CS Paper Radar

Safety Certificates for Systems under Attack via Stackelberg Set Games

Nikolaos Athanasopoulos, David Laverty, Gregory Provan, Quanyan Zhu

eess.SY math.OC ·submitted 2026-11-13 13:42 UTC · v1

Abstract

We study a Stackelberg set selection game for linear systems subject to bounded disturbances and additive attacks. The defender selects the vector parameter of a polytopic safe set template; the attacker, after observing this choice, selects the vector parameter of an admissible attack set. The payoff is a signed, facet-normalised invariance margin that tests invariance exactly and quantifies either the available contraction or the facet inflation needed when invariance fails. Both controlled and robust controlled invariance are treated, corresponding to different information patterns for the control input. Exploiting the structure of parameterised polyhedra, we show that within each validity region the margin is concave in the attack parameter, which reduces the follower minimisation to finitely many extreme parameters. The complete max--min game is then solved by a finite family of LPs, one per defender validity region, each enforcing all attacker regions under a common defender decision and guaranteed margin. The framework handles hard state constraints and additional costs related to the safe set size, and recovers optimal set parameters together with state and attack realisations that activate the certificate. A load frequency control example under false data injection illustrates the construction, the validity decomposition, and the two information patterns.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Antagonistic Control: Foundations, Scalability and Nonlinearity

eess.SY math.OC ·2026-08-23 ·Sribalaji C. Anand, André M. H. Teixeira
similarity 0.63
Abstract · Under review

This paper studies the worst-case impact of constrained control inputs: an input seeks to maximize the average cost of some outputs, measured in the $L_2$ or $L_1$ norm, while remaining bounded in terms of other outputs. This problem template subsumes classical metrics such as the $H_\infty$ norm and the output-to-output gain, and arises in adversarial control, security assessment, and robust control. For linear time-invariant systems, we provide an exact semi-definite program (SDP) when there is a single constraint, and SDPs computing upper bounds when there are multiple constraints. We derive sufficient conditions, in terms of system zeros and relative degrees, under which the worst-case cost is unbounded, together with a constructive closed-loop modification that removes the unboundedness. From a security standpoint, unbounded values reveal structural limitations in detecting certain attack inputs. For positive systems, we provide scalable formulations whose complexity grows linearly in the state dimension: a scalable SDP for quadratic costs, and an exact linear program for linear costs. The results extend to nonlinear polynomial systems via a sum-of-squares program. We illustrate the results with numerical examples.

0.20

Hierarchical Defense in Leader-Defender-Attacker Games: Nested Equilibria and Receding-Horizon Control

eess.SY ·2026-10-07 ·Honglei Guo, Hanfang Zhang, Guochuan Zhang, Yuhan Zhao
similarity 0.62
Abstract

We formulate a discrete-time leader-defender-attacker game that combines hierarchical interaction within a protective group with competition against an external attacker. The leader seeks to reach a prescribed demand point while avoiding capture, whereas the defender seeks to intercept the attacker while remaining near the leader. To capture their distinct objectives and asymmetric interactions, we introduce a nested equilibrium concept combining a leader-defender Stackelberg relationship with a Nash-type best-response condition for the attacker. For linear dynamics and quadratic objectives, we derive affine response laws and a backward recursion, together with sufficient conditions for unique stagewise solutions. We further express arrival, capture, and interception conditions as quadratic inequalities in the initial joint state, characterizing winning regions under the resulting policy. A receding-horizon algorithm implements the computed control laws using updated state information. Numerical experiments over randomized initial configurations examine the influence of the prediction horizon and compare the proposed method with an independent-control baseline, illustrating differences in game outcomes and the agents' realized costs.

0.18

Exact Feasibility Certification and Optimal Responsibility Allocation for Multi-Robot CBF Safety Filters

cs.RO cs.MA ·2026-09-14 ·Chandan Kumar Sah, Jishnu Keshavan
hot direction similarity 0.61
Abstract

Multi-robot Control Barrier Function (CBF) safety filters can become infeasible, but a failed quadratic program (QP) does not indicate why the conflict occurred or how to resolve it. To address this, we develop an exact feasibility certificate for multi-agent CBF filters with heterogeneous control-affine dynamics and convex input sets. The certificate quantifies a feasibility reserve by separating the demand imposed by safety constraints from the available actuator supply. This decomposition shows when CBF gain tuning or increased actuation can and cannot resolve infeasibility, and identifies the agents and interactions responsible for the conflict. We further propose an algorithm to optimally allocate shared safety constraints by maximizing the worst local feasibility margin, yielding a linear program for polyhedral input sets. In $320$ paired closed-loop simulations, the proposed allocation reduces infeasible control steps from roughly $50\%$ to $6.2\%$, and reduces safety-violating runs from $118/160$ to $24/160$. In addition, across $52$ infeasibility events, the certificate identifies an interaction whose relaxation restores feasibility in $94\%$ of cases.

0.31

Observation Design for Certified Control Authority: Projection--Estimability Separation and Active-Face Equivalence

cs.RO eess.SY ·2026-09-05 ·Guangxi Wan, Hualong Du, Yuqi Liu, Qingwei Dong, Qingxin Li +2 more
theory similarity 0.60
Abstract · 12 pages, 3 figures, 2 tables

A sound runtime admission gate executes only actions it can certify, and certifies only what its observations support. This paper asks how observations should be designed to maximize the set of actions that can be safely admitted, and shows the question is not a re-vocabulary of classical design problems. First, a projection--estimability separation: decomposing a constraint normal as $c=c_{\mathrm{Range}}+c_{\ker}$ relative to an information matrix, two-point discrimination along $c$ becomes arbitrarily reliable as the budget grows whenever $c_{\mathrm{Range}}\neq 0$, while robust admission of an action with normal $c$ is impossible at every budget whenever $c_{\ker}\neq 0$; such mixed directions are generic at any deficient rank, and at full rank the decoupling is bounded by the Kantorovich ratio and diverges with the condition number. Discrimination-optimal designs, being corner solutions of a linear criterion, land in exactly this regime. Second, an active-face equivalence theorem: the permissiveness-optimal design is $L$-optimal for a target matrix generated endogenously by the action faces that become certification bottlenecks, weighted inversely by their remaining slack; single-face collapse recovers $c$-optimal and goal-oriented design exactly, and a Caratheodory argument yields a bottleneck certificate of at most $r(r+1)/2+1$ faces. Around these we assemble exact certifiability per convex contract mode, for which $κ\approx 3.29$ is derived rather than calibrated, the $\sqrt{r}$ price of contract-agnostic design, an information-to-slack transfer theorem with a curvature-budget corollary, and a two-part audit in which a design meeting every margin requirement still leaves an action face at a certification cost above ten times its testing cost, in every probe library tested.

0.56

On the Degree of Safety: Beyond Safe or Unsafe with Control Barrier Functions

eess.SY ·2026-09-03 ·Ruoyu Lin, Fabio Pasqualetti, Magnus Egerstedt
similarity 0.59
Abstract

A valid control barrier function (CBF) certifies if its represented safe set can be rendered forward invariant, and the sign of its value indicates whether a state is safe or not, but it does not quantify a degree of safety beyond the binary indication. In this paper, we show that among valid CBFs representing the same safe set, interior values and gradients can be changed arbitrarily, so neither quantity determines a degree of safety that is independent of how the set is represented. We also show that whether a candidate CBF-based inequality constraint is feasible does not by itself quantify a degree of safety. In particular, infeasibility can occur either because the safe set is not controlled invariant or because the candidate CBF representation fails. This motivates our distinction between intrinsic and representational infeasibility. Finally, we introduce the invariance authority demand (IAD), a representation-independent degree of safety that quantifies the control authority required for maintaining safety and can be used to guide actuator redesign or safe set repair.

0.28

Networked Multi-Resource Defense Capabilities in a General Lotto Game

cs.GT cs.CReess.SY ·2026-08-28 ·Faezeh Shojaeighadikolaei, Keith Paarporn
publishedbenchmark similarity 0.58
Abstract · 9 pages, 3 figures, Accepted for presentation at the 65th IEEE Conference on Decision and Control (CDC 2026)

Ensuring the security of complex systems involves the strategic allocation of defensive resources to prevent various types of attacks from succeeding. A defender often has multiple types of defensive assets at its disposal, where it must decide how to optimally deploy their heterogeneous capabilities across different attack types. In this paper, we formulate a multi-resource allocation problem in the form of a General Lotto game where a defender possesses various types of resources. A feature that we introduce is that their individual effectiveness against different types of attacks is characterized by a network weight matrix. In our analysis, we derive upper and lower bounds on the performance of the defender, and provide numerical evidence suggesting that they are tight. For the case of two attack types, we analytically prove that the bounds coincide, establishing an exact equilibrium characterization. We then numerically compare our proposed networked multi-resource architecture to an independent-defense benchmark from the existing literature. These results highlight fundamental and tractable structures underlying multi-attack-type defense problems.

0.21

Robust Direct Preference Optimization under Preference Label-Flip Attacks

cs.LG cs.AIstat.ML ·2026-10-18 ·Chenye Yang, Weiyu Xu, Lifeng Lai
similarity 0.58
Abstract

Direct Preference Optimization (DPO) is widely used for offline Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback. However, recent works have shown that DPO can be easily manipulated by adversarial preference label flip attacks, which are specifically designed to mislead the learner toward an attacker-chosen target policy. To address this issue, we design robust DPO methods that can defend against such attacks. Building on the property that lable flips induce parameter-independent gradient shifts in log-linear DPO, we propose Trim-$K$ Robust-DPO, which removes the $K$ highest-impact pairs, and Soft-Trim-$K$ Robust-DPO, which smoothly downweights them. We establish deterministic gradient perturbation bounds uniformly over all attack sets containing at most $K$ flips, explicitly separating defense-induced bias from surviving attack effects. Under bounded-region assumptions, these bounds yield time-uniform parameter and policy deviation guarantees. We further quantify how quadratic regularization improves curvature while introducing additional bias. Experiments on Stanford Human Preferences, HH-RLHF, and UltraFeedback-Binarized validate our analysis.

0.11

Preventing Model Extraction in Contextual Linear Optimization

cs.LG math.OC ·2026-10-21 ·Adam N. Elmachtoub, Tianyi Lin, Wenxuan Liu
theory similarity 0.58
Abstract · 25 pages, 11 figures

Consider a contextual linear optimization problem, where a predict-then-optimize (PTO) system returns optimal decisions without revealing the cost vectors used in its downstream linear program. Our focus is on how to prevent attackers, who can submit context queries, from extracting the underlying prediction model. Although the cost-to-decision map is many-to-one, observations across contexts can reveal the underlying prediction model. For linear models, we provide sufficient conditions where the attacker can learn the model up to positive scaling by only observing the decision. These conditions motivate an adaptive attack that alternates inverse optimization with boundary sampling, i.e., using context queries leading to decision boundaries of the current attacker model. To prevent extraction, we propose a mechanism that perturbs decisions only when the predicted cost vector is near a decision boundary. We establish a regret bound in terms of the perturbation radius. For the attackers that fit the defended responses as optimal decisions under the evaluation distribution, we also prove a lower bound on expected extraction error. Experiments on synthetic instances and real data quantify the security-performance trade-off of the defense mechanism and illustrate that our defense can increase the extraction error.

0.18