CS Paper Radar

Adjacent Heat Transfer Effects Can Bias Savings Estimates When Controlling Only Part of a Multi-Zone Building

Arash J. Khabbazi, Kevin J. Kircher

eess.SY ·submitted 2026-11-12 14:37 UTC · v1
publishedtheory

Abstract

Field demonstrations of advanced heating, ventilation, and air-conditioning control often operate a few thermal zones within a larger building and report savings for those zones alone. A recent theorem showed that this practice overestimates whole-building savings, because heat drawn from the neighboring zones is paid for by their equipment and is not counted. The error grows with the thermal conductance between the controlled and uncontrolled zones, with how much colder the controlled zones run over the test, and with the price of the heat their neighbors supply. For one controlled zone with one neighbor, a single thermal price, and slowly changing prices, the relative error reduces to the ratio of two conductances, a screening number that can be evaluated from the two conductances before a demonstration begins. This paper tests how far that reduction can be taken. A two-story house with one thermal zone per floor is simulated over a 90-day heating season in West Lafayette, Indiana, with receding-horizon model predictive control on the first floor and setpoint control on the second, under four combinations of electricity tariff (time-of-use or flat) and heating plant (heat pump or electric resistance). The exact correction from the theorem recovers the true savings in every case, and the full theorem, evaluated from the controlled zone's temperatures, the prices, and the building parameters, reproduces the measured relative error in every case. The conductance ratio bounds that error from above in all four cases, tightly under a flat tariff, within 3%, and loosely under a time-of-use tariff, where most of the controller's savings come from shifting load through the thermal mass rather than from lowering the temperature.

Comment
10 pages. Accepted at the 2027 ASHRAE Winter Conference

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

Data-driven estimation of design heating loads for HVAC equipment sizing

eess.SY ·2026-09-07 ·Alex H. Lee, Elias N. Pergantis, Kevin J. Kircher
similarity 0.66
Abstract

Oversized heating and cooling equipment can unnecessarily increase up-front costs, energy costs, pollutant emissions, and strain on electrical infrastructure. This paper develops two data-driven methods for estimating heating loads at design conditions to improve equipment sizing. One method uses smart thermostat data; the other uses utility bills. We test the methods on a dataset that we gathered from 74 detached single-family houses in five United States climate zones. The dataset includes smart thermostat time-series data, monthly utility bills, weather data, existing equipment specifications, and Manual J design load calculations (the United States industry standard) purchased from practitioners. The two methods have strong goodness-of-fit statistics individually and show fair agreement with each other. On average over the 74 houses, existing heating equipment is 2.75 (2.5th to 97.5th empirical percentile: 1.34-6.52) times larger than the thermostat-method estimate and 2.96 (1.36-7.76 times larger than the bill-method estimate. As implemented by practitioners, the Manual J estimate is 2.26 (0.87-5.21) times larger on average than the thermostat-method estimate and 2.35 (1.02-5.28) times larger than the bill-method estimate. We discuss prospects for implementing the data-driven methods at scale and for incorporating data-driven sizing into industry standards.

0.26

The one-step surface-air lag in the EnergyPlus zone heat balance: order of accuracy, correction and consequences

cs.CE ·2026-11-07 ·Wooyoung Jung
unusual similarity 0.62
Abstract · 24 pages, 7 figures, 10 tables. HUBS Lab Paper No. 2026-010. Code and data: doi:10.5281/zenodo.24041718

The order of accuracy sets how fast numerical error falls as the timestep shortens. This study measured that order for the zone heat balance of EnergyPlus 26.2 against exact or converged references and tested a correction on 45 U.S. Department of Energy prototype cases. All three zone air formulas, the third-order default included, give first order or lower, because the surfaces use the previous timestep's air temperature. Solving surfaces, air and HVAC to agreement within each timestep raises the default to about second order, and in a room with an exact solution two extra passes cut the error eightfold at 1.65 times the runtime. In the prototype cases, the correction changed annual site energy by at most 0.45% but an outpatient clinic's heating by 5.1%. Window-upgrade savings changed by 10% or more in 13 of the 34 applicable cases, about as often as under a change of timestep.

0.31

User-specified Kelvin-hour budgets within model predictive control for energy-efficient buildings: Simulation and field demonstration

eess.SY ·2026-09-06 ·Jicheng Shi, Colin N. Jones
similarity 0.61
Abstract

For energy-efficient building control, model predictive control (MPC) has been widely proposed to reduce energy use while maintaining prescribed indoor temperature bounds. In practice, MPC implementations may still produce temperature-bound violations because of model mismatch, weather-forecast errors, and softened constraints introduced to preserve feasibility. Existing soft- constrained MPC usually handles this trade-off through slack-weight tuning, so users cannot prescribe a violation-severity budget before operation. This paper develops a Kelvin-hour (Kh)-budget MPC that allows users to specify a running-average budget for temperature-bound violation severity. During operation, the controller uses the realized Kh budget surplus or overspend to update the temperature bounds, providing step-by-step budget feedback. We evaluate the method in two high-fidelity BOPTEST simulation cases and in an occupied residential deployment. In the first one-zone case, prescribed budgets produce clear running-average Kh violation responses across predictors and disturbance settings. At a prescribed budget of 0.005 Kh/step, the controller reduces energy use by 31.9% and Kh violation by 36.2% relative to the built-in default controller. In the second coupled two-zone case, separate zone budgets produce zone-level responses, with 18.9%-20.5% energy reduction and 9.4%-64.3% zone-level Kh violation reduction. In the occupied residential deployment, the running-average Kh violations remain close to or below their prescribed budgets under real sensing, actuation, weather, and occupancy conditions.

0.27

Model-Free Control for Residential Heating: Deployment and Simulation of Nonlinear Data-Enabled Predictive Control

eess.SY math.OC ·2026-09-18 ·Sebastian Zieglmeier, Chris Verhoek, Jaap Eising, Mathias Hudoba de Badyn
similarity 0.60
Abstract · 19 pages, 8 figures, 7 tables

Residential heating accounts for a large share of building energy use, and predictive control strategies can reduce it by anticipating rather than reacting to the room temperature alone. The usual manner of implementing predictive control, model predictive control (MPC), requires an accurate model of each individual residential unit for heating control. Obtaining this model is time-consuming to obtain manually or even impossible, and such models do not transfer across a heterogeneous building stock. Data-enabled predictive control (DeePC) removes this modeling step by designing the controller directly using measured trajectories of the system. The foundations of DeePC, however, are built on the class of deterministic linear time-invariant systems, which is an unrealistic assumption for residential heating. This work applies three recently proposed nonlinear extensions of DeePC, collectively referred to as data-driven predictive control (DPC): Select-DPC, gain-scheduling DPC, and linear parameter-varying DPC. These are compared against standard DeePC and the hysteresis controller, the industry standard in residential heating. The comparison runs over a full heating season on a calibrated digital twin of an occupied research unit, the NEST research building in Switzerland, assessed by heating energy and comfort-band violation. Moreover, gain-scheduling DPC was deployed on the real residential apartment and validated the conclusions from the simulations. Each of the DPC controllers consumes significantly less energy than the hysteresis controller, amounting to roughly $11\%$ over the season, validating the use of DPC. The nonlinear methods further outperform linear DeePC in all assessed scenarios, and we analyze the relative costs and benefits of each nonlinear method.

0.40

Carbon reductions through optimized solar heat gain glass properties considering future climate and grid emissions: case study of Chicago's residential buildings

cs.CE ·2026-08-14 ·Yiwei Lyu, Jialiang Xiang, Holly Samuelson
publishedhighly cited similarity 0.60
Abstract · 19 pages, 10 figures. Published in Energy and Buildings 327 (2025) 115080

Existing resources leave confusion over the benefits of high versus low Solar Heat Gain Coefficient (SHGC) windows for energy performance in residential buildings retrofits in cold climates. Additionally, few studies have considered the impact of expected future climate conditions and time-variable grid emission rates on energy-related metrics. Utilizing the ResStock, residential building stock models from the National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL), this study investigates retrofits increasing the SHGC of windows in Chicago, a cold US city. The results indicate that increasing window SHGC increases summer cooling needs; however, in most cases, this effect is more than offset by reduced winter heating needs. This balance is particularly beneficial considering the state's expected long-run marginal carbon emission rates. The study also examines the combined effects of high SHGC with improved window insulation values, demonstrating that such strategic window retrofits not only enhance overall building energy performance but also contribute to greater emission reductions. On average, the current Chicago residences (n = 4,826) save 4.6 % on heating and cooling carbon emissions by increasing the SHGC of the windows. If we assume that those homes are upgraded with heat pumps (electrification), a popular retrofit that reduces heating-related carbon emissions in particular, the increased window SHGC saves 2.5 % of long-run marginal carbon emissions. These results provide new insight into the carbon benefits of higher SHGC replacement windows in a cold climate. The benefits are significant, even considering future trends of a warming climate, higher demand grid emissions, and building electrification.

0.68

Model Predictive Control for Dynamic Hydraulic Balancing in Building Radiator Heating Systems: Modeling, Design, and Experimental Validation

eess.SY math.OC ·2026-09-08 ·Erfan Shakhesi, Maurice Heemels, Paula Chanfreut
similarity 0.58
Abstract

Hydronic radiator systems are among the most widely used heating systems in buildings. In the literature, radiator heat outputs are often assumed to be independent of one another and arbitrarily adjustable in time when designing controllers. However, in practice, radiators are supplied by one or multiple common heat sources and are hydraulically coupled through the water circulation system. Maintaining occupant comfort in multi-zone buildings therefore requires not only an appropriate supply temperature but also proper hydraulic balancing to distribute the available water flow according to the heating demand of each zone. To this end, we develop a grey-box thermal model that captures the hydraulic interactions among radiators and the effects of radiator valves, circulation pumps, and heat sources. In a real building, we show that accounting for hydraulic interactions reduces the root mean square error (RMSE) between the measured and modeled zone temperatures by approximately 11% compared with a model that neglects these interactions. Additionally, we integrate the developed model into a model predictive control (MPC) framework for dynamic hydraulic balancing that jointly optimizes valve openings and the supply temperature to maintain thermal comfort in each zone while reducing energy consumption. Through both real-world experiments and numerical case studies, we demonstrate that, compared with existing MPC formulations that neglect hydraulic interactions or do not control radiator valves, the proposed MPC reduces comfort-range violations by at least 27% while requiring a similar or even lower cumulative supply temperature.

0.40

One Agent per Zone: Decentralised Active Inference under Partial Observability for Multi-Zone HVAC Control on Edge Hardware

cs.MA cs.AI ·2026-10-14 ·Panagiotis Kasnesis, Lazaros Toumanidis, Christos Chatzigeorgiou, Amalia Contiero Syropoulou, Miguel De Prado
published similarity 0.57
Abstract · 9 pages, 3 figures, accepted in European Conference on EDGE AI Technologies and Applications, EEAI 2026, Malta

Multi-zone HVAC control is a shared-resource problem: zones on a floor share one fan and cooling coil, so each zone's demand affects its neighbours and the building's peak power. One controller per zone scales well and isolates faults, but each controller then observes only its own zone, not the shared air loop. In this work, we present a decentralised controller that assigns each zone an independent active-inference agent, which plans by minimising expected free energy and learns its zone dynamics online. The agents exchange no messages, so none depends on peers or a coordinator; each accounts for the unobserved coupling through a latent disturbance and a congestion signal derived from the metered power of the other floors. Fifteen agents are evaluated in EnergyPlus on a Sinergym office building against three rule-based controllers and three MADDPG fleets, one given the same floor meters. On five noisy weather years unseen during training, the fleet attains the lowest mean building peak (88.3 kW, 3 to 17 % below the baselines) and staggers the floor peaks better than any baseline, with a coincidence factor (building peak over the sum of the floor peaks) of 0.929 versus 0.936 to 0.994. Compared with a reactive rule at similar comfort (0.912 versus 0.916), it lowers the sum of monthly peaks, on which demand charges are billed, by 33 kW (4 %) in every year, at the cost of about 10 % more energy. It costs 9% less per year than the proactive rule (at lower comfort) and 1% less than the MADDPG fleet given the same floor meters, in every test year. The whole fleet runs on a single low-cost Raspberry Pi 5, closing the observation-to-action loop over MQTT in 442 ms at p95, far below the 15-minute control step.

0.32

Online Optimization for Controlling HVAC Systems

eess.SY math.OC ·2026-11-05 ·Tong Wu, Dominik Baumann, Angela Fontan, Nicola Bastianello
similarity 0.57
Abstract

Heating, ventilation, and air-conditioning (HVAC) systems account for a significant portion of buildings' energy consumption, motivating the design of energy- and cost-efficient control strategies. However, conventional strategies employ simple, reactive control, without incorporating a model. Therefore, in this paper we adopt an economic model predictive control framework and focus on designing online algorithms to solve the control input design problems with a limited computational budget. In particular, we propose two tailored online algorithms based on projected gradient descent, with a custom projection routine, and the projected primal-dual method. We discuss the pros and cons of both algorithm designs, focusing in particular on computational efficiency. We further compare them through numerical experiments simulating the control of an HVAC system over the course of a day. The results show that computationally efficient online solvers for HVAC systems control are indeed possible. Moreover, the performance closely matches that of a baseline algorithm with unlimited computational budget, in terms of reference temperature tracking and comfort temperature range enforcement.

0.30