CS Paper Radar

Frequency Measurement Practices for Inertia Assessment in Inverter Based Resources Dominated Power Systems

Christos M. Nikolakakos, Hassan Haes Alhelou, Nikos Hatziargyriou

eess.SY ·submitted 2026-09-28 08:01 UTC · v1

Abstract

Transmission system operators and protective relays compute the rate of change of frequency (RoCoF) from frequency averaged over tens to hundreds of milliseconds, as standards and grid codes specify. Any response delivered inside that window lowers the measured RoCoF, so the inferred inertia depends on the window and the responses in service. This paper defines the windowed inertia estimate and derives an exact identity the system inertia divided by one minus the fraction of the disturbance energy delivered inside the window and a closed-form prediction that applies the same estimator to the trajectory of a linear response model. Eleven IEEE 9-bus RMS runs synchronous, grid-following and grid-forming configurations, disturbance sizes and parameter sweeps are reproduced by that model, and the identity closes on the measured response powers. Fast frequency response inflates the estimate most: at 500 ms a grid-following system with 20 % less synchronous inertia reports the same value as the all-synchronous system, the grid-forming system a higher one. On a reduced Greek transmission system the 500ms estimate exceeds the inertia by 17-26%, and a scenario with 10% less synchronous inertia reports more than the all-synchronous scenario's inertia. Operators can thus compute what their measurement reports.

Comment
Under Review in IEEE Transactions on Power Systems

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Beyond Scalar Inertia: Frequency-Response-Based Assessment of Finite-Duration Inertial Support in Grid-Forming Converters

eess.SY ·2026-11-13 ·Ziqi Zhou, Mahdieh S. Sadabadi, Sante Pugliese, Xiaoqiang Li, Xiaojie Wu +1 more
hot direction similarity 0.71
Abstract · This paper has 6 pages with 5 figures. The target journal will be determined at a later stage

Conventional scalar inertia characterizes only the low-frequency terminal behavior of grid-forming converters (GFMs) and cannot fully predict inertial energy delivery during short-duration frequency disturbances. This letter proposes a frequency-response-based method to assess finite-duration inertial support using complex terminal power--frequency responses, such as those provided by Network Frequency Perturbation (NFP) plots. For GFMs with nonzero steady-state droop, a duration-dependent energy-equivalent inertia is defined after subtracting the ideal static-droop contribution. An exact spectral relationship is established, expressing this metric as a duration-weighted integral of frequency-dependent inertia, without requiring knowledge of the internal controller structure and parameters. The duration dependence of the metric is further shown to encode observable oscillation frequencies and damping ratios. A coefficient-decoupling GFM control with identical scalar inertia and droop across different settings is used for verification.

0.27

On the Achievable Inertia Constant of Inverter Based Resources

eess.SY ·2026-09-28 ·Christos M. Nikolakakos, Hassan Haes Alhelou, Nikos Hatziargyriou
similarity 0.63
Abstract · Under Review in IEEE Transactions on Power Systems

As inverter-based resources (IBRs) displace synchronous generators, the inertia they can actually contribute to the grid becomes a critical planning parameter. Unlike synchronous machines, this contribution is bounded simultaneously by the available energy reserve, the converter power rating combined with voltage ride-through (VRT) obligations, and the inertia-emulation control scheme with its activation delay. This paper derives each bound in closed form and combines them into a unified envelope $\Heff(t,λ,V_g)=\min(\HE,\HP,\HC)$, which uses parameters accessible to the system operator to quantify how much inertia a plant can provide at a given loading $λ$, grid voltage $V_g$, and time $t$ after a disturbance. The analysis shows that below a loading-dependent critical voltage, VRT reactive-current priority does not leave active-current headroom for inertial power injection; that the converter overload ratio $κ$ matters mainly during voltage dips; and that de-loading yields a linear, quantifiable inertia gain, while collocated energy storage (ESS) removes the source-coupling constraint, making grid-following (GFL) and grid-forming (GFM) plants with storage equivalent post-activation, up to the GFL activation-delay discount within short RoCoF measurement windows. Simulations on the IEEE 9-bus system confirm the framework and motivate a two-dimensional inertia capability curve $H(λ,V_{g,\min})$ as a grid-code instrument analogous to the P--Q diagram of synchronous generators.

0.28

Quantifying Power to Voltage and Frequency Dynamics for Oscillation Propagation Assessment

eess.SY ·2026-09-03 ·Onur Alican, Dionysios Moutevelis, Marc Cheah-Mañe, Oriol Gomis-Bellmunt, Eduardo Prieto-Araujo
benchmark similarity 0.62
Abstract

The integration of Inverter-Based Resources (IBRs) into power systems introduces multi-timescale dynamics and oscillations which may propagate to distant areas and endanger the safe system operation. These oscillations pose a significant challenge as their source, frequency, and propagation pathways are often challenging to identify in large interconnected systems, comprising numerous synchronous machines and IBRs. For the above reasons, analytical tools that identify the sensitivity of the system to oscillations within a large frequency spectrum, affecting both voltage and frequency variables across various network locations, are of interest. This paper addresses this topic by introducing a frequency-domain framework based on linear analysis, which characterizes the sensitivity to oscillations of each network bus voltage and of each generation unit frequency. Within this framework, two quantitative indicators are proposed, namely the Frequency Sensitivity Index (FSI) and Voltage Sensitivity Index (VSI). These indexes are derived analytically from the transfer functions which relate the active and reactive power injections to each bus with the voltage and frequency variables across the network, derived from the linear Electromagnetic Transient (EMT) power system model. The proposed indices quantify the sensitivity of the system to oscillations of different type and frequency, providing insights for both oscillation detection and propagation analysis. The methodology is applied to a case study based on the modified IEEE 68-bus benchmark system under partial and full IBR penetration, while its accuracy is validated through EMT time-domain simulations using linear and nonlinear models developed in Matlab/Simulink environment.

0.28

Measurement-Based Assessment of Decadal Inertia and Primary Frequency Response Trends in the US Eastern Interconnection

eess.SY ·2026-10-30 ·Saurav Dulal, Mark Baldwin, Narges Ghiasi, Mohammed Olama, Ali R. Ekti +2 more
similarity 0.62
Abstract · Presented in CIGRE 2026 Grid of the Future Symposium.The paper has 12 pages and 6 figures in total

Changes in the generation mix of the U.S. Eastern Interconnection (EI) raise questions about long-term frequency performance, particularly inertia and primary frequency response (PFR). This paper jointly examines these characteristics using synchronized FNET/GridEye frequency measurements and confirmed generation-trip events from 2013 to 2025. A representative EI frequency trajectory is constructed using the median of geographically distributed measurements. Effective inertia is estimated quarterly from the early post-disturbance rate of change of frequency (RoCoF), using a 3-second window and least-squares fitting. PFR is evaluated using the beta metric, which measures aggregate frequency response from disturbance size and the A-to-B frequency deviation. Annual beta estimates are obtained after filtering events by starting frequency and disturbance size to improve comparability across years. Results show that EI effective inertia varies seasonally and follows a non-monotonic trend rather than a uniform long-term decline. Over the same period, coal generation decreased while natural gas, wind, and solar generation increased. Changes in synchronous generator commitment and operating conditions may have offset some expected inertia reductions. Filtered beta generally increased from the mid-2010s to the early 2020s, with year-to-year variability thereafter. The different trends show that early inertial behavior and broader aggregate frequency response have not evolved in parallel. Joint analysis of inertia and beta offers a more complete measurement-based assessment of EI frequency performance during the generation transition.

0.30

AGI: Agility Index for Power Systems Dynamic Performance, Inspired by Reynolds Number

eess.SY ·2026-11-13 ·Maria Vabson, Amir Sajadi, Bri-Mathias Hodge
similarity 0.61
Abstract

Multiple established metrics and indices exist to quantify the dynamic performance of power systems. With the growth of inverter based resources, these mostly conventional metrics and indices may not encompass all important elements and variables that hold information about the grid performance, especially the damping properties. This paper proposes the Agility Index (AGI), which is a Reynolds number-inspired metric for power system dynamics relating the ratio of inertia to damping. With the current trends towards high-power inverter assets and reduced-inertia grids, explicit attention is necessary in monitoring inertia and damping together. This paper shares insights the AGI presents about the dynamic performance of power systems.

0.28

Comparative Assessment of Frequency Scans using EMT and RMS Models

eess.SY ·2026-08-27 ·Clea Bürgel, Gustavo Valverde, Gabriela Hug
similarity 0.61
Abstract

Frequency scans of inverter and grid impedances are crucial for assessing small-signal stability and system strength in inverter-dominated power systems. This paper compares frequency-scan results for several generating units, including a synchronous generator, grid-following, and grid-forming inverters, using fully dq electromagnetic transient and root-mean-square (RMS) models in Simulink. The scans are performed for the same device rating and operating point. Frequency scans and time-domain simulations show that the RMS models are valid only at low frequencies. We find that the current-controlled grid-forming inverter is more difficult to represent in RMS than the voltage-controlled grid-forming inverter. However, including the inner voltage-control loops improves the accuracy of the RMS representation. The paper also investigates the influence of generator and grid impedance on the total system impedance seen from the point of common coupling and relates the oscillatory modes and zeros of the system to peaks and dips in the first and second singular values of the system impedance, respectively.

0.22

Impact of Grid-Forming Inverter Placement and Penetration on Local and Aggregate Frequency

eess.SY ·2026-11-13 ·Fatma Alfailkawi, Marena Trujillo, Bri-Mathias Hodge
similarity 0.59
Abstract

Modern power systems are undergoing a huge shift in generation mix, including inverter-based resources that are fundamentally changing the stability dynamics of the grid. Thus, synchronous Generators (SG) are gradually being displaced by Grid-forming inverters (GFM) that are proposed as a solution to continue supporting grid stability. However, the effect of GFM placement in the network on frequency performance and how well aggregate-frequency assessment captures placement sensitivity observed in local frequency metrics remains unclear. This paper evaluates all SG and droop-controlled GFM assignments in the IEEE 39-bus system. A reduced-order model is used for the exhaustive search with load disturbances applied separately at every eligible load bus while considering nadir and Rate of Change of Frequency (RoCoF) derived from both device rating weighted aggregate frequency and local bus frequencies. Results reveal that at fixed GFM penetration, placement produced up to 104 mHz variation in worst-case local nadir and 0.21 Hz/s in maximum local RoCoF. Aggregate-frequency assessment reduced the apparent across placements by 89\% for nadir and 88\% for RoCoF at 50\% GFM penetration. These results indicate that aggregate-frequency assessment alone may obscure favorable or adverse placement effects on local frequency performance.

0.28

Enhancing Transient Stability of VSG-Controlled Converters Under Grid Frequency Disturbances

eess.SY ·2026-11-13 ·B. Li, Y. Zhang, X. Wang, S. Yang, Z. Hao +1 more
similarity 0.57
Abstract

Strong damping feedback can substantially improve the transient synchronization stability of renewable energy converters employing virtual synchronous generator (VSG) control. However, conventional damping feedback uses the nominal frequency as its reference. When the frequency of a weak grid deviates from nominal, strong damping tends to keep the VSG frequency near nominal. This can sustain a frequency difference between the VSG and the grid and compromise transient synchronization. To address this problem, this paper proposes a complex-frequency-based method to estimate the grid reference frequency from local terminal measurements. The estimated frequency replaces the nominal reference in the VSG synchronization loop, so that damping acts on the frequency difference between the VSG and the real grid. Controller hardware-in-the-loop tests validate the effectiveness of the proposed method under grid frequency disturbances and its robustness to grid parameter uncertainty and adverse grid conditions.

0.26