CS Paper Radar

Automated Artifact Removal in EEG Age Prediction: A systematic comparison

Davoud Hajhassani, Paul-Adrien Graignic, Bruno Aristimunha, Apolline Mellot, Tom Mariani, Clément Nober, Bruna J. Lopes, Léo Burgund, Lionel Kusch, Thomas Semah, Arnault H. Caillet

eess.SP ·submitted 2026-09-25 12:30 UTC · v1

Abstract

Automated EEG artifact removal may improve downstream analysis but can also alter predictive information. We benchmarked nine automated artifact removal methods against a common no-artifact-removal baseline for cross-dataset EEG age prediction. We introduce Signal Quality Index (SQI)-guided GEDAI, which leverages local signal-quality assessment to restrict correction to the channel--epoch pairs requiring intervention. Three deep neural architectures were trained on TUEG and evaluated without target-domain fitting on ds005385, LEMON, and TDBRAIN. Across this setting, GEDAI and SQI-guided GEDAI were the only methods with consistent gains over baseline in age prediction performance across all datasets and architectures ($Δ$MAE $=-0.77/-0.64$ years, $ΔR^2=+0.083/+0.072$, respectively). The remaining methods were neutral or detrimental on average ($Δ$MAE $=+0.22\pm0.16$ years, $ΔR^2=-0.023\pm0.016$ across methods). The two GEDAI-based methods achieved closely matched performance, while SQI guidance reduced the median modification ratio from $74.78\%$ to $42.80\%$. These findings show that curation benefits are method-dependent and establish SQI guidance as a more selective operating point, leaving more of the original EEG unchanged and limiting the potential loss of neural activity while retaining most of GEDAI's predictive benefit.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Beyond Reconstruction: A Unified Framework for Trustworthy and Explainable EEG Artifact Removal Evaluation

eess.SP cs.AI ·2026-11-16 ·Phat Lam, Hung Nguyen, Lam Pham, Huy Phan, Dat Tran +3 more
similarity 0.68
Abstract · IEEE journal manuscript under review

Deep-learning methods have achieved strong performance in EEG artifact removal, but evaluation remains dominated by reconstruction metrics such as error, correlation, and signal-to-noise ratio. Although these metrics assess similarity to clean EEG, they do not establish whether models effectively suppress artifacts, preserve neural activity, or provide reliable explanations. To address these limitations, we propose TriX-EEG, a three-level framework for trustworthy and explainable EEG artifact removal. Level 1, Signal Validity (SV), evaluates reconstruction quality and neural band-power preservation. Level 2, Removal Faithfulness (RF), assesses the removed component through artifact error and residual artifact/neural leakage. Level 3, Explanation Reliability (ER), examines model behavior through temporal alignment, causal relevance, and stability. We evaluate TriX-EEG using nine published neural denoisers across three public benchmarks derived from EEGDenoiseNet and the PhysioNet Motion Artifact Contaminated EEG Dataset, covering EOG, EMG, and motion artifacts. Results show that reconstruction metrics alone are insufficient for trustworthy denoiser assessment: RF complements it by revealing whether errors stem from residual artifact or suppressed neural activity, while ER captures distinct aspects of explanation behavior, supporting joint evaluation of three aspects within a unified framework rather than reliance on any single factor. External validation on an independent EEG/EOG dataset and the BCI Competition IV-2a motor-imagery dataset further demonstrates broadly consistent rankings under dataset shift. Higher-ranked denoisers generally preserve more task-relevant information or cause less downstream performance degradation. Overall, TriX-EEG provides a comprehensive basis for EEG denoiser assessment, encouraging models that are not only accurate but also faithful and explainable.

0.27

Best Practices in EEG Analysis: Preprocessing, Modeling, and Machine Learning

eess.SP cs.LG ·2026-09-29 ·Parsa Razmara, Woojae Jeong, Aditya Kommineni, Raymundo Cassani, Richard Leahy +1 more
published similarity 0.65
Abstract · 38 pages, 5 figures. Chapter 16 of the 2026 monograph "Electroencephalogram Signals and Cognition," edited by Hema A. Murthy, Shrikanth Nara…

Electroencephalography (EEG) analysis requires careful choices in preprocessing, statistical modeling, and machine learning because EEG signals are highly susceptible to artifacts, volume conduction, low signal-to-noise ratio, and substantial inter-subject variability. This chapter provides a practical and methodological guide to modern EEG analysis, spanning EEG preprocessing, artifact removal, filtering, bad-channel detection and interpolation, re-referencing, independent component analysis (ICA), and preprocessing of simultaneous EEG-fMRI recordings. We review major approaches for computational EEG analysis, including event-related potentials (ERPs), time-frequency analysis, functional and effective connectivity, source localization, multivariate decoding, permutation testing, and multiple-comparison correction. We then examine machine-learning methods for EEG, from feature-based classifiers to deep learning and emerging EEG foundation models, with emphasis on cross-subject generalization, limited-data regimes, data leakage, evaluation metrics, and fair benchmarking. Reproducibility is treated as a core requirement throughout, including transparent preprocessing, BIDS-EEG data organization, standardized derivatives, preservation of raw data, and FAIR data practices. The chapter is intended as a practical reference for researchers developing reliable, interpretable, and reproducible EEG analysis and machine-learning pipelines.

0.47

Benchmarking EEG Foundation Models at Scale: Lessons from 20,000 Evaluations

cs.LG eess.SP ·2026-09-26 ·Zhige Chen, Shu Peng, Chengxuan Qin, Rui Liu, Rui Yang +2 more
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.61
Abstract · 91 pages, including appendices and supplementary material

Electroencephalography (EEG) foundation models (FMs) promise transferable neural representations, yet their advantages over strong supervised baselines and their prospects for further scaling remain unclear. To address these questions, we introduce EEG-Arena, an open-source benchmark covering 30 EEG FMs and 25 supervised baselines evaluated on 57 downstream tasks from 23 public datasets. Through more than 20,000 evaluations across five experimental protocols, we assess downstream performance, pretraining benefits, model size scaling, pretraining data scaling, and robustness to channel configuration. We find that (1) EEG FMs outperform strong task-specific supervised baselines on most evaluated tasks, particularly under non-bipolar settings; (2) compared with architecture-matched supervised training from scratch, pretraining improves both early optimization and final downstream performance, with larger and more consistent gains as more labeled downstream data become available; (3) existing EEG FMs do not exhibit a consistent positive relationship between parameter count and downstream performance; (4) under a fixed architecture, increasing the pretraining data scale yields sustained downstream gains; and (5) channel-flexible FMs achieve higher absolute performance than channel-constrained models across most evaluated channel configurations. Together, these findings demonstrate the downstream value of EEG FMs and identify pretraining data expansion as a promising direction for further progress. To support continued research, we release EEG-Arena as an open-source evaluation framework that provides shared infrastructure for reproducible benchmarking, model comparison, and community-driven development.

0.56

OOD Detection for EEG-based Machine Learning in High-Risk Environments

cs.LG ·2026-08-18 ·Philipp Bomatter, Henry Gouk
benchmark similarity 0.56
Abstract

Machine learning models for electroencephalography (EEG) analysis show great promise across a wide range of applications, but their deployment in high-risk domains is hindered by their vulnerability to distribution shifts. Encountering out-of-distribution (OOD) data can lead to catastrophic, overconfident predictive failures. While OOD detection methods can mitigate these risks, they remain heavily under-explored for EEG. Moreover, evaluations in the broader literature typically evaluate OOD detection performance in isolation, ignoring their practical impact on downstream applications. To bridge this gap, we introduce a benchmark for EEG OOD detection, evaluate a broad range of methods, and furthermore evaluate their value in two clinical downstream prediction task. Our results disentangle OOD detection and model uncertainty estimation capabilities, which are frequently conflated in the literature, provide actionable insights about the current state of the art for EEG OOD detection and model uncertainty estimation, and demonstrate how complementary methods for both aspects can be combined to form a robust safety net for the deployment of EEG-based machine learning models in real-world applications.

0.31

A Proof-of-Concept Study of Weakly Supervised Labeling of Fine-Grained EEG Components for Artifact Attenuation

cs.LG eess.SP ·2026-10-07 ·Lu Wang-Nöth, Hai Huang, Philipp Heiler, Shuqiong Wu, Liyun Zhang +1 more
similarity 0.56
Abstract

Electroencephalography (EEG) is highly susceptible to electromyographic (EMG) artifacts, whose temporal heterogeneity and spatial-spectral overlap with neural activity can leave mixed sources after blind source separation. Existing artifact-removal methods are further limited by scarce reliable component-level ground truth: expert annotations are costly and subjective, while no established method provides realistic simulation-based ground truth for EMG contamination in multichannel scalp EEG. To address these limitations, we propose a framework combining a frequency-aware high-dimensional representation with Multi-Instance Learning. The representation unfolds separated components into frequency-resolved intra-components, creating a space in which mixed neural and muscular activity becomes more separable, while the weakly supervised learning formulation enables artifact-likelihood scores for individual intra-components to be learned from epoch-level labels without finer-grained ground truth. The resulting intra-component classifier supports fine-grained EMG artifact detection and score-guided attenuation. Experiments on held-out subjects show that the framework learns informative intra-component scores and reduces artifact-related spectral deviations most clearly for jaw tension, with moderate effects for raising eyebrows and limited effects for frowning.

0.12

Artifact removal improves electrodermal waveforms but not downstream classification in a virtual-reality balance task

cs.HC cs.LGeess.SP ·2026-10-05 ·Haochen Chai, Qixu Zhu, Siyao Li, Fangfang Jiang
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.55
Abstract · 10 pages, 9 figures, 3 tables. Code and frozen data: https://github.com/rtb-1005/FairEDA

Artifact removal routinely precedes the classification of electrodermal activity (EDA), on the assumption that a cleaner signal supports a better decision. We tested this assumption in a virtual-reality (VR) balance-disturbance task. A residual gating network was trained on a benchmark with expert-corrected EDA, frozen, and applied to VR recordings, where raw and gated signals were classified by five published time-series methods under identical leave-one-participant-out evaluation. On the benchmark the gate detected artifacts well (median record AUROC 0.94) and reduced error inside artifact regions by 17.8%. In the VR task it did not improve classification. Changes in balanced accuracy ranged from -1.35 to +0.93 percentage points, no classifier improved and two lost accuracy, and all five were equivalent to raw input within +/- 3.32 points. The benefit was lost between waveform and decision. The correction that lowered waveform error also reduced skin conductance response detection in all 43 benchmark records. Processing left 92.8% of predictions unchanged, and the predictions it did change were corrected and corrupted at similar rates. The VR recordings also carried little contamination (an estimated 4.6% of samples), and even perfect localization of deliberately injected artifacts recovered only 3.3 points in the most sensitive classifier. A pooled association between artifact level and accuracy (11.3 points) disappeared within participants (0.1 points), showing how differences between people can make cleaning look useful. Preprocessing should be judged by the decision it supports, against an unprocessed arm.

0.40

Matched-Input Estimates Differ in Sign Across Architectures: Auditing EEG Foundation Models on Motor Imagery

cs.LG q-bio.NC ·2026-09-20 ·Kevin Zhou, Sparsh Roy
similarity 0.55
Abstract

Pretrained EEG foundation models are increasingly proposed as general-purpose encoders for brain-computer interfaces, yet recent benchmarks disagree about when their representations transfer to downstream tasks. We audit LaBraM and CBraMod on motor imagery under a validation-locked protocol in which preprocessing, architecture, optimization, freeze depth, checkpoint, temperature, and method selection are determined using training-session data only. On four-class BCI Competition IV-2a, every supervised comparator evaluated here outperforms every foundation-model configuration, including validation-selected fine-tuning. We then examine a key confound: foundation models and task-specific decoders are normally evaluated using different input pipelines. Retraining three supervised architectures on the broadband arrays consumed by the foundation models produces matched-input accuracy differences of opposite sign across architectures: broadband input improves ATCNet by 0.078 accuracy while reducing EEG Conformer accuracy by 0.088. None of the three individual matched-input terms is significant after multiple-comparison correction at n = 9, so we treat the sign variation descriptively rather than as a formal architecture-by-pipeline interaction. These observed sign differences suggest that a single comparator may not provide an architecture-invariant decomposition of a pretrained-versus-supervised performance gap. The four-class deficit also does not reproduce uniformly across motor-imagery datasets: on two-class BNCI2014-004 we cannot detect the same separation between fine-tuned CBraMod and the supervised comparators. Finally, validation-fitted temperature scaling returns foundation-model calibration error to the supervised range despite substantially lower four-class accuracy.

0.32

Benchmarking Label-Revealed Online Updates for EEG BCI Decoding

cs.LG eess.SP ·2026-10-05 ·Bogdan Kozyrskiy, Artem Grachev, Abraham I. Camelo Guerrero
benchmark similarity 0.55
Abstract

Electroencephalography (EEG) signals drift over time, which can cause static brain-computer interface (BCI) models to degrade in practice. We present a benchmark for online adaptation and compare two widely used pipeline families, Common Spatial Patterns (CSP) and Riemannian covariance-based methods, under time-ordered prequential (test-then-train) evaluation. We examine (i) which pipelines benefit most from label-revealed updates, (ii) whether controlled forgetting of older data improves robustness, and (iii) how a minimal-calibration cold start compares with starting from a pretrained model. Across four datasets (three motor-imagery datasets and one movement-decoding dataset), label-revealed online updates improve 13 of 14 model/dataset pairs on the two largest streams, with relative accuracy gains of up to about 18% over a frozen model. A Shapley-based data-valuation analysis over temporal blocks assigns the largest mean value to the most recent block in each of the three analyzed datasets, while older blocks retain positive value.

0.42