CS Paper Radar

Plurality Consensus for $h$-Majority via First-Repetition Rules

Niccolò D'Archivio, George Giakkoupis, Frédéric Giroire, Emanuele Natale

cs.DC cs.DS ·submitted 2026-11-11 21:46 UTC · v1

Abstract

In the h-Majority dynamics, each of n agents holds one of k opinions and, in every synchronous round, observes the opinions of h agents chosen independently and uniformly at random and adopts a most frequent one among them, breaking ties uniformly at random. Let M_0 be the initial number of agents holding the most frequent opinion, and Delta_0 its bias, its lead over the second most frequent opinion. We show that, for every sample size h >= 3, if Delta_0 >= L sqrt(M_0 log n) max{1, n/(h^2 M_0)} for a sufficiently large constant L, then h-Majority reaches consensus on the initially most frequent opinion within O((1 + n/(h^2 M_0)) log n) rounds with high probability. This is the time bound proved for the DejaVu dynamics with h samples (arXiv:2604.03648); our bias condition is that of DejaVu when h >= sqrt(n/M_0), and larger by a factor sqrt(n/(h^2 M_0)) otherwise. Our main contribution, the analysis of one round, rests on a comparison principle: among all rules that read the same observations and treat opinions symmetrically, plurality maximizes the difference between the probability of outputting the most frequent opinion and that of outputting any fixed competitor. We apply it to the rule that adopts the first opinion repeated among h-1 observations, and otherwise the h-th observation: its output law is the law of the new opinion of a random agent after one round of DejaVu with h-1 samples. Hence, in expectation, one round of h-Majority widens the gap between the most frequent opinion and each competitor at least as much as that round of DejaVu, whose analysis we use as a black box. Independently and concurrently, d'Amore, Rybicki, Shimizu, Shiraga and Vacus (arXiv:2610.40562) obtained, among other results, the same time bound under the weaker bias condition of DejaVu, with a different analysis of one round and a martingale analysis over many rounds.

Comment
16 pages

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Nearly-Optimal Time-Sample Trade-off in Consensus Dynamics

cs.DC cs.DSmath.PR ·2026-10-29 ·Francesco d'Amore, Joel Rybicki, Nobutaka Shimizu, Takeharu Shiraga, Robin Vacus
theory similarity 0.79
Abstract

How does the number of sampled opinions affect the time required to reach consensus in distributed consensus dynamics? We study the synchronous $h$-Majority, in which every node independently samples $h$ nodes uniformly at random with replacement in each round and adopts a most frequent sampled opinion, breaking ties uniformly at random. We show that $h$-Majority achieves the nearly-optimal trade-off between the sample size and the consensus time, among a broad class of consensus dynamics. In particular, we prove the following results. For every sample size $h \ge 3$ and for every initial configuration, we prove that the process reaches consensus with high probability within $$\widetilde{O}\left(1+\min\left\{\frac{1}{\min\{h^2p_{\max},1\}},\frac{\sqrt{n}}{h}\right\}\right)$$ rounds, where $n$ is the number of nodes and $p_{\max}$ is the largest initial fraction of nodes supporting any single opinion. This is the first bound on the consensus time for $h$-Majority that holds for every $h\ge3$ and every initial configuration. When the initially most popular opinion has a sufficiently large lead over every other opinion, we show that all nodes adopt this opinion with high probability within $O(\log n/\min\{h^2p_{\max},1\})$ rounds. We establish a matching lower bound up to polylogarithmic factors for any fixed update rule that treats all opinions symmetrically and that selects either a sampled opinion or the node's current opinion.

0.49

Scaling Laws for Majority-based Opinion Dynamics in the Presence of Stubborn Agents

cs.MA math.PR ·2026-08-11 ·Luke Meredith, Arpan Mukhopadhyay
similarity 0.65
Abstract

In a multi-agent system, there are often stubborn followers of specific opinions or beliefs. Motivated by this observation, in this paper, we aim to understand how stubborn agents affect the distribution of opinions in a network where both stubborn and non-stubborn agents interact with each other. To do so, we assume that all agents have an opinion in the set $\{0,1\}$ and each non-stubborn agent updates its opinion according to the $2k$\textit{-choices rule}, where the agent samples $2k$ neighbours (including both stubborn and non-stubborn neighbours) uniformly at random and adopts the majority opinion among the sampled group of neighbours and itself. We assume that a proportion of agents, $γ_i$, are stubborn followers of opinion $i\in \{0,1\}$. It is natural to expect that the steady-state distribution of the opinions in the network will be dominated by the opinion with the larger proportion of stubborn followers. We show that while this is true, the time to reach steady-state depends heavily on the values of the parameters $γ_0$ and $γ_1$. When the individual values of these parameters, as well as their difference, are small, it can take an exponentially long time (in the network size) to reach the steady-state. In sharp contrast, when at least one of the parameters $γ_0$ and $γ_1$ is large, the network reaches the steady-state in a time that is only logarithmic in the network size. Hence, there exists a sharp phase transition in the network dynamics based on the proportions of stubborn agents. We also characterise the behaviour of the system when the parameters $γ_0$ and $γ_1$ lie on the boundary of the phase transition. In this boundary region, we show using Stein's method that the dynamics are driven by a diffusion process which takes polynomial time to mix.

0.04

Ordinal Hegselmann-Krause Systems

cs.DS cs.GTcs.SI ·2026-11-18 ·Martin Hoefer, Tim Koglin, Jakob Lindner, Jannis Schramek
published similarity 0.61
Abstract · A preliminary version will appear in the proceedings of WINE 2026

We study opinion formation in the popular Hegselmann-Krause model when agents replace the traditional averaging update by a median update or more general ordinal aggregation methods. We analyze the convergence properties of synchronous and asynchronous dynamics. For asynchronous dynamics, we show that every HKS with a $1$-Lipschitz ordinal aggregation function converges in worst-case time $\mathcal{O}(n^4)$. For the special case of median aggregation and for the family of $k\textsf{-large}$ aggregation functions, in which agents select the $k$-th largest opinion in their neighborhood, we obtain sharper bounds of $\mathcal{O}(n^3)$. For general ordinal aggregation, some sequence of $\mathcal{O}(n^2)$ updates reaches an equilibrium from every initial state. Nevertheless, other update sequences may cycle, and uniform random activation can require exponentially many updates with overwhelming probability. For synchronous dynamics, we obtain a tight characterization. Ordinal aggregation functions satisfying the $1$-Lipschitz condition are shown to guarantee convergence in linear time. This result applies to many natural examples such as minimum, maximum, median, and $k\textsf{-large}$ functions. When the Lipschitz condition is violated, there exist instances in which synchronous dynamics do not converge at all.

0.48

Multi-agent discussion gains less when dissent is withheld

cs.CL physics.soc-phcs.MA ·2026-09-29 ·Chand Sahil Mansuri, Xin Wang, Mengying Li, Bryan Acton, Rory Eckardt +2 more
benchmark similarity 0.61
Abstract

Multi-agent systems of LLMs add discussion to majority voting and are therefore expected to be more capable. However, empirical reports conflict on whether discussion improves accuracy or leads to an incorrect consensus. Here, we introduce a parsimonious model that explains when discussion improves accuracy and when it ends in an incorrect consensus, built from four behaviors repeatedly observed in LLM agents: (1) withholding dissent, (2) internalizing a stated answer, (3) reconsidering after seeing dissent, and (4) correcting toward the correct answer. The model shows that discussion can overturn an incorrect initial majority only when the withholding rate $c$ is below a critical rate $c^* = γ/(γ+ a)$, set by the net correction rate $γ$ and the internalization rate $a$. We estimate these rates from conversation logs with a Bayesian method and place LLM teams relative to $c^*$. As the model predicts, the gain from discussion shrinks as withholding rises, across LLMs and on a hidden profile benchmark, HiddenBench, and MedEInst. Instructing agents not to withhold dissent increases this gain. Turning reasoning off also increases the gain, because reasoning raises the internalization rate $a$ and keeps agents from reconsidering a minority answer. These findings reconcile the conflicting reports and identify when discussion outperforms majority voting.

0.46

Trembling toward Duverger: Convergence and Cycles in Synchronous Plurality Dynamics

cs.GT ·2026-10-16 ·Maximilian Weigel, Damien Berriaud, Roger Wattenhofer
similarity 0.60
Abstract · 19 pages, 2 figures

Duverger's law states that plurality elections tend to concentrate support on two candidates. Pivotal-voter models typically derive this from aggregate uncertainty about votes, so that two-candidate competition emerges in the limit of large electorates. We instead propose a model for a fixed, finite population. A poll reveals the current support counts, and each voter best responds under trembling-hand beliefs, assuming that every other voter may deviate with a small probability. Starting from truthful votes, we show that a single update typically suffices for the dynamics to converge to a stable profile in which every voter supports her preferred candidate among the two poll leaders. For any number of candidates and any full-support tremble belief, a four-vote lead of the runner-up over all lower candidates suffices; for three candidates, a lead of two suffices. As a consequence, under random preferences, Duverger's law emerges after one update with probability $1-\mathcal O(N^{-1/2})$. While these results may suggest that the dynamics always settle, convergence can fail. Mild period-two cycles already arise, with a few voters swapping ballots around an otherwise stable profile. We show that substantially richer behavior is possible, even with three candidates. Period-three cycles arise with six voters changing their ballots, and no such cycle can involve fewer than four. Cycles can also alternate the plurality winner. Moreover, larger electorates support ever longer cycles: for every odd $\ell\geq3$, truthful voting can lead to a cycle whose vote counts repeat every $\ell$ rounds and whose full ballot profile repeats every $2\ell$ rounds.

0.29

The Voter Model with Opinion Graph

cs.GT cs.DC ·2026-10-12 ·Petra Berenbrink, Thorsten Götte, Martin Hoefer, Tim Koglin
similarity 0.58
Abstract · Abstract shortened to comply Arxiv requirements

We study the \emph{voter model with opinion graph}, a generalization of the standard (pull) voter model that adds a notion of bounded confidence. In this process, we consider a finite set $A$ of $n$ agents. Each agent $u \in A$ has an opinion $x_u \in O$, where we model opinions as vertices in an undirected opinion graph $G = (O,E)$ with $|O|=q$. In each step, an agent $u$ interacts with another agent $v \in A$. In contrast to classical voting, $u$ adopts the opinion $x_v$ if and only if $x_v$ and $x_u$ are neighbors in $G$. The process is stable once all remaining opinions are an independent set in $G$. We analyze two variants of the process: the ordinary EdgeVOG process, which samples a pair of interacting agents uniformly at random from all possible pairs, and the productive EdgeVOG process, which samples only pairs with neighboring opinions in $G$. We show the following: - For every opinion graph and every initial configuration, ordinary EdgeVOG stabilizes within $O(n^2\log n)$ steps in expectation and with high probability. The expectation bound is asymptotically tight. For the productive EdgeVOG process, the expected stabilization time is exactly the initial number of compatible agent pairs, while $O(n^2\log n)$ steps suffice with high probability. - An opinion $i$ with initial support $s_i$ survives with probability at least $p_i:=s_i/(s_i+\sum_{j\in N(i)}s_j)$. Further, let $μ= \sum_{i \in O} p_i$, then we show the probability that less than $(1-δ)μ$ opinions survive is at most $\exp(-δ^2μ/(2(Δ^2+1)))$ for every $0\leqδ\leq1$. -If $G$ has maximum degree $Δ$ and every opinion initially has support at most $\hat{s}$, then no opinion ever acquires more than $\tilde{O}(\min\{n,Δ^6\hat{s}\})$ agents with high probability. This yields near-linear stabilization bounds for productive EdgeVOG for a large class of configurations.

0.21

Counting in Population Protocols on Graphs

cs.DC ·2026-08-18 ·Petra Berenbrink, Robert Elsässer, Tom Friedetzky, Thorsten Götte, Lukas Hintze +1 more
published similarity 0.55
Abstract · Accepted to DISC 2026

We consider the problem of counting the number of agents in a population protocol where the agents are connected by an underlying graph $G=(V,E)$ with $|V|=n$ nodes. In each step, a random scheduler selects an edge uniformly at random, and the incident nodes make a state transition. As per standard assumptions, agents are identical and anonymous, that is, have no identifiers. To break symmetry, in each interaction one of the agents is declared as the initiator uniformly at random. Our size counting protocol uses $\tilde O(n)$ states and stabilizes in $O( B(G) \cdot \log^2(n) + L(G) \cdot \log(n))$ interactions with high probability, where $B(G)$ is the broadcast time and $L(G)$ is the load balancing time. Our protocol is based on novel protocols for sampling independent random bits (given that the scheduler determines an initiator and responder) and approximating $\log n$ up to an additive error of $O(\log \log n)$ with high probability. The latter uses $O(poly\log(n))$ states and $O(B(G)\cdot\log^2 n)$ interactions. Both results may be of independent interest. The main protocol for exact counting requires the presence of a unique leader, the other two do not. None of the protocols requires any knowledge about the graph $G$. We conclude with impossibility results for terminating uniform population protocols that compute graph-size properties (like counting nodes or determining parity) with and without a leader.

0.46

Coherence-Driven Belief Formation and Population Dynamics of Contagion in LLM Agents

cs.AI cs.MAcs.SI ·2026-10-02 ·Tathagata Banerjee, Nima Moghaddas
published similarity 0.54
Abstract · 18 pages, 6 figures. Accepted at the NeurIPS 2026 Workshop on Foundations of Agentic Systems Theory (FAST)

Models of social contagion usually assume how individuals adopt beliefs and derive population behavior from it. We instead empirically measure belief adoption in language model agents, quantifying the probability an agent adopts a claim given how many peers endorse it. We find this adoption kernel to be sigmoid, a characteristic of complex contagion, with a threshold that is sensitive to three sources: the claim's plausibility, the source's reliability, and the agent's disposition. These three dimensions are well approximated by a single effective dimension which we propose can be understood as the coherence of the incoming belief with the LLM agent's prior beliefs. Further, we observe a characteristic of complex contagion in the collective dynamics of belief adoption in a system of AI agents: further spread on clustered than random networks. These systems also exhibit a bifurcating cascade window, and self-sustaining hysteretic consensus which lead to consensus being far harder to remove than to establish.

0.38