CS Paper Radar

How the Classical Baseline Shapes Machine-Learning Speed Claims in Topology Optimization

Shaoliang Yang, Jun Wang

cs.CE cs.LG ·submitted 2026-10-12 01:45 UTC · v2

Abstract

Topology optimization places material in a design domain to optimize a structure's performance, such as its stiffness or heat conduction. Machine-learning methods often report large speed-ups over classical, non-learned optimization, but a slow classical code or a lower-quality learned design can exaggerate them. We re-ran released code for eight methods on one workstation and studied two in depth: Optimize Any Topology (OAT), a diffusion model that generates designs, and a graph-based neural optimizer. Replacing the classical code with an efficient implementation of the same algorithm cut these two methods' speed-ups by up to 20-fold. We then timed the classical code until its design was at least as stiff as the learned one; for OAT, we picked this point after the runs, which gives the classical code its best case. Published timings imply a 134x speed-up for OAT on a 256 x 256 grid; our matched single-design comparisons gave 1.5x to 3.5x. At matched stiffness, the graph-based optimizer was slower than the classical code in all six two-dimensional problems. Of the six other methods, two kept their advantage, one shrank, one reversed, and two were not comparable. In an exploratory audit, language models judged that 8 of 28 speed comparisons in randomly sampled, openly accessible articles lacked evidence of equal design quality; our own review counted 11, so the count depends on who judges. We provide a comparison procedure and a minimum report: classical code, hardware, design quality, what each timing includes, and data-generation and training costs.

Comment
32 pages, 8 figures, 10 tables. Research article: tests of released code for eight topology-optimization methods and an exploratory audit of published speed claims

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Scalable Stress-Constrained Topology Optimization: A Simultaneous Approach Based on Machine Learning

cs.LG ·2026-10-20 ·Xiangyu Sun, Shirin Hosseinmardi, Ramin Bostanabad
similarity 0.63
Abstract · 41 pages, 19 figures, journal paper

Large-scale topology optimization (TO) remains computationally demanding, especially for stress-constrained problems. To address this challenge, we propose the simultaneous neural topology optimization (SNTO) framework where state, adjoint, and design variables are represented with custom neural networks (NNs) whose parameters are jointly optimized within a single loop using adjoint analysis and automatic differentiation. The loss function combines the design objective, an aggregation of the local stress constraints, and the potential energy functionals. Our NNs have a unique architecture that accelerates convergence while capturing the sharp gradients and boundaries which are critical to stress-constrained TO. To scale to millions of degrees of freedom, we develop a hardware-aware training scheme in which the design domain is partitioned into subdomains distributed across multiple graphics processing units (GPUs). To control peak GPU memory, we further slice each subdomain into smaller regions whose loss gradients are evaluated sequentially and accumulated. Unlike domain decomposition, our partitioning naturally ensures field continuity across subdomains without additional loss terms. We first evaluate SNTO on two-dimensional (2D) stress-constrained benchmarks and compare the results to a conventional finite element-based approach, showing that SNTO produces designs with sharper boundaries and smaller gray areas. We then solve three-dimensional (3D) problems with up to eight million collocation points on eight GPUs. The training time decreases nearly in proportion to the number of GPUs and the peak GPU memory is reduced by increasing the number of sub-slices. Overall, SNTO offers an effective pathway to large-scale stress-constrained TO on limited computational resources.

0.24

Bilevel Optimization of Topology and Hyperparameters (BOTH)

cs.LG ·2026-09-18 ·Suryanarayanan Manoj Sanu, Miguel Anibal Bessa, Alejandro Marcos Aragón
similarity 0.60
Abstract · Currently under submission to SMO journal

Topology optimization (TO) represents a significant step towards automating the design process: given a working simulation, TO can produce a viable prototype at the press of a button by differentiating the simulation and iteratively improving the design. In practice, however, TO is riddled with ``magic numbers''---hyperparameters whose tuning significantly affects the outcome. Finding the right values typically requires not only deep problem-specific knowledge but also extensive trial-and-error. While practitioners can use surrogate-assisted hyperparameter optimization as an alternative, this approach requires strictly limiting the number of hyperparameters through careful problem formulation. Here, we propose differentiating TO itself using automatic differentiation. This yields ``hypergradients'' that allow us to tune these hyperparameters in tandem with the primary optimization. We show that evaluating just one or two steps of TO is sufficiently informative and that the method scales favorably to thousands of hyperparameters at an expense comparable to only a few standard TO runs. We demonstrate this approach on stress-constrained and compliance problems, with the latter utilizing a neural parameterization of the density field.

0.50

Batch Before You Lift: Scalable Topological Deep Learning on Large Graphs

cs.LG cs.AI ·2026-10-08 ·David Leko, Luka Benić, Guillermo Bernárdez, Nina Miolane, Olga Fink +1 more
similarity 0.59
Abstract

Topological Deep Learning extends graph-based learning to higher-order domains, such as hypergraphs, cellular, and simplicial complexes. These domains are typically constructed from patterns in an input graph through a process of graph lifting. Full-domain training constructs and stores the complete lifted representation before model execution. On large and dense datasets like Reddit (233k nodes and 57.3M edges), this global materialization becomes a severe computational bottleneck, often rendering training infeasible. To address this limitation, we introduce Cluster-TNN, a domain-agnostic framework that avoids this bottleneck by lifting locally instead. After partitioning the input graph during preprocessing, at runtime Cluster-TNN dynamically samples groups of node clusters, reconstructs their induced subgraphs to form mini-batches, and applies the chosen lifting within each mini-batch. Retaining all edges among sampled nodes preserves the connectivity needed to construct higher-order structures across clusters, producing topological mini-batches that existing Topological Neural Networks can process directly. Across 21 matched comparisons with full-graph execution, Cluster-TNN reduces peak GPU memory in every configuration, by 83.2% on average while maintaining competitive predictive performance. Notably, such a reduction enables, to our knowledge, the first training of multiple different higher-order Topological Neural Networks on large datasets such as Reddit and OGBN Products. These results establish Cluster-TNN as a general strategy for scaling Topological Deep Learning beyond the limitations of global domain construction.

0.41

KATOsuper: Surrogate-accelerated neural topology optimization with sensitivity-consistent Fourier neural operators

cs.CE cs.AIcs.LGmath.NA ·2026-09-23 ·Shengyu Yan, Jasmin Jelovica
benchmark similarity 0.58
Abstract · 32 pages, 24 figures, 7 tables

Topology optimization (TO) remains computationally intensive due to repeated finite element analysis (FEA) evaluations required at each iteration. While neural network-based surrogates offer potential acceleration, existing approaches often suffer from gradient inconsistency between predicted objectives and sensitivities, leading to optimization instability. This work presents KATOsuper, an objective-agnostic framework that couples neural-reparameterized topology optimization with a Sensitivity-Consistent Fourier Neural Operator (SC-FNO). The framework employs the forward_split architecture, which derives deployed sensitivities via automatic differentiation through the predicted objective field and thereby preserves consistency between the predicted objective and the gradient used for optimization. The case studies include three 2D benchmark problems and three 3D structures considering compliance or stress minimization. A physics-informed multi-channel input encoding with Fourier position embedding enables resolution-invariant learning, supporting zero-shot extrapolation beyond the training resolution, with useful performance at moderate scaling factors and topology-preserving exploration at up to 64x without retraining. The framework extends to 3D through KATO3D, featuring novel KANConv3D blocks with learnable B-spline activations. KATOsuper demonstrates 15--110x deployment-time speedup over MATLAB baselines while maintaining competitive optimality, with the clearest gains observed in complex 3D and stress-optimization cases. The insight that sensitivity direction matters more than magnitude enables robust optimization even with approximate physics evaluation, extensible to other differentiable physics-driven design objectives.

0.58

Towards Easier-to-Tune Training Algorithms: New Results from AlgoPerf

cs.LG ·2026-10-09 ·Priya Kasimbeg, Ahmed Khaled, Aahlad Chandrabhatta, Yifan Wang, Andy Liu +7 more
benchmark similarity 0.57
Abstract

Evaluating deep learning optimizer is challenging because confounding factors such as hyperparameter tuning and optimizer-model co-design often obscure true algorithmic performance. We present results of the updated AlgoPerf V1 benchmark, in which we evaluate a new set of training algorithms on wall-clock time-to-target across nine workloads on fixed hardware. This report focuses on the results of the benchmark's self-tuning ruleset, which requires submissions to use a single configuration across all workloads. Out of the 13 submissions in PyTorch and JAX, Schedule-Free AdamW ranked first. In addition to the wall-clock scores, we also analyze the trade-offs between step efficiency and wall-clock execution, revealing that matrix-preconditioned and two-loop methods achieve good sample efficiency but require more aggressive computational optimizations to be competitive in runtime. Finally, our hyperparameter saliency and retention analyses show that the learning rate and momentum are highly sensitive across domains and algorithms, highlighting the need for methods that are more robust against hyperparameter tuning and can generalize well to new tasks.

0.11

TopoSHAP: Shapley for Explainable and Efficient Topological Deep Learning

cs.LG ·2026-11-05 ·Mathilde Papillon, Nina Miolane
benchmark similarity 0.57
Abstract

Topological deep learning (TDL) extends learning on graphs, such as molecules or social networks, to higher-order structures, such as rings in a molecule or groups in a social network. Explaining which of these structures drive a model's predictions, and which architectural components matter most for its performance, remains challenging. We introduce TopoSHAP, an efficient and general explanation framework that addresses both questions across topological domains and model architectures. TopoSHAP-cell assigns Shapley values to topological data cells and extracts compact explanations. These explanations match or outperform graph-based counterparts on GraphXAI benchmark data while running up to 112$\times$ faster. They also reveal advantageous topological feature design, leading to measured improvements in explanation recovery and predictive accuracy. On the architecture side, TopoSHAP-neighbor explains how neighborhoods contribute to model performance, and turns these evaluations into a backward-elimination search that identifies smaller, competitive architectures early in training. This is up to $11.3\times$ cheaper than traditional TDL training sweeps.

0.17

ATLAS: Adaptive TDA-guided Landscape-Aware Transistor Sizing

cs.AR ·2026-10-07 ·Youngmin Oh, Jihwan Won, Yuntae Park, Bosun Hwang, Suwan Kim
code/data similarity 0.56
Abstract

Analog transistor sizing, finding design parameters that simultaneously satisfy multiple performance specifications, is a labor-intensive bottleneck in circuit design. To support analog circuit experts, various automation methods have been proposed, including Bayesian optimization (BO), reinforcement learning (RL), and others. Yet existing methods are oblivious to the topological structure of a feasible design space, which can fragment into disconnected regions due to operating-regime transitions, conflicting specification trade-offs, and nonconvex device physics. This topological blindness causes the optimizer to converge within a single feasible region while missing others that may contain superior designs. To address this limitation, we propose ATLAS. a BO framework utilizing Topological Data Analysis (TDA). At each iteration, a Mapper graph is constructed over a surrogate-predicted feasible region to estimate connected regions, enabling topology-aware exploration from the very first iteration without any observed feasible points. A topological sensitivity score classifies candidates as bridge, frontier, or interior points, injecting a targeted exploration bonus into the acquisition function. Experiments on four analog circuit benchmarks in the GF180 and SKY130 processes demonstrate that \coin finds feasible designs with significantly fewer simulations than baselines, including RL and BO methods. To the best of our knowledge, this is the first work to apply topological data analysis to analog circuit design automation. The official implementation is publicly available on https://github.com/youngmin0oh/atlas.

0.44

Machine-learning-assisted multiscale topology optimization of functionally graded superimposed lattice structures

cs.CE ·2026-08-28 ·Prashant Kumar Gupta, Jonathan Stollberg, Dominik Schillinger, Mohammad Ashraf Iqbal
benchmark similarity 0.55
Abstract

Functionally graded lattice structures enable lightweight designs with spatially tunable stiffness and density, but their use in multiscale topology optimization is limited by the cost of repeated computational homogenization. This work presents a machine learning-assisted multiscale optimization framework for regular superimposed lattice structures. The unit cell is formed by combining body-centered cubic, face-centered cubic, and simple cubic lattice components, each controlled by an independent geometric parameter. Offline computational homogenization is used to generate effective stiffness data, which are then used to train a Cholesky-constrained neural network surrogate. This representation reconstructs the homogenized stiffness tensor in a physically admissible form. A separate neural network is trained to predict relative density from Monte Carlo-based density estimates. We incorporate our surrogates into a two-stage topology optimization strategy. First, a macroscale topology is obtained using the solid isotropic material with penalization (SIMP) method. The resulting solid region is then used for microscale lattice optimization, where the local lattice parameters are updated using the method of moving asymptotes (MMA). The trained stiffness and density surrogates replace repeated online homogenization during this stage. The method is demonstrated on a three-dimensional Messerschmitt-Bölkow-Blohm (MBB) beam benchmark, producing spatially varying lattice parameters and relative density fields consistent with compliance minimization under a material constraint.

0.27