CS Paper Radar

UltraBench 2: Towards Robust Evaluation of Vision Foundation Models on Ultrasound

Ashwath Radhachandran, Adam Tupper, Christian Gagné, William Speier

cs.CV cs.LG ·submitted 2026-09-23 17:01 UTC · v1
benchmark

Abstract

Benchmarking is an increasingly critical part of research in machine learning and the domains where it is applied, including healthcare. Yet, despite the steady development of new ultrasound foundation models in recent years, the development of well-designed benchmarks to evaluate them has lagged behind. This deficiency has led to fragmented and inconsistent evaluations of competing models, making it difficult to measure progress. To address this issue, we introduce UltraBench 2, a comprehensive benchmark with wide anatomical and task coverage, and a focus on standardization, reproducibility, and ease-of-use. Using this benchmark, we compare existing vision foundation models for ultrasound image analysis. Our analyses demonstrate that ultrasound-specific pretraining still leads on classification, but that state-of-the-art general-purpose models have drawn level on segmentation.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

UltraPIPS: Improving model perception in B-mode ultrasound with foundation models

cs.CV eess.IV ·2026-08-26 ·Tal Grutman, Tali Ilovitsh
publishedcode/datahot direction similarity 0.75
Abstract · MICCAI ASMUS 2026

In medical imaging, it is common to use learned perceptual image patch similarity (LPIPS) to compare images semantically in feature space. Although backbones pretrained on natural images are widely used for LPIPS computation, B-mode ultrasound images possess distinct speckle patterns and acoustic-specific image statistics that are fundamentally different from natural images and even from other images in radiology. Consequently, we propose that domain-specific models are needed to measure perceptual similarity in ultrasound data, a finding which is not necessarily the case for other imaging modalities. We compare LPIPS metrics across downstream tasks like classification, segmentation and reconstruction using natural image, medical generalist and ultrasound backbone models and show that selection of LPIPS backbone is a non-trivial design choice. In particular, the ultrasound backbone models were more correlated with downstream performance of supervised models than classical and natural image models, and optimization of the LPIPS loss with an ultrasound backbone achieved a strong balance between reconstruction quality and realism. Our code is available at https://github.com/talg2324/UltraPIPS and introduces the UltraPIPS library, a set of LPIPS metrics based on the open-source foundation models analyzed in this paper.

0.51

UltraG-Bench: A Multi-task Benchmark for assessing Large Vision-Language Models on Pixel-level Evidence Grounding in Ultrasound

cs.CV cs.AI ·2026-09-25 ·Quanhao Zhu, Bo Xu, Rui Lin, Chenyuan Wang, Yu Shao +5 more
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.69
Abstract

Ultrasound is one of the most widely used medical imaging modalities, and recent large vision-language models(VLMs) have shown increasing capabilities in ultrasound image understanding. However, these models fail to provide pixel-level visual evidence aligned with their semantic predictions, and their fine-grained grounding capability in ultrasound remains largely unclear. We introduce UltraG-Bench, a large-scale multi-task benchmark for evaluating pixel-level evidence grounding in ultrasound. UltraG-Bench is built by annotating 40 public ultrasound segmentation datasets spanning 13 anatomical categories, and comprises three progressive tasks: instruction-guided segmentation, evidence-grounded VQA, and evidence-grounded report generation, with 331125, 666779, and 138832 annotations, respectively. Comprehensive evaluation of 14 state-of-the-art models reveals a substantial gap between semantic understanding and fine-grained pixel-level localization. We further propose UltraG-Agent, which combines the semantic reasoning capabilities of a VLM with the ultrasound-specific segmentation capability of UltraSAM3. Experiments show that UltraG-Agent substantially improves both semantic prediction and pixel-level visual grounding. Our dataset and code are available at https://github.com/zhuqh19/UltraG-Bench.

0.60

Open ultrasound foundation model for robust segmentation and clinical measurement across heterogeneous settings

cs.CV ·2026-09-16 ·Chao Qin, Fahad Shahbaz Khan, Salman Khan, Sarim Ather, Siddiq Anwar +2 more
code/data similarity 0.69
Abstract · The PDF includes the Supplementary Information. Code is available at https://github.com/AlfredQin/sonobase

Ultrasound is the most widely deployed imaging modality worldwide, yet clinical AI remains fragmented into narrow single-task models that fail when device, operator, or anatomy changes. Here we present SonoCorpus, an open resource unifying 456,963 images and 1,626,085 expert masks from 53 public datasets spanning 24 clinical applications and 17 countries, and SonoBase, an interactive segmentation foundation model pretrained on it. Across fifteen evaluation datasets introducing new organs, devices, operators, and geographies, SonoBase outperforms SAM2, MedSAM2, and the concept-promptable MedSAM3 on every dataset and matches per-dataset specialist models trained on the same data; on fully external data it exceeds the accuracy these baselines achieve on their own in-distribution benchmarks. Ejection fraction derived from its segmentations falls within inter-observer variability (6.63\% error), with fewer misclassifications at the defibrillator-candidacy threshold than either promptable baseline (13\% versus 18--42\%); fetal head-circumference (1.81~mm) and gestational-age (1.2 days) errors fall below inter-observer variability. Where a baseline fails outright, one in four test cases, SonoBase recovers a usable segmentation in 81\% of them, including on handheld probes operated by minimally trained users in two low- and middle-income countries (Sierra Leone and Tanzania). Five labeled examples can help the model adapt to a new setting, and the identical training protocol transfers well to newer models such as SAM3, locating the advantage in ultrasound-specific pretraining rather than any single architecture. To ensure reproducibility and enable the community to build on SonoBase as a platform, we release all checkpoints, optimizer states, data-split indices, deduplication hashes, and starter code at https://github.com/AlfredQin/sonobase.

0.36

Medical Image Segmentation: Foundation Model Adaptation versus Task-Specific Training

cs.CV cs.AI ·2026-11-10 ·Emre Kutlusan, Yongmin Li
benchmark similarity 0.69
Abstract

Foundation models pretrained on large natural-image collections are increasingly adapted for medical image segmentation, in the expectation that they will replace models trained for each task. Most comparisons, however, use data from the training distribution and a single task-specific baseline whose configuration is rarely justified, and therefore provide limited evidence of performance at new clinical sites. It also remains unclear how much of a foundation model must be adapted, and what determines this. We adapted a foundation model, DINOv2, with strategies ranging from tuning only its bias terms to full fine-tuning, and compared it with U-Nets and ResU-Nets trained from scratch. Experiments covered colonoscopy, breast ultrasound and dermoscopy, with testing on held-out data from the training source and on independent datasets from other institutions. The adapted foundation model generalised better on every external dataset. Within the training distribution, the task-specific models remained competitive when training data were abundant, and delineated boundaries more precisely, while the foundation model more often missed small lesions. Only a small fraction of the foundation model required adaptation, and the capacity needed was determined by the imaging domain rather than by the adaptation method. A widely used polyp test set was also found to duplicate images from another benchmark. Foundation-model adaptation is therefore warranted where models must work across sites, with capacity selected on the target domain.

0.11

Expert-like Bone Ultrasound Segmentation through Expert-in-the-loop Mask-conditioned Progressive Learning

eess.IV cs.CV ·2026-08-31 ·Arash Tavangar, Larissa K. Chiu, Hamidreza Khodashenas, Gregory K. Berry, Amir Hooshiar
top venue similarity 0.67
Abstract

Manual annotation remains a major bottleneck in ultrasound (US) bone segmentation, where experts typically iteratively refine rough brush masks rather than delineating precise contours in a single pass. We present ExiL, a mask-conditioned progressive learning framework that models annotation as a structured refinement trajectory. ExiL combines a synthetic expert-like brush simulator based on signed distance fields with a lightweight 7.8M-parameter U-Net that learns to complete and refine imperfect masks from US images. During deployment, an expert mode updates the model directly from accepted refinements, enabling continual adaptation to expert behavior. Evaluated using UltraBones100k cadaver data for quantitative segmentation and a prospective volunteer dataset for annotation-efficiency analysis, ExiL reduced single-expert average annotation time from 60 to 20 seconds per frame (66.7\%) and improved mean Dice by approximately 0.045 over non-progressive training, while achieving 0.87 Dice and 2.7 px boundary error in the best trajectory-aware setting. With 10--50 ms inference, ExiL enables real-time, self-improving annotation for US-guided orthopedic workflows in practical clinical labeling.

0.67

Beyond In-Distribution Metrics: A Systematic Out-of-Distribution Evaluation of Congenital Heart Disease Segmentation

cs.CV cs.AI ·2026-09-15 ·Aniketh Vijesh, Shrisharanyan Vasu, Abhijit Ramesh, Clare Pomeroy-Ward, Harikrishnan Anil Maya +3 more
published similarity 0.63
Abstract · 12 pages, 6 figures, 2 tables. Accepted at STACOM 2026, held in conjunction with MICCAI 2026

Congenital heart disease (CHD) diagnosis and surgical planning often require patient-specific 3D anatomical models, but manual segmentation is labor-intensive, particularly in complex anatomies. Although deep-learning methods can automate this process, they are typically evaluated in-distribution, despite clinically relevant shifts in scanner, protocol, institution, population, and imaging modality. We present, to our knowledge, the first systematic evaluation of out-of-distribution (OOD) generalization in CHD segmentation, using ImageCHD as a held-out target cohort. We compare representative segmentation architectures under combined CT and CMR training, CT-only training, self-supervised pretraining, and limited target-domain adaptation. In-distribution performance proves to be a poor indicator of cross-cohort robustness: nnU-Net achieves the highest validation Dice (0.77) but falls to 0.51 on ImageCHD, while SwinUNETR generalizes substantially better, reaching 0.67 Dice. MAE and JEPA pretraining provide only modest additional benefit, suggesting that architecture contributes more to robustness than the tested pretraining strategies in this setting. When limited target-domain supervision is introduced, all SwinUNETR variants exceed 0.76 Dice with only 11 labeled ImageCHD cases. These findings demonstrate that conventional in-distribution evaluation can obscure clinically important generalization failures and support explicit cross-dataset testing as a key component of CHD segmentation evaluation.

0.28

Zero-Shot Adaptation of Medical Vision Foundation Models for High-Frequency Micro-Ultrasound Prostate Segmentation

cs.CV cs.LG ·2026-08-14 ·Ayusha Abbas, Saram Abbas, Kabita Adhikari
similarity 0.63
Abstract

Prostate cancer claims a life every 80 seconds. Early detection is needed to prevent disease progression, and both PSA density calculation and biopsy decisions rely on knowing the exact boundary of the gland. Conventional ultrasound at 6-12 MHz blurs this boundary, missing one in three high-risk cancers. Micro-ultrasound (29 MHz) improves resolution threefold but introduces dense acoustic speckle that obscures the outer wall; given the same image, two clinicians draw outlines differing by over 10% in area. Supervised methods are costly and generalise poorly across scanners. Can a foundation model segment the prostate with no training data? We present the first zero-shot pipeline for this modality: MedSAM, pre-trained on over 1.5 million medical images, localises the prostate; we then apply CLAHE to sharpen the outer wall, binary dilation to recover missed pixels, and Fourier smoothing (4 modes, s=1.05) to refine the boundary. MedSAM requires a spatial prompt, so we evaluate bounding-box and point-click strategies across 75 patients of the Micro-Ultrasound Prostate Segmentation dataset (2,621 slices). On the 20-patient held-out test set, the pipeline reduces mean boundary-distance error by 45% (Dice 0.749+/-0.043 to 0.865+/-0.029; HD95 217.2+/-36.9 to 120.1+/-26.1 px), reaching Dice 0.859 across the cohort. Its mean overlap shows no significant difference from the three non-expert rater groups (p>0.19), while segmenting 38-52% more consistently (lower inter-patient standard deviation). Point-click prompts fail regardless of placement (best Dice=0.350), because speckle gives no stable local contrast. Only an approximate bounding box is required, so any clinic can deploy it without data collection, annotation, or retraining.

0.04

Computationally Efficient Pathology Segmentation using Knowledge Distillation from Foundation Models

eess.IV ·2026-09-03 ·Jiaqi Lv, Yijie Zhu, Saki Okada, Maxwell Stanley Renna, Robert Goldin +2 more
similarity 0.63
Abstract · Submitted to Medical Image Analysis

Automatic tissue segmentation is essential for large-scale analysis of histopathology whole-slide images (WSIs), but accurate pixel-level segmentation remains challenging. Pixel-level annotations are expensive to obtain, models pre-trained on natural images may transfer poorly to histopathology, and pathology foundation models, despite their strong representations, are computationally expensive to deploy at scale. We address these challenges with a foundation-model knowledge distillation framework for efficient tissue segmentation. We first train Virchow2-based segmentation teachers, including a LoRA-adapted variant, achieving state-of-the-art or highly competitive performance across four datasets: PUMA, IGNITE, BEETLE, and a private blood vessel segmentation dataset. We then transfer response-level and feature-level knowledge from these teachers into compact student networks. Distillation consistently improves student performance over supervised training alone, producing state-of-the-art or near state-of-the-art results with substantially fewer parameters and up to ten-fold higher inference throughput than foundation-model-based segmentation networks. These results show that foundation-model knowledge can be effectively transferred to efficient segmentation models for scalable deployment without compromising performance. Models trained on the public datasets will be released through TIAToolbox.

0.35