs.CY ·2026-09-28 ·Shamil Chandaria, Arvo Muñoz Morán, Fernando Rosas, Anil Seth, Henry Shevlin +9 more
code/data similarity 0.60
Abstract · 150 pages, 43 figures, 6 tables. Interactive tool: https://ai-cognition.org/cacophony-tool/ ; code: https://github.com/arvomm/cacophony-publ…

The question of AI consciousness is one of the most urgent pre-emptive problems in philosophy and computer science, yet progress is hampered by a cacophony of competing theories that often talk past each other. Separating the hard problem from the mapping problem allows the deepest metaphysical disagreements to be set aside: granting that experience supervenes on a system's organisation, the tractable question becomes at which grain of description that supervenience base sits. We extend Marr's three levels of analysis into a five-level hierarchy of functional descriptions (behavioural, computational, intrinsic causal-structural, organismic, and organism-environment) grounded in supervenience, coarse-graining, and multiple realisability. The major theories of consciousness are positioned within this hierarchy according to which level they take to be critical, and for each level we develop operationalisable indicators and assess current AI systems against them. A Bayesian model then combines theoretical credences with indicator evidence into an overall credence in a system's capacity for consciousness. In illustrative assessments, the verdict for current LLMs is driven as much by where theoretical credence is placed as by how the evidence is read: under different stipulated readings and credence distributions, assessments range from below 0.01 to roughly 0.8, showing sensitivity to assumptions. Finally, the consciousness indicators at each level closely overlap with the architectural features needed for general intelligence, suggesting that increasingly capable AI may become a stronger candidate for consciousness. The framework supports a structured agnosticism, in which theoretical commitments are made explicit, credences are updated as evidence accumulates, and assessments take the form of aggregated probabilities rather than verdicts.

0.62

Conscious Access as Continuous-to-Discrete Translation

cs.SC q-bio.NC ·2026-08-21 ·Tianming Yang
position similarity 0.60
Abstract

The scientific study of consciousness frequently stalls on ontological debates regarding the "Hard Problem." This paper proposes a pragmatic pivot. Rather than asking what consciousness is metaphysically, we ask how modeling conscious access as a specific computational transformation may address existing bottlenecks in neuroscience and artificial intelligence. We introduce the Continuous/Discrete (C/D) framework, which holds that the brain implements two distinct processing regimes: System C, a distributed sensory-motor network operating over continuous, high-dimensional manifolds, and System D, a centralized engine structured around discrete, scale-invariant symbols. We argue that conscious access requires a structure-preserving translation between these regimes, which maps localized continuous states onto discrete symbolic tokens, coupled with an inverse projection that grounds those tokens back into sensorimotor dynamics. By formalizing conscious access as this continuous-to-discrete conversion, we derive a unified set of testable predictions centered on representational geometry, specifically, on a measurable collapse from graded similarity structures to low-dimensional categorical equivalence classes. These predictions explicitly differentiate our account from Global Neuronal Workspace Theory, Integrated Information Theory, Predictive Processing, and Higher-Order Theories, shifting the focus from ontological status to computational mechanism. Beyond neuroscience, the framework provides a principled architecture for neuro-symbolic artificial intelligence. We argue that treating conscious access as translational computation offers a pragmatic, empirically tractable pathway forward, clarifying what conscious states functionally accomplish without requiring resolution of the hard problem of phenomenology.

0.21

Why machines will still not rule the world

cs.AI ·2026-10-08 ·Jobst Landgrebe, Barry Smith
position similarity 0.57
Abstract

In our book Why machines will never rule the world [13, 14] we argue that arti- ficial general intelligence is mathematically impossible. This is because the human beings and the processes which exhibit intelligence are complex systems whose be- haviour cannot be captured by the kinds of models that we can generate with or without computers. Proponents of contemporary machine intelligence respond with two lines of argument: a theoretical one, grounded in the universal approximation theorems for neural networks and the Church-Turing-Deutsch principle; and an em- pirical one, grounded in rapidly rising scores on standardized benchmarks. In this communication we examine and reject both responses. First, we show serious issues in the physicalist counter-argument based on the Church-Turing-Deutsch principle. Second, we review recent evidence to the effect that prominent benchmarks are compromised by training-data contamination, flawed test construction, and strate- gic optimization. Our central argument remains: That models required to perform cognitive behaviour in open-ended, thermodynamically complex and non-ergodic environments are not and will not become achievable.

0.24

Quo Vadis? Scientific Discovery in the Age of Artificial Intelligence

cs.CY ·2026-08-18 ·Petr O. Jedlicka
publishedsurvey similarity 0.57
Abstract · To be published in Theory of Science

This paper examines the growing role of AI in scientific discovery. It first surveys the rapid rise of AI capabilities, especially in reasoning, abstraction, planning, and long-horizon task execution, before turning to scientometric evidence of AI's diffusion across the sciences. It then proposes a typology of AI systems used in research, ranging from specialized scientific AI through scientific AI assistants and agents to hybrid experimental systems that combine computation and physical experimentation. On this basis, it offers a selective overview of recent achievements in mathematics and computer science, physics, chemistry, the life sciences, and the behavioural and social sciences. It argues that, despite these advances, current systems remain constrained by important technical, epistemic, and institutional limitations, and that their growing use introduces both near-term and longer-term risks. The conclusion further suggests that the advancement of AI in science raises broader questions concerning the division of cognitive labour between human researchers and machines.

0.26

Sensing to Intelligence: Principles for Neuromorphic Circuits and Systems

cs.NE ·2026-09-19 ·Saptarshi Maiti, Chetan Singh Thakur
position similarity 0.55
Abstract

Neuromorphic engineering began with the idea that the physical behavior of a system could itself be used for computation, taking inspiration from the way nervous systems sense, adapt, and evolve in time. The field has since expanded far beyond its early analog circuits to include event-based sensors, spiking processors, emerging memory devices, mixed-signal systems, and large-scale neural accelerators. With this expansion, however, the meaning of neuromorphic has become increasingly broad. In this Perspective, we argue that neuromorphic engineering should be defined neither by resemblance to biological components nor by any particular device, signal representation, or substrate. Its potential lies in identifying computational principles in biological systems and translating them into the organization and dynamics of artificial machines. A system is truly neuromorphic when the invoked biological or physical principle plays a causal, design-relevant role in how information is represented, how state evolves, or what capability the complete system achieves. We develop this view across sensing, collective computation, memory, learning, and interaction. Adaptation, nonlinear dynamics, attractor structure, variability, and closed-loop action illustrate how computation can be embedded in a machine's evolving physical state. From these examples, we identify a set of design principles for neuromorphic systems. As neuromorphic engineering moves toward wider deployment, this perspective shifts the central question from how closely machines resemble nervous systems to what computation becomes possible when their principles are understood and deliberately translated into new machines.

0.23

The Logic of Emergence

cs.LO math.LOphysics.hist-ph ·2026-11-04 ·David H. Wolpert, David C. Krakauer
similarity 0.54
Abstract · 52 pages, 44 pages main text, 3 figures

``Emergence'' refers to the fact that different mathematical languages and theories seem to be required to describe scientific theories that operate at different spatial and temporal scales. Highly circumscribed, special cases of emergence have been investigated using many different formal tools, including coarse-graining (over space and / or time), renormalization, dimension reduction, broken symmetry, and various formulations of causality. Here we extend the mathematics of model theory to unify and extend these earlier investigations. As a preliminary application of our framework, we investigate canonical examples of emergence, including the emergence of genetics from chemistry, of psychology from neurobiology, and of different forms of collective behavior from the laws governing their constituent parts. By exploiting the power of model theory we also uncover many aspects of emergence that were previously obscured. In particular, we uncover some of the rich hierarchical structure that relates different scientific fields. For example, we show that scientific fields can be related via a collection of multiple partial orders, all defined over the same set. On the other hand, under an alternative relation among scientific fields, one which allows cycles, we show that it is possible that the set of all of scientific fields must collapse into a single scientific field. Going forward, these investigations point to the formal tools that might need to be developed in order to arrive at a deeper understanding of this emergent hierarchy of scientific reality.

0.38

An information-geometric formulation of distributed computation

cs.IT ·2026-11-02 ·Alberto Liardi, George Blackburne, Pedro A. M. Mediano
similarity 0.54
Abstract · 16 pages, 6 figures + supplementary material

Understanding how complex systems perform computations, i.e. how they store, transmit, and transform information across their components, is a major goal across the natural sciences. However, characterising genuinely collective computations across multiple inputs and outputs that cannot be reduced to contributions from individual components remains an open problem. In this work, we introduce $Φ\text{ID}^{IG}$, a geometric theory of information dynamics that captures irreducible collective phenomena and enables a complete decomposition of multi-input multi-output operations into interpretable computational modes, providing a complete informational profile of a system. We first validate our framework to identify and quantify distinct computational modes in discrete and Gaussian systems with known ground truth. We then apply it to uncover the computational architecture of complex systems across synthetic and real-world scenarios, including chaotic maps, where distinct universality classes are associated with characteristic modes of computation; brain anatomy of over 100 mammalian species, revealing an evolutionary shift towards more distributed computation in the human neocortex; and financial markets, where collective computations recover the modular organisation of market sectors. Overall, our results show how complex systems can be quantitatively investigated through multidimensional computational portraits derived from the geometry of their underlying probability distributions.

0.28

From S3Q Theory to Implementation: Towards an Architecture for Machine Qualia

cs.AI ·2026-09-25 ·Tetiana Grinberg, Katrina Schleisman, Patryk Laurent, Bogdan Udrea, Minda Myers +4 more
similarity 0.53
Abstract

A key challenge in machine consciousness research is translating theoretical models into computational-level implementations. In this paper, we address this challenge by proposing a five-layer implementation architecture for the S3Q (Simulated, Situated, Structurally Coherent) theory of consciousness. Rather than introducing novel formalisms, the architecture composes published computational primitives into a single pipeline. S3Q identifies three jointly necessary conditions for qualia: (1) grounded sensorimotor situatedness, (2) internal simulation via a world model, and (3) structural coherence between predictions and observations. No existing computational system implements all three simultaneously. We map each S3Q tenet to specific, compatible computational machinery and specify how these components interface within a single representation pipeline that operates on continuous, differentiable, per-object slot vectors, along with a developmental bootstrap sequence and falsifiable predictions for the composed system that no subset of the architecture produces in isolation. The model suggests that a basic sense of "self" develops by linking actions to their outcomes, and that behavior falls into three patterns (hesitation, curiosity, or avoidance) depending on how unexpected an outcome is and whether it is experienced as positive or negative. Each prediction is individually falsifiable, providing the field with a testable framework to advance our understanding of machine consciousness.

0.23