CS Paper Radar

Same path, different walk: a mechanistic comparison of looped and stacked transformer encoders on 12-lead ECG

Pawel Olszowiec, Michal Byra, Grzegorz Gruszczynski, Grzegorz Stefanski, Alberto Presta

cs.LG math.DS ·submitted 2026-09-14 12:50 UTC · v2

Abstract

Recurrent Transformers reusing their weights rather than stacking $L$ distinct layers are becoming widely adopted due to their parameter efficiency [1,2,3]. However, the exact representational and dynamical differences between looped and stacked architectures remain uncharacterized. This paper presents a controlled study on the example of bViT model [1] applying one weight-tied block $L$ times. We train two models: bViT and standard ViT [4] on 12-lead electrocardiogram (ECG) classification tasks from the PTB-XL dataset under identical training protocols. Despite an $8.9\times$ parameter reduction, bViT achieves accuracy parity with ViT. Geometric similarity metrics demonstrate that both architectures construct comparable latent representations in an equivalent canonical order. Crucially, their dynamics differ: bViT exhibits smaller step sizes and inter-patient sensitivity, as well as near-neutral behavior away from the data manifold, whereas ViT exhibits collapsing dimensionality of representations and out-of-distribution feature expansion.

Comment
5 pages, 7 figures

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

TRACE: Tractable Routing Autoencoder for Clinical ECG

cs.LG ·2026-09-20 ·Shunbo Jia, Runze Ma, Haonan Lyu, Haijin Zhang, Qiang Yang +1 more
similarity 0.66
Abstract · 20 pages, 7 figures, 7 tables

Deep learning has advanced automated electrocardiogram (ECG) diagnosis, but the field's most accurate models, foundation models pretrained on millions of recordings, are not decision-pathway auditable: a clinician cannot trace a diagnosis to a physiological pathway or intervene on one. We propose TRACE, a Tractable Routing Autoencoder for Clinical ECG, whose 32-dimensional clinical latent space is specified in advance from domain knowledge rather than discovered by optimization. TRACE partitions this space into perfusion, structure, and conduction subspaces, routes each to its own diagnostic head by design, regularizes the partition with an orthogonality penalty, and reconstructs the ECG through a decoder that permits latent perturbation. On PTB-XL and Georgia, TRACE exceeds unconstrained classifiers and stays ahead of an ECG foundation model pretrained on ten million recordings, evaluated by linear probe on frozen features, at roughly an eighth of the parameter count. On the nine-label CPSC2018 cohort, which carries no structural class, the framework transfers with only the routing table re-specified to a perfusion/rhythm/conduction partition. Joint probe, erasure, and perturbation analyses verify the routing contract, and perturbing the depolarization and repolarization pathways modulates the reconstructed waveform. Removing the specified partition and its orthogonality penalty costs 1.70 AUC and 11.30 macro-F1 points on PTB-XL, and 2.76 AUC and 16.92 macro-F1 points on Georgia. A capacity-matched permutation control places arbitrary assignments within 0.34 AUC points of the ontology routing and leaves macro-F1 statistically level (p=0.619): the ontology supplies decision-pathway auditability at no macro-F1 cost.

0.32

The Impact of Temporal Context Length and Encoding Strategies on Self-Supervised ECG Representation Learning

cs.LG eess.SP ·2026-08-13 ·Ahmed Sameh, Ramzi Al-Sharawi, Yogatheesan Varatharajah
publishedcode/data similarity 0.64
Abstract · Accepted at the 48th Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society (EMBC 2026). 6 pages, 2 figures…

Self-supervised electrocardiogram (ECG) models are often trained on a few seconds of ECG signal and, increasingly, on discretized token sequences. It remains unclear whether these choices sacrifice information needed for rhythm inference and longitudinal consistency in real-world ambulatory recordings. We present a controlled study on the Icentia11k single-lead dataset that varies (i) the input horizon (16 seconds, 1 minute, 5 minutes, and 10 minutes) and (ii) the front-end representation (continuous convolutional patch embeddings vs. fixed vector-quantized tokens), while holding the Transformer backbone and training protocol constant. Representations are assessed by downstream abnormal rhythm detection and by patient-level retrieval that probes cross-session stability. Our results show that increasing temporal context beyond 16-second snapshots yields stronger transfer and higher retrieval accuracy, with the strongest performance achieved by the 5- and 10-minute models, indicating improved capture of slow-varying rhythm dynamics and individual-specific structure. Across all evaluated horizons, continuous patch embeddings outperform discretized tokens, suggesting that quantization can discard clinically relevant waveform detail. These findings motivate ECG foundation models that emphasize extended context and continuous encoders for clinical prediction and similarity-based applications. Our code and pretrained models are publicly available at https://github.com/muha-0/ecg-ssl-representation-learning.

0.41

Compact and Decodable Electrocardiogram Text for Large Language Models

cs.CL ·2026-11-17 ·Elif Dorukbaşı, İlker Türker
code/data similarity 0.61
Abstract · 9 pages, 5 figures, 5 tables. Preprint of a chapter submitted to "Advances in Artificial Intelligence and Data Science: Methods, Systems, an…

When a twelve-lead electrocardiogram is written as text for a large language model, the number of tokens has to be balanced against the information lost through compression. This paper presents a deterministic encoding that writes eight independent leads as amplitude letters and exact time gaps and recovers the remaining four limb leads algebraically. The key points are selected with a cardiac-cycle-dependent tolerance, the amplitudes are parameterized by a 26-letter logarithmic codebook learned from a training set, and a 10-step tolerance schedule keeps all records within a fixed token budget. The encoding was applied to 21,388 records from the public PTB-XL database and evaluated using an exact decode-and-re-encode round trip, waveform reconstruction error, and a paired comparison of convolutional classifiers trained with 5 different seeds on signals from the original and decoded databases. All records were contained in 4,080 tokens (average: 2,866 tokens, 64.3% fewer than a per-sample transcription), and all stored lead strings were exactly reproduced. The average correlation between the decoded and reference signals was 0.982. The macro-averaged area under the receiver operating characteristic curve was 0.9167 for the reference signals and 0.9157 for the decoded signals (paired difference -0.0010; 95% patient-level bootstrap interval, -0.0028 to 0.0007), within the pre-specified non-inferiority margin of -0.010; this is not a confirmatory result, because the test fold had been used during encoder development. The diagnostic content of a compact text can therefore be preserved, while the language model's ability to read the text is yet another matter.

0.43

On the role of the tokenizer in ECG transformer models

cs.LG cs.AI ·2026-09-14 ·Jiawei Li, Fabio Bonassi, Johan Sundström, Thomas B. Schön, Antônio H. Ribeiro
code/datahot direction similarity 0.61
Abstract

Tokenization determines both the physiological content presented to an ECG Transformer and the sequence over which attention operates. We compare eight tokenization strategies across Transformer, Informer, Reformer, and FEDformer on the nine-label CPSC2018 classification task. The input projection and principal backbone capacity are controlled to isolate the effect of token construction. Median-beat and HeartLang tokenization achieve mean macro-AUCs of 0.893 and 0.889 across the four backbones, compared with 0.822 and 0.824 for point-wise and patch-wise tokenization. Pooling the two physiology-aware representations yields an 8.2% relative improvement in macro-AUC. They also reduce mean sequence length from 1,250 to 158 tokens and mean peak training memory from 5.21 to 0.27 GB. The results show that aligning tokens with ECG morphology can improve both predictive performance and memory efficiency without increasing backbone capacity. The source code is available on https://github.com/LeeJarvis996/ecg_tokenizer.

0.35

Multi-Label 12-Lead ECG Classification on the PTB-XL Dataset: A Comparative Evaluation of Deep Learning Architectures and Heterogeneous Ensemble Approaches

eess.SP ·2026-09-11 ·Yunus Emre Mert, Ece Akdoğan, Hüseyin Üvet
similarity 0.61
Abstract · 6 pages, 2 figures, 1 table

This study aimed to compare the performance of different deep learning architectures and heterogeneous ensemble learning approaches for multi-label 12-lead ECG classification on the PTB-XL dataset. Five different models, namely 1D-ResNet18, Bidirectional Mamba, xLSTM, CWT-ViT-KAN, and the pre-trained ECGFounder, were evaluated. Utilizing the recommended split structure of the PTB-XL dataset, folds 1-8 were allocated as the training set, fold 9 as the validation set, and fold 10 as the independent test set. In addition to the individual models, three different ensemble approaches were investigated: Equal-Weight Soft Voting, Validation-Weighted Soft Voting, and stacking. Among the individual models, the highest performance was achieved by ECGFounder, with a Macro AUROC of 0.930 and a Macro AUPRC of 0.823. For the ensemble models, the highest values in the primary macro performance metrics were obtained by the stacking approach, achieving a Macro AUROC of 0.936, a Macro AUPRC of 0.836, and a Macro F1 of 0.763. The highest subset accuracy of 0.630 was achieved using the Validation-Weighted Soft Voting method. The findings indicate that heterogeneous ensemble models, which combine different representation learning approaches, can provide additional performance improvements over individual models in multi-label ECG classification.

0.20

Beat-Synchronous Tokenization for ECG Transformers

cs.LG eess.SP ·2026-08-31 ·Ahmed Sameh, Nolan Wilson, Max Enderlein, Yogatheesan Varatharajah
published similarity 0.61
Abstract · 6 pages, 1 figure, 3 tables. Accepted at the 2026 IEEE International Workshop on Machine Learning for Signal Processing (MLSP 2026)

Transformer-based electrocardiogram (ECG) models commonly tokenize waveforms into fixed temporal patches. Though convenient, fixed patching can split heartbeat structures across token boundaries. We study beat-synchronous tokenization as a physiologically grounded alternative, comparing fixed patches with three beat-aligned strategies: resampled beats, adaptive pooled beats, and resampled beats augmented with R--R interval information. Experiments span two settings: 10-second 12-lead diagnostic classification on PTB-XL after MIMIC-IV-ECG masked pretraining, and 60-second single-lead rhythm classification on Icentia11k after patient-level contrastive pretraining. On PTB-XL, resampled beat tokens achieve the highest mean macro Area Under the ROC Curve (AUROC; 0.8945) and nearly match the best fixed-patch macro Area Under the Precision-Recall Curve (AUPRC; 0.7414), reducing average sequence length from 100 to 11.2 tokens. On Icentia11k, beat-synchronous tokenizers obtain comparable AUPRC to fixed patching with better stability across runs. These results suggest morphology-preserving beat tokenization is a compact, competitive alternative to fixed temporal patching.

0.21

TransECG-SSL: Hybrid Self-Supervised Representation Learning for ECG Arrhythmia Classification

cs.LG ·2026-10-26 ·Ahtisham Ayyub, Fasih Haider, Muhammad Rehan Usman, Saturnino Luz, Christos Politis +1 more
similarity 0.61
Abstract · Submitted to IEEE Journal of Biomedical and Health Informatics

Cross-dataset generalisation remains a major challenge for automated electrocardiogram (ECG) arrhythmia classification because of differences in patient populations, acquisition protocols, annotation practices, and class distributions. Learning representations that remain informative across independent datasets could reduce reliance on dataset-specific labelled data. We propose TransECG-SSL, a self-supervised framework for transferable heartbeat representation learning from unlabelled ECG data. A Transformer encoder is pretrained using a hybrid objective combining masked signal reconstruction and contrastive learning, then frozen and evaluated by linear probing under patient-disjoint evaluation. Experiments across three public ECG databases and seven source--target settings show that Hybrid SSL consistently outperforms randomly initialised Transformers and achieves higher balanced accuracy than architecture-matched source-supervised pretraining. Reconstruction-only SSL remains competitive with Hybrid SSL, whereas contrastive-only pretraining performs substantially worse, highlighting the importance of masked reconstruction for transferability. Cross-dataset transfer nevertheless reduces balanced accuracy relative to target-specific self-supervised pretraining, while minority arrhythmia classes remain challenging under severe class imbalance. These findings demonstrate the potential of label-efficient self-supervised learning for cross-dataset ECG representation transfer while highlighting persistent limitations from domain shift and class imbalance.

0.24

A Hybrid CNN--State-Space--Attention Backbone with Joint-Embedding Predictive Pretraining for 12-Lead ECG Classification

cs.CV ·2026-09-24 ·Yakoub Bazi, Sarah Aljuhani, Mohamad M. Al Rahhal, Mansour Zuair, Naif Alajlan
code/data similarity 0.60
Abstract

Automatic 12-lead electrocardiogram (ECG) classification requires representations that jointly capture local waveform morphology, long-range temporal dynamics, and cross-lead dependencies, yet integrating these properties within a single efficient architecture remains challenging. This paper introduces a hybrid CNN-SSM-Attention backbone for 12-lead ECG classification. A convolutional stem performs early waveform tokenization and temporal reduction, mixed state-space and depthwise-convolutional blocks model temporal dynamics and local morphology, and a late self-attention stage enables global token interaction at reduced resolution. To improve transfer from unlabeled data, we further develop an ECG-oriented Joint-Embedding Predictive Pretraining (JEPA) framework. Unlike ViT-based JEPA methods that mask patch tokens before the encoder, the proposed method samples span masks at the latent temporal resolution and projects them back to the waveform domain, then predicts clean latent targets from a momentum encoder without waveform reconstruction. Experiments on CPSC2018, Chapman-Shaoxing, and PTB-XL, with pretraining on approximately 350K unlabeled CODE-15 recordings, show that the proposed backbone provides strong supervised baselines under a compact parameter budget. JEPA pretraining further improves transfer, particularly in reduced-label settings and under both full fine-tuning and LoRA-based adaptation. Code: https://github.com/yakoubbazi/Hybrid_ECG_Jepa

0.26