CS Paper Radar

Model-Free PID Tuning by Step-Response Inspection

Daniel Pachner, Pavel Otta, Jiří Dostál, Vladimír Havlena

eess.SY eess.SP ·submitted 2026-09-14 15:13 UTC · v1
unusual

Abstract

Industrial PID loops are still tuned by hand: step the setpoint, look at the response, change a gain. This paper turns that procedure into an algorithm, SPIN, for Step-response Phase-portrait INspection. From a single closed-loop step response we form three phase portraits of the control deviation and count how many times each trajectory winds around its settling point. The counts are dimensionless and independent of the step size and of the clock. They show which channel is under-damped: integral, proportional, or derivative. A triangular rule reads the three counts, cutting the gain of the one band whose fault is certain and raising that of every band the same test shows to be within its limit. No model is identified and no optimization is solved. The iteration is deterministic and its gains stay inside a fixed box. Because a ringing count is itself the evidence that the loop is in the regime where cutting that band's gain reduces the count, the iteration settles into a cycle at the edge of the well-damped set. It needs no excitation beyond a routine setpoint step, so it can run on a process in operation, and it may start from arbitrary gains, including destabilizing ones. SPIN assumes a stable, self-regulating process whose gain and phase both fall with frequency, which covers the lag-plus-dead-time models common in process control, and a controller from the nested family $\mathrm{I} \subset \mathrm{PI} \subset \mathrm{PID}$ with integral action present. We validate it on a battery of process-typical plants with one fixed step size and one set of dimensionless constants throughout. Every decision is visible: the operator sees what the algorithm sees. A reference implementation and an interactive demonstration are public.

Comment
12 pages, 4 figures, ready for submission

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Learning to Tune with Biased Gradients: Iterative Feedback Tuning of Model-Free Control on Throttle Valves

cs.LG cs.AI ·2026-11-04 ·Félix Martinez-Jiménez, Sander Miller-Murphy, Tobie Ondoa-Essomba, Emmanuel Witrant
similarity 0.52
Abstract

Iterative feedback tuning (IFT) learns the parameters of a fixed-structure controller by stochastic gradient descent. At each iteration, two closed-loop experiments are run on the plant: the first one measures the tracking error, and the second one, driven by this error, provides the sensitivities from which the gradient of the cost is estimated. This estimate is unbiased for linear plants only. We study the biased case on automotive electronic throttle valves, whose friction and stiction vary between valves and runs, controlled by an intelligent proportional (model-free) controller, which is an incremental PI controller. We show that the mismatch of the controller state at the start of the two experiments, which stiction makes unavoidable, adds an error inversely proportional to the amplitude of the second experiment. On digital twins of ten valves, the IFT gradient is a descent direction in only 69\% of the low-cost region, friction being the cause, and all update rules plateau and then drift. On two hardware valves, the best update rule depends on the noise structure of the gradient. On the first valve, where one gradient component is buried in noise, Adam outperforms Gauss--Newton, its normalisation and its momentum each improving one parameter. On the second valve, where both components are consistent, the same normalisation amplifies a direction that Gauss--Newton rightly discounts, and Adam drifts to a controller worse than the initial one. The twins reproduce the mechanism but not this ranking.

0.30

Locally homogeneous PID gain-scheduling for motion control systems

eess.SY ·2026-11-16 ·Andrey Polyakov, Michael Ruderman
unusual similarity 0.50
Abstract

A method for upgrading linear PID controller to a locally homogeneous PID regulator is developed. The homogeneous PID shares the gains with linear PID while the tuning of local homogeneity degrees could allow better regulation quality comparing with the linear algorithm. The homogeneous algorithm is obtained by means of the scaling the gains of the linear controller dependently of the current value of the output and its derivative. The linear algorithm can be recovered from the homogeneous one by assigning zero homogeneity degree. The tuning scheme for the homogeneous controller is suggested and illustrated experimentally in comparison with a standard PID control, which is robustly designed by the loop-shaping around the critical frequency range. The experiments are accomplished on a linear-motion stage system with voice-coil-motor and noisy contactless output measurements.

0.28

A Plantwide Simulation Library for Control-Oriented Design: Analytical and Data-driven Use Cases

eess.SY ·2026-10-21 ·Kyle Territo, Luis A. Briceno-Mena, Jose A. Romagnoli
similarity 0.49
Abstract · 6 pages, 3 figures, Submitted to the American Control Conference (ACC) 2027

Control structures and operability indices for plantwide processes are developed and compared on fixed simulated flowsheets, and the configuration of a study is rarely reported in a form that another group can reproduce. In this contribution, plantbench, a library of plantwide process simulations in which the design, the controller tuning and the instrumentation of a plant are declared as hashed plain-data configurations, is presented. On a heat-integrated reactor--separator--recycle plant with an open-loop unstable reactor, a heuristic plantwide control design prices four heat-exchanger networks (HENs) by the least damping ratio of the linearized closed loop, and 2016 closed-loop runs over networks, tuning, analyzer deadtime and upsets test that ranking. Results show that the damping ratio orders the networks as the runs do with the network that recovers the most heat reaching 0.013 against 0.157 for the selected one and cycling under a throughput increase, but that it is a weak detector of which operation will oscillate. At the recall of a random forest on the first 100 min after an upset, 60 of 82 limit cycles, a damping-ratio threshold raises 173 false alarms against 5. The integral time of the temperature loop, to which the damping ratio is nearly insensitive, decides in part whether the plant holds an operating point.

0.26

Fast Sampling or High Gain? iP versus PI Control

eess.SY ·2026-11-09 ·Mohamed Camil Belhadjoudja
similarity 0.46
Abstract · Submitted to IEEE ECC 2027

Intelligent proportional (iP) controllers, introduced in the framework of model-free control, are often presented as an alternative to proportional-integral (PI) controllers that requires no model of the plant. This paper studies this property for a first-order linear plant under sampled-data implementation with a zero-order hold. When the time derivative of the output is estimated by a backward difference, the discrete-time iP and PI controllers are known to obey the same control law under a one-to-one correspondence between their parameters. Building on this correspondence, the paper derives necessary and sufficient conditions for exponential stability of the iP closed loop, in closed form, in terms of the controller parameters KP and alpha, the sampling period h, and the plant parameters. It then shows that, when the iP parameters are held fixed and the sampling period tends to zero, the closed-loop decay rate tends to the iP gain KP, provided that KP is positive and that the ratio rho between the input gain of the plant and alpha satisfies 0 < rho < 2. One closed-loop pole then behaves as 1 - h KP, while the other tends to 1 - rho. With fixed PI gains, by contrast, the decay rate tends to that of the continuous-time PI loop, which depends on the plant parameters. The two parametrizations therefore suggest different tuning procedures, although they achieve the same closed loops at every fixed sampling period. High gain for the PI is, in some sense, replaced by fast sampling of the iP. The results also make explicit which plant information the iP controller requires: the sign of the input gain and a bound on its magnitude in the limit of fast sampling, and bounds on both plant parameters at a given sampling period. Numerical experiments illustrate these results.

0.34

From PID to Reinforcement Learning in Building HVAC Control: A Control-Architecture Review of Tuning Strategies, Formulations, and Deployment Trade-offs

cs.LG ·2026-11-02 ·Erfan Haghighat Damavandi, Davide Papurello, Mahdi Alibeigi, Armin Keshavarz
similarity 0.45
Abstract · 52 pages, 6 Figs

This paper reviews control architectures for building heating, ventilation and air-conditioning (HVAC) systems, addressing the tension among energy demand, occupant comfort and equipment operability, and situating proportional-integral-derivative (PID) regulation within a layered control stack that also includes rule-based and model-based supervisory control and data-driven reinforcement learning (RL). It examines the thermostat-PID layer from two-position and scheduled setpoint control through proportional, PI and PID regulation and their tuning, then formulates RL for building control as a Markov decision process. Its central contribution is a taxonomy of where RL meets PID: RL as a gain tuner for an existing loop, as a direct replacement for the regulatory controller, as a hybrid with model predictive control, and as supervisory setpoint and schedule generation. Across these classes, the review establishes that the physical loop remains invariant while the intervention point changes, and that the classes differ in their requirements for actuation authority, state information, modelling, commissioning and constraint handling. It further establishes that PID is inexpensive and well codified but limited by nonlinearity, time variation, discrete mode switching, loop interaction and slow plant dynamics, while RL's admissible position must be argued rather than assumed. The paper concludes that these architectures are not competing philosophies of control but nested points of attachment on one HVAC plant, with hybrid implementations possible, and that deployment trade-offs must be assessed according to the specific control interface and scaffolding required.

0.25

A Modular State-Machine Based Event PID Controller

eess.SY ·2026-09-30 ·Sandesh Thapa, Zhen Qi
benchmark similarity 0.45
Abstract · pid control, time-trigged control, robust control, discrete events , state machine

In this paper, we present a modular proportional-integral-derivative (PID) controller whose computation and mode logic are executed by a higher-level state machine. Inspired by real-time safety-critical applications where computational load, actuator chattering, sensing error and noise are design challenges, the proposed algorithm wraps a standard PID inside a finite state machine with three states (pidInit, ErrorOutRange, ErrorInRange). The goal is to regulate a desired reference within a safe region of operation while reducing actuator chattering and creating a sizable hold band over the range of operation. This design is modular and can be easily integrated into a higher-level state machine with multiple low-level loops and states. The algorithm also has low computational complexity and is suitable for embedded hardware deployment. We demonstrate the effectiveness of the algorithm in simulation on the two test benches of a published event-based PID benchmark. The algorithm computes the control updates significantly less often than the time-triggered PID and less often than both dominant event-driven controllers, while keeping a fairly equivalent control performance profile. Furthermore, we also present some experimental results of the designed algorithm for a real-time flow control.

0.25

Tuning the Stochastic Machine: A Systems Engineer's Operating Model for Human-AI Engineering

cs.AI cs.SE ·2026-08-19 ·George Andrikopoulos
similarity 0.45
Abstract · 8 pages, 3 figures. Experience report and operating model

When an expert corrects an LLM assistant's error, the correction usually dies with the session, and the error class returns. I argue this is an operations problem, not a tooling problem: mechanisms for persisting corrections exist and are shipping, but the discipline for governing them -- versioning with provenance, recurrence monitoring, counter-metrics, retirement of stale rules -- does not. Writing as a systems engineer of thirty years, I map the LLM stack onto the machines my profession already operates (frozen silicon, firmware, loadable modules, persistent configuration, volatile memory), identify where the mapping fails (stochastic generation, configuration that binds only probabilistically, no general-purpose retirement (verification) stage by default), and derive from the failures a seven-principle operating discipline with an error loop at its core. Three cases from my own practice illustrate the mechanism, among them a control that silently became the exact harm it was built to prevent. I close with the measurement framework this view implies and the lab study required to test it.

0.21

An Enclosed Mode Is a Gauge Choice: Topology Relative to Reach in Certified Code World Models

cs.LG cs.AIeess.SY ·2026-08-28 ·Javier Aguilar Martín
theorycode/data similarity 0.45
Abstract · 33 pages, 2 figures. Paper 3 of a series (companion papers: arXiv:2607.14169, arXiv:2608.17956). Code, data, and Lean formalization: https:/…

A code world model accepted by a sampling gate can be exactly right on everything the gate can see and arbitrarily wrong beyond it. We characterize what a certified model can know, and what its errors can cost, when the omission is an annular freeze mode enclosing an unreachable interior. The gate quotient makes the question precise: acceptance-with-certainty determines the model exactly on the reachable query set; beyond reach is gauge. On a minimal ring instrument we prove the extreme case (a wrong-topology filled-disc artifact unfalsifiable by any sampling gate and bitwise harmless at play) and measure, with LLM synthesis across three model families, how one knob (a channel of width gamma) walks the same artifact through three regimes: unfalsifiable-and-harmless, falsifiable-and-costly, and instantly falsified. Three principles organize the empirics. First, danger is topology relative to reach: a channel the planner can use collapses the blind model's exploitation (play cost 1.09 to ~0 over a knee at gamma ~ 0.1), while a hidden channel with the same first Betti number keeps it at full strength (1.12). Second, repair is parameter-bound and sensor-bound: no family recovers the region from outside evidence; from inside, models pose the right topology but cannot pin its parameters, and the posed topology tracks the guiding persistent-homology summary's wrong beta_1 (a sensor with a measured geometric resolution limit), not the truth. Third, mitigation must match the error's dimension and direction: point fences fail against the one-dimensional boundary, a dimension-matched persisted fence collapses exploitation to a two-lesson transient (0.999 to 0.058), and the dual freedom certificate collapses the invented-mode failure symmetrically (1.769 to 0.029). In n dimensions the shell makes misidentification near-certain while the danger stays fully exploitable: the two axes are independent.

0.26