CS Paper Radar

Electrodermal Activity (EDA) for Stress Detection: A Comprehensive Survey and Benchmark

Gang Liu, Zixiong Ning

eess.SP ·submitted 2026-09-18 22:19 UTC · v1
surveybenchmark

Abstract

Electrodermal activity (EDA) is widely used for pervasive stress monitoring because of its sensitivity to sympathetic arousal and its computational efficiency. However, research remains fragmented: studies concentrate on a small subset of available datasets, preprocessing and evaluation protocols are inconsistent, and widely adopted methodological conventions remain unvalidated. Existing reviews summarize these practices without evaluating them under a common protocol. To bridge these gaps, this paper presents a comprehensive survey and benchmark for EDA-based stress detection. We review the technical pipeline from preprocessing to modeling and compile 26 public datasets and 22 representative unimodal studies to inform future dataset selection and methodological design. Under a subject-independent protocol spanning five diverse datasets, we benchmark decomposition, filtering, and channel-input choices alongside a broad range of machine learning (ML) and deep learning (DL) models in both in-domain and cross-domain transfer settings. Our results provide the first multi-dataset validation of cvxEDA, the default decomposition method, show that feature-based ML outperforms end-to-end (E2E) DL, and identify ecological validity as a key factor in cross-domain transfer. We conclude with directions toward robust, data-efficient, and trustworthy deployment.

Comment
19 pages, 5 figures, 7 tables

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Bridging the Gap in ECG-Based Emotion Recognition: A Unified Evaluation of Deep Learning Models

eess.SP cs.LG ·2026-09-14 ·Timothy C Sweeney-Fanelli, Ajan Ahmed, Masudul Imtiaz
publishedbenchmarkcode/data similarity 0.71
Abstract · Accepted at 2026 IEEE 17th Annual Ubiquitous Computing, Electronics & Mobile Communication Conference (UEMCON) - 2026 IEEE UEMCON

Deep learning has led to numerous proposed architectures for Automated Emotion Recognition (AER) from electrocardiogram (ECG) data, but inconsistencies in preprocessing, training, and evaluation make direct comparisons difficult. Most studies train and validate models on individual datasets collected under homogeneous conditions, limiting variability and raising concerns about generalizability. Cross-dataset validation is sometimes used but primarily assesses model adaptability rather than true generalization. This study presents a comparative analysis of prominent deep learning architectures in AER, emphasizing model generalization over dataset adaptability. To enable this benchmark, we introduce two open-source frameworks: Affective Research on Representations and Classifications (ARRC), a standardized benchmarking toolkit, and Affective Research Dataset Toolkit (ARDT), a framework for inter-dataset training and validation. Using ARDT, we consolidate three publicly available AER datasets, CUADS, ASCERTAIN, and DREAMER, into a single dataset, increasing variability in sensor types, recording conditions, and participant demographics. We then use ARRC to evaluate three widely studied deep learning models and two CNN baselines through hyperparameter optimization and 10-fold cross-validation. Our findings provide insights into the trade-offs between classification accuracy and model complexity, establishing a reproducible benchmark for AER research. All source code for ARRC, ARDT, and model evaluation is publicly available to ensure transparency and facilitate further research.

0.57

From Stress to Affect: Multimodal Deep Learning for Physiological Emotion Recognition Across Wearable Sensor Modalities

cs.LG ·2026-09-17 ·Desta Haileselassie Hagos, Saurav Keshari Aryal, Legand L. Burge
similarity 0.68
Abstract · Under review

Physiological emotion recognition using wearable sensors has important applications in mental health monitoring, affective computing, and human-computer interaction. However, existing studies typically evaluate a single model, sensing configuration, or dataset, limiting our understanding of how these factors influence recognition performance. We present a comparative study of temporal deep learning architectures for physiological emotion recognition using two multimodal wearable datasets: WESAD and EmoWear. Bidirectional long short-term memory (LSTM), temporal convolutional network (TCN), and Transformer models are evaluated under wrist-only, chest-only, and multimodal sensing configurations using participant-independent leave-one-subject-out cross-validation (LOSO-CV). We also investigate soft-voting ensembles, sensor ablation, sampling frequency, and gradient-based saliency. The Transformer achieved the highest multimodal accuracy on WESAD (99.02% +/- 0.51%), whereas the LSTM achieved the best multimodal accuracy on EmoWear for both arousal (91.80% +/- 1.06%) and valence (89.96% +/- 0.36%). These results show that relative architecture performance depends on dataset characteristics rather than one architecture being uniformly superior. Multimodal sensing consistently outperformed wrist-only and chest-only configurations across both datasets. Sampling-frequency analysis showed that 4 Hz provides a practical operating point, with performance comparable to higher frequencies at substantially lower training cost. These findings provide guidance for selecting architectures, sensing modalities, and sampling frequencies for wearable physiological emotion recognition.

0.09

MUPA${}^2$S: Multimodal Unified Perception with Asymmetric Attention for Stress Assessment

cs.CV cs.AI ·2026-11-01 ·Stefanos Gkikas, Thomas Kassiotis, Yu Fang, Christian Arzate Cruz, Miao Cheng +6 more
similarity 0.65
Abstract

Stress is a leading contributor to long-term physical and mental health decline. The automatic assessment of stress is a promising approach for continuous monitoring and mitigating human biases. However, the development of automated systems remains challenging due to the heterogeneity of physiological and behavioral signals. This paper presents MUPA${}^2$S, a multimodal framework for automatic stress assessment that combines facial video and ECG signals within a unified perception architecture. Both modalities are mapped into a shared token representation without modality-specific components, and processed through asymmetric attention comprising segment-local cross-attention and global self-attention across segment states. Experiments on a newly collected 58-subject stress dataset, evaluated under a stratified subject-level protocol, show that facial video achieves 69.44% test accuracy, while ECG-only performance remains close to chance under the proposed representation. Unified Video-ECG fusion achieves a test accuracy of 69.58% at approximately half the number of parameters of feature-level fusion, with negligible additional computational cost. Feature-level fusion does not exceed the video-only baseline, while unified input-level integration provides a parameter-efficient mechanism for jointly processing the two modalities.

0.14

UNWIND: Any-Length Facial Video for Stress Detection without Temporal Windowing

cs.CV cs.AI ·2026-08-26 ·Stefanos Gkikas, Christian Arzate Cruz, Eric Nichols, Giorgos Giannakakis, Randy Gomez
similarity 0.62
Abstract

Automatic stress recognition from facial video provides a non-contact approach for affective monitoring. However, most existing video-based methods divide complete recordings into shorter temporal segments before performing classification. Such segmentation requires additional decisions concerning segment duration, overlap, and prediction aggregation, and may restrict the model from exploiting information distributed across the entire recording. We introduce UNWIND, a facial-video framework for stress detection that analyzes a complete recording as a single model input, eliminating the need for temporal windowing or external segmentation. UNWIND reorganizes the video by folding its temporal dimension into the channel dimension of a two-dimensional spatial representation, which is subsequently processed through a unified asymmetric-attention architecture. With a temporal stride of $τ=1$, the framework processes the entire $120$-second sequence, corresponding to $3{,}600$ frames sampled at $30$~fps, in a single input. We evaluate seven temporal-stride settings on a stress dataset comprising $58$ subjects, using a stratified subject-level protocol that covers configurations from dense frame retention to sparse temporal sampling. The highest test accuracy, $70.02\%$, is obtained at $τ=15$, while processing all frames at $τ=1$ achieves a comparable accuracy of $69.73\%$. Computational requirements range from $12.48$ to $348.78$ GFLOPs across the evaluated stride settings, illustrating the balance between temporal sampling density and computational efficiency. The findings show that effective facial-video stress recognition can be achieved without dividing recordings into temporal windows and that complete-recording inference can be performed within a single unified model.

0.32

PPG-Bench: A Unified Benchmark for PPG Foundation Models

cs.LG ·2026-10-09 ·Arvasu Kulkarni, Mahir Jain, Aditya Ray Mishra, Sandeep Singh, Siddharth Panwar
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.61
Abstract

Photoplethysmography (PPG) is increasingly recorded by wearable and clinical devices at enormous scale, and a growing number of PPG foundation models (FMs) have been developed to compute reusable representations for various downstream tasks. These models are difficult to compare: different evaluations use different datasets, task definitions, preprocessing, downstream heads, hyperparameter tuning, and baselines. We present PPG-Bench, a unifying open-source benchmark evaluating five public PPG FMs across nine open-access datasets and 26 tasks spanning cardiovascular state estimation, activity, sleep, screening, and identification. We evaluate models under four downstream regimes of increasing adaptability (linear probing, random forests, frozen MLP probes, and end-to-end finetuning), with model-specific hyperparameter optimization and subject-disjoint cross-validation. We also evaluate against three controls: random/constant baseline, a deterministic pulse-rate-variability (PRV) feature set, and a generic time-series FM (MOMENT). Across all 68 task-regime combinations, 35.3% show no meaningful FM advantage over the random/constant baseline, and in 83.8% no PPG-specific FM outperforms both PRV and MOMENT. We also find that added downstream head capacity generally improves performance, but can cause significant degradation if the model is performing at chance/constant level. Current PPG FMs therefore cannot yet claim to provide generalised and transferrable representations of PPG signals, and future evaluation in this field should include checks against simple, non-learned controls. Code for the benchmark and instructions to evaluate more models can be found here - https://github.com/mannas-ai/ppg-bench.

0.31

Interpretable Stress Detection from ECG Signals Using Motif-Based Anomaly Analysis

eess.SP cs.LG ·2026-08-27 ·Zhanna Balyan, Sachin Kumar
similarity 0.61
Abstract

Stress detection using physiological signals has gained significant attention due to its impact on both physical and mental health. While existing approaches based on machine learning and deep learning achieve strong predictive performance, they often rely on black-box models and fail to capture individual variability in physiological responses. In this work, we propose an interpretable and personalized framework for stress detection using electrocardiogram (ECG) signals based on motif discovery and Matrix Profile analysis. Instead of training a classifier, the method learns subject-specific baseline cardiac behavior by extracting recurring heartbeat patterns (motifs) from ECG signals. Stress is then detected as a deviation from these baseline patterns using a distance-based anomaly score. Experiments are conducted on the WESAD dataset using a carefully designed train-validation-test protocol to ensure reliable evaluation. The results show that the proposed approach can effectively detect stress for several subjects while providing clear interpretability through direct comparison of ECG patterns. However, the performance varies across individuals due to differences in physiological responses, with some subjects exhibiting minimal morphological changes under stress. Additional analysis incorporating heart rate variability (HRV) features reveals that while HRV can improve performance in certain cases, its contribution is not consistent across all subjects. These findings highlight the importance of personalization and interpretability in physiological stress detection and demonstrate that motif-based approaches provide a meaningful alternative to black-box models, while also revealing inherent limitations due to inter-subject variability.

0.23

Beyond the Raw Waveform: Fusing Visual Representations of EDA for Stress Detection

eess.SP cs.LGcs.SDeess.AS ·2026-08-10 ·Stefanos Gkikas, Thomas Kassiotis, Yang Guo, Guangliang Li, Eric Nichols +3 more
top venue similarity 0.61
Abstract · The paper has been accepted at: IEEE | 2026 9th International Conference on Pattern Recognition and Artificial Intelligence (PRAI 2026)

Electrodermal activity (EDA) is widely used in automatic stress detection, yet most pipelines treat it only as a raw one-dimensional waveform. This study examines whether complementary visual representations of EDA provide useful information for stress classification and whether their fusion im- proves recognition performance. Six image-based representations are derived from each EDA recording: an unwrapped short-time Fourier transform (STFT) phase spectrogram, an instantaneous-frequency map computed from that phase, a power spectral density (PSD) spectrogram, a continuous wavelet transform scalogram, a recurrence plot, and a rendered waveform trace. The selected representations are stacked as channels of a single multichannel input, together with the raw waveform, and processed by a shared asymmetric-attention architecture. Experiments on a 58-subject stress dataset show that representation fusion improves over the raw waveform. The best configuration, which combines five representations while excluding the unwrapped phase spectrogram, reaches 70.97% test accuracy, compared with 67.36% for the raw waveform. The single PSD spectrogram achieves 69.44%, remaining close to the best-fused configuration at a lower computational cost. The results show that alternative visual forms of the same EDA signal can provide useful inductive biases for stress detection, and that a compact selection of complementary representations can be more effective than the raw waveform alone.

0.68

Label-Efficient Deep Learning for ECG Delineation: A Multi-Dataset Benchmark against Widely Used Delineation Tools

cs.LG cs.AIcs.CVeess.SP ·2026-10-06 ·Jeonghwa Lim, Minje Park, Yeongyeon Na, Yujin Eom, Soyeon Lim +4 more
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.61
Abstract · 20 pages, 5 figures. First two authors contributed equally

Electrocardiogram (ECG) delineation, the identification of waveform boundaries, is a foundational step that translates raw ECG signals into clinically interpretable measurements. Deep learning has advanced this task but remains dependent on costly expert annotations. Label-efficient strategies such as self-supervised pretraining and semi-supervised learning are expected to ease this burden, yet it remains unclear whether they yield reliable delineation and whether the deep models they produce outperform the delineation tools used in practice. We address this in two stages. First, comparing self-supervised objectives with supervised or semi-supervised fine-tuning across one internal and four external datasets, we find that pretraining helps but the objective matters, and that the value of semi-supervised fine-tuning depends on the pretraining objective. Second, we benchmark the selected deep learning model against widely used open-source (NeuroKit2, Prominence, ECGdeli) and commercial (CalECG) tools using three complementary metrics. The model ranks best on every metric and dataset, outperforming the strongest tool by a clear margin on the rhythm-diverse set (mIoU 71.3 vs. 54.8%; averaged point-wise sensitivity 92.6 vs. 76.4%), and degrades the least from sinus to arrhythmia. A rhythm-stratified and point-wise analysis further characterizes the distinctive behavior of each tool, yielding practical guidance for tool selection. These results provide systematic, multi-dataset evidence that self-supervised pretraining is effective for ECG delineation and enables a label-efficiently trained deep learning model to outperform widely used delineation tools by leveraging abundant unlabeled data. This supports adopting such models in diverse, real-world clinical settings.

0.30