CS Paper Radar

The determinantal complexity of the 4*4 permanent is 15

Karthik Sheshadri

cs.CC ·submitted 2026-11-04 15:34 UTC · v1
theory

Abstract

The best known lower bound on the determinantal complexity of the 4x4 permanent is 10. In this short note, I prove that this value is exactly 15: the 4x4 permanent is the determinant of a 15x15 matrix of affine linear forms, and cannot be that of any smaller matrix. To do so, I must establish both a lower and upper bound. To establish the upper bound, I use Grenet's construction of size 2^n-1. Hence that construction is optimal at n=4 (and n=3). This now constitutes the first knwon exact value of the determinantal complexity of the permanent at n=4. Only the value at n=3 was exactly known, prior to this note. The general quadratic bound only gives 8 for n=4. To establish the lower bound, I work from a normal form at a zero of the permanent. In the first row (and column) of the normal form, the linear forms vanish on a linear space inside the singular locus of the permanent. A hessian inequality bounds the size of the matrix in terms of that space. Then, a matrix of sie 14 foces the space into any of nine corordinate types. The forcing is either up to symmetry, or else into a family that degenerates to one of them. I then rule out every case. All involved computations are exact. In respect of the claim, I have made all certificates public.

Comment
8 pages

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Cubic lower bounds for the permanent in odd characteristic, for Pfaffian representations, and for polynomial entries

cs.CC math.AC ·2026-10-29 ·Karthik Sheshadri
theory similarity 0.66
Abstract · 18 pages; stand-alone; submitted to International Mathematical Research Notices

The determinantal complexity of a polynomial is the order of the smallest matrix whose entries are polynomials of degree at most one and whose determinant equals the polynomial. A lower bound for the permanent in this measure is the algebraic form of the question whether the permanent is harder to compute than the determinant. Over the complex numbers, the best known lower bound grows cubically in the size of the permanent. It holds even when the permanent only has to be a limit of such determinants. I prove that the cubic lower bound holds over every algebraically closed field of odd characteristic $p$, with a constant that depends on $p$. Hence the cubic bound does not depend on characteristic zero. I also prove the bound for Pfaffians, which are square roots of determinants of skew symmetric matrices. Lower bounds for Pfaffians imply the same bounds for determinants. Further, I prove the bound, divided by $a$, for matrices whose entries are polynomials of degree at most $a$. All three results come from one lower bound for smooth hypersurfaces. I prove it in every characteristic by counting intersection points together with their multiplicities.

0.28

Determinant boundaries and gaps in determinantal complexity

cs.CC ·2026-11-02 ·Karthik Sheshadri
theory similarity 0.60
Abstract · 75 pages, in submission to FoCM

Landsberg, Manivel, and Ressayre constructed determinant-boundary components whose defining forms, for odd n >= 3, are limits of n x n determinants but cannot themselves be represented by determinants of that size. Their border determinantal complexity (DC) is therefore smaller than their exact DC. We prove that the difference can grow linearly with n. For every n >= 10, we construct an explicit homogeneous form of degree n, concise in n^2 variables, whose orbit closure is a boundary component, whose border DC is n, and whose exact DC is at least 2n - 1. Thus n rows suffice when limits are allowed, whereas every exact representation requires at least 2n - 1 rows. The same bound holds for the unpadded odd-skew forms at every odd n >= 3. We also prove that every concise degree-n boundary form in n^2 variables has exact DC at least n + 2. We construct three families of pairwise distinct boundary components. Together with the traceless determinant, they give at least floor((n-1)/2) + floor(n/3) components for every n >= 3, with an additional term counted explicitly in the paper. The main lower bound follows from a general degree lemma. If an affine matrix represents an irreducible homogeneous polynomial f of degree d and has globally free rank-one cokernel over the coordinate ring of f = 0, its size is at least 2d - 1. The adjugate factors into two nonzero kernel vectors, each requiring a coordinate of degree at least d - 1. Comparing their product with the degree of a cofactor proves the bound. The lemma is sharp for individual representations, as witnessed by algebraic branching programs. Whether the exact-versus-border gap can grow superlinearly remains open.

0.32

A Quadratic Lower Bound on Determinantal Complexity

cs.CC math.ACmath.AG ·2026-09-28 ·Mrinal Kumar, Ben Lee Volk
publishedtheory similarity 0.60
Abstract

We prove an $Ω(n^2)$ lower bound on the determinantal complexity of the power sum polynomial $\sum_{i=1}^n x_i^n$ over the field of complex numbers. A similar result was claimed in a recent paper of Sheshadri (arXiv:2606.13628), via an AI-assisted and AI-written proof. Assuming its correctness, this was the first super-linear lower bound for this fundamental algebraic problem for any explicit polynomial. However, the authors of this note were unable to follow the details and verify the argument in arXiv:2606.13628, in spite of considerable effort on their part. The proof we provide here is short, (almost) self-contained and seemingly simpler.

0.60

An $n^2\log\log n$ Lower Bound for Permanent Circuits with Valid Division

cs.CC math.AG ·2026-08-26 ·Jizhou Guo
theoryhot direction similarity 0.58
Abstract · 14 pages. Version 2: the passage to valid division is credited to Strassen and Baur-Strassen (version 1 presented it as new); refines the cr…

We record lower bounds for permanent circuits with valid division over characteristic zero, counting nonscalar multiplications and divisions while additions and scalar operations are free. Chapter 5 of OpenAI's Ten Advances supplies the block construction and critical-locus estimate; these, with the parameter choice made here and the classical bounds of Strassen and Baur-Strassen, give liminf as n tends to infinity of L_div(per_n)/(n^2 log_2 log_2 n) >= 1/12. Our finite-parameter refinement for matching-minor polynomials observes that the coefficient vector at deletion size h lies in a space of dimension at most min{binom(t,h), binom(t,d-h)}. Twelve machine-checked declarations of the Lean development accompanying OpenAI's manuscript on border determinantal complexity of the permanent (September 24, 2026) imply, by a short written argument, the existence of a geometric slice; a further written, unformalized application of the same criterion gives L_div(per_n) >= (n^2/119790) log_2(n/44) for n >= 1936. Assuming Proposition 7.3 of that manuscript gives the bound (n^2/86400) log_2(n/48) for n >= 1408. These are order-of-growth results; the elementary Hessian bound n^2/2 is larger at practical orders.

0.39

An $\widetilde{O}(n^3)$-time FPRAS for the Permanent

cs.DS cs.DMmath.COmath.PR ·2026-09-17 ·Xiaoyu Chen, Heng Guo, Eric Vigoda, Xiongxin Yang
theory similarity 0.57
Abstract · 62 pages

We give an FPRAS for the permanent of an $n\times n$ $0/1$ matrix with running time $\widetilde O(n^3)$. Our algorithm extends to a strongly polynomial FPRAS for arbitrary nonnegative matrices with the same running-time bound (but in the unit-cost arithmetic model). Jerrum, Sinclair, and Vigoda (2004) gave the first FPRAS for the permanent of a nonnegative matrix. The running time was subsequently improved to $\widetilde{O}(n^7)$ by Bezáková, Štefankovič, Vazirani, and Vigoda (2008), and recently to $\widetilde{O}(n^6)$ by Chen, Vigoda, and Yang (2026). We introduce a multicommodity-flow bound inspired by electrical flows, replacing the usual path-length factor by routing energy. For the classical JSV chain with perfect-matching weights multiplied by $n^2$, we prove a relaxation-time bound of $O(n^3\log n)$ and obtain comparable bounds for estimating the stationary probabilities of having a specified pair of unmatched vertices. We use a separate chain on assignments to generate a warm start at any given temperature, avoiding the long initialization of the JSV chain. Finally, we replace the JSV chain with a new chain that uses only $n$ hole weights and speeds up hole-weight learning by a factor of $n$.

0.20

Beyond the Bethe Approximation of the Permanent

cs.DS math.CO ·2026-08-28 ·Nima Anari
theorycode/data similarity 0.57
Abstract · 34 pages. Accompanying Lean 4 formalization: https://github.com/nimaanari/formalization-beyond-bethe. Palomar Registry entry: https://paloma…

The canonical Bethe approximation gives a deterministic approximation to the permanent of every nonnegative matrix within a factor of $(\sqrt{2})^n$. We improve the base of this exponential factor: for some absolute constant $c<\sqrt{2}$, there is a deterministic polynomial-time $c^n$-approximation for the permanent of every nonnegative matrix. This shows that the canonical Bethe guarantee is not a barrier for deterministic approximation of the permanent. The proof augments the Bethe lower bound with a new certificate tailored to matrices on which that lower bound loses nearly the full factor. The author supplied the high-level plan of attack, and the proof was developed in an interaction with ChatGPT 5.6 Sol Pro. The author subsequently verified the results. Codex assisted with proof checking, manuscript assembly, and typesetting.

0.67

Subexponential Approximation of the Permanent in Deterministic Polynomial Time

cs.DS cs.CCmath.CO ·2026-09-09 ·Sergei Kudria, Jason Luo, Mahbod Majid
theory similarity 0.56
Abstract · 44 pages

We give the first deterministic polynomial time algorithm that approximates the permanent of arbitrary nonnegative rational matrices within a subexponential factor. For a matrix of order $n$, the approximation factor is \[ \exp\!\left(O\!\left(\frac{n(\log\log n)^2}{\log n}\right)\right)=\exp(o(n)). \] All previously known deterministic polynomial time guarantees for unrestricted inputs had approximation factors $\exp(Ω(n))$. Our proof uses convex optimization to tighten an upper bound on the permanent. The bound is based on weighted sums over all matchings in a bipartite graph representing the matrix, and correlations between unmatched vertices control its error. We approximate these sums deterministically using correlation decay and a bound on the effect of vertex deletion.

0.45

An integer determinant approach to the length of Type II codes and the weights of shadows

cs.IT ·2026-10-22 ·Jae-Hyun Baek, Jon-Lark Kim
theory similarity 0.56
Abstract · 10 pages

It is well known that the length $n$ of a binary Type II code is divisible by $8$. The classical proof relies on Gleason's theorem on weight enumerators. Motivated by a question of Vera Pless, we give elementary proofs of this fact that avoid invariant theory. Our main tool is a congruence modulo $8$ for the determinant of the integer Gram matrix $AA^{\mathsf T}$ of a binary orthogonal matrix $A$, obtained directly from the Leibniz expansion. It gives a short proof of a theorem of Janusz: the number of rows of weight congruent to $3 \pmod 4$ in a binary orthogonal matrix is divisible by $4$. From this single statement we derive both the length restriction for Type II codes and the theorem of Conway and Sloane that every vector in the shadow of a binary self-dual code of length $n$ has weight congruent to $n/2 \pmod 4$. We also give two short character-theoretic proofs of the length restriction and explain how all of these arguments detect the Arf invariant of a quadratic form.

0.30