CS Paper Radar

Representation Risk in Pretrained Image Encoders

Ardyn Nordstrom, Morgan Nordstrom, Vamuyan Sesay, Matthew D. Webb

cs.CV econ.GN ·submitted 2026-09-28 15:53 UTC · v1
benchmark

Abstract

Applied researchers increasingly convert images into features with pretrained encoders, then use those features in a downstream prediction model. The encoder is often treated as an implementation detail. We show that it can instead be a consequential source of model uncertainty. We call this uncertainty representation risk: plausible pretrained encoders map the same images into different feature spaces and can yield sharply different out-of-sample conclusions from predictive performance. We compare ten modern and legacy frozen encoders across applications involving house prices, racehorse performance, breast-cancer histology, chest radiographs, continuous facial age, and rice disease. With common dimension control, heads, and group-safe splits, validation selects SigLIP 2 for houses, raising test $R^2$ from 0.396 for ResNet50 to 0.629, and DINOv2 for horses, raising $R^2$ from 0.029 to 0.105. No encoder is best in every task. Candidate procedures are constructed using training data and compared on a separate validation partition. The selected procedure reaches 0.658 for houses and 0.979 accuracy for pneumonia. Fixed-split gains are small for horses and rice, while repeated partitions reveal instability in horse feature union. Continuous age selects SigLIP 2 at 4.786 years MAE. The principal representation gaps persist with neural heads, similarly sized DINOv2 and ViT models, and limited adaptation. These results support a simple workflow: benchmark plausible representations, select on locked validation data, combine only when separate validation evidence justifies the additional cost, and report paired and split-level uncertainty. We implement this workflow in LOOKAGAIN-ML, the software package used to conduct the analyses in this paper.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

CRS-Bench: A Reference-Relative Reliability Benchmark for Medical Image Encoders

eess.IV cs.AIcs.CV ·2026-08-22 ·Xingtao Lin, Hangqi Ren, Caiwan Sun, You Chen
benchmark similarity 0.66
Abstract · 10 pages, 7 figures. Submitted to WACV 2027

Pretrained image encoders are central to medical image classification, where expert annotation is costly and task-specific cohorts are often limited. As the model space expands from general-purpose to broad-medical and specialty-specific encoders, selecting the representation becomes a substantive modeling decision. Clean-test discrimination alone is insufficient for this purpose: encoders with similar AUROC can differ in calibration, label efficiency, and stability under acquisition perturbations or distribution shift. We introduce CRS-Bench, a controlled benchmark for multi-objective medical encoder selection. CRS-Bench evaluates 15 pretrained encoder families across dermatology, ophthalmology, and radiology using ISIC 2019, APTOS 2019, and CheXpert, with CheXpert-to-MIMIC-CXR as an observed institutional shift, yielding 17,575 controlled run records and 3,515 seed-aggregated metric rows. Each encoder is characterized along four operational reliability dimensions: discrimination, calibration, label efficiency, and robustness. We summarize these dimensions using the Clinical Reliability Score (CRS), a Pareto-aware, reference-relative score combining dominance, profile balance, and worst-axis performance. AUROC and CRS are positively associated but not decision-equivalent: 21 of 105 pairwise orderings reverse, with a mean absolute rank displacement of 1.87. Paired-seed bootstrap analysis identifies PanDerm, MedSigLIP, and MedGemma as a stable leading reliability tier rather than a statistically resolved single leader. CRS-Bench provides a controlled framework for selecting medical image encoders from multi-axis reliability profiles rather than clean-test AUROC alone.

0.33

FRAME: Separating sampling variation from performance disparities in medical image analysis

cs.CV cs.AIcs.LG ·2026-08-26 ·Mahshad Lotfinia, Daniel Truhn, Andreas Maier, Soroosh Tayebi Arasteh
similarity 0.61
Abstract

Fairness audits of medical imaging models commonly report the largest performance difference between demographic subgroups and treat any positive value as evidence of bias. Yet a perfectly fair model also produces a positive difference, which grows as subgroups shrink. Some mitigation methods remove demographic information from models because they assume that it produces the difference. Here we introduce Fair-model Reference And Mechanism Evaluation (FRAME). Its first step compares each reported difference with the difference expected from a perfectly fair model at the same subgroup counts. Its second step tests whether candidate causes of any excess over this fair-model reference change the difference when they are injected into model features. We evaluated 36 encoders on nine datasets in three modalities and audited 89 published differences across six modalities. For 10 frozen encoders and 13 chest radiograph findings, the reference is a median 41% of the race difference and 22% of the age difference. It is exceeded by 40 of 53 published differences in sensitivity or false positive rate and by one of 36 in the area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUROC). Adding race information to the features of two encoders does not change the race difference significantly. At matched disease performance, mitigation reduces the race difference by less than its spread across three pretraining seeds (medians 0.005 and 0.012) and the age difference by more (0.008 and 0.006). Image-text pretraining raises the worst-group AUROC for race by a median 0.049 over self-supervised pretraining. Reporting the fair-model reference beside every new and published subgroup difference could direct mitigation to the differences above it.

0.11

Different Models, Shared Failures: Auditing Frozen-Encoder Pools for Medical Segmentation

cs.CV cs.AI ·2026-10-30 ·Eunseob Choi, Kyeonghun Kim, Hyuk-Jae Lee, Nam-Joon Kim
top venuecode/datahot direction similarity 0.61
Abstract · Accepted at NeurIPS 2026, Track on Evaluations and Datasets. 47 pages, 8 figures. Code and data: https://github.com/eunseobchoi/CoFailMed

Average segmentation accuracy and model count do not reveal whether models fail on the same cases. We present CoFailMed, an audit of correlated failures in pretrained-encoder pools for medical segmentation. Across five 2D tasks, we evaluate 11 public pretrained encoders (a controlled sample, not a census) using frozen features and separately trained $1\times 1$ readouts with four seeds per encoder. Shared-checkpoint pairs have the highest mean per-case Dice correlation. An expanded 17-encoder analysis shows that distinct checkpoints within the same encoder family remain more correlated than cross-family pairs. At the pooled 33rd-percentile Dice threshold, four-member pools drawn from distinct encoders have mean effective sizes of 1.56-2.92, estimated from failure correlations in pools with enough failures and passes per member. In the primary pool, richer readouts and fine-tuning narrow the Dice-correlation gap between pairs sharing a checkpoint (or the DINOv2-B/S release) and all other pairs. Yet dependence between different encoders can increase, and fine-tuning does not consistently increase effective pool size at 33rd-percentile thresholds recomputed for each training recipe. A smaller between-group gap can coexist with greater dependence. Pool evaluation should therefore report absolute dependence and threshold-specific effective size alongside accuracy and nominal pool size. The CoFailMed release provides aligned per-case traces, analysis scripts and study code to reproduce the central audit results.

0.63

SigLIP2 for aerial fire risk classification

cs.CV ·2026-10-02 ·Yunus Serhat Bıçakçı
code/data similarity 0.61
Abstract · 7 pages, 3 figures, 2 tables. Code available at https://github.com/yunusserhat/firerisk

We examine the transfer of a pretrained SigLIP2 image encoder to seven class fire risk classification from aerial imagery. We introduce a reproducible partition of the public FireRisk training mirror and an implementation that records data provenance, preprocessing and model selection. Two initial runs compare a frozen encoder probe with full model adaptation. On the validation partition, full adaptation reaches 63.05% accuracy and 58.94% macro F1, compared with 55.95% and 50.19% for the probe. Both runs use one training seed and select their checkpoint on the same validation partition. These development results support further evaluation of SigLIP2 but do not establish performance on an independent test set or unseen regions. The accompanying code provides a common framework for repeated experiments and comparisons with additional visual encoders.

0.35

Wrong Organ, Right Physics: Transferring Echocardiography Pretraining to Lung Ultrasound for Tuberculosis Screening

eess.IV cs.CVcs.LG ·2026-10-02 ·Christiaan M. Geldenhuys, Joshua M. Jansen van Vüren, Véronique Suttels, Trevor Brokowski, Ablo P. Wachinou +4 more
published similarity 0.61
Abstract · 10 pages, 3 figures, 4 tables. Accepted at SATNAC 2026, Drakensberg, South Africa, 11-14 October 2026

Lung ultrasound (LUS) is attractive for tuberculosis (TB) screening at primary-care level, but labelled cohorts are small. Echocardiography carries no such constraint, while sharing the same underlying ultrasound imaging physics, signal processing and B-mode appearance as LUS. We ask whether an encoder pretrained on that high-resource ultrasound domain carries representations that remain usable in the low-resource one. Only the encoder varies, across seventeen encoders spanning three architecture families. Among them, a latent-predictive video encoder pretrained on generic video (V-JEPA2-L) and its echocardiography counterpart (EchoJEPA-L) differ in pretraining corpus alone. The choice among these encoders does not resolve the classification, the whole family spanning 2.50 percentage points against a measurement resolution of 2.71. What moves the task instead is feature conditioning. Standardising the features between the encoder and the classifier improves all seventeen encoders by a mean of +1.23 percentage points at $p=1.5\times10^{-5}$. On the held-out test set every encoder selected on the development folds stands above the baseline system by up to +2.57 percentage points of area under the receiver operating characteristic curve (AUROC), and specificity at 90% sensitivity reaches 79.3% against 60.3%. The contrast specified in advance, EchoJEPA-L against V-JEPA2-L, measures -0.16 percentage points at $p=0.926$. We therefore find no evidence that shared ultrasonic physics alone makes echocardiography a more productive pretraining corpus than generic video, and any advantage, if present, is smaller than this cohort can resolve. The video encoders receive replicated still images, however, so whether this absence of an effect reflects the pretraining domain or a video encoder applied to static frames cannot be separated. The limiting factor is the labelled cohort rather than the encoder.

0.26

Picking the Right Image to Classify: Reliable-Input Selection in Teledermatology

cs.CV cs.AI ·2026-08-17 ·Fabian Gröger, Marco Weishaupt, Philippe Gottfrois, Simone Lionetti, Linda Wermelinger +4 more
benchmarktheory similarity 0.59
Abstract

Dermatology models face distribution shifts in teledermatology settings, where submitted images differ from the training data in lighting, angle, distance, focus, and framing. These test-time images are ordinary clinical photographs, but some fall outside the model's training conditions, leading the model to often misclassify them due to shifts in acquisition between training and deployment. When multiple images of the same case exist (several photos of one patient or lesion), a natural way to improve accuracy is therefore to select the image the model is most likely to classify correctly. We call this task reliable-input selection. An oracle that, for each case, selects a correctly classified image when one exists raises weighted F1 by about 20 percentage points on average across six dermatology datasets and nine frozen backbones. This oracle is an upper bound that sees the labels, whereas a selector must choose blindly. Capturing this gain in practice is hard. A selector that needs no pretraining data applies to any frozen model, including those whose data is not public. It must judge reliability from quantities the model exposes at inference: its embeddings, their norms, and its confidence. We benchmark four such training-data-free selectors: the embedding norm, the neighborhood consensus among a case's images, the stability of the prediction under small perturbations, and the model's own confidence. No training-data-free selector substantially narrows this oracle gap. The best of them is the model's own confidence, but it recovers only a small part of the gap on the clinical datasets. A small labeled reference set does not help either: the best selector overall, a fusion of confidence and Mahalanobis distance, still leaves most of the gap. To our knowledge, this is the first study to introduce and benchmark reliable input selection, a clinically important, unsolved task.

0.31

The Predictability Bias of Joint-Embedding Predictive Learning in Medical Imaging

eess.IV cs.CVcs.LG ·2026-10-09 ·Fabian Drexel, Bernhard Kainz, Jakob N. Kather, Daniel Rueckert, Lisa C. Adams +2 more
similarity 0.59
Abstract · 45 pages, 6 figures

Joint-embedding predictive architectures (JEPAs) learn by predicting teacher representations of masked regions from visible context. Point prediction summarizes the conditional target distribution and cannot reproduce variation that the context does not resolve. We call this constraint predictability bias. In computed tomography (CT), recurrent anatomy is predictable from context, whereas the sporadic, localized pathology that determines clinical interpretation often is not. We introduce TAP-JEPA, a ViT-B/3D trained on 113,611 CT volumes that is competitive with state-of-the-art encoders (COLIPRI, Merlin, VoxelFM) in scan-level classification. We then audit the learned predictive pathway by replaying the exact masking, teacher, and predictor computations used during training. Prediction lowers the mean Skill (prevalence-normalized average precision) from 0.388 to 0.271 for pathology, but only from 0.921 to 0.873 for anatomy. Along the teacher direction, separating pathology from matched control regions in the same organ, prediction moves pathology 34.7% toward the controls and controls 13.6% toward pathology, with larger shifts farther from visible context. Replacing visible matched-control representations increases surrounding-target prediction loss more than fully replacing pathology representations across four pathology categories. Downstream, removing all final-layer pathology tokens reduces the decision margin by at most 0.45% in four of seven scan-level probes. Together, these results show that contextual predictability is not a sufficient proxy for clinical relevance in medical representation learning. Training objectives should therefore retain diagnostic features regardless of their predictability from surrounding anatomy.

0.19

When Foundation Models Disagree: Representational Heterogeneity for Calibrated Uncertainty in Whole-Slide Image Classification

cs.CV q-bio.QM ·2026-11-19 ·Yekai Shen, Yuqian Wang, Zishun Liao, Rongsheng Wang, Wenting Chen +2 more
published similarity 0.59
Abstract · accepted by IEEE BIBM 2026

Pathology foundation models supply strong representations for whole-slide image classification, yet the confidence attached to their predictions remains hard to trust. Prevailing uncertainty estimators act within a single feature space and thereby overlook the uncertainty that the choice of foundation-model representation itself induces. This work introduces CALIFUSE, a calibration-oriented framework that fuses several pathology foundation models for the specific purpose of uncertainty estimation. Departing from accuracy-driven fusion, CALIFUSE reads representational heterogeneity across encoders as an explicit confidence cue. Slide-level decision consensus is coupled with chunk-level evidence agreement quantified through Jensen-Shannon divergence, so that both prediction stability and fine-grained evidence consistency inform the estimate. Foundation-model encoders stay frozen. A task-specific nnMIL classifier is still trained for each FM; CALIFUSE then estimates confidence at inference without training an extra fusion module. Evaluated on seven WSI classification tasks under several foundation-model combinations, the framework sharpens calibration, misclassification detection, and selective prediction relative to both the strongest single-encoder baseline and naive ensemble averaging, all while preserving competitive balanced accuracy.

0.36