CS Paper Radar

The Impact of Processing Parameters on High-Accuracy Measurements in UAV Photogrammetry

Paweł Ćwiąkała, Edyta Puniach, Elżbieta Pastucha, Wojciech Gruszczyński

cs.CV ·submitted 2026-10-01 10:34 UTC · v1
publishedhighly cited

Abstract

Unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV) photogrammetry is increasingly used in applications requiring high accuracy, such as determining ground surface changes caused by landslides, mining, or microrelief transformation. While acquisition strategies have been widely studied, the influence of the processing workflow-particularly Bundle Block Adjustment parameter settings-remains insufficiently explored. This study addresses this gap through a systematic, full-factorial evaluation of 768 processing variants applied to ten UAV datasets collected over 1.5 years in a 220 ha study area. Eight key parameters were analysed. The results show substantial variability in final 3D accuracy: the best performing variant achieved a root mean square error (RMSE) of 16 mm, whereas the weakest reached 303 mm. The most influential factors were the number of ground control points, the application of additional camera calibration corrections, and the use of the Post-Processing Kinematic GNSS method for determining camera projection center coordinates. The study also evaluates how workflow optimization affects the accuracy of displacement, tilt changes, and horizontal strain determination. While random displacement errors remained stable (RMSE of ~6-7 mm), systematic errors were significantly reduced by over half in all axes, with vertical median absolute error decreasing from 14 mm to 7 mm in the optimized configuration compared to the baseline previously used by the authors. This study provides the first large-scale, practice-oriented assessment of how processing parameter selection shapes the accuracy of both photogrammetric products and deformation indices determination. The results offer actionable guidance for developing more robust and repeatable UAV photogrammetry workflows tailored to high-precision monitoring.

Journal ref
Measurement, Volume 265, 2026, 120315, ISSN 0263-2241
DOI
10.1016/j.measurement.2026.120315

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Determining Vertical Displacement of Agricultural Areas Using UAV-Photogrammetry and a Heteroscedastic Deep Learning Model

cs.CV ·2026-09-30 ·Wojciech Gruszczyński, Edyta Puniach, Paweł Ćwiąkała, Wojciech Matwij
published similarity 0.63
Abstract

This article introduces an algorithm that uses a U-Net architecture to determine vertical ground surface displacements from unmanned aerial vehicle (UAV)-photogrammetry point clouds, offering an alternative to traditional ground filtering methods. Unlike con-ventional ground filters that rely on point cloud classification, the proposed approach em-ploys heteroscedastic regression. The U-Net model predicts the conditional expected val-ues of the elevation corrections, aiming to reduce the impact of vegetation on determined ground surface elevations. Concurrently, it estimates the logarithm of the elevation cor-rection variance, allowing for direct quantification of the uncertainty associated with each elevation correction value. The algorithm was evaluated using three metrics: the root mean square error (RMSE) of vertical displacements, the percentage of nodes with deter-mined displacement values, and the percentage of outliers among those values. Perfor-mance was assessed using the technique for order of preference by similarity to ideal so-lution (TOPSIS) method and compared against several ground-filter-based algorithms across four datasets, each including at least two time intervals. In most cases, the U-Net-based approach demonstrated a slight performance advantage over traditional ground filtering techniques. For example, for the U-Net-based algorithm, for one of the test da-tasets, the RMSE of the determined subsidences was 6.1 cm, the percentage of nodes with determined subsidences was 80.5%, and the percentage of outliers was 0.2%. For the same case, the algorithm based on the next best model (SMRF) allowed an RMSE of 7.7 cm to be obtained; for 77.3% of nodes, the subsidences were determined; and the percentage of outliers was 0.3%.

0.45

Observation Quality in DSM-Assisted Aerial Localization: A Benchmark and Base-Anchored Uncertainty Calibration

cs.CV ·2026-10-13 ·Pengyu Yin, Jie Pan, Junxiang Tan, Mengqi Fu, Kun Cheng +1 more
benchmark similarity 0.58
Abstract · 15 pages, 7 figures, 7 tables. Submitted to IEEE Journal of Selected Topics in Applied Earth Observations and Remote Sensing

Aerial map matching provides position observations for navigation, but a position error alone does not determine how an observation should be weighted. We define five benchmark tasks: position availability and agreement, grouped error structure, predictive uncertainty, controlled updates, and temporal accumulation. We use digital-surface-model-assisted localization to test whether base-anchored uncertainty calibration improves the weighting of unchanged position estimates. The method combines propagated image and map sensitivities with the second moment of a compact configuration subset relative to the reported position. Scale is fitted using separate position references without local surface-height ground truth. Thirteen covariance models are evaluated on two held-out query sets from locations represented in the calibration data. Using reference residuals, we compare the method with a constant full-matrix baseline. With all localization failures included, the method reduces the normalized position-update risk, averaged equally across locations, by 7.70% on 728 conditions and 5.46% on a separate 142 conditions under an independent prior. On the primary set, the equal-location average negative log likelihood on reference residuals improves by 2.571 nat. At these seen locations, exploratory base-only quality calibration and conditional-addition controls leave the incremental update benefit of configuration disagreement unresolved. Navigation benefit and real temporal accumulation remain untested.

0.23

GeoPilot: Diagnosis-Guided Interventions and Geometric Evaluation for Aerial Reconstruction

cs.CV ·2026-11-09 ·Pengyu Yin, Jie Pan, Junxiang Tan, Mengqi Fu, Kun Cheng +1 more
hot direction similarity 0.58
Abstract · 33 pages, including supplementary material

When a mesh reconstructed from aerial remote-sensing imagery disagrees with reference geometry, deciding what to change requires a diagnosis of the reconstruction process. We present GeoPilot, a workflow that turns diagnostics and prior observations into executable program or camera-configuration interventions. A large language model proposes the change, numerical tools reconstruct the mesh, and an external evaluator measures its geometry under a stated coordinate and reference protocol. The main case tests a shared-intrinsics hypothesis proposed before the comparison. On 224 Metashape-raster development images, shared intrinsics improved all six native-coordinate measures and reduced mean surface-to-reference distance by 7.04%. Reference-assisted alignment fitted and evaluated on separate within-scene checkerboard samples reversed the mean-distance ranking, limiting that gain to native-frame delivery. A separate matched comparison on publisher-undistorted images favored fixed published cameras on all six measures, reducing mean distance by 12.11%; the cameras retain upstream image and laser-scanning adjustment information. With one reconstruction per configuration, these comparisons provide conditional evidence for camera handling. Three end-to-end runs each delivered a mesh and six-metric evaluation from all 327 images of a second development scene.

0.32

Camera Calibration Using Inaccurate and Asynchronous Discrete GPS Trajectory from Drones

eess.SY cs.CV ·2026-08-27 ·R. Yang, Y. Bar-Shalom, H. A. J. Huang
theory similarity 0.57
Abstract · 11 pages, 12 figs, published on JAIF

This paper considers a stationary camera calibration problem, which estimates the camera orientation angles yaw, pitch and roll, using a drone trajectory recorded by a GPS. There are three challenges in using a GPS trajectory as ground truth for camera calibration. One, the altitude of GPS data is inaccurate with an unknown bias. Two, the GPS receiver and camera are not time synchronized, and there is an unknown time offset between the two systems. Three, the GPS trajectory is time-discrete and accurate interpolation is needed. This is actually an estimation problem since velocity is also needed. To address the first two challenges, we formulate the problem as a parameter estimation problem to estimate a vector consisting of the GPS altitude bias and time offset in addition to the camera yaw, pitch and roll biases. We then develop a special maximum likelihood estimator using the Iterated Least Squares algorithm which can work with a non-synchronized time-discrete GPS trajectory for the third challenge. Since the camera measurement errors are usually small, this requires a high calibration accuracy so that the residual bias error following the calibration should not be significant compared to the measurement error standard deviation. The calibration accuracy depends highly on the drone trajectory. This paper also recommends an appropriate drone trajectory which can yield a good calibration accuracy, namely, 14\% of the measurement error standard deviation. Simulation tests are conducted to demonstrate the algorithm performance. The estimation results meet the Cramer-Rao Lower Bound (CRLB) since the Normalized Estimation Error Squared w.r.t.\ the CRLB is statistically acceptable.

0.18

When to Ask for Help: Uncertainty-Triggered Aerial Refinement for Off-Road Navigation

cs.RO eess.SY ·2026-11-04 ·Pranay Samineni, Adam Thorpe, John Chubick, Anand Balakrishnan, Christian Ellis +2 more
code/data similarity 0.57
Abstract · Project page: https://anonymous.4open.science/w/when-to-ask-for-help/

Heterogeneous air-ground teams can use aerial sensing to address the limited range and viewpoint of ground-vehicle sensors, but deciding when the UGV needs assistance and what information the UAV should collect remains a challenge. This paper presents a planner-conditioned air-ground assistance method that evaluates how uncertain map information affects the UGV's current MPPI rollouts. When navigation remains degraded, we score the same rollouts under resolved map hypotheses, select the map layer with the largest useful improvement, request the corresponding aerial measurement, fuse the returned information, and replan. Unlike approaches driven by fixed support roles, task structure, or uncertainty alone, our method conditions assistance on whether resolving uncertainty improves predicted ground navigation. Across 180 simulation trials on three off-road routes, the method achieves 98.9% goal attainment while reducing mean UAV flight time by 87.7% relative to continuous greedy aerial mapping. Aggregated across the routes, each second of estimated UAV flight time saves 2.94 s of UGV navigation time. Field experiments spanning approximately 2 km of UGV operation demonstrate uncertainty resolution and successful navigation recovery.

0.21

An Open Panoramic Aerial Robot: Airframe-Integrated Multi-Fisheye Sensing, Onboard ERP Formation, and Field Evaluation

cs.RO ·2026-09-02 ·Dun Dai, Ze Lu, Cheng He, Yaowen Wang, Quan Quan
code/data similarity 0.56
Abstract

We present an open panoramic aerial robot with four synchronized fisheye cameras integrated into a carbon-fiber airframe and an onboard NVIDIA Jetson Orin NX. The robot outputs calibrated raw views and an equirectangular panorama (ERP; 1280x640 in all experiments). The ERP pipeline uses overlap-specific projection radii, gated local alignment, seam control, and multi-rate state updates, and it runs onboard on the live four-camera stream during flight. The field dataset contains 18 sequences and more than 50,000 synchronized groups from seven sites. On a 60-frame far-field sample, the method reduces the median per-frame AKAZE P90 misalignment by 40.7% compared with Fixed Radius, and with fixed parameters it gives the lowest geometric errors among the tested controls at two held-out sites. Controlled replay on the same NVIDIA Jetson Orin NX measures final-ERP continuity, timing, and module-input power at a 20 Hz input rate. Compared with external stitching software given the same calibrated projection, the onboard pipeline gives final-ERP line continuity no lower than any tested method, while every external configuration measured on the module needs 5.3 to 147 times the input period and 3.8 to 106 times the energy per output. Frozen detection and place-recognition models are used to evaluate the exported images. Code, calibration, reference hardware, and data-access documentation are available in an anonymized repository at https://anonymous.4open.science/r/Open-Pano-Field-CE1F/README.md.

0.42

Agreement Is Not Accuracy: LiDAR Elevation Errors Hidden in LiDAR-Camera Extrinsics

cs.CV ·2026-11-18 ·Yeon Kun Lee, Dongseok Yang, Deok-Kyeong Jang, Choongho Chung, Junyoung Lee +1 more
similarity 0.56
Abstract · 14 pages, 6 figures, including supplementary material

LiDAR and cameras provide complementary measurements for 3D vision, yet agreement between their observations does not establish the accuracy of either sensor's internal geometry. We show that systematic LiDAR elevation biases can be absorbed into the estimated extrinsics. Using synchronized LiDAR intensities and camera-estimated checkerboard poses, we jointly estimate a sensor-specific elevation correction shared across recordings and extrinsics for each recording. Ray-plane intersections locate the checker pattern without using reported ranges, preventing range errors from directly moving the lookup. Under matched intensity and correction models, this lookup gives smaller camera-consistency residuals than measured-point lookup. Across six identically designed rigs using the same sensor models, recording-excluded corrections reduce the mean translation-reference distance from 7.57 to 3.04 mm. On separate structures, they reduce inter-plane angle errors against references from independent dense camera scans and improve image-edge alignment. Rolling the rigs shifts the plane pairs exhibiting the largest angular improvements, as predicted for an elevation-only correction. Within the ray-plane model, calibration-target projections and loop-consistency residuals change little despite these geometric improvements. These findings show why agreement after extrinsic calibration need not establish correct internal LiDAR geometry. Synchronized observations of a familiar checkerboard provide a practical route to estimating and testing elevation corrections without a dedicated large calibration field. We plan to release code and data for reproducing the main results.

0.25

Early versus Late RGB-Infrared Fusion for Counter-UAV Detection: A Comparative Study

cs.CV ·2026-10-21 ·Alberto De Zan, Denis Tavaris, Gian Luca Foresti, Ivan Scagnetto
published similarity 0.55
Abstract · This version differs from the article published in IEEE Access. It includes revisions requested by the reviewers during the final review rou…

This paper presents a novel strategy for UAV detection through visible (RGB) and infrared (IR) fusion, in order to improve accuracy and precision in harsh environments and weather conditions. In this research, two opposite approaches have been studied and implemented: the first concerns image-level (early) fusion, which merges two different spectra into a single image to which one detector is applied. On the other hand, the second approach, called decision-level (late) fusion, focuses on blending together the output bounding boxes of two different detection pipelines, aiming to create a common result that can be applied to both spectra simultaneously. Both strategies have been extensively tested in a dedicated environment, which included alternating low and high brightness scenes, different backgrounds (sky and ground), distances (5, 25 and 60 m), altitudes and zoom levels (1X, 2X and 4X). These tests allowed for the assessment of actual detection capabilities and system reliability in real-world applications. Furthermore, the two fusion strategies were evaluated and compared over a set of aligned images in order to highlight the better approach of the two. The results indicate that early fusion achieves better raw performance, since it incorporates the thermal information from the beginning of the training process. However, late fusion presents an innovative and useful detection workflow that can be applied in cases of sensor or frame misalignment. Both positive and negative aspects have also been pointed out and discussed, in order to give a more comprehensive overview. Finally, the paper outlines implementation considerations and practical recommendations based on operational priorities. Overall, the findings contribute to the research in RGB-IR fusion modalities, with the goal of enhancing UAV detection capabilities.

0.38