CS Paper Radar

On Global Regulatability of Robot Manipulators by Classical PID

Cheng Zhao, Jingru Zhu, Lei Guo

cs.RO eess.SY ·submitted 2026-09-01 13:13 UTC · v2

Abstract

A long-standing open problem in robot manipulator control is whether global regulation can be achieved by classical PID control. This paper provides an answer to this question for classical PID controllers with triple parameters (k_p,k_i,k_d) in R^3. We find and prove that for one-degree-of-freedom manipulators, the classical PID control guarantees global stability and asymptotic regulation under standard structural assumptions, and further derive explicit quantitative design conditions for the PID gains. However, for multi-degree-of-freedom cases, we can construct a robot manipulator satisfying the same structural assumptions for which no choice of PID gains (k_p,k_i,k_d) can achieve global asymptotic regulation. These results provide a fundamental understanding of the abovementioned open problem, revealing both the fundamental capability and intrinsic limitation of the classical PID control for robot manipulator dynamics.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Collocated Shape Regulation for Soft Robots

cs.RO eess.SY ·2026-09-23 ·Pietro Pustina, Ebrahim Shahabi, Daniel Feliu-Talegon, Alessandro De Luca, Cosimo Della Santina
hot direction similarity 0.65
Abstract · 33 pages, 22 figures

Controlling the shape of a continuum soft robot typically requires an accurate dynamic model and actuation of all degrees of freedom. We show that regulating only the actuated coordinates, through collocated shape control, achieves provably stable convergence of those coordinates and, under an explicit compatibility condition, of the entire robot shape. While collocated control is a cornerstone of high-performance motion control in rigid robotics, extending this formulation to continuum soft robots has remained challenging due to the complexity of their dynamics. We present the first general framework for collocated control of continuum soft robots and derive a unified family of controllers, including PD, PID, PsatID, and their counterparts with compensation and cancellation components. The framework unifies existing approaches while introducing new controller designs. In particular, we develop three classes of PD and PID like regulators with local, semi-global, and global stability guarantees, and provide rigorous convergence analyses for each. Extensive experimental validation demonstrates the effectiveness of the proposed methods across different model discretizations and controller parameters. The resulting framework provides practical design guidelines for selecting and implementing controllers with known stability guarantees, without requiring a complete dynamic model of the robot

0.33

SPPID: Saddle-Point PID for Constrained Optimization

eess.SY math.OC ·2026-09-25 ·Veronica Centorrino, Rawan Hoteit, Efe C. Balta, John Lygeros
similarity 0.58
Abstract · 37 pages, 11 figures

This paper studies constrained optimization problems through the lens of feedback control. Building on the interpretation of Lagrange multipliers as feedback controllers, we propose the \emph{saddle-point PID (SPPID) dynamics}: a unified proportional--integral--derivative (PID) framework for continuous-time saddle-point dynamics. The proposed dynamics employ PID control for equality constraints and anti-windup PI control for inequality constraints. We show that SPPID is equivalent to a preconditioned primal--dual gradient flow of the augmented Lagrangian. This equivalence reveals the distinct role of each feedback component: integral action enforces constraint satisfaction, proportional action induces the augmented Lagrangian structure, and derivative action modifies the geometry of the primal dynamics via a state-dependent Riemannian metric. For convex problems, we establish convergence to the KKT set together with conditions for global asymptotic stability. For equality-constrained problems, we establish local exponential convergence for nonlinear equality constraints under standard assumptions, and show that projected gradient flow emerges as the infinite derivative-gain limit. For strongly convex problems with affine equality or inequality constraints, we establish global exponential convergence by leveraging contraction theory. Finally, we provide various numerical examples to illustrate the utility of SPPID.

0.42

Three High Performance Global Tracking Composite Adaptive Controllers for Fully Actuated Euler-Lagrange Systems: Experimental Validation

eess.SY ·2026-09-22 ·Luis Cervantes-Pérez, Jose Guadalupe Romero, Romeo Ortega, Víctor Santibáñez, Jesús Sandoval
similarity 0.57
Abstract

Three adaptive global tracking controllers for fully actuated Euler-Lagrange systems, with verifiable performance improvement over existing designs, are reported in this letter. Two of these controllers ensure global exponential convergence under a weak interval excitation condition. Besides, one of the proposed controllers features a simple adaptive PID-like structure that-unlike classical solutions-avoids the need for additional filtering. We adopt a composite adaptation architecture, invoke a novel parameterization of the system dynamics and use a high performance estimation scheme recently introduced in the literature. Real-time experiments and a comparative study with a learning-based adaptive controller on a two-degrees-of-freedom manipulator arm illustrate the effectiveness of the proposed controllers.

0.21

Dual Path Following for an Aerial Manipulator Under State and Input Constraints via Transverse Feedback Linearization

cs.RO eess.SYmath.OC ·2026-11-01 ·Hamza Tariq, Adeel Akhtar
code/data similarity 0.55
Abstract · 8 pages, 3 Figures

This paper studies dual path following for a quadrotor carrying a three-degree-of-freedom arm. The center of mass of the combined system must follow a vehicle path and the end effector must follow a second path, while the arm respects its joint limits and avoids its singular postures. The vehicle and the arm are mechanically coupled, so one controller must handle both paths. With the center of mass and the end-effector path coordinates as outputs, and a dynamic extension of the thrust, the system admits a normal form without internal dynamics. We characterize the states where this normal form fails. We formulate the transverse feedback linearizing controller as a quadratic program that relaxes only the speed of the end effector along its path and imposes safety and actuator limits as inequality constraints. The program reduces to a scalar problem with a closed-form solution. If it remains strictly feasible for all time, the feedback is locally Lipschitz, both paths are invariant and attractive, and every constraint holds. In the physics engine Drake, the controller resolves a conflict between the two speed references by slowing the end effector while both paths remain invariant. By contrast, a cascade with a safety filter leaves both paths. Code and animations are available at https://gradslab.github.io/am_dual_pf-/

0.22

Conditions for Normality of Pontryagin's Maximum Principle in the Absence of State Constraints

eess.SY math.OC ·2026-11-03 ·André Tits, Pierre-Antoine Absil, Noé Tits
similarity 0.53
Abstract

Pontryagin's Maximum Principle is said to be "normal" for the problem at hand when it has a solution (maximizer u*) that explicitly involves the problem's cost function, making the maximum principle helpful (while in the opposite situation it is of no help). The aim of the present paper is, for Lagrange optimal control problems without state constraints, to identify classes of problems for which the Principle is normal. General conditions are introduced that guarantee normality, and classes of problems that satisfy these conditions are identified. Such classes include problems for which the constrained (by bounds on the control values) "augmented" reachable set, with cost along an upward vertical axis, has a convex lower-boundary function and the optimal terminal state lies in the relative interior of the reachable state set, with the terminal constraint within the affine hull of that set. Such classes include problems for which the constrained (by bounds on the values of the control signal) "augmented" (with the cost value along an upward "vertical axis") reachable set has a "convex" lower boundary for which the optimal terminal state lies in the relative interior of the set of reachable states. Special attention is given to Lagrange steering problems: sufficient conditions are obtained on a nested sequence of sub-classes of such problems, culminating with the class of steering problems with scalar control signal and linear time-invariant (LTI) state dynamics and objective integrand, for which normality is guaranteed whenever all eigenvalues of the state dynamics matrix A are real (e.g., if A is symmetric or triangular or the system is overdamped) or have small enough imaginary parts; simple 2 x 2 examples show that, in contrast with the situation in the finite-dimensional case, this property does not extend to arbitrary A matrices.

0.31

Beyond Terminal Constraints: Reliable Robot Control with Learned Safe Sets

cs.RO ·2026-11-04 ·Gianni Lunardi, Elias Fontanari, Matteo Saveriano, Andrea Del Prete
similarity 0.53
Abstract

Ensuring safety in advanced robot control methods such as Model Predictive Control (MPC) and Reinforcement Learning remains an open challenge. A common approach relies on control-invariant sets, yet their exact computation for nonlinear systems is generally intractable, and numerical approximations compromise theoretical guarantees. In this work, we show that safety does not need to rely exclusively on control invariance. We introduce novel classes of safe sets, each broader than classical control-invariant sets, and analyze corresponding MPC schemes that guarantee recursive feasibility by constraining different nodes of the prediction horizon rather than only the terminal state. Furthermore, when the safe set is an inner approximation of a suitable control-invariant set, our methods can ensure safety through a safe-abort strategy, even in the absence of recursive feasibility. We validate our approaches in extensive simulations on a 6-joint robot manipulator, showing fewer constraint violations than state-of-the-art methods while maintaining comparable tracking performance and computational efficiency. Hardware experiments further demonstrate the practicality of our schemes for real-world robotic applications.

0.13

Constrained Koopman Control Parametrization: Convex Controller Synthesis for Tracking under Input Constraints

eess.SY ·2026-10-21 ·Taha Ondogan, Ran Jing, Andrew P. Sabelhaus, Roberto Tron
similarity 0.52
Abstract · 16 pages, 8 figures

Koopman operator theory represents nonlinear systems with linear and bilinear terms in the state and input observables, greatly simplifying control design. However, incorporating input constraints into Koopman-based controller synthesis remains challenging, limiting their applicability to constrained control tasks such as tracking. This paper develops a constrained Koopman Control Parametrization (cKoCoP) framework for synthesizing state-feedback controllers that satisfy prescribed input constraints with Lyapunov-certified stability of the identified lifted closed loop. The cKoCoP offers nonlinear state-feedback via linear-in-observables feedback, enabling linear controller design. The proposed controller is obtained through convex optimization: we incorporate ellipsoidal or polytopic input constraints with the S-procedure or Farkas-lemma-based conditions. We also introduce a Control Lyapunov Function (CLF) for trajectory tracking which incorporates input constraints. The approach is validated on two canonical nonlinear systems, a double pendulum and a unicycle, demonstrating data-driven tracking while respecting input constraints. Experiments validate the method's robustness to measurement noise, and runtime improvements over Koopman Model Predictive Control (KMPC) baselines. The results demonstrate that cKoCoP achieves competitive tracking performance with substantially reduced online computational cost, supporting its potential for real-time constrained tracking applications.

0.25

Capability-Conditioned Graph Control Barrier Functions for Zero-Shot Safe Navigation of Heterogeneous Mobile Robot Teams

cs.RO ·2026-10-30 ·Joonkyung Kim, Janghyun Cho, Jeehyun Lee, Changjoo Nam, Yiwei Lyu
similarity 0.52
Abstract · 9 pages, 5 figures, 2 tables

Multi-robot systems are increasingly deployed as heterogeneous fleets with diverse kinematic and actuation capabilities. While graph control barrier function (GCBF) methods provide a scalable framework for decentralized safe control, existing approaches typically assume homogeneous robot dynamics. Methods that directly encode robot classes can distinguish known types, but do not represent state-dependent motion capabilities or naturally transfer to unseen robot models. To address this challenge, we propose the Capability-Conditioned Heterogeneous Graph Control Barrier Function (CC-HGCBF), defined in a shared second-order reference-point operational space. This formulation provides a common geometric representation of safety across heterogeneous robots while retaining their model-specific dynamics and admissible control constraints. To enable zero-shot transfer, we introduce the Radial Capability Field (RCF), a compact, fixed-dimensional representation of each robot's state-dependent finite-horizon reachable velocity set. Conditioning the shared graph barrier and decentralized policy on the RCF enables them to adapt to changes in robot state, kinematic constraints, and control limits without relying on predefined robot identities. We jointly train the barrier and policy using proactive safety labeling and neural CBF-QP supervision, and evaluate them on mixed teams containing both seen and unseen robot models. Experiments demonstrate scalable safe coordination and zero-shot transfer to robot models and capability variations withheld during training. Physical-robot experiments further demonstrate zero-shot deployment to unseen kinematic models without retraining.

0.58