CS Paper Radar

Minimizing Bid Cost Recovery for Energy Storage with Uniform Pricing

Yaxuan Yu, Jingguan Liu, Cong Chen

eess.SY ·submitted 2026-09-18 02:24 UTC · v1
published

Abstract

We study in-market uniform pricing and out-of-market bid cost recovery (BCR) payments in rolling-window dispatch for real-time power system operations with energy storage resources (ESRs). Due to intertemporal state-of-charge (SOC) constraints, ESR operations are temporally coupled, and existing in-market locational marginal pricing (LMP) may fail to compensate ESR's intertemporal opportunity costs, thereby triggering out-of-market BCR payments. We show that positive BCR is unavoidable when dispatched generators or ESRs have supply-side bids higher than the demand-side bid. We further identify an intertemporal coupling indicator associated with binding SOC constraints and demonstrate empirically that positive BCR arises only when this indicator is active, revealing that BCR is fundamentally driven by intertemporal coupling. In the simulation, we compare a BCR-minimizing uniform pricing scheme (UP-BCR) with existing real-time pricing methods under forecast uncertainty and show that UP-BCR substantially reduces BCR and demand payments relative to LMP while maintaining zero merchandising surplus in a copper-plate model.

Comment
Accepted to the 65th IEEE Conference on Decision and Control (CDC 2026)

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Scarcity Pricing for State-of-Charge Management in Real-Time Markets Under Intra-Day Uncertainty

eess.SY ·2026-11-09 ·Shailesh Wasti, Aravind Retna Kumar, Sushant Varghese, Anthony Giacomoni, Parviz Alivand +2 more
similarity 0.71
Abstract

The growth in renewable resources will increase net load variability and forecast error. Energy storage resources can provide flexibility when ramp capability is limited and contribute to load leveling over the day. The challenge for system operators is how to balance these two functions in real time, when updated net load forecasts are available for a limited lookahead horizon. U.S. electricity markets are seeking ways to manage state-of-charge (SoC) within their energy markets to more efficiently utilize these resources. We propose a method to manage energy storage SoC in a real-time market by extending Hogan's (2013) scarcity pricing framework. A day-ahead SoC schedule is modified using existing multi-interval real-time unit commitment engines as net load forecasts change. To address 30-minute-ahead forecast errors, an updated 5-minute SoC target and a dynamically updated shortage price for violating the constraint are provided to each economic dispatch. We simulate PJM's energy markets for 365 days and demonstrate reliability improvements relative to a strategy that enforces the day-ahead schedule. We show cost reductions and improved price formation relative to a strategy that updates target quantities but uses an administratively chosen shortage penalty.

0.24

Optimal Uniform Pricing for Multi-Interval Dispatch without Make-Whole Uplifts

eess.SY econ.EM ·2026-09-01 ·Valentina Norambuena-Guzman, Cong Chen, Lang Tong, Timothy D. Mount
similarity 0.70
Abstract · 5 pages, 4 figures, 2 tables

In a network with ramp-limited generators and inaccurate net-demand forecasts, practical rolling-window dispatch can drive locational marginal prices (LMPs) below generators' bid-in offers. In such cases, out-of-market (OOM) settlements are used to compensate generators and maintain dispatch-following incentives, but OOM can have negative consequences, including nontransparent real-time price signals, discriminatory compensation, and incentives for untruthful bidding. This paper presents an optimal uniform pricing rule that minimizes demand payments, eliminates OOM make-whole payments, preserves LMP-based congestion charges, and ensures revenue adequacy. We derive the proposed pricing rule in closed form and relate it to existing pricing schemes. Numerical comparisons demonstrate favorable generator profits and reduced price volatility. However, higher generator profits are accompanied by increased demand payments, reflecting the in-market, uniform allocation of ramping costs while preserving the LMP-based congestion charges widely used in real-time market settlements. The numerical results also show that, under LMP with OOM settlement, a price-taking generator has an incentive to inflate its offer, whereas this incentive is absent under the proposed pricing rule within the tested bid range.

0.52

State-of-Charge Targets for Storage Participation in Two-Settlement Markets: Reliability, Price, and Compensation Impacts

eess.SY ·2026-11-13 ·Yichen Li, Alexandre Moreira, Ruiwei Jiang, Miguel Heleno, Julie Mulvaney-Kemp
hot direction similarity 0.69
Abstract

As energy storage assumes a larger role in electricity systems, market operation must coordinate its use across time to support reliability during periods of system stress. Minimum state-of-charge (SOC) targets provide a means of preserving energy for these periods, but their design shapes reliability, operating efficiency, and storage compensation. This paper evaluates alternative SOC target designs in a California-based day-ahead and real-time electricity market model. The comparison examines targets based on day-ahead schedules or rolling centralized dispatch, enforced at the individual-resource or system level, across seasons, stress conditions, and participant information settings. The results show that retaining more energy does not necessarily reduce load shedding: targets that restrict discharge can limit storage support during shortages. Under critical summer conditions, individual targets derived from rolling centralized dispatch reduce weekly load shedding by approximately 83--84\% relative to operation without targets. Lower RT clearing costs and average prices can coexist with higher storage compensation, reflecting the role of day-ahead positions and real-time deviations in determining settlement outcomes. These findings highlight the importance of coordinating energy retention with timely discharge and network deliverability when designing SOC requirements for storage participation in electricity markets.

0.20

Locational Marginal Pricing for Adaptive Robust Look-Ahead Dispatch with Casual Affine Recourse

eess.SY ·2026-09-04 ·Aidan Looney, Qian Zhang, Le Xie
similarity 0.65
Abstract · 12 pages, 3 figures, 5 tables

This paper develops a marginal pricing mechanism for adaptive robust look-ahead economic dispatch (LAED) under net-load uncertainty. In current market practice, deterministic multi-interval dispatch can misprice flexibility when forecast error is large. Fully adaptive robust (FAR) dispatch captures this uncertainty, but competing worst-case trajectories can imply different marginal values of demand, leaving no single price for market settlement. We propose causal affine recourse (CAR) as a tractable, price-forming approximation. CAR replaces independently optimized trajectory-specific schedules with a causal affine response policy, yielding a market-clearing model that retains the standard energy and congestion decomposition of DC Locational Marginal Pricing. We then demonstrate that CAR-LMP together with a ramp-adjusted current settlement supports dispatch-following and eliminates current-period lost opportunity costs. We solve the CAR problem by deriving a robust counterpart and present computational evidence on exact small DC instances, a ten-generator system, and an IEEE 300-bus public-network case. These simulations show that the proposed prices collapse exactly to deterministic LAED-LMP when robustness is inactive, remain stable in loose-ramp regimes, and produce economically meaningful price shifts when flexibility is scarce. The proposed pricing mechanism provides a practical bridge between adaptive robust dispatch and market-based pricing.

0.28

Extended Version: Storage-Based Strategic Manipulation of Constraint-Binding Patterns in Power Networks

eess.SY econ.GN ·2026-09-14 ·Mehdi Davoudi, Minghao Mou, Junjie Qin
similarity 0.64
Abstract · Extended version of our paper submitted to IEEE Transactions on Power Systems

This paper studies the strategic market participation of a monopolistic energy storage aggregator (ESA) in a day-ahead electricity market. The ESA coordinates geographically distributed storage units, submits a coordinated bid for its portfolio, and may hold financial transmission rights (FTRs). The system operator clears the market through a network-constrained, multi-period economic dispatch, determining generation and load schedules, nodal prices, energy-market payments, and FTR payoffs. We formulate the ESA--system-operator interaction as a Stackelberg game and characterize its equilibrium through a constraint-binding-pattern decomposition of the market-clearing problem. Beyond enabling equilibrium computation, the framework reveals how the ESA can increase its profit by strategically inducing or avoiding particular constraint-binding patterns. It also establishes a novel welfare result: although strategic storage without FTRs is known to weakly improve social welfare relative to the no-storage case, certain FTR positions can overturn this guarantee by strengthening the ESA's incentive to induce particular patterns, causing social welfare to fall below the no-storage level. Motivated by these findings, we develop two system-operator mechanisms for limiting undesirable ESA behavior and its adverse effects on market outcomes and social welfare. Finally, a three-bus study illustrates the theoretical findings, while IEEE test systems demonstrate the scalability of the proposed method.

0.18

A Primal-Dual Formulation for Pricing Static Voltage Stability Services within a Unit Commitment Model

eess.SY ·2026-09-10 ·Peng Wang, Luis Badesa
similarity 0.63
Abstract

In modern power systems with high penetration of Inverter-Based Resources (IBR), most converters operate in Grid-Following (GFL) mode. Some buses exhibit inherently low Short-Circuit Ratios (SCRs), a property majorly shaped by network topology. The integration of GFL-IBR onto such weak buses thus demands attention to static voltage stability. To address this issue, market mechanisms have been proposed to incentivize generators to provide voltage stability services, such as commitment of synchronous generators for reducing the equivalent impedance at low SCR buses and adaptive reactive power support from GFL-IBR. To compute shadow prices for these services, previously proposed methods such as the `restricted' and `dispatchable' approaches may fail to guarantee operating cost recovery for voltage-stability service providers. As the resulting prices are determined purely from a social surplus maximization objective, the profitability of units is entirely overlooked. This suggests that new pricing methodologies are needed to satisfy cost-recovery requirements. Therefore, this paper proposes a pricing method based on a primal-dual formulation. Case studies demonstrate that the proposed method can consistently produce revenue-adequate shadow prices, enabling all participating units to recover their costs without supplementary uplift payments.

0.17

A Power-Trajectory Framework for Data Center Participation in Day-Ahead Markets

eess.SY ·2026-10-12 ·Menghan Zhang, Caisheng Wang
similarity 0.62
Abstract · 10 Pages, 7 Figures, 4 Tables

The rapid expansion of artificial intelligence (AI) is driving substantial growth in data center electricity demand. Interval-based energy blocks in day-ahead markets do not explicitly retain predictable intra-interval demand evolution, potentially creating mismatches with ramp-feasible generation trajectories and affecting settlement. This paper proposes a power-trajectory framework in which data centers declare predictable aggregate demand evolution through continuous demand-side power trajectories before market clearing. The declared trajectories are treated as exogenous inputs for constructing generation trajectories and the corresponding price trajectory. For feasible market-clearing outcomes, physical temporal consistency is established through continuous-time power balance and satisfaction of the modeled generation operating constraints, while economic temporal consistency is established by preserving the dispatch-price correspondence in energy settlement on a common temporal basis. Under the adopted settlement definitions, a trajectory-based settlement analysis separately quantifies the monetary magnitude of representation-induced power imbalances and the supply-side compensation that may remain under temporally consistent clearing and settlement. An illustrative 5-bus case demonstrates the elimination of representation-induced power imbalance and identifies the timing and physical sources of supply-side compensation. A modified IEEE RTS-GMLC case further illustrates these compensation effects across multiple generating units under workload-driven data center demand variations.

0.17

Prosumer Synchronisation Risk: Impacts of Time-Varying Tariffs on Distribution Network Expansion

eess.SY ·2026-09-02 ·Dillon Zadoks, Alfredo Oneto, Carlo Tajoli, Yi Guo, Philipp Heer +2 more
published similarity 0.61
Abstract

The rapid deployment of distributed energy resources, including heat pumps, electric vehicles, photovoltaics, and battery storage, is reshaping the operation of low-voltage networks. While distribution system operators often aim to develop time-varying tariffs to incentivise network-friendly behaviour and defer reinforcements, they risk triggering prosumer synchronisation. As prosumers follow price signals, their behaviour may synchronise, avoiding existing load peaks while creating undesirable peaks at other times. This paper quantifies the impact on low-voltage network reinforcement needs when shifting from flat tariffs to two time-varying tariffs: Time-of-Use and Real-Time Pricing. Applying a mixed-integer linear model across 471 low-voltage reference networks in Switzerland, we evaluate expansion requirements under projections of distributed energy resource deployment for 2050. In the model, prosumers operate their distributed energy resources in accordance with their subscribed electricity tariff to minimise costs, and the distribution system operator subsequently optimises reinforcements. Our results demonstrate that while adopting time-varying tariffs can reduce reinforcement investment costs by more than 50%, high adoption rates can reverse this declining trend. Specifically, once prosumer adoption exceeds the optimal thresholds of 50% for Time-of-Use and 40% for Real-Time Pricing, reinforcement needs increase by 39% and 134%, respectively, for an additional 20% of tariff adoption.

0.24