CS Paper Radar

Toward Open ISA Supercomputing: A Comparative Study of RISC-V, Arm, and x86 Architectures on HPC Workloads

Emanuele Venieri, Giacomo Madella, Gabriele Ceccolini, Simone Manoni, Federico Ficarelli, Filippo Barbari, Jenny Lynn Almerol, Elisabetta Boella, Nitin Shukla, Simone Bnà, Luca Benini, Andrea bartolini

cs.DC cs.ARcs.PF ·submitted 2026-10-23 13:43 UTC · v2
code/data

Abstract

RISC-V is emerging as a candidate architecture for high-performance computing (HPC), but its competitiveness against established x86 and Arm processors remains difficult to assess because existing studies use different platforms, workloads, and methodologies, and rarely consider energy efficiency. Our work provides an evaluation of contemporary HPC RISC-V, Arm, and x86 processors using a common software stack and methodology. We characterize the Sophgo SG2044 and compare it with the NVIDIA Grace CPU Superchip and Intel Xeon Platinum 8480+ across four HPC benchmarks (STREAM, HPL, HPL-MxP, and HPCG) and four representative applications (iPIC3D, PLUTO, OpenFOAM, and llama$.$cpp). The version of HPL-MxP linked to OpenBLAS built and used for this work is made available as open-source software. The SG2044 reaches 8.02 GFLOP/s of FP64 performance and 7.8 GB/s of memory bandwidth per core, increasing to 294 GFLOP/s and 107 GB/s at 64 cores. L2-cache-aware process placement enables near-linear scaling up to 16 cores, beyond which memory-bandwidth saturation limits further gains. Across generations of RISC-V hardware, in the context of the Monte Cimone (MC) project, the SG2044-based MCv3 doubles both single-core performance and peak memory bandwidth relative to MCv2, while improving memory bandwidth, node-level FP64 performance, and energy efficiency by approximately 100x, 158x, and 10x, over MCv1. Against the Arm and x86 systems, the SG2044 shows 8-15x less absolute performance, reflecting its narrower vector resources and less advanced technology node, but delivers competitive scaling and energy efficiency on several workloads. Its most notable result is LLM decode, where 64-core execution provides the highest relative scaling and energy efficiency among the evaluated platforms while exceeding Intel in throughput. Our results show that RISC-V processors are closing the gap with the competition.

Comment
Preprint submitted to Future Generation Computer Systems

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Great Expectations: Benchmarking the Real-World Performance of RVV 1.0 in HPC

cs.DC cs.ARcs.ET ·2026-08-28 ·Stepan Nassyr, Prateek Chawla, Daniel Seibel, Jayesh Badwaik, Kaveh Haghighi Mood +1 more
similarity 0.73
Abstract · Accepted for International workshop on RISC-V for HPC at ISC26

Following the ratification of the RISC-V Vector Extension (RVV 1.0), new commercially available silicon has been adopting the extension. This paper revisits the question of RISC-V viability for High-Performance-Computing (HPC) by benchmarking the latest RVV 1.0-capable hardware (SiFive X280 (Tenstorrent Blackhole), SpacemiT X60 (K1) and X100/A100 (K3), and T-Head C920v2 (Sophon SG2044)). We assess these platforms using standard HPC benchmarks (BLAS, FFTW, HPL, HPCG) and synthetic workloads (STREAM, FMA throughput) and compare them to a state-of-the-art HPC ARM64 chip (NVIDIA Grace). Our findings show that while RVV 1.0 delivers significant performance improvements over scalar execution, hardware-specific implementation challenges remain. We detail these performance characteristics and discuss the remaining hurdles for RISC-V, including RVV, to become a mainstay in the HPC landscape.

0.44

NVIDIA Vera: A Microarchitecture-Level Comparison with Grace, Turin, and Granite Rapids

cs.DC cs.ARcs.PF ·2026-11-11 ·Joseph Moore, Thomas Green, Simon McIntosh-Smith
published similarity 0.71
Abstract · Accepted at PMBS26 (SC26 Workshops). 9 pages + 3-page artifact description, 11 figures, 1 table. Corrects a typo in Sec. IV-B relative to th…

The majority of new HPC systems are centered around NVIDIA, AMD, or Intel CPUs. Vera is NVIDIA's latest data-center CPU, including its first custom data-center core design, Olympus. This paper investigates Vera in comparison to AMD Turin and Intel Granite Rapids, using NVIDIA Grace as a baseline. We navigate up the performance ladder, from microbenchmarks that isolate performance metrics, through NAS kernels and miniapps, to single-socket performance of a range of scientific codes. We find that Vera achieves the best performance of the architectures evaluated in most codes tested, and that this gain is primarily attributed to its high memory bandwidth, effective Spatial Multithreading implementation, and low-latency memory subsystem aided by the architecture's predictive structures. While Vera represents a major leap over its predecessor, we show that its comparatively modest floating-point performance trails Intel and AMD in a small number of compute-bound workloads reflecting NVIDIA's GPU focus for such workloads.

0.43

Porting and Benchmarking Chapel on Emerging RISC-V Hardware: An HPC Viability Study

cs.DC cs.ET ·2026-08-14 ·Ian Henriksen, Chris Taylor, Patrick Diehl, Jade Abraham, Palmer Cox +2 more
benchmark similarity 0.67
Abstract

The Chapel programming language recently added support for the RISC-V architecture. Here we discuss what changes were needed for Chapel to work on RISC-V as well as lessons learned from the porting process. We use some of Chapel's extensive benchmark suite to gain further insight into the suitability of the RISC-V architecture for future HPC use. We compare performance on SiFive P550 and Unmatched boards and a Sophon SG2042 with a variety of other recent HPC CPU platforms. Various portability and performance anomalies arose on different architectures and are discussed. While the RISC-V machines represent smaller preliminary offerings and not HPC-class hardware, these results still provide hope that RISC-V hardware can become viable for HPC in the near future.

0.04

GPU implementation of a resource-constrained virtual machine

cs.DC cs.GR ·2026-08-17 ·Simone Li, Vladislav Brusokas, Andrei Ghita, Shuxuan Li, Wim Vanderbauwhede
benchmark similarity 0.66
Abstract · 5 pages, 5 figures. Accepted at the 2nd International Workshop on Low Carbon Computing (LOCO 2026), Lancaster University, United Kingdom, 10…

One of the main reasons compute hardware becomes obsolete is software bloat: resource requirements increase for every iteration of a software product. Resource constrained VMs are one way to combat software bloat as they post a hard limit on the resources and so force the programmer to be frugal. In this paper we explore the deployment of one such resource constrained VM, Uxn, on GPU. We show that for competitive performance it is essential to make use of the GPU data parallelism. We present an OpenMP-style parallelism API for Uxntal, the stack-based assembly-style language for the Uxn platform. We demonstrate that exemplar code using our API can run at comparable performance even on an integrated GPU. Specifically, our evaluation results show that using this approach improves performance on the compute-intensive Stencil benchmark with 19x and frame rate on the graphics-intensive Bunnymark benchmark with 7x. In practice, all laptops and desktops and even mobile devices have a GPU and our work shows that they can be used to execute frugal workloads effectively.

0.25

Superscalar Loop Processors

cs.AR cs.DC ·2026-11-01 ·Luca Colagrande, Pascal Etterli, Luca Benini
top venuecode/data similarity 0.66
Abstract · Accepted at MICRO 2026

To sustain the computational demands of modern ML and HPC workloads, programmable accelerators integrate large arrays of processing elements (PEs), typically built around single-issue in-order cores to maximize integration density and energy efficiency. As a result, each PE's instruction throughput is upper-bounded at one instruction per cycle (IPC), often suffering from significant underutilization of its functional units (FUs). Conventional superscalar processors can improve FU utilization by increasing IPC, but they typically incur substantial area and energy overheads. This work proposes the Superscalar Loop Processor (SLP) architecture, a lightweight approach to superscalar execution that targets regular, compute-intensive loop kernels. We present the SLP execution model, which exploits the static structure of these workloads to enable efficient multiple-issue execution without the complexity of dynamic out-of-order scheduling. We demonstrate the SLP architecture through an open-source prototype implementation, Schnizo, developed as an enhancement of a tiny RV32I core with floating-point support. Across several ML and HPC microkernels, Schnizo achieves substantially higher IPC and FPU utilization than the scalar baseline while retaining the efficiency of lightweight in-order designs. These results demonstrate that SLPs can provide an efficient architectural solution for programmable accelerators targeting regular, compute-intensive workloads.

0.51

Operating System Support for Accelerators as First-Class Compute Elements in Heterogeneous Systems

cs.AR cs.DCcs.OS ·2026-10-24 ·Mohammad Shahidzadeh, Lesley Shannon
similarity 0.66
Abstract · 13 pages, 12 figures

Heterogeneous systems-on-chip (SoCs) increasingly rely on domain-specific hardware accelerators (HAs) to deliver performance and energy efficiency gains beyond what general-purpose processors can provide. However, operating systems (O/S), such as Linux, assume that processors are the Compute Elements (CEs) and HAs are peripheral devices rather than specialized CEs. As a result, HA execution incurs substantial software (SW) overheads that reduce the effective benefits of hardware (HW) acceleration. This work demonstrates that significant inefficiencies arise from ``O/S peripheral device taxes'' (O/S taxes), including SW stack-accelerator communication, invocation, interrupt handling, and scheduling. We built MEERKAT, a Field-Programmable Gate Array (FPGA)-based framework for configurable multicore systems that include HAs; it allows the user to migrate Linux O/S support from SW to HW and identify, study, and quantify the impact. Here we study four major sources of O/S tax and introduce techniques to mitigate them. These include a virtual-memory-aware (VMA) communication method that enables efficient HA access to application data, a lightweight HA invocation interface, Interrupt Policy Adaptation (IPA) for dynamic polling and interrupt selection, and an HA-aware scheduler that dynamically distributes work across Central Processing Units (CPUs) and multiple HA instances. Experimental results demonstrate up to $260\times$ faster communication and $2$--$6\times$ performance improvements in wall-clock time over conventional schedulers. Furthermore, our study reveals that overall system performance depends not only on HA speed, but also on O/S overheads, resource availability, and scheduling decisions. These findings highlight the importance of treating HAs as first-class computational resources and motivate a more accelerator-centric O/S design for future heterogeneous systems.

0.15

Portability of Fortran's 'do concurrent' on GPUs II

cs.PL astro-ph.IMastro-ph.SRcs.CE+1 ·2026-08-20 ·Ronald M. Caplan, Miko M. Stulajter, Jon A. Linker, Jeff Larkin, Nikolaos Tselepidis +4 more
similarity 0.65
Abstract · 12 pages, 6 figures

There continues to be growing interest in using standard language constructs for parallel and accelerated HPC computing, avoiding the need for (sometimes vendor-specific) external APIs. For Fortran applications, language features such as 'do concurrent' loops open the door for compilers to implement multi-threaded, GPU-accelerated, and even distributed multi-node code with only the standard language. Here, we explore the current status of using 'do concurrent' for GPU-accelerated Fortran applications across three major GPU vendors (NVIDIA, AMD, and Intel). Using a production application, we test their current capabilities, showing where the standard language alone can be used, and where augmenting the code with a directive-based API (e.g., OpenMP) is still desirable or required. Multi-GPU tests are performed with GPU-aware MPI libraries. We find that the three GPU vendors can now GPU-accelerate pure Fortran (zero directives), but that manual data movement directives can help with performance and compatibility. The results show that there is rapid advancement towards making GPU-accelerated scientific HPC code performance portable using the Fortran standard language.

0.09

FP64 Performance and the Limits of Ozaki Emulation on HPC Systems

cs.DC math.NA ·2026-11-09 ·Katarzyna, Swirydowicz, Nicholas Malaya, Noah Wolfe, Paul Bauman +2 more
similarity 0.64
Abstract · 11 pages, 7 figures

A growing industry narrative holds that native double precision can be deprioritized in HPC accelerators, on the hypothesis that low-precision tensor cores can emulate FP64 on demand, and that most HPC workloads are bandwidth-bound. This paper evaluates some of those claims and explores the importance of FP64 in scientific computing. We show roofline profiling data of representative HPC workloads, across a variety of common computational motifs, to evaluate the arithmetic-intensity and accuracy requirements of these workloads. We also consider FP64 emulation via the Ozaki method to ascertain some of the possibilities and limitations of these approaches. These results indicate that Ozaki emulation should not be evaluated as a general replacement for FP64, but as an optimization for the subset of workloads whose dominant computation is sufficiently large, dense, and GEMM-shaped. Our analysis indicates this is less than 10\% of the HPC ecosystem. Furthermore, even in this favorable regime, standalone GEMM speedup is not enough to accelerate (or avoid performance regression) for the application: numerical behavior, workspace requirements, matrix shape, and integration overhead determine whether the benefit survives at application scale. This paper characterizes those boundaries empirically. Furthermore, we show that dense GEMM accounts for only a small fraction of FP64 computation across HPC workloads, leaving most application-level FP64 work beyond the reach of GEMM-based emulation.

0.32