CS Paper Radar

Calibrating demand models versus adjusting OD matrices with traffic counts: a controlled comparison

Yue Li, Shujuan Chen, Ying Jin

cs.CE stat.ME ·submitted 2026-11-06 16:27 UTC · v1

Abstract

Traffic counts are routinely used to calibrate travel demand models, particularly when the origin-destination (OD) matrix is not observed directly. An important modelling decision is whether to adjust individual OD flows or the parameters of the demand model that generates them. The latter approach uses fewer parameters and preserves a relationship between zonal characteristics and demand, but its accuracy depends on the assumed model structure. We compare three established approaches using the same prior information, traffic counts and equilibrium assignment. They estimate five production-gravity coefficients, origin and destination adjustment factors, or individual OD flows. Synthetic experiments on the Eastern Massachusetts and Chicago Sketch networks allow recovery to be assessed against known demand under different forms of model misspecification. Calibrating the five-coefficient model gives better OD recovery and held-out link-flow prediction when demand follows its assumptions or a two-purpose gravity process. Its advantage declines or reverses when destination choice or production relationships vary across zones. Cellwise adjustment achieves the closest fit to calibration counts in 65 of 66 evaluated conditions, yet it recovers OD demand least accurately of the three approaches in 45 of them. These findings show that model parameterisation matters beyond calibration fit. For transport planning, traffic counts should be used alongside independent evidence on trip production and distribution when selecting and validating a demand model.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Decision Aware Origin-Destination Demand Estimation with Structurally Constrained Data

cs.LG ·2026-11-09 ·Xianzhe Wang, Yueyue Fan, Johannes Royset
position similarity 0.64
Abstract

Origin-destination (OD) demand plays an important role in transportation system design and management applications. Conventional OD estimation methods typically judge estimation quality based on how estimated demand aligns with observed traffic data and historical demand patterns. We argue that data alignment alone is insufficient; how errors in OD estimates influence downstream decision quality should also be considered. This paper develops a decision aware OD demand estimation framework that leverages structurally constrained traffic data to characterize an admissible demand region, within which we identify OD estimates that would lead to least regret in the downstream decision. Therefore, our OD estimates are both data-consistent and decision-relevant. Methodologically, we approximate the admissible demand region induced by physical network constraints through a geometric representation, which regularizes the search over feasible OD estimates. Within this regularized region, we use a convex surrogate of downstream regret to obtain a tractable decision aware optimization problem. Numerical experiments show that the proposed framework consistently reduces decision regret relative to conventional estimation benchmarks, demonstrating the value of aligning OD demand estimation with downstream decision quality.

0.27

Estimate then Predict: Convex Formulation for Travel Demand Forecasting

cs.GT ·2026-09-15 ·Youngseo Kim, Gioele Zardini, Samitha Samaranayake, Soroosh Shafiee
benchmarkhighly cited similarity 0.61
Abstract

Travel demand forecasting is essential for evaluating large-scale infrastructure projects, yet the traditional sequential four-step process can produce inconsistencies across trip distribution, mode choice, and traffic assignment. Although combined models address these inconsistencies, their practical use has been limited by simplified behavioral assumptions, computational burden, and the lack of a unified parameter-estimation framework. We propose a convex programming approach that integrates destination, mode, and route choices within a hierarchical extended logit model. The optimal primal solution characterizes the joint travel-demand equilibrium, while the optimal dual variables recover taste coefficients, alternative-specific constants, and destination- and mode-level scale parameters. The model captures mode correlations through nested logit and route overlap through path-size logit. Its convex structure provides global optimality guarantees and enables efficient solution using off-the-shelf conic solvers. Observed travel patterns are incorporated through moment and conditional-entropy constraints, while the route-level dispersion parameter is calibrated separately using partial link counts. Numerical experiments on eight benchmark networks demonstrate the scalability and computational efficiency of the formulation.

0.50

A Performative Control Approach to Day-to-Day Traffic Signal Retiming

eess.SY ·2026-10-13 ·Shuchang Jiang, Xinwu Qian, Santiago Segarra, Zhongyuan Zhao
similarity 0.59
Abstract · 8 pages, 6 figures, 2 tables

Conventional fixed-time traffic signal optimization and recent day-to-day signal retiming generally model route adaptation under prescribed route-choice behavior and origin-destination (OD) demand, while neglecting the fact that travelers' behavior can be performative to the signal control policy. A signal timing policy learned from historical traffic observations must therefore account for how its own deployment changes the distribution on which it will be evaluated in the future. We formulate this problem as performative signal control under observed traveler responses and characterize performative stability of the coupled policy-demand system. We propose incremental day-to-day retiming using the local policy gradient at the current operating point, estimated offline through simulation-based zeroth-order optimization without an explicit day-to-day demand-response model. This gradual approach provides a feasible path for policy and demand to co-evolve toward stability. Experiments on a downtown Denver network show that our approach improves congestion, throughput, and stability, generalizes across different demand levels, and remains effective when the offline simulator contains mismatched travel demand and routing behaviors.

0.21

Inferring Urban Mobility Interactions from Aggregated Dynamics

cs.LG ·2026-09-07 ·Yi Wang, Jing Li, Jinliang Deng, Zhenghong Wang, Yizhi Zhang +3 more
similarity 0.58
Abstract

Real-time urban governance depends not only on knowing where people are, but on how they move between places, directional flows that could be conventionally resolved by tracking individuals through space, i.e., expensive to sustain and built on traces that are highly unique and readily re-identifiable. Here we show that this directional structure need not be observed to be known: aggregated counts which cities already collect retain enough information to reconstruct the temporal evolution of origin-destination (OD) matrix. Using an uncertainty-aware physics-informed framework, we infer future OD flows from area-level counts alone across twelve mobility datasets from cities in the United States and China, reaching accuracy comparable to models that take historical OD matrices as input. Probabilistic modeling corrects the systematic underestimation of sparse, high-value corridors and yields calibrated predictions consistent with observed flows. Architectures that respect the generation-before-assignment logic of transport planning recover interactions more faithfully, indicating that location-level spatial heterogeneity should be preserved before pairwise interactions are reconstructed. Because inference requires only aggregated observations after training, recovering interactions this way reduces reliance on continuous individual-level tracking, pointing toward a more deployable and less exposure-heavy basis for real-time urban intelligence.

0.14

Online Estimation of Dynamic Origin-Destination Matrices Using Reinforcement Learning with Link-Flow Propagation Guidance

cs.LG cs.AI ·2026-08-31 ·Donggyu Min, Dong-Kyu Kim
similarity 0.54
Abstract

Dynamic origin-destination (OD) matrix estimation calibrates time-dependent input demand for simulations to reproduce observed link flows. Reinforcement learning is well suited to online estimation because a trained policy estimates demand in a single evaluation, but varying target flows complicate learning from aggregate rewards. We propose reinforcement learning with link-flow propagation guidance (LFPG-RL), combining simulated vehicle propagation records with downstream errors to guide individual OD components. Using 250 weekday link-flow trajectories from a Melbourne arterial network, LFPG-RL achieves a mean test root mean squared error (RMSE) of 7.41 vehicles per 15-minute interval, mean absolute percentage error of 31.24%, and Pearson correlation of 0.987. Comparisons with optimisation, filtering and reinforcement learning without guidance show a 40.1% RMSE reduction over the strongest baseline, gradient descent with propagation guidance. LFPG-RL enables rapid demand updates that keep traffic simulations consistent with observed conditions, supporting the evaluation of traffic management strategies.

0.25

SeoulMMOD: A Large-Scale Multimodal Origin-Destination Flow Benchmark

cs.LG ·2026-10-09 ·Taeyoung Yu, Seonbin Jo, Jiwon Kim, Junyoung Byun
benchmark similarity 0.53
Abstract

Origin-destination (OD) flow forecasting supports urban mobility decisions by predicting the volume and patterns of human movement across a city. Most existing public OD benchmarks provide only a partial view of citywide mobility, covering a single transport service or at most two modes. With partial mode coverage, observed demand changes are difficult to separate into shifts across transport modes and changes in total travel. We introduce SeoulMMOD, a large-scale public benchmark for citywide multimodal mobility in Seoul. SeoulMMOD provides three years of hourly OD flows estimating total mobility for 6 urban travel modes across 25 districts and 426 sub-districts, together with travel-time, travel-distance, calendar, rainfall, and point-of-interest (POI) signals. Using SeoulMMOD, we benchmark 14 forecasting baselines under a common protocol and analyse the effects of spatial scaling, joint versus mode-separate training, and cross-year generalization. Results show that several spatio-temporal models that work at district level do not scale to sub-district OD forecasting, and that naive joint multi-mode training does not consistently improve accuracy. Together, the dataset and benchmark establish a reproducible testbed for multi-mode, multi-year OD forecasting at the city scale.

0.04

Demand-Driven Vertiport Siting and Discrete-Event Fleet Simulation for On-Demand Urban Air Mobility Network Design

cs.AI eess.SY ·2026-08-15 ·Hossein Z. Saghazadeh, Yonas Ayalew, Reza Ahmari, Parham Kebria, Abdollah Homaifar
published similarity 0.53
Abstract · Accepted for presentation at the 2026 IEEE International Conference on Systems, Man, and Cybernetics (SMC 2026)

This paper presents a demand-driven framework for on-demand Urban Air Mobility (UAM) network design that links vertiport siting, fleet simulation, and door-to-door travel-time feasibility. Demand is estimated from commuter and passenger activity data, converted into spatial trip-end points, and clustered using K-means to generate candidate vertiport locations. Candidate networks are screened using range and minimum station-spacing constraints, then evaluated with a discrete-event simulation that models multi-vehicle dispatch, deadhead relocation, battery swaps, and service regularity. Flight time and energy consumption are computed using a point-mass eVTOL performance model. In a Greater Los Angeles case study, the preferred design expands from four stations and four eVTOLs at low demand to sixteen stations and twelve eVTOLs at the highest tested demand level. Results show that larger fleets improve completion time and vehicle-arrival regularity but do not eliminate deadhead flights, indicating that spatial demand imbalance remains an operational burden. The travel-time savings analysis further suggests that UAM is most defensible for longer or congestion-heavy trips where sufficient non-flight time remains after accounting for flight time.

0.22

Beyond corridor averages: Lane-level validation of microscopic freeway simulation with empirically parameterized arrivals

cs.CE ·2026-11-18 ·Korede R. Bishi, Casey Bowman, John A. Miller
similarity 0.52
Abstract

Traffic flow modeling is an essential part of civil planning around the world, and traffic simulation is an important component of the analyses that city planners must perform to ensure safe and efficient road networks for their citizens. This work advances microscopic traffic simulation through lane-level validation of speed and flow dynamics, addressing a critical gap in conventional macro-aggregated approaches. We systematically evaluate the trade-offs between numerical integration methods and vehicle arrival processes when reproducing empirical trajectory data from California's freeway network. Results demonstrate that numerical-integrator choice has negligible impact on simulation accuracy, with less than one percent variation across eight methods, while vehicle arrival-process modeling substantially affects fidelity. The shifted Erlang-2 distribution reduces flow-prediction error by approximately 28% compared to Poisson processes by enforcing a realistic minimum headway. Lane-level validation across five detector stations reveals lane-specific dynamics that aggregated metrics often obscure.

0.33