CS Paper Radar

Battery Second Life : A Review of Experimental Studies

Marwan Hassini, Eduardo Redondo-Iglesias, Pascal Venet

eess.SY ·submitted 2026-10-08 10:13 UTC · v1
survey

Abstract

As electric vehicle volume increase, the interest for reusing their retired batteries grow. Giving a second life to batteries reduce their environmental impact and provide access to more affordable energy storage systems. This lifespan extension is of interest in a wide range of fields as the reuse offer a solution for end-of-life batteries management and the development of renewable energies. Although several review articles have described opportunities and barriers related to reuse, to our knowledge none have synthesized insights from studies that conducted experiments on retired batteries. This article aims to address this gap by providing a detailed analysis of more than 150 articles. This article's main findings are the proposition of a new vocabulary for batteries end-of-life, an evaluation of state of health and dispersion in retired batteries as well as the synthesis of aging and safety studies on these batteries. In a nutshell, this review show that the performance of retired batteries can be high, their dispersion should be managed and their degradation can be slow and safe. Limitations of current battery research ideas for future experiments and ideas for future studies are also presented.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

From Laboratory Aging Studies to Field Predictions: Quantifying Uncertainty in Battery Storage Lifetime Predictions

eess.SY ·2026-09-09 ·Melina Graner, Jan Figgener, Andreas Jossen, Holger Hesse
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.65
Abstract

Predicting how long a battery energy storage system will last is critical for warranty design, maintenance planning and investment decisions, yet degradation models are mostly deterministic and rarely validated against real field data. We apply an open-source probabilistic degradation framework, combined with a cell-to-system approximation, to bridge the gap between cell-level laboratory aging models and system-level field predictions for residential battery energy storage systems with quantified uncertainty. The framework predicts cell-level state-of-health to within 0.4 % mean absolute error, roughly half the error of prior models for this dataset. When applied to field operation data, the framework's predictions are consistent with all three available system-level capacity measurements - a benchmark rarely available for open probabilistic degradation models. Cell-level heterogeneity is approximated by two bounding stress scenarios differing only slightly (a 5 % spread in temperature and a 9 % spread in current). The mean degradation trajectories of the two scenarios reach end-of-life 10 months apart, while the full predicted end-of-life range across both scenarios spans approximately three years, about a third of the expected system lifetime. We link this uncertainty to two drivers. One is a systematic mismatch between laboratory test conditions and field-representative operating stress. The other is variability in the training data itself. These insights translate into concrete, resource-efficient recommendations for future aging study design, supporting more confident predictions of battery lifetime under real-world conditions.

0.17

Quantifying the Gap Between Laboratory Battery Test Patterns and Field Duty Profiles

cs.LG ·2026-08-17 ·Chunyang Zhao, Chresten Træholt
publishedunusual similarity 0.65
Abstract · 5 pages, 4 figures. Accepted to ECCE Europe 2026

Laboratory battery tests provide the main empirical basis for battery performance and degradation studies, but their operating patterns do not directly represent field duty profiles. This paper quantifies the gap by comparing six accessible evidence sources covering controlled cycling, drive-cycle testing, dynamic cycling, NMC811 laboratory ageing, a real electric-vehicle charging trace, and fleet-scale electric-vehicle state-of-health (SOH) data. The analysis combines usage frequency, usage intensity, usage C-rate, and a duty-structure index (DSI) based on normalized current dispersion and ramping. The representative single-segment DSI ranges from 0.630 for the field source trace and 0.699 for NASA to 2.936 for Oxford and 2.855 for Imperial, while usage C-rate ranges from 0.14-0.40 for Imperial, NASA, Stanford, and Hyundai to 2.00 for Oxford. Long-term ageing also differs: the 80 percent retention region occurs near 351 NASA cycles, 6292 Oxford checkpoints, and 1019 Stanford cycles. In chemistry-aligned NMC/NCM evidence, Imperial retains 0.813 under standard cycling and 0.865 under drive-cycle ageing, while the field source has median SOH 0.889 with visible dispersion. Field operation further shows a median use intensity of 137.2 km/day and 56.9 percent of charges ending at or above 95 percent SOC. These results show that battery performance metrics are conditional on the duty pattern that generated them; application-oriented studies should report explicit duty-profile descriptors together with chemistry, capacity, and ageing metrics.

0.46

Assessing Modeling Fidelity for Long-Term Battery Energy Storage Planning: Operation, Degradation, and Temporal Representation

eess.SY ·2026-09-30 ·Hassan Zahid Butt, Xingpeng Li
similarity 0.61
Abstract

Long-term battery energy storage system (BESS) planning often relies on simplified degradation, operational, and temporal representations to maintain computational tractability, yet their effects on lifecycle conclusions are not well understood. This paper assesses the modeling fidelity needed for long-term lifecycle evaluation of BESS designs used in planning studies. A 20-year grid-connected microgrid is sized using a degradation-naive planning model, after which the installed portfolio is fixed and evaluated through sequential lifecycle validation. The reference representation combines nonlinear calendar and cycle aging, C-rate-dependent efficiencies, state-of-health-dependent performance, self-discharge, battery replacement, and full 8,760-h chronology. Battery-model hierarchies, targeted ablations, linear degradation surrogates, health-update intervals, temporal reductions, and combined simplifications are compared using lifecycle cost, replacement timing, state of health, and energy adequacy. The reference case produces replacements in years 9 and 18, a $111.25 million lifecycle net present cost, and 24.01 MWh of cumulative energy not served. Omitting calendar aging eliminates both replacements and understates lifecycle cost by 35.1%, whereas a separately calibrated linear surrogate model reproduces both replacement years and limits the cost deviation to 0.2%, although energy not served remains 31.8% below the reference. A peak-informed calibrated 12-day representation preserves replacement timing but reports zero energy not served, while replacing the preserved peak day with the maximum daily-energy-deficit day substantially overstates energy not served because representative-day closure alters the battery state surrounding the critical event. The results show that modeling fidelity is metric-dependent and should be selected according to the lifecycle outcome to be preserved.

0.10

TREDD: Robust Trend-Based Reference Evaluation for Interpretable Degradation Detection

eess.SY ·2026-09-14 ·Elisabeth Vogel, Ronny Porsch, Peter Langendoerfer
similarity 0.58
Abstract · 7 Pages, 2 figures, Conference: IECON 2026 (18 to 21 October 2026)

Technical systems are increasingly monitored using sensor and operational data to detect degradation and performance deterioration at an early stage. However, observed trends in measurement data do not necessarily correspond to physical aging, since noise, outliers, unstable initial regions, or changing operating conditions may produce similar patterns. This paper proposes Trend-based Reference Evaluation for Degradation Detection (TREDD), an interpretable method for detecting degradation as a persistent, trend-based deviation from an early reference state. TREDD combines rolling-window smoothing, baseline estimation, a direction-dependent degradation index, long-term trend extraction, and persistent drift detection. In addition, the method separates computational drift detection from the interpretation of drift as plausible physical aging by incorporating data-quality assessment, context checking, and robust auxiliary analysis. The approach is evaluated on the NASA Lithium-Ion Battery Aging Dataset using discharge-cycle capacity as the degradation-relevant condition variable. The representative case study illustrates that TREDD can identify clear degradation trajectories while assigning reduced confidence to weak, gradual, or atypical trends. The method therefore supports transparent and confidence-based degradation interpretation rather than purely predictive battery health estimation.

0.13

Joint Remaining Useful Life Prediction and Capacity Estimation of Lithium-Ion Batteries Using Partial-Charging Data

cs.LG ·2026-09-18 ·Khoa Tran, Ho-Si-Hung Nguyen, Phone Wai Yan Moe, Hung-Cuong Trinh, Thi-Hoang-Giang Tran
similarity 0.55
Abstract

Joint remaining useful life (RUL) prediction and capacity estimation require representations of both gradual degradation and recent battery behavior. This paper presents a cross-expert framework using partial-charging measurements without requiring measured historical full-cycle capacity as an input. The RUL Expert captures long-term degradation from nominal 10-min segments sampled across a 30-cycle history, while the Capacity Expert characterizes recent battery behavior from statistical descriptors of nominal 40-min segments over ten consecutive cycles. Their complementary representations are integrated through feature-wise linear modulation for joint RUL and capacity prediction. A key contribution is a three-stage training strategy that progressively controls frozen and trainable components: supervised representation pretraining, independent expert pretraining, and final fusion training with both experts frozen. This staged optimization preserves expert-specific degradation knowledge while improving the balance between the two prediction tasks, with RUL treated as the primary prognostic objective. On two public battery-aging datasets, the reference configuration achieves mean RUL root-mean-square errors of 143.69 and 161.10 cycles and capacity errors of 12.36 and 7.28 mAh, respectively. On Dataset I, cross-expert fusion reduces both mean errors relative to either standalone expert. The proposed framework achieves the lowest reported RUL RMSE among the compared methods on both datasets while maintaining competitive capacity-estimation accuracy.

0.20

A Framework for Discharge Time Prediction of Energy Storage Units Based on Coupled Dynamics and Multi-Factor Aging Models

cs.CE ·2026-09-10 ·Jiaye Yang, Hansheng Su, Wangzi Zhu
published similarity 0.55
Abstract · 6 pages, 4 figures. Accepted for presentation at the 2026 IEEE Industrial Electronics and Applications Conference (IEACon 2026)

This paper presents a physically interpretable framework for predicting time to empty (TTE) in portable embedded systems. The framework couples usage-driven load-power decomposition, electrical power-voltage-current closure, a semi-empirical aging model, and SOC-temperature dynamics. Smartphone telemetry is mapped to battery current through an interpretable load model and conversion-efficiency correction. Battery capacity loss is modeled by combining Arrhenius temperature dependence, SEI diffusion behavior, and cycle-related power-law degradation. The coupled dynamic model then predicts TTE under different initial SOC values, ambient temperatures, and usage profiles. Chronological hold-out evaluation on a 6.9-h smartphone discharge session yielded a current RMSE of 0.0095 $\pm$ 0.0006 A, a temperature RMSE of 2.93 $\pm$ 0.24$^\circ$C, and a TTE MAPE of 4.81 $\pm$ 0.61%. Evaluation on NASA cell B0005 produced a capacity-loss RMSE of 0.031 Ah. Baseline, ablation, and counterfactual analyses further illustrate the contributions of thermal and aging corrections and the relative influence of load features. The results demonstrate the feasibility and interpretability of the proposed framework, while broader validation across devices and batteries remains necessary.

0.34

Single-Cycle Battery Remaining Useful Life Prediction with Compressed Continuous Wavelet Features and Deep Neural Networks

cs.LG cs.AI ·2026-10-25 ·Sungeun Kim, Mingyu Jung, Yuri Kim, Jin-Sung Park, Jongbin Ryu
publishedbenchmark similarity 0.54
Abstract

Lithium-ion batteries are widely used in industrial applications, but their performance gradually degrades over time, making accurate lifetime prediction important for safety and reliability. However, reliable lifetime assessment generally requires extensive degradation testing, which is both costly and time-consuming. To reduce this burden, recent data-driven approaches have sought to predict the end-of-life cycle of batteries from only the initial few cycles. Nevertheless, identifying reliable degradation patterns from such limited early-cycle data remains challenging because early aging dynamics are often subtle and nonlinear. To address this issue, we adopt the continuous wavelet transform to convert cycle-wise voltage, current, and capacity signals into time-frequency representations, enabling multi-resolution characterization of degradation behavior. Building on this representation, we apply scale compression to reduce redundancy while preserving structural information in the scalograms. We evaluate the proposed framework on eight benchmark datasets derived from seven public battery datasets covering diverse electrode chemistries, cell form factors, and cycling protocols. Experimental results show that the proposed framework consistently outperforms prior approaches in single-cycle remaining useful life prediction and remains robust as the number of input cycles increases from 1 to 100. In addition, redundancy-fidelity analysis characterizes the trade-off introduced by scale compression, and gradient-based visual explanations indicate that the model focuses on localized time-frequency regions associated with structured signal transitions during charge-discharge operation. These results demonstrate the effectiveness and interpretability of the proposed framework for early-cycle battery remaining useful life prediction.

0.23

A Hybrid State Space-Attention Architecture for Forecasting the Trajectories of Battery Degradation

cs.AI physics.chem-ph ·2026-11-14 ·Shrey Patel, Bhargav Srinivas Rao, Samet Ayhan
benchmark similarity 0.52
Abstract

Early-life battery degradation trajectory forecasting aims to predict a battery cell's full state-of-health (SOH) trajectory from its initial charge-discharge cycles, potentially reducing cell qualification and evaluation time from months to days. Despite recent advances, accurate forecasting remains challenging for emerging battery chemistries, data-scarce domains, and cells exhibiting degradation behaviors beyond those observed during training. Existing state-of-the-art approaches increasingly rely on model scaling, large language model-derived aging-condition embeddings, and extensive fold-specific hyperparameter tuning, raising concerns about computational efficiency, reproducibility, and generalization. This work introduces DecayFormer, a compact hybrid state-space and attention architecture designed for early-life degradation trajectory forecasting. DecayFormer combines cycle-level selective recurrence, using a single scalar state per channel, with an attention mechanism queried by the recurrent state. It further incorporates state-of-charge (SOC) interval statistics and a master curve head that jointly estimates a scalar lifetime and a monotonically non-increasing SOH profile parameterized by normalized lifetime. We evaluate DecayFormer on the BatteryLife benchmark using all 22 aging-condition-exclusive folds, with a single run per fold and one fixed configuration across all folds, without fold-specific tuning. DecayFormer achieves mean test MAPE values of 2.25% on Li-ion, 2.76% on CALB, 0.95% on Na-ion, and 7.19% on Zn-ion. These results demonstrate the potential of compact sequence models to deliver accurate early-life degradation forecasts across diverse battery chemistries and aging conditions, without relying on extensive model scaling or per-fold optimization.

0.10