CS Paper Radar

Ancillary Services in High-Renewable Power Systems: Comparing Market Design, Emerging Trends, and Future Challenges

Andreas Makrides, Andrey Churkin, Fei Teng, Pierre Pinson

eess.SY ·submitted 2026-09-29 10:30 UTC · v1

Abstract

Rapid growth in renewable generation is changing power-system operation and increasing the importance of ancillary services for security and reliability. As inverter-based resources displace conventional synchronous generation, system operators must procure a broader set of services spanning five categories: frequency control and reserves, voltage and reactive power support, system stability, restoration, and congestion management. This paper compares ancillary-service market design in Great Britain, Germany, Denmark, Italy, California, Texas, and Australia. It examines how these systems define, procure, remunerate, and coordinate services as variable renewable generation increases. The review develops a consistent product-level classification, provides comparable timing visualisations of frequency-control and reserve products, and maps implementation modalities across services and systems. Four trends emerge: faster and more granular frequency-response products, more explicit procurement of stability capabilities including inertia, system strength, and dynamic voltage support, broader participation by storage, demand-side resources, and other inverter-based resources, and greater use of locational, targeted, and technology-neutral procurement. Challenges include limited harmonisation, incomplete valuation of flexibility and stability capabilities whose value depends on location and operating conditions, barriers to participation by distributed and emerging resources, and insufficient coordination between market and operational arrangements. The comparison finds no convergence towards a single market design and supports differentiated but coordinated ancillary-service frameworks reflecting each service's technical, temporal, and locational characteristics.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Integrating Fast-response Capability into Virtual Power Plant Operation for Ancillary Services

eess.SY ·2026-08-26 ·Qixing Liu, Ruike Lyu, Zhe Zhai, Yan Shen, Xue Liu +1 more
published similarity 0.62
Abstract · Published in: 2025 IEEE Kiel PowerTech

Virtual power plants (VPPs) can aggregate distributed energy resources (DERs) to provide ancillary services for power systems, creating new profit opportunities. Ancillary services such as secondary frequency regulation require providers to have sufficient response capability to follow rapidly changing control commands. If overlooking the response requirement, the VPP will not be able to accurately measure its regulation capability, reducing its earnings in performance-based markets or risking disqualification. This paper integrates the requirement for fast-response capability into the operational framework of VPPs providing ancillary services. We leverage historical control commands to formulate chance constraints in the bidding model, mandating that the VPP's fast-response capability meets the requirement of ancillary services with a specified probability. Case studies verify that considering fast-response capabilities can enhance VPP operation.

0.63

Frequency-Security-Aware Real-Time Economic Dispatch with Data Center UPS Flexibility for Inertia and Primary Frequency Response Services

eess.SY ·2026-11-13 ·Shengyi Wang, Liang Du
hot direction similarity 0.59
Abstract

The increasing penetration of renewable energy and the rapid growth of AI data centers are introducing significant challenges to power system frequency security. There is an urgent need to identify grid-compatible resources capable of providing fast frequency support. This paper proposes a frequency-security-aware real-time economic dispatch (RTED) model that enables data center (DC) uninterruptible power supply (UPS) systems to provide steady-state power balancing, inertia response, and primary frequency response (PFR) services. Specifically, tractable analytical frequency-security constraints are derived and incorporated into the RTED framework through second-order cone programming (SOCP) formulation. The proposed model jointly optimizes energy, reserve, and inertia to minimize system operation cost while preventing under-frequency load shedding (UFLS). Numerical validation on a modified IEEE 39-bus system demonstrates that the proposed RTED model with UPS flexibility can economically support system operation and significantly improve frequency security under active-power deficit disturbances.

0.30

Optimizing Multi-Market Participation of Battery and Electrolyser Systems Based on Field Performance

cs.LG ·2026-08-17 ·Chunyang Zhao, Stoyan Trenchev, Shi You, Chresten Træholt
published similarity 0.58
Abstract · 6 pages, 8 figures. Accepted at the 2026 IEEE Power and Energy Society General Meeting (PESGM)

The increasing share of renewable energy in power systems creates a need for fast-response and flexible resources to maintain system stability. With the expansion of electricity markets and ancillary service products, opportunities arise to stack revenues across multiple services. Long-term Power-to-X (PTX) electrolysers and short-term battery energy storage systems (BESS) are prevalent flexible resources, yet most studies neglect real hardware behavior, such as ramp limits, efficiency, and setpoint-tracking accuracy. This work presents experimental and modeling results for a 55 kW/79 kWh BESS and an electrolyser comprising three 2.4 kW units. Key characteristics are identified through measurements and embedded into a price-driven optimization framework for participation in the Danish electricity and ancillary service markets, utilizing real market data from 2022 to 2025. The optimized daily profits for multi-market participation are 1,749.27 DKK and 289.46 DKK for the BESS and electrolyser, respectively. With the demonstrated business cases for BESS and PTX systems, this work highlights the importance of incorporating experimental performance when evaluating participation across multiple markets and years.

0.38

Dynamic and Risk-Aware Procurement of Fast Frequency Response from Electric Vehicles and Heat Pumps

eess.SY ·2026-11-18 ·Savvas Panagi, Fanourios Kourougianni, Andreas Olympios, Chrysovalantis Spanias, Petros Aristidou
similarity 0.57
Abstract

Low-inertia power systems increasingly rely on Fast Frequency Response (FFR) to keep the frequency nadir above under-frequency load-shedding thresholds without oversized Frequency Containment Reserve or synchronous inertia. This paper proposes two complementary methodologies that interface with an existing day-ahead FFR capacity market. On the Transmission System Operator (TSO) side, a dynamic procurement rule maps forecasted kinetic energy and contingency magnitude onto an offline neighborhood-need surface, yielding interval-wise FFR capacity requests rather than constant seasonal or annual volumes. On the aggregator side, a risk-aware, TSO-certifiable bidding strategy quantifies reliable FFR capacity from fleets of electric vehicles (EVs) and heat pumps (HPs) by offering lower conditional quantiles of day-ahead headroom at a prescribed delivery reliability. The resulting requests and offers are cleared through a pay-as-bid capacity auction. A Cyprus 2025 case study shows that dynamic neighborhood-based procurement yields an annual clearing cost of about EUR 476,000, which is 30%-33% lower than the seasonal and annual static rules and also below the UFLS VoLL of EUR 637,500 estimated from the fifteen real 2025 events with fmin <= 49 Hz. EV and HP offers meet their target delivery reliabilities, and RMS validation finds 46 of 50 operating points above 49 Hz at both full and 85% FFR delivery.

0.25

Optimal Coordination of Multiple Ancillary Service Provisions in Active Distribution Networks

eess.SY ·2026-11-14 ·Xinbao Jia, Yi Guo, Ognjen Stanojev, Zhen Chen, Yuning Jiang +1 more
similarity 0.57
Abstract · 16 pages

We propose a multi-rate model predictive control (MPC) framework for coordinating primary frequency control (PFC), automatic generation control (AGC), and voltage control (VC) in active distribution networks. The framework allocates distributed energy resource (DER) flexibility among these three ancillary services while retaining their different update rates. To account for the intertemporal flexibility of electric vehicle aggregations and aggregations of buildings with thermostatically controlled loads (TCLs), we incorporate time-varying power-energy envelopes into our multi-rate MPC formulation. These constraints couple the combined PFC and AGC response to the demand-side flexibility available later in the prediction horizon. Furthermore, the input-multirate structure enables coordinated ancillary service provision by DERs with different response dynamics. The controller optimizes the three services together, allowing fast regulation to be coordinated with the developing slow response within the available DER flexibility. We demonstrate the coordinated provision of the three ancillary services through closed-loop simulations on a modified IEEE 33-bus system using a nonlinear differential-algebraic model.

0.25

Degradation-Aware Participation of Battery Storage in Frequency Regulation Markets

eess.SY math.OC ·2026-11-09 ·Anand Gokhale, Siddharth Bhela
hot direction similarity 0.56
Abstract · Extended version of IEEE PESGM submission

As data centers make the load on the power grid fluctuate faster, frequency regulation grows more valuable. Battery energy storage systems (BESSs) are well suited to provide frequency regulation, but providing this service speeds up aging, especially during operation at extreme state of charge (SoC). In the PJM interconnection, the grid operator supplies a regulation signal that a participating BESS is expected to follow, within a capacity that it must bid before the signal is known. Accordingly, we decompose the degradation-aware frequency regulation problem into a bidding layer and an operations layer. For bidding, we propose an adaptive strategy, assuming perfect tracking in which the bid depends on the SoC expected at the start of the bid period by means of choosing basepoints. For operation, the BESS further protects its battery by deliberately giving up a perfect performance score, to keep its SoC away from the extremes. On the PJM regulation signal and prices of 2023, adaptive bids lengthen the battery life by $31\%$ against bidding full capacity, for $2.2\%$ of the revenue. Giving up a perfect score in operation lengthens the battery life of constant bids by $10\%$ to $27\%$, at a change in revenue of at most $0.2\%$.

0.30

Resource-Aware Rolling-Horizon Controller for Renewable-Based Virtual Power Plants Providing Automatic Frequency Restoration Reserves

eess.SY ·2026-09-25 ·Marco Vinicio Avendaño-Caiza, Juan Diego Rios-Peñaloza, Javier Roldán-Pérez, José Luis Rodríguez-Amenedo, Milan Prodanovic
similarity 0.56
Abstract · Submitted to a scientific journal for possible publication. 10 pages, 11 figures

Virtual power plants (VPPs) are an effective solution for increasing the penetration of renewable energy sources (RES) in power systems. Moreover, VPPs can provide ancillary services if generators and loads are closely connected and properly coordinated. This aspect has been addressed in several studies, yet they mostly focus on the dispatch optimisation level, leaving real-time operation aspects unresolved. To close this gap, a central controller for VPPs based on a rolling-horizon optimisation is proposed in this work. Its main objective is to maximise revenues while delivering frequency restoration services. A day-ahead optimisation firstly defines the power setpoint and the upward and downward reserves of the VPP. Then, the rolling-horizon optimiser, executed every minute, distributes the power and reserve references between the VPP units to achieve their close tracking while taking into account resource availability (wind speed, irradiance, etc.), operational constraints and battery degradation. The effectiveness of the controller is tested using a two-area interconnected power system under different RES generation and demand profiles. The simulations are performed in MATLAB/Simulink and include detailed dynamic models of the VPP elements, demonstrating the applicability of the algorithm to real systems. The day-ahead and the rolling-horizon optimisation problems are modelled using YALMIP and solved using Gurobi. The obtained results demonstrate the VPP supporting grid frequency restoration by optimally allocating its resources, even under the presence of forecast uncertainty.

0.18

Report on Stability Analysis of Islanded Power Systems with Grid-Forming Converters

eess.SY ·2026-10-30 ·Anup Joshi, Luis A. Garcia-Reyes, Qingyuan Gong, Xavier Guillaud, Javier Renedo +1 more
published similarity 0.56
Abstract · Danmarks Tekniske Universitetet, Katholieke Universiteit Leuven, Department of Electrical Engineering, Electrical Energy Computer Architectu…

Islanded power systems are inherently challenging to operate due to limited interconnection, low inertia, and weak short-circuit strength. As renewable and inverter-based resources replace synchronous machines, these challenges worsen, causing faster frequency deviations, greater voltage volatility, and higher risk of instability. This report summarizes the differences between islanded and interconnected systems and reviews key stability issues in islanded grids: frequency stability, converter-driven interactions, voltage stability, large-disturbance behavior, and small-signal dynamics. Grid-forming (GFM) voltage source converters are a promising solution because they can establish voltage and frequency, emulate synchronous machine behavior, and provide grid strength, virtual inertia, fast frequency response, voltage regulation, and black-start capability. The report examines relevant GFM control strategies and evaluates their capabilities in weak, low-inertia islanded grids. Challenges remain, particularly interoperability, control coordination among multiple inverter-based resources, lack of standardized grid code requirements, and coordination of protection devices. Successful deployment requires advances in interoperability, harmonized grid codes, and grid planning that considers the unique features of islanded systems, along with clear GFM functionality requirements. Finally, a case study illustrates the stability-enhancing capability of GFM converters in weak grids through small-signal stability analysis. Overall, GFM technology is a key enabler of reliable, renewable-dominant island power systems, but broader adoption depends on continued technical and regulatory development.

0.36