CS Paper Radar

Impact of Reduced-Order Modelling on Sum-of-Squares Region-of-Attraction Certification for Grid-Forming and Grid-Following Converters

Chenxi Yuan, Jeremy D. Watson, Neville R. Watson

eess.SY math.OC ·submitted 2026-11-10 03:08 UTC · v1

Abstract

With the increasing penetration of power-electronic equipment, the transient stability of grid-forming (GFM) and grid-following (GFL) converters is increasingly characterized through the region of attraction (ROA) of the post-fault equilibrium. Sum-of-squares (SOS) programming yields certified inner approximations of the ROA, yet its computational cost grows rapidly with system order. Reduced-order models are therefore widely used to reduce computational cost and, more importantly, to enable analytical investigation. However, ROA analyses based on these models often assume that reproducing the converter's transient response, or retaining more dynamics in the correct time-frame, is sufficient to preserve the ROA of the full-order system. Using time-domain ODE simulations as a reference, the SOS-based ROA of each reduced-order GFM and GFL model is assessed against both its own simulated ROA and that of the corresponding full-order model, thereby separating SOS-induced conservativeness from model-order-induced ROA distortion. The results indicate that increasing reduced-order model complexity does not necessarily improve SOS-based ROA fidelity. In the cases examined, more complex reduced-order models yield lower SOS coverage of the full-order reference ROA, despite closer ODE-boundary agreement in some regions. Model selection should therefore consider both full-order ROA fidelity and certified coverage of the practical operating range, rather than model complexity alone.

Comment
13 pages, 5 figures, 3 tables

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

An Analytical Review of Model Order Reduction Methodologies of Converter-Dominated Power Systems for Stability Studies

eess.SY ·2026-10-02 ·Goran Grdenić, Marco Fraccaro, Josipa-Pina Milišić
similarity 0.62
Abstract · 53 pages, 4 figures

The rapid integration of renewable energy sources is transforming modern electric power systems into converter-dominated networks characterized by complex multi-timescale dynamics and new stability interactions over a wide frequency range. Accurate analysis of these phenomena requires high-fidelity models of transmission networks and power electronic converters, which often result in large-scale differential-algebraic systems with significant computational burden. This paper provides an analytical review of model order reduction techniques for converter-rich power systems, with particular emphasis on the key equations employed in the reduction process. Advantages and limitations of commonly used strategies, including timescale-based singular perturbation, projection-based, operator-based, data-driven, and machine-learning based methods, are discussed. The synthesis highlights key challenges related to harmonic interactions and multi-frequency dynamics, and outlines directions for the development of computationally efficient yet dynamically accurate reduced-order models for future power systems.

0.29

Limitations of RMS-based Stability Assessment of Converter-based Grids: A Case Study

eess.SY ·2026-08-19 ·Pol Jane-Soneira, Ognjen Stanojev, Francisco Canales Perez, Qian Long, Mario Schweizer +1 more
similarity 0.60
Abstract

The increasing penetration of power electronic converters in industrial grids introduces stability challenges at frequencies well above the electromechanical range of traditional power systems. Commercial software tools typically perform eigenvalue-based stability analysis using root-mean-square (RMS) models that assume a quasi-stationary network, thereby neglecting electromagnetic dynamics of assets --- which is standard practice in power system analysis. This paper presents a case study of an industrial grid where the conventional RMS-based eigenvalue analysis predicts stable operation, while a detailed electromagnetic transient (EMT) simulation reveals growing oscillations, indicating instability. To bridge this gap, we introduce an alternative modeling approach that formulates the network dynamics in the rotating $dq$ reference frame, retaining the differential equations of electromagnetic dynamics. The resulting model enables eigenvalue analysis that correctly identifies the unstable modes, consistent with the EMT simulation results. Our findings highlight a fundamental limitation of RMS-based stability assessment for converter-dominated grids and demonstrate that dynamic impedance models in the dq frame provide a viable path toward accurate small-signal analysis encompassing high-frequency converter-network interactions.

0.32

Modular Model Order Reduction for Inverter-Based Power Systems with Stability and Accuracy Guarantees

eess.SY ·2026-10-01 ·Hanqing Zhang, Pudong Ge, Mohammad Fahim Shakib, Adrià Junyent-Ferré, Balarko Chaudhuri +3 more
similarity 0.60
Abstract · 10 pages, submitted to IEEE Transactions on Power Systems

This paper proposes a modular model order reduction framework for large-scale power grids integrated with renewable energy sources. The proposed framework has the advantage of reducing individual sub-areas independently while retaining the power grid interconnection structure. Moreover, given a user-defined accuracy specification on the overall reduced-order interconnected power grid, corresponding target specifications for the individual reduced sub-areas are determined: satisfaction of such individual specifications guarantees the overall user-defined accuracy specification, while also preserving the stability of the overall reduced-order interconnected power grid. The proposed framework is validated on a modified IEEE 118-bus system (where synchronous generators have been replaced by inverter-based resources) by assessing the accuracy specification satisfaction of the overall reduced-order interconnected power grid, in terms of frequency response, stability, active power, and sub-synchronous behaviour when injected with disturbances.

0.33

Impedance-Based Sensitivity Analysis for Stability Enhancement of LCC-HVDC Links Connected to Weak Grids Using Grid-Forming Converters

eess.SY ·2026-09-09 ·Luis A. Garcia-Reyes, Anup Joshi, Javier Renedo, Macarena Martin-Almenta, Oriol Gomis-Bellmunt +3 more
benchmark similarity 0.58
Abstract · Best Paper Award in the 2026 5th IEEE International Conference on Power Systems and Electrical Technology

This paper presents a frequency-domain, impedance-based sensitivity methodology for stability assessment and enhancement of line-commutated converter HVDC (LCC-HVDC) links operating under weak-grid conditions. The methodology integrates frequency-domain identification tailored for black-box systems, the Generalized Nyquist Criterion (GNC) for multivariable stability assessment, and modal impedance decomposition with participation-factor analysis to locate and interpret interaction mechanisms. The approach is validated against a detailed linearized state-space model and nonlinear EMT simulations of an LCC-HVDC benchmark. A sensitivity study varying the grid short-circuit ratio (SCR) reveals a stability limit for the standalone LCC-HVDC link and demonstrates that the integration of a grid-forming voltage source converter (GFM-VSC) substantially increases the stability margin.

0.20

Equivalent Modeling of Load-Side Systems With Distributed Renewable Generation Considering Fault Responses and Nodal Voltage Coherence

eess.SY ·2026-09-21 ·Yuqi Cao, Chen Shen, Shaowei Huang, Ying Chen, Hongyi Zhu
similarity 0.58
Abstract · Submitted to IEEE Transactions on Power Systems

Operating conditions and fault severity change both the initial states and control modes of active distribution networks. Direct capacity aggregation can therefore lose the power responses required for transmission-system dynamic analysis. This paper develops a procedure for generating low-order physical electromagnetic transient equivalents from a small set of representative operating conditions. Device power, ride-through states, load mechanical states, and local sequence voltages are combined with electrical distance to form response families. Response reconstruction and terminal simulation errors determine the retained architecture, after which bounded sensitivity calculations determine effective dynamic coefficients. The architecture and coefficients are then fixed. For a new operating condition, capacity and power balances, voltage-dependent load relations, and an initialization correction generate the model parameters from static inputs and power-flow results. A representative severe fault establishes a template for each fault type, which is reused across fault depths. Aggregation and switching-time bounds explain the roles of voltage coherence and state separation. Comparisons with direct aggregation show improved terminal responses across operating conditions and several fault types, with the largest gains under severe unbalanced faults. The method provides a reusable physical equivalent for operating-condition studies and fault-depth screening.

0.17

Relative-Degree Wall Restricts Passivity-Based Stability Analysis in Inverter-Dominant Grids

eess.SY ·2026-08-30 ·Xiaoyu Peng, Zhongze Li, Xi Ru, Xinghua Chen, Feng Liu
top venue similarity 0.57
Abstract

This letter reveals a fundamental limitation of passivity-based distributed stability analysis in power systems. Under the standard formulation, passivity certification inherently imposes a relative-degree compatibility constraint that excludes many high-fidelity inverter dynamic models (e.g., those that include electromagnetic transients). Potential extensions of passivity frameworks are discussed to break this limitation.

0.43

An Energy-Based Framework for Transient Stability of Grid-Forming Converter Networks With Current Limiting

eess.SY ·2026-09-29 ·Wei Zhou, Yunjie Gu
similarity 0.57
Abstract · 10 pages, 6 figures

Existing analyses for the transient stability of grid-forming (GFM) converters under current limiting mainly address single-converter systems, while network-level transient stability analysis remains challenging. This paper develops a network energy construction that incorporates current limiting while retaining a provable dissipation property. This structure enables Lyapunov-based analysis consistent with classical direct method for synchronous-machine based systems, without switching between mode-dependent energy functions. A two-GFM example using a reactive circular current limiter and impedance insertion illustrates the proposed framework. Electromagnetic transient simulations support the theoretical results.

0.25

Impacts of Heterogeneous Grid-Forming Devices on Power System Dynamics Quantified by DW Shells

eess.SY ·2026-08-22 ·Liangxiao Luo, Linbin Huang, Hangyu Chen, Ruohan Leng, Zhixian Hou +2 more
similarity 0.56
Abstract

The concept of grid-forming (GFM) converters has gained great attention in the past years. However, it remains challenging to analyze and quantify the impacts of heterogeneous GFM devices (e.g., GFM energy storage systems, GFM wind turbines, GFM HVDC stations) on power system dynamics, especially when taking into account the complex interaction between GFM converters and grid-following (GFL) converters. To this end, this paper focuses on the decentralized and scalable stability analysis of power systems containing both GFM and GFL converters, where we use Davis-Wielandt (DW) shells to characterize the dynamics of the converters and the power grid. In particular, we analytically derive how integrating heterogeneous GFM converters affects the DW shell of the power grid and therefore the system stability. Our approach does not require the detailed parameters or control schemes of the GFM converters; instead, we define the local passivity and imaginary-axis indices of GFM converters to compactly describe their characteristics. These two indices can be conveniently obtained by testing a GFM converter and greatly simplify the stability analysis and computation when handling large-scale power systems.

0.29