CS Paper Radar

Comparing Haptic Feedback Across Hand Tracking and Controllers in VR Object Interaction Tasks

Natalia Ocampo, J. Felipe Gonzalez, Robert J. Teather, Kiyoshi Kiyokawa

cs.HC ·submitted 2026-09-18 14:57 UTC · v1
published

Abstract

Hand tracking offers natural VR interaction but lacks controllers' inherent tactile feedback, while haptic feedback across input methods remains understudied. We conducted a participant study comparing vibration, impulse, and no feedback in hand- and controller-based VR interaction across grasp-, pinch-, and tap-like gestures assessing performance, workload, and preference. A custom glove and controller-mounted device provided both feedback types, aiming for consistency across input modalities. Controllers were faster for grasp and pinch, whereas hand tracking was more accurate for pinch and preferred overall. Haptics had limited performance effects, although impulse reduced grasp accuracy with controllers. Participants preferred vibration and impulse over no haptic feedback, favouring vibration overall. Our findings reveal a more nuanced relationship between haptic feedback, input device, and interaction context than suggested by previous work.

Journal ref
32nd ACM Symposium on Virtual Reality Software and Technology 2026 (VRST)
DOI
10.1145/3822517.3848655

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Selfrionette: A Fingertip Force-Input Controller for Continuous Full-Body Avatar Manipulation and Diverse Haptic Interactions

cs.HC ·2026-11-02 ·Takeru Hashimoto, Yutaro Hirao
top venuehighly cited similarity 0.84
Abstract · 14 pages, 12 figures. Author-prepared version of the UIST 2024 paper. Both authors contributed equally

We propose Selfrionette, a controller that uses fingertip force input to drive avatar movements in virtual reality (VR). This system enables users to interact with virtual objects and walk in VR using only fingertip force, overcoming physical and spatial constraints. Additionally, by fixing users' fingers, it provides users with counterforces equivalent to the applied force, allowing for diverse and wide dynamic range haptic feedback by adjusting the relationship between force input and virtual movement. To evaluate the effectiveness of the proposed method, this paper focuses on hand interaction as a first step. In User Study 1, we measured usability and embodiment during reaching tasks under Selfrionette, body tracking, and finger tracking conditions. In User Study 2, we investigated whether users could perceive haptic properties such as weight, friction, and compliance under the same conditions as User Study 1. Selfrionette was found to be comparable to body tracking in realism of haptic interaction, enabling embodied avatar experiences even in limited spatial conditions.

0.61

Comparing Hand and Controller Avatars with Hand Tracking and Controller-Based Interaction

cs.HC ·2026-09-18 ·Natalia Ocampo, J. Felipe Gonzalez, Robert J. Teather
top venuehighly cited similarity 0.79
Abstract

Previous research suggests that the congruency between common VR input devices - such as controllers or hand tracking - and their visual representations (e.g., hand or controller avatars) influences user experience and performance. However, the specific effects of input-avatar combinations remain underexplored. We study the effects of common input devices (hand tracking and controllers) and visual representations (hand and controller avatars) on performance and perceived success in target acquisition tasks. We included both grasping and pinching gestures across 16 combinations of input, avatar, and target size. Results indicate that hand tracking benefits from any form of visual representation - even when mismatched - achieving up to 5.8% greater accuracy compared to having no avatar, likely due to its reliance on visual feedback in the absence of a physical prop. Controllers were generally preferred and offered faster task completion. However, mismatched avatars had a stronger negative effect with controllers, particularly when the virtual gesture did not align with the physical action, leading to a 5.6% drop in accuracy compared to the matched condition - suggesting that inaccurate feedback can be more disruptive than having no avatar feedback at all.

0.65

TapID: Rapid touch interaction in virtual reality using wearable sensing

cs.HC eess.SP ·2026-10-19 ·Manuel Meier, Paul Streli, Andreas Fender, Christian Holz
top venuepositionhighly cited similarity 0.73
Abstract · accepted to IEEE VR 2021

Current Virtual Reality systems typically use cameras to capture user input from controllers or free-hand mid-air interaction. In this paper, we argue that this is a key impediment to productivity scenarios in VR, which require continued interaction over prolonged periods of time---a requirement that controller or free-hand input in mid-air does not satisfy. To address this challenge, we bring rapid touch interaction on surfaces to Virtual Reality---the input modality that users have grown used to on phones and tablets for continued use. We present TapID, a wrist-based inertial sensing system that complements headset-tracked hand poses to trigger input in VR. TapID embeds a pair of inertial sensors in a flexible strap, one at either side of the wrist; from the combination of registered signals, TapID reliably detects surface touch events and, more importantly, identifies the finger used for touch. We evaluated TapID in a series of userstudies on event-detection accuracy (F1 = 0.997) and hand-agnostic finger-identification accuracy (within-user: F1 = 0.93; across users: F1 = 0.91 after 10 refinement taps and F1 = 0.87 without refinement) in a seated table scenario. We conclude with a series of applications that complement hand tracking with touch input and that are uniquely enabled by TapID, including UI control, rapid keyboard typing and piano playing, as well as surface gestures.

0.63

Tactile Search: Enhancing Targeting in 3D Space

cs.HC ·2026-09-05 ·Amber Maimon, Iddo Yehoshua Wald, Jonas Keppel, Eunhee Chang, Yoshifumi Kitamura +3 more
top venue similarity 0.73
Abstract · Accepted to the 2026 IEEE International Symposium on Mixed and Augmented Reality (ISMAR 2026)

Visual search is crucial in daily life, from scanning for relevant information to spotting signs of danger. When sensory channels are overloaded or degraded, cognitive tasks can be supported by crossmodal information representations through vibrotactile cues. We introduce Tactile Search, an approach that uses modulation of frequency and amplitude of vibrations to the hands, for guiding attention to the location of objects in 3D space. We evaluated this approach in a competitive VR game where participants searched for targets using both vision and touch. Across two studies -- an in-the-wild demonstration (n=55) and a controlled laboratory experiment (n=28) -- we found that vibrotactile feedback significantly improved performance and increased user confidence. In the combined haptic condition, performance did not differ across target heights. We further analyzed participants' subjective experiences and search strategies highlighting the benefits of the tactile cues. Our findings suggest that Tactile Search can enhance interaction and provide design considerations for integrating haptic search into interactive systems.

0.24

Sharing Roughness with Hand-Outline Visualization to Reduce Sensory Asymmetry in VR Collaboration

cs.HC ·2026-08-29 ·Minju Baeck, Yoonseok Shin, Hyunjin Lee, Boram Yoon, Sang Ho Yoon +1 more
published similarity 0.72
Abstract · 10 pages, 8 figures, 9 tables. Accepted for publication in TVCG Special Issue on the 2026 IEEE Symposium on Mixed and Augmented Reality (IEE…

In collaborative VR, asymmetric access to haptic hardware creates a critical information gap: tactile evidence remains private to the haptic user, hindering the shared understanding needed for joint decision-making. While prior work has explored crossmodal sensory cues in virtual environments, it remains unclear how such cues should be designed for asymmetric collaboration, where collaborators receive information through different modalities. In our setting, the haptic user feels roughness through fingertip vibration, whereas the non-haptic user relies on vision alone. To reduce this asymmetry, we propose externalizing an object's tactile state through a glanceable hand-outline visual proxy. Specifically, we examine whether abstract visual roughness cues based on line shape and motion can encode three discrete roughness levels for both haptic and non-haptic users. Two preliminary studies establish a shared visual semantics by identifying visually distinguishable cues for non-haptic users and validating their visuo-haptic correspondence for haptic users. In a main study of a collaborative sorting task, showing this visualization on both users' hands significantly reduced completion time relative to a no-visualization baseline. Moreover, NU-side cue visibility was associated with higher confidence and perceived contribution for the non-haptic user. These findings show that hand-anchored abstract visual cues provide a lightweight means of externalizing object tactile state, reducing information asymmetry without compromising social presence.

0.17

Beyond Task Performance: Lessons Learned from Evaluating an Exploratory VR Interaction Technique

cs.HC ·2026-09-21 ·Nevzat Umut Demirseren, Corey Pittman, Isayas Berhe Adhanom, Karthikeyan Umapathy, Kevin Pfeil
similarity 0.70
Abstract · 6 pages, 10 figures

Dense virtual environments present significant challenges for object selection and manipulation, motivating the development of novel interaction techniques. This paper presents RodCast as an exploratory case study to investigate explicit trajectory visualization for interaction in dense virtual environments. We conducted a within-subjects user study comparing RodCast with Go-Go Hand and FlowerCone across three representative interaction tasks using objective performance measures, subjective evaluations, and qualitative feedback. The results revealed that the proposed implementation incurred performance costs on more demanding manipulation tasks, while qualitative feedback suggested that participants attributed these challenges to the complexity of the bimanual control scheme. Additionally, subjective evaluations and qualitative feedback identified benefits in spatial awareness and target accessibility that were not fully reflected by conventional performance measures. Together, these findings highlight the importance of control simplicity in interaction technique design and emphasize that incorporating qualitative feedback into the evaluation process is essential for distinguishing implementation limitations from the potential of the interaction concept. Collectively, these lessons provide guidance for the design and evaluation of future interaction techniques.

0.26

GraspPressure: Understanding Pressure Input With Busy Hands

cs.HC ·2026-10-29 ·Anand Kumar, Aditya Shekhar Nittala
published similarity 0.69
Abstract · To appear in the Proceedings of the ACM on Human-Computer Interaction (PACM HCI), presented at ACM Interactive Surfaces and Spaces (ISS 2026…

In many real-world scenarios, users interact with digital systems while their hands are partially occupied, such as when holding tools or everyday objects. Prior work on busy-hand interaction has focused on microgestures and motion-based techniques, which rely on finger articulation or relative movement. In situations where a stable grasp is required, such as handling fragile, heavy, or precision objects, such motion can be undesirable or impractical. Pressure-based input offers a complementary modality that enables interaction without changing finger pose, yet its use while holding objects has received limited empirical attention. To explore this, we conducted two within-subject experiments examining users' ability to perform controlled pressure selections and analyzing finger-specific performance across different grasps and geometries. Results indicate that participants can reliably perform pressure-based selections in these conditions, achieving high success rates (92.7% on average) with low selection times (1.74s on average). Our findings characterize the potential of pressure input as a complementary microinteraction modality under grasp-constrained, busy-hand scenarios.

0.28

Altered Visual Hand Feedback in Virtual Reality: An Exploratory Study in Essential Tremor

cs.HC cs.GR ·2026-10-30 ·Alejandro Pascual-Valdunciel, Marcos Sacristán-Moraleda, Verónica Giménez de Béjar, Julián Benito-León, Juan Marín-Lahoz +2 more
similarity 0.68
Abstract · 12 pages, 5 figures, 3 tables. Under revision

Pathological tremor is the most prevalent movement disorder worldwide, characterized by involuntary muscular oscillations within a frequency of 3 to 12 Hz. Despite extensive research, the underlying mechanisms that generate and modulate tremor are not yet understood, and treatments are usually insufficient. While it is known that visual feedback is an important afferent pathway, little is known about the impact of altering the hand's visual representation on tremor expression. With the development of immersive technologies, VR poses an excellent tool to study how alterations to the representation of the hands affect tremor. In this work, we study this through two complementary experiments. In the first one, we show that a consumer-level hand-tracking system substantially attenuates tremor-band movements without preventing successful task completion. In the second one, with eight patients with essential tremor, we observe task-dependent differences in physical tremor between VR and the real world, with several patients exhibiting lower tremor-band activity in both hand kinematics and muscle oscillations, particularly during reaching tasks. Our findings represent an initial step toward validating the use of VR as an experimental tool for the research and treatment of pathological tremor, while highlighting strong user- and task-dependent effects.

0.19