CS Paper Radar

Tight Worst-Case Completion-Time Bounds for Dominant Resource Fairness

Mugen Blue, Sungjin Im, Alexander Lindermayr

cs.DS ·submitted 2026-11-05 12:23 UTC · v1
theory

Abstract

Dominant Resource Fairness (DRF) is an influential policy for sharing multiple resources among jobs with heterogeneous demands. It combines sharing incentive, strategy-proofness, envy-freeness, and Pareto efficiency, making it particularly attractive for shared computing systems. DRF has been implemented in major resource-management frameworks, including Apache Mesos and Hadoop YARN. DRF is also nonclairvoyant: it requires no advance knowledge of job sizes, making it practical when processing requirements are difficult to predict. This motivates understanding its completion-time performance relative to an optimal schedule that knows all job sizes. However, elementary arguments can only give an $Ω(\sqrt D)$ lower bound and an $O(D)$ upper bound for total completion time, where $D$ is the number of resource types. In this paper, we close this gap by proving that DRF is $Θ(\sqrt D)$-competitive. More generally, for every fixed real $q\geq1$, we show that DRF is $Θ(D^{1/(q+1)})$-competitive for the $\ell_q$ norm of completion times, with larger $q$ placing greater emphasis on late-finishing jobs. These bounds hold with arbitrary release times. We also give a refined analysis of total completion time for small $D$.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

The Price of Strategyproofness in Fair Multi-Resource Allocation for Cloud Computing

cs.GT ·2026-09-29 ·Yunpeng Lou, Junjie Luo
publishedbenchmarktheory similarity 0.72
Abstract · Accepted to WINE 2026. Version 1 corresponds to the conference version; Version 2 includes improved results

We study fair and strategy-proof allocation of multiple divisible resources with Leontief utilities, motivated by cloud computing. The canonical mechanism, Dominant Resource Fairness (DRF), satisfies sharing incentive (SI), envy-freeness (EF), strategy-proofness (SP), and Pareto optimality (PO), but can be highly inefficient in terms of utilitarian social welfare. Under the classical approximation benchmark, no mechanism satisfying even one of SI, EF, and SP can improve on the trivial worst-case guarantee. We therefore adopt the recently introduced \emph{fair-ratio} benchmark, which compares a mechanism only with the welfare-maximizing allocation that itself satisfies SI and EF. For two resources, we first introduce Adaptive-Speed Fairness (ASF), a unified parametric framework that captures previous mechanisms as special or boundary cases. Every ASF mechanism satisfies SI, EF, and PO, and we derive a general sufficient condition that guarantees SP. Optimizing within this framework yields a strategy-proof mechanism with asymptotic fair-ratio $2/(2\sqrt{2}-1)\approx 1.094$, substantially improving the previous best guarantee $3-\sqrt{3}\approx1.268$. We complement this upper bound with a lower bound of $1.0789$ for all ASF mechanisms. To overcome this limitation, we introduce Corrected Resource Balancing (CRB), which uses the full resource-load structure together with a one-agent incentive correction. CRB satisfies SI, EF, SP, and PO and achieves fair-ratio at most $1+1/n$. Together with a general $1+Ω(1/n)$ lower bound, this establishes the optimal asymptotic order $1+Θ(1/n)$ for two resources. Finally, for every $m\ge3$, any deterministic mechanism satisfying SI and SP has fair-ratio exactly $m$. The same lower bound holds for randomized mechanisms satisfying ex-post SI and truthfulness in expectation.

0.25

Online Fair Division under Eligibility Constraints

cs.GT ·2026-10-06 ·Joes Biburger, Nicole Megow, Golnoosh Shahkarami
theory similarity 0.65
Abstract

We study fair division of indivisible items under eligibility constraints: each item may be assigned only to a subset of eligible agents. This model coincides with restricted assignment in scheduling, with agents as machines and items as jobs, and captures settings where work or resources must be split among parties with different capabilities. Eligibility makes the usual fairness benchmarks inadequate, as agents should not be measured against items they could never receive. We therefore use eligibility-aware versions of proportionality and envy-freeness, where an agent's proportional share splits each item equally among its eligible agents, and envy comparisons discount items the agents are not eligible for. Our main finding is a sharp chore--goods separation for proportionality. We focus on identical valuations: under arbitrary valuations, no online algorithm can guarantee even an $o(m)$-approximation for chores. For chores, Prop1 is achievable offline, whereas exact proportionality and proportionality up to any item are not. For online chores, the optimal approximation factor for Prop1 for deterministic algorithms is $Θ(\sqrt m)$, with the lower bound holding even for unit-size jobs. For goods, Prop1 is again achievable offline, but the tight online bound drops to $Θ(\log m)$. For envy-based fairness, the picture is different. Goods and chores are equivalent under eligibility-aware envy notions, while the choice of notion is decisive. Strong EF1 may fail to exist even offline and cannot be approximated online. In contrast, weak EF1 can be maintained online, while weak EFX separates offline from online. Together, these results give a systematic study of online proportional and envy-based fairness in restricted assignment and show which fairness guarantees remain achievable under eligibility constraints.

0.35

Fair Division Meets Scheduling: Approximately Envy-Free Interval Scheduling

cs.DS cs.GT ·2026-08-15 ·Sander Borst, Golnoosh Shahkarami, Rohit Vaish
benchmarktheory similarity 0.64
Abstract

We study interval scheduling from the perspective of fair allocation. There are $m$ identical machines and a set of intervals, each specified by a start time, an end time, and a nonnegative weight. A schedule assigns a subset of the intervals to the machines so that no two intervals on the same machine overlap, and the goal is to maximize the total weight of scheduled intervals. Viewing machines as agents and intervals as goods, we require the schedule to be envy-free up to one item (EF1), and we measure efficiency against the offline optimum without fairness. In the offline setting, we give an algorithm that computes an EF1 schedule whose loss is at most a factor of $3/2$ in the unweighted regime, and we prove lower bounds of $\frac{3m-2}{2m-1}$, approaching $3/2$, in both the unweighted and the unit-length weighted regimes, so the price of fairness is $3/2$ in the limit. In the online setting, intervals arrive in nondecreasing order of start times; an arriving interval must be accepted or rejected, rejections are irrevocable, and an accepted interval may be revoked, and lost, at any time before it ends. For the unweighted regime we present Greedy-Balanced, a simple algorithm that maintains EF1 at every point in time and is $(2-\tfrac{1}{m})$-competitive against the offline optimum without fairness, and we prove a matching lower bound for every deterministic algorithm; the optimal deterministic fair competitive ratio is thus exactly $2-\tfrac{1}{m}$. Experiments on real-world benchmark instances show that Greedy-Balanced performs well beyond its worst-case guarantee, with an observed ratio never exceeding $1.306$.

0.38

Bounding Queue Waits for Fair Scheduling of Bursty HPC Workloads via Hierarchical Algorithms

cs.DC ·2026-10-23 ·Karaen Senthilkumar, Suman Raj, Maxime Gonthier, Kyle Chard, Donpaul Stephens +1 more
hot direction similarity 0.64
Abstract · 12 pages, 9 figures, 4 tables

HPC clusters are shared among many projects, each holding an allocation of node-hours, and ensuring fairness is becoming harder. Foundation models workflows and automated pipelines have made job submissions bursty and concentrated among a few heavy users, so occasional users absorb queueing delays created by frequent ones, with no indication of how long their jobs will wait. Existing schedulers either forget past usage, protect only the job at the head of the queue, or assume that running jobs can be preempted. We propose HyDRA, a Hybrid Deadline and Ranking-Aware scheduler that enforces fairness among users while bounding the queue wait of every job. HyDRA assigns each job a deadline on arrival based on its size, the priorities of its project and user, the current backlog, and how far its project and user are from their entitled share. It ranks waiting jobs by a priority score that grows with waiting time, serves jobs close to their deadlines first, and backfills a job only when no deadline, or fairness limit is violated. We evaluate HyDRA on workloads derived from a year of ALCF Polaris job traces, against conventional schedulers and variants inspired by PCS, Themis, and the PBS job-sort formula used at ALCF. HyDRA achieves $2\times$ the project-level Jain's fairness of the best baseline, starts 47\% of jobs by their deadlines compared with at most 36\% for the baselines even for largest workloads, and lowers the 95th-\%ile bounded slowdown by 4.2$\times$ relative to the next best baseline, at a moderate cost in utilization.

0.38

Optimally Selecting Representative Agents from a Metric Space

cs.GT cs.LG ·2026-08-29 ·Benjamin Cookson, Eva Deltl, Yeeseok Oh
theory similarity 0.61
Abstract

This paper studies the problem of proportionally fair clustering, where the goal is to select $k$ ``centers'' from a metric space that fairly represent a set of agents who also lie in the metric space. Specifically, we focus on finding a clustering satisfying a fairness property known as the Droop core. In the practical special case in which the set of feasible center locations contains every agent location, the previous best-known result guaranteed a $(1 + \sqrt{2})$-approximation of the Droop core, while the best-known lower bound was $2$. In this paper, we show that this lower bound is tight and that a clustering in the $2$-Droop core always exists. Further, we show that such a clustering can be achieved by only selecting centers from locations in the metric space where an agent resides. We establish this using Scarf's theorem guaranteeing a nonempty core for balanced non-transferable utility games. This result has several interesting corollaries. Most notably, it resolves the $β$-plurality problem of Aronov et al. [2021] for general metric spaces. The main result of this paper was generated by $\mathtt{ChatGPT}$-$\mathtt{5.6}$-$\mathtt{Sol}$ through a series of interactions with the authors. The authors of this paper verified the generated proof and rewrote it for clarity.

0.27

Single-Machine Guarantees on Unrelated Machines and Beyond: Proportional Fairness for Nonclairvoyant Polytope Scheduling

cs.DS ·2026-10-23 ·Sven Jäger, Alexander Lindermayr, Bart Zondervan
theory similarity 0.61
Abstract · Shortened abstract

The Polytope Scheduling Problem (PSP) is a general framework for preemptive scheduling in which feasible instantaneous job allocations form a packing polytope. In the nonclairvoyant online setting, Proportional Fairness (PF), a practical allocation rule rooted in market theory, is the leading general-purpose algorithm. On a single machine, PF coincides with weighted Round-Robin, which is $2$-competitive for weighted completion time with uniform release dates (optimal for nonclairvoyant algorithms) and $(2+\varepsilon)$-speed $O(1/\varepsilon)$-competitive for weighted flow time. Known guarantees beyond a single machine are weaker. This raises a central question: Are these heterogeneous environments intrinsically harder than a single machine under nonclairvoyance? We show that they are not: PF retains both single-machine guarantees on the novel class of support-submodular polytopes, which includes unrelated machines and polymatroids. On unrelated machines, this refutes a belief (JACM'18, SODA'25) that PF is not $O(1)$-speed $O(1)$-competitive for weighted flow time. Our main technical contribution is an equivalent characterization: a polytope is support submodular if and only if, for all job weights, the optimal weighted completion time is concave in the processing requirements. This structural insight underlies both guarantees. For general PSP, the picture changes: we give the first lower bound above $2$, showing that every randomized nonclairvoyant algorithm has a competitive ratio of at least $2+10^{-5}$ for weighted completion time, even with uniform release dates. On the positive side, we substantially improve the best known guarantee for weighted completion time from $27$ (SICOMP'26) to $4$ via a new dual-fitting analysis of PF. For weighted flow time, we show that PF achieves the first $O(1)$-speed $O(1)$-competitive nonclairvoyant guarantee for graph scheduling.

0.27

Improved Impossibility Bounds for Maximin Share Allocations

cs.GT ·2026-09-14 ·Tomer Ezra, Tamar Garbuz
benchmarkhighly cited similarity 0.61
Abstract

The maximin share (MMS) is a central fairness benchmark for allocating indivisible items, but it need not be simultaneously attainable even under additive preferences. While extensive work has developed approximation guarantees, quantitative impossibility bounds have received comparatively little attention. We establish improved asymptotic and constant impossibility bounds for both goods and chores. For every sufficiently large number $n$ of agents, we construct additive goods instances in which every allocation gives some agent at most a $1-Ω((\log n)^{-2})$ fraction of her MMS. This strengthens the $1/n^4$ shortfall of Feige, Sapir, and Tauber (2021) to an inverse-polylogarithmic shortfall. For chores, we construct instances in which every allocation gives some agent cost at least a $1+Ω((\log n)^{-2})$ factor of her MMS. Consequently, for every fixed $\varepsilon>0$, guarantees of $1-O(n^{-\varepsilon})$ for goods and $1+O(n^{-\varepsilon})$ for chores are impossible. Both asymptotic constructions use $n+O(\log n)$ items. Together with concurrent existence results of Feige (2026), this determines the threshold $n+Θ(\log n)$ for guaranteed MMS existence under additive preferences, for both goods and chores. We also give four-agent, eleven-item instances that improve the universal impossibility bounds from $39/40$ to $20/21$ for goods and from $44/43$ to $31/30$ for chores.

0.40

Beating One Half for Online Bipartite Matching with Reusable Resources

cs.DS ·2026-10-01 ·Xiaohui Bei, Zhihao Gavin Tang, Wenhao Wu
benchmarktheory similarity 0.61
Abstract

We study online bipartite matching with unit-inventory reusable resources, where requests arrive in an adversarially fixed order, and each use of a resource makes it unavailable for an independent duration drawn from a resource-dependent distribution. The benchmark knows all requests in advance but cannot observe a duration before choosing the corresponding use. The classical Ranking algorithm of Karp, Vazirani, and Vazirani (STOC 1990) fixes a uniformly random priority order of the resources and matches each arriving request to its highest-priority available neighbor. It achieves the optimal competitive ratio $1-1/e$ for unweighted nonreusable resources, but whether it beats $1/2$ for reusable resources has remained open. We prove that, for unweighted resources with resource-dependent stochastic durations, Ranking achieves a competitive ratio of $(5-2\sqrt3)/3\approx0.511966$. We also give a black-box reduction from unweighted Ranking to resource-weighted matching: any unweighted competitive ratio $α>1/2$ yields a weighted ratio strictly above $1/2$. With independent sampling access to the duration distributions, the reduction gives a weighted ratio of $0.500034$. These results resolve two questions left open by Delong et al. (MOR 2024): whether Ranking beats $1/2$, and whether one can beat $1/2$ under stochastic durations. We analyze Ranking resource by resource, rather than request by request. For deterministic durations, this gives a reduction to random-order greedy for a coverage function. We then extend the analysis to stochastic durations by comparing the residual schedules of Ranking and a greedy algorithm, and apply a finer analysis of the random ranks to obtain the stated $0.511$ bound. For the weighted reduction, we apply Ranking within groups of similar weights and uses weighted greedy to control the loss between groups.

0.28