CS Paper Radar

Reversing the Clock: Layout-Aware Recovery of Design Intent from Clock Distribution Networks

Sascha Tommasone, Zehra Karadağ, Christopher Pawlowicz, Michael Green, Bruno Machado Trindade, Eunsung Seo, Christof Paar, René Walendy, Steffen Becker

cs.CR ·submitted 2026-10-02 11:55 UTC · v1
publishedcode/data

Abstract

Hardware reverse engineering supports competitive analysis and hardware assurance by recovering information about an integrated circuit (IC) from its physical implementation. While existing techniques primarily recover the gate-level netlist, which represents logical functionality, they often overlook physical design decisions such as placement, routing, delay insertion, and interconnect optimization. The clock distribution network encapsulates many of these decisions; however, no prior published work has recovered this network from a fabricated IC to infer design intent. We present a layout-aware methodology that recovers and analyzes the clock distribution network by integrating a recovered gate-level netlist with layout information extracted from scanning electron microscope imagery. Our four-phase pipeline recovers clock-tree topology, buffering, gating and switching, interconnect delay, and crosstalk-mitigation measures. We demonstrate our methodology on a commercial 450 nm IC, recovering a global H-tree backbone with local X-tree-like branching, identifying an independent clock tree and global clock gating, quantifying latency, skew, and routing lengths, and confirming the absence of dedicated crosstalk mitigation. Together, these findings let us reason about the designer's intent. To encourage further research and support reproducibility, we release our clock tree recovery algorithm as open source.

Comment
Accepted at the IEEE International Conference on Physical Assurance and Inspection of Electronics (PAINE) 2026

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Design Space Exploration of Backside Clock Meshes for 2 nm GAAFET BSPDN Technology

cs.AR ·2026-10-01 ·Wajid Ali, Muhammad Hadir Khan, Dalton Gaddy, Matthew Guthaus
similarity 0.62
Abstract

Clock meshes are used in high-performance VLSI designs to minimize skew and tolerate on-chip variation, but they spend scarce routing resources on premium metal layers. Backside power delivery creates a new option: it adds thick, low-resistance metal layers on the back of the wafer, and the power grid does not consume all of them. Flip-flops remain on the frontside; a backside mesh therefore cannot drive them directly, and every connection passes through a through-silicon via. We present the first design-space exploration of backside clock meshes, implemented in OpenROAD on GT2N, a 2 nm nanosheet technology. Four benchmarks (1,938 to 15,311 flip-flops) are explored with multi-objective Bayesian optimization, and every design point is verified by transistor-level SPICE simulation, since the cyclic mesh cannot be evaluated by static timing analysis. Across all four designs, the backside mesh consistently outperforms an identical frontside mesh, with on average 45% lower skew, 25% lower sink slew, 4.5% lower power, and 28% less frontside clock wiring, and its skew spread under 10,000-sample Monte Carlo is a third of the frontside mesh's.

0.28

A Surrogate Model for Variation-Aware Clock-Mesh Analysis and Design-Space Exploration using Graph Neural Networks

cs.AR cs.LG ·2026-11-01 ·Muhammad Hadir Khan, Wajid Ali, Arya Thottiparambil Manikandan, Matthew Guthaus
similarity 0.59
Abstract

Clock meshes are widely used in high-performance VLSI systems to minimize skew and tolerate On-Chip Variation (OCV) in nanometer technologies. However, analyzing meshes is difficult because reconvergent paths and multi-source drivers prevent static timing analysis (STA) tools from handling mesh loops, making SPICE the industrial standard. SPICE simulations are accurate but slow, so clock-mesh synthesis relies on approximate models that overlook critical effects such as non-linear buffer driving caused by input slew and input skew. We propose a Graph Neural Network (GNN) based surrogate model of the clock mesh with a new graph representation and a new architecture that predicts power while also improving the delay and slew predictions at the sinks and capturing the skew histogram under OCV. Trained on SPICE data and tested on unseen real designs, our model achieves average errors of $3.40$~ps in delay, $4.14$~ps in slew and $4.46$~ps in skew, compared with $6.28$~ps, $12.35$~ps, and $11.62$~ps for our prior model, and $74.37$~ps delay and $27.51$~ps skew for the approximate method used in current state-of-the-art works. Our model predicts power within $3.4\%$ of SPICE on average, while delivering $18\times$-$1706\times$ speed-ups over the approximate method under OCV modeling, enabling faster and more accurate clock-mesh design-space exploration. A case study on a real design further shows that our surrogate model finds buffering candidates that, at a balanced tradeoff, improves $99^{\text{th}}$-percentile skew by $49.1\%$, reduces power by $25.7\%$, and reduces area by $37.3\%$ at the cost of a $6.8\%$ increase in $99^{\text{th}}$-percentile maximum slew as compared to the state-of-the-art work.

0.21

Clock-Gating Insertion Strategies on an Open-Source MSP430 Core: A Reproducible PPA Study and a Gate-Level Simulation Caveat

cs.AR ·2026-08-31 ·Xingran Huang, Qiming Guo, Jinwen Tang, Wenqi Jia, Dongzheng Wang
publishedcode/data similarity 0.58
Abstract · 8 pages, 9 figures, 5 tables. Accepted for presentation at IEEE UEMCON 2026. Code and reproducibility artifact: https://github.com/yanyana11…

Clock gating, the standard technique for cutting dynamic power, is introduced either as hand-written behavioral clock gates at the register-transfer level (RTL) or as integrated clock-gating (ICG) cells inserted automatically during synthesis; the two are widely treated as interchangeable. In this paper we show, on a real open-source 16-bit microcontroller core (openMSP430) synthesized with a 32 nm standard-cell library, that they are not equivalent in practice: behavioral latch-based RTL gating is functionally correct in ideal RTL simulation (10/10 self-checking testcases, identical to the ungated baseline) yet fails at gate level: the gated multiplier result is never captured and reads zero, while tool-inserted ICG cells pass gate-level simulation cleanly (10/10). We root-cause the failure to a hold race introduced by the late latch+AND gated clock, and show it persists across eight simulation configurations including full Standard Delay Format (SDF) back-annotation, not a simulator-setting artifact. We then quantify the power/area/timing (PPA) impact of three gating strengths: RTL behavioral (Opt1), synthesis ICG (Opt2), and both (Opt3), against the ungated baseline, across four workloads and three process corners (ss/tt/ff). The benefit is corner-robust: ICG (Opt2) cuts dynamic power by 74-81% and total power by 25-30% at every corner. We also show that in this leakage-dominated 32 nm regime the total-power win comes from the area/leakage reduction that gating brings (leakage -24 to -30%), not from the large dynamic saving, which instead dominates active-mode energy. Our recommendation for low-power design on open-source cores is to prefer tool-inserted ICG cells over hand-written behavioral clock gates. The full flow (Design Compiler synthesis, PrimeTime PX power, and self-checking verification) is released as an open artifact.

0.73

CU-3D: A Scalable Legality-Aware RTL-to-GDS Flow for 3D-IC Physical Design

cs.AR ·2026-11-08 ·Mingjun Wang, Guanqi Li, Yihan Wen, Lancheng Zou, Mingjun Li +8 more
similarity 0.58
Abstract

Face-to-face (F2F) hybrid bonds shorten interdie connections, but data, clock, and power-grid (PG) connections must be realized together. CU-3D is a RTL-to-GDS physical design flow based on commercial EDA tools. It derives role-compatible hybrid-bond (HB) sites from a 17-metal ASAP7-based technology model, complete HB footprints, and constructed PG geometry. To coordinate partitioning with placement flexibility, Scaled refines an inherited 2D placement, whereas Fresh places the receiving die first and uses its pin locations and clock loads to guide placement of the other die. Data and clock HB assignments are jointly optimized while retaining alternative data sites and reserving capacity for subsequent PG assignment. The selected HB sites and stacks are preserved during 3D clock-tree synthesis, supply-aware cell insertion, and routing. Across eleven designs, including a 133-macro processor, the flow achieves zero backend DRC violations and passes signal-connectivity checks. Nine paired designs admit lower-footprint, lower-power implementations; four improve setup WNS. On JPEG, early joint planning gains 87 ps and mobility-aware partitioning gains 346 ps. Path analysis explains why cell-delay savings can outweigh net-delay increases.

0.21

E-Layout: Layout-Stage Logic Restructuring via RL-Optimized Equality-Saturated Graph Retrieval-Augmented Generation

cs.AR ·2026-10-19 ·Wenji Fang, Rongjian Liang, Yi-Chen Lu, Cunxi Yu, Chen Chen +5 more
published similarity 0.57
Abstract · Accepted by ICCAD'26

Achieving high sign-off performance in advanced ICs increasingly depends on layout-stage optimization under realistic physical conditions. While recent efforts have moved toward synthesis-layout fusion, most existing works still focus on bringing estimated physical information earlier into synthesis, whose optimization does not fully correlate with real layout-stage behavior. Meanwhile, layout-stage optimization remains largely restricted to a fixed logic structure, relying mainly on buffering and sizing. This fundamentally constrains the optimization space under realistic physical conditions. To address this, we present E-Layout, an ML-driven framework for post-placement layout restructuring. E-Layout jointly optimizes logic transformation and physical implementation across multiple subcircuits under design-level timing feedback. This enables the selection of the most timing-beneficial set of disjoint restructured subcircuits to form the optimized circuit. Specifically, it first constructs equivalence-preserving logic alternatives via e-graph equality saturation, then couples logic selection with physical realization through a graph-based retrieval-augmented generation (RAG) model, and finally refines these local logic-physical decisions with reinforcement learning under design-level timing feedback. Evaluated on 9 diverse designs, it achieves on average 6% TNS improvement and 2% WNS improvement, while even reducing area by 1%, over an industry-leading commercial physical design flow.

0.37

ICLayout-Bench: Benchmarking LLM Agents for Custom Circuit Layout Design

cs.AR cs.AIcs.SE ·2026-11-08 ·Zhangmai Li, Tianrui Ma, Zheng Weng, Mo Zou, Zidong Du +6 more
benchmarkcode/data similarity 0.56
Abstract · 12 pages, 7 figures, 3 tables, including appendices. Project page: https://lizhangmai.github.io/ICLayout-Bench Code: https://github.com/lizh…

Large language model (LLM) agents are being explored for circuit design, but their ability to produce high-quality custom layouts has not been extensively evaluated. ICLayout-Bench is a benchmark in which agents use electronic design automation (EDA) tools to construct and optimize GDSII layouts from transistor-level circuit netlists. These layouts are evaluated using physical verification, parasitic extraction, and post-layout simulation. Layouts that pass the physical and functional checks are scored on electrical performance and area. The benchmark includes 165 tasks across 13 process design kits (PDKs), covering technology nodes from 3 nm to 180 nm. The tasks span analog, mixed-signal, and digital circuits in open-source and commercial EDA flows. The experiments evaluate 22 configurations spanning seven models on 21 public and 19 private tasks. Mean layout scores range from 4.22 to 80.26 on public tasks and from 1.43 to 67.01 on private tasks, on a 100-point scale. Higher reasoning effort does not consistently improve mean scores, and configurations with comparable scores can incur substantially different model costs.

0.43

Scalable AXI4 Transaction Monitoring for Mixed-Criticality SoCs: From Phase-Level Precision to ID-Level Efficiency

cs.AR ·2026-08-31 ·Chaoqun Liang, Thomas Benz, Alessandro Ottaviano, Michael Rogenmoser, Luca Benini +2 more
top venue similarity 0.56
Abstract

Mixed-criticality Systems-on-Chip (SoCs) with on-chip interconnects based on the AXI4 open standard protocol lack a protocol-level timeout mechanism, exposing systems to deadlocks and missed real-time deadlines when subordinate devices or managers fail or stall due to hardware faults, radiation-induced upsets, or software errors. This work presents a configurable hardware intellectual property (IP), non-intrusive in fault-free operation, that detects AXI4 protocol violations and timing faults at runtime and restores interconnect liveness through a cut-and- drain isolation mechanism. To address the fundamental trade-off between monitoring granularity and area cost, we introduce three designs at decreasing monitoring granularity: Phase-Level Track-ing (PLT), which provides cycle-accurate fault localization across individual protocol phases; Channel-Level Tracking (CLT), which coalesces per-phase monitors into channel-level supervision; and ID-Level Tracking (ILT), which achieves sub-linear area scaling by monitoring only per-ID transaction boundaries. Synthesized in GlobalFoundries 12 nm technology, CLT reduces area by 36.7% relative to PLT while preserving worst-case detection bounds at a minimal detection latency overhead, whereas ILT achieves an 89.2% area reduction suitable for tightly constrained deployments at the cost of a 3.7x higher median detection latency with coarser fault localization. Fault injection campaigns on a RISC-V SoC across 1.2 million scenarios confirm that no fault manifesting as an AXI4 protocol or liveness violation escaped detection, with observed detection latencies consistently bounded by theoretical worst-case predictions.

0.41

Evaluating AI Agents for Industrial-Level Chip Floorplanning: A Framework and Empirical Study

cs.AI ·2026-11-09 ·Nova-Silicon Team
similarity 0.55
Abstract

Floorplanning is an early step in turning a logical circuit into a physical chip: it positions large circuit modules and constrains the space available for subsequent logic placement and wiring. These decisions affect congestion and timing, but their physical consequences emerge through downstream implementation. For AI agents, the task requires translating engineering constraints into spatial decisions whose quality cannot be judged by successful tool execution alone. We present an evaluation framework that connects submitted layouts to a prescribed downstream implementation flow, checks geometric validity, measures physical quality, and reports resource use. On one industrial design whose 99 macros occupy approximately 71\% of a fixed L-shaped layout region, we compare our specialized system Nova-SI with general-purpose engineering agents and agents restricted to file access, obtaining complete physical measurements for 39 layout outputs. Under our 0--100 composite quality score, Nova-SI achieves a mean of 57.97 without online feedback from the prescribed power-grid and placement evaluation, compared with 31.17 for the strongest measured general-purpose configuration, GPT-6 Astra. The difference is supported by raw congestion and timing measurements and persists across scoring-sensitivity checks. Layout-level analysis further shows that similar global utilization can conceal substantially different local congestion. Together, the protocol and case study assess agents through the physical consequences of their delivered layouts and provide evidence about system performance on this industrial instance.

0.28