CS Paper Radar

Single-Machine Guarantees on Unrelated Machines and Beyond: Proportional Fairness for Nonclairvoyant Polytope Scheduling

Sven Jäger, Alexander Lindermayr, Bart Zondervan

cs.DS ·submitted 2026-10-23 12:23 UTC · v2
theory

Abstract

The Polytope Scheduling Problem (PSP) is a general framework for preemptive scheduling in which feasible instantaneous job allocations form a packing polytope. In the nonclairvoyant online setting, Proportional Fairness (PF), a practical allocation rule rooted in market theory, is the leading general-purpose algorithm. On a single machine, PF coincides with weighted Round-Robin, which is $2$-competitive for weighted completion time with uniform release dates (optimal for nonclairvoyant algorithms) and $(2+\varepsilon)$-speed $O(1/\varepsilon)$-competitive for weighted flow time. Known guarantees beyond a single machine are weaker. This raises a central question: Are these heterogeneous environments intrinsically harder than a single machine under nonclairvoyance? We show that they are not: PF retains both single-machine guarantees on the novel class of support-submodular polytopes, which includes unrelated machines and polymatroids. On unrelated machines, this refutes a belief (JACM'18, SODA'25) that PF is not $O(1)$-speed $O(1)$-competitive for weighted flow time. Our main technical contribution is an equivalent characterization: a polytope is support submodular if and only if, for all job weights, the optimal weighted completion time is concave in the processing requirements. This structural insight underlies both guarantees. For general PSP, the picture changes: we give the first lower bound above $2$, showing that every randomized nonclairvoyant algorithm has a competitive ratio of at least $2+10^{-5}$ for weighted completion time, even with uniform release dates. On the positive side, we substantially improve the best known guarantee for weighted completion time from $27$ (SICOMP'26) to $4$ via a new dual-fitting analysis of PF. For weighted flow time, we show that PF achieves the first $O(1)$-speed $O(1)$-competitive nonclairvoyant guarantee for graph scheduling.

Comment
Shortened abstract

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Coordinating Boundaries: Improved Approximation Algorithms for Unweighted Non-Preemptive Throughput Maximization

cs.DS ·2026-10-26 ·Weitian Tong, Yao Xu
similarity 0.66
Abstract · 34 pages, 8 figures

We study unweighted nonpreemptive throughput maximization: given jobs with processing times, release times, and deadlines, schedule a maximum-cardinality subset on identical machines. For every fixed $\varepsilon>0$, we give randomized algorithms with expected approximation ratios $17/13+\varepsilon$ in polynomial time and $21/17+\varepsilon$ in pseudopolynomial time. These improve the respective $4/3+\varepsilon$ and $5/4+\varepsilon$ guarantees of Armbruster, Grandoni, Tinguely, and Wiese [STOC'26]. Both results hold for an arbitrary number of identical machines. Our algorithms build on their configuration-LP and matching framework, which partitions time into blocks. For a job whose window meets multiple blocks, its boundary blocks are the first and last such blocks. Crossing boundary pairs, whose endpoints strictly interleave, permit additional assignments to sampled execution slots, while a noncrossing family can be coordinated using consistent joint distributions on at most three blocks. The exchange analysis accounts for fractional job assignments that must be erased before inserting an additional job. For the pseudopolynomial implementation, we project configurations onto selected job identities and use separate configuration distributions with common placement marginals. This retains efficient pricing while enforcing the correlations needed for coordination.

0.15

Speed-Robust Scheduling for Total Completion Time

cs.DS cs.DM ·2026-11-16 ·Moritz Buchem, Nicole Megow, Morten Weber
similarity 0.64
Abstract

We study two-stage speed-robust scheduling for minimizing total completion time. Jobs must be partitioned into $M$ bags before an adversary reveals the speeds of at most $M$ machines. Each bag is then assigned to one available machine, and the jobs on each machine may be processed in any order independent of the bags. We compare with an optimal schedule that knows the speeds in advance and assigns jobs individually. This model has been studied for makespan minimization. We initiate its study for total completion time, as suggested by Stein and Zhong (TALG 2020). For an unknown number of identical machines, we show that the optimal deterministic robustness factor is exactly~$13/12$, both for unit-size jobs and for arbitrary processing times. For infinitesimally small jobs, the factor lies between $31/30\approx1.0333$ and $28/27\approx1.0370$, well below the optimal makespan factor of about $1.2071$. General speeds make the problem strictly harder: no deterministic algorithm is better than $1.2669$-robust, already for infinitesimally small jobs. We give a $25/16$-robust algorithm for arbitrary processing times and improve the guarantee to $1681/1152\approx1.4592$ for infinitesimally small jobs. Our main tools are a layer decomposition that extends guarantees from unit-size jobs to arbitrary processing times when one assignment satisfies them for every prefix in non-increasing processing-time order, and a threshold analysis of the bag counts produced by greedy assignment rules.

0.17

A QPTAS for Stochastic Scheduling of Bernoulli Jobs

cs.DS cs.CCmath.OC ·2026-10-08 ·Junho Hwang
benchmark similarity 0.64
Abstract · 23 pages, 1 figure

We study the classical problem of scheduling jobs with random processing times on $m$ identical machines to minimize the expected sum of completion times, for Bernoulli jobs: job $j$ takes time $p_j$ with probability $q_j$ and time $0$ otherwise, and its outcome is revealed when it starts. The benchmark is an optimal adaptive policy. We give a quasi-polynomial-time approximation scheme for every number of machines. Previously, quasi-polynomial time was known to give an $O(\log N)$-approximation, and approximation schemes were known only for a constant number of distinct sizes. The scheme rests on a simple observation: it suffices to round the times at which machines become free, rather than the times at which jobs start, to a grid whose width is proportional to the job size, and an optimal policy stretched by a factor close to one already respects such grids. We also show that every policy that fixes the order of the jobs in advance loses a factor $Ω(\log N)$, already on two machines, so a constant factor requires adapting the order to the observed outcomes. Further results include a polynomial-time adaptive rule with ratio $\min\{m,1+\sum_j q_j\}$, a simpler approximation scheme for a constant number of sizes, and #P-hardness of computing the optimal expected cost on two machines.

0.25

Approximation algorithms for identical parallel machine scheduling with assignment costs

cs.DS ·2026-10-24 ·Wei Li
similarity 0.63
Abstract

We study non-preemptive scheduling on identical parallel machines in which assigning job $j$ to machine $M_i$ incurs the cost $c_{ij}=a_iw_j+b_j$. The processing times $p_j$ and the cost weights $w_j$ are independent, and the number of machines is part of the input. For every fixed $\varepsilon\in(0,1]$ and every deadline $T$ for which a schedule with makespan at most $T$ exists, we give a polynomial-time algorithm that computes a schedule with makespan at most $(1+\varepsilon)T$ whose total assignment cost does not exceed the minimum under the deadline $T$. Using this algorithm as a subroutine, we obtain a polynomial-time approximation scheme for minimizing the makespan under a total cost budget whose schedules always satisfy the budget; this answers an open question for costs $c_{ij}=l_ic_j$ with $c_j$ independent of $p_j$. For the lexicographic problem, in which the total assignment cost is minimized among all schedules of minimum makespan, we obtain in polynomial time a schedule with makespan at most $1+\varepsilon$ times the minimum and total assignment cost at most that of a lexicographically optimal schedule; this improves the makespan guarantees of earlier algorithms for additive and multiplicative costs. For costs $c_{ij}=s_i+a_iw_j$, where $s_i$ is charged for each job processed on $M_i$, the same guarantees are obtained in quasi-polynomial time.

0.24

Asymmetric Weighted Earliness-Tardiness: Scheduling with a Nonrestrictive Common Due Date

cs.CC math.OCcs.DMmath.CO ·2026-09-12 ·Nicholas G. Hall, Hans Kellerer, Miao Song
similarity 0.63
Abstract · 268 pages, 12 figures, 29 tables

Single-machine asymmetric weighted earliness--tardiness (AWET) scheduling asks how to sequence jobs around a common synchronization date when early and late completion incur unrelated job-dependent penalties. At the boundary nonrestrictive date $d=\sum_jp_j$, a compact V-shaped schedule reduces the continuous-time problem to a quadratic choice of a nonempty early set. We establish four complementary results for this model. First, the positive-integer problem is strongly NP-complete by a unary-polynomial reduction from Restricted Exact Cover by 3-Sets. Second, unrestricted AWET admits a polynomial-time $(3+2\sqrt2+\varepsilon)$-approximation based on an anchored semidefinite relaxation and deterministic marginal thresholding. Third, when the earliness and tardiness ratio orders are strict reversals, the problem is weakly NP-complete but has an exact two-resource pseudopolynomial dynamic program. Fourth, for fixed total refinements whose ratio permutation is separable, an exact separating-tree recurrence and coordinated geometric trimming yield an FPTAS. The proofs use different manifestations of the same canonical objective: scale-separated prefix penalties, positive-semidefinite minimum-kernel covariance, a dominant completed load square, and a bounded four-coordinate decomposition interface. Together, the results show that the decisive issue is not merely whether the two ratio orders agree, but whether their interaction can be controlled by a global certificate or compressed into a bounded constructive interface.

0.21

Non-Clairvoyant Scheduling is Hard Even for Trees

cs.DS ·2026-10-07 ·Kunal Agrawal, Owen Druzgal, Milind Prabhu, Jinhao Zhao
theory similarity 0.62
Abstract

We study online scheduling of parallel jobs on $m$ identical processors to minimize maximum flow time. Each arriving job is represented by a directed acyclic graph (DAG) whose vertices are unit-time subjobs and whose edges specify precedence constraints. We consider non-clairvoyant algorithms: the DAG is not known when a job arrives, and each subjob is revealed only when it becomes ready. Agrawal, Moseley, Newman, and Pruhs (SPAA 2024) showed that First-In-First-Out (FIFO) has competitive ratio $Ω(\log m)$ even when every job is an out-tree. They also proved that FIFO is $O(\log m)$-competitive in several natural settings and asked whether this guarantee extends to general instances. More broadly, they asked whether any non-clairvoyant algorithm can be $O(1)$-competitive. We answer both questions in the negative by proving a lower bound of $Ω(\min\{m,\mathrm{OPT}\})$ for every non-clairvoyant online algorithm, where $\mathrm{OPT}$ is the maximum flow time of an optimal offline schedule. In particular, every non-clairvoyant algorithm has competitive ratio $Ω(m)$ on some instance with $\mathrm{OPT} \ge m$. The lower bound holds even when every job is an out-forest. We complement these lower bounds with an asymptotically optimal non-clairvoyant algorithm. FIFO is $O(m)$-competitive, but can have competitive ratio $Ω(m)$ even when $\mathrm{OPT}=O(1)$. For instances with small $\mathrm{OPT}$, we design a Small-Frontier-First algorithm that is $O(\mathrm{OPT})$-competitive. Combining the two algorithms yields an $O(\min\{m,\mathrm{OPT}\})$-competitive non-clairvoyant algorithm.

0.34

Tight Worst-Case Completion-Time Bounds for Dominant Resource Fairness

cs.DS ·2026-11-05 ·Mugen Blue, Sungjin Im, Alexander Lindermayr
theory similarity 0.61
Abstract

Dominant Resource Fairness (DRF) is an influential policy for sharing multiple resources among jobs with heterogeneous demands. It combines sharing incentive, strategy-proofness, envy-freeness, and Pareto efficiency, making it particularly attractive for shared computing systems. DRF has been implemented in major resource-management frameworks, including Apache Mesos and Hadoop YARN. DRF is also nonclairvoyant: it requires no advance knowledge of job sizes, making it practical when processing requirements are difficult to predict. This motivates understanding its completion-time performance relative to an optimal schedule that knows all job sizes. However, elementary arguments can only give an $Ω(\sqrt D)$ lower bound and an $O(D)$ upper bound for total completion time, where $D$ is the number of resource types. In this paper, we close this gap by proving that DRF is $Θ(\sqrt D)$-competitive. More generally, for every fixed real $q\geq1$, we show that DRF is $Θ(D^{1/(q+1)})$-competitive for the $\ell_q$ norm of completion times, with larger $q$ placing greater emphasis on late-finishing jobs. These bounds hold with arbitrary release times. We also give a refined analysis of total completion time for small $D$.

0.17

Parallel Machine Scheduling with a Singler Server and Loading-Unloading Operations

cs.DS math.OC ·2026-08-12 ·Keramat Hasani, Frank Werner
theory similarity 0.60
Abstract · 20 pages, 3 figures

This paper investigates a parallel machine scheduling problem featuring a single common server responsible for both loading and unloading operations. Each job consists of a unit-time loading operation, non-preemptive processing on one of \(m\) identical machines, and a unit-time unloading operation executed by the same server. The objective is to minimize the makespan. Unlike classical loading-only common-server models, our setting requires the server to handle an unloading operation immediately after a job's processing phase concludes. We prove that the corresponding decision problem is strongly NP-complete when the number of machines is given as part of the input. Furthermore, we analyse the worst-case performance of the List Scheduling (LS) and Longest Processing Time (LPT) heuristics. For three machines, we establish that Algorithm LS achieves an approximation ratio of at most \(5/2\). For an arbitrary fixed \(m \ge 3\), we show that the general LS bound approaches \(4-3/m\) as the number of jobs grows, whereas for Algorithm LPT, we prove the finite-instance ratio $3-\frac{2}{m}+\frac{(m-1)(m-2)}{mn}.$ Thus, for each fixed \(m\), the LPT bound approaches \(3-2/m\) as the number of jobs grows.

0.38