CS Paper Radar

Sensitivity Hot Spot Penalization: A Robust Topology Optimization Framework against First-Order Worst-Case Perturbations

Junpeng Wang, Niels Aage, Ole Sigmund

cs.CE ·submitted 2026-08-31 09:29 UTC · v1

Abstract

Deterministic topology optimization can efficiently generate high-performance structural designs, but it does not explicitly control localized fragility induced by manufacturing variations and geometric uncertainties. Such fragility often appears as stress concentrations or hinge-like deformation mechanisms. Conventional robust topology optimization can suppress these features, but typically requires multiple design realizations and substantially increased computational cost. Recent work by Sigmund et al. (2026) introduced sensitivity hot spot penalization (SHoSP), which augments the nominal objective by a smooth maximum of its sensitivities and suppresses localized fragile features at low additional cost while promoting more even stress distributions. This paper establishes a general connection between SHoSP and a first-order worst-case robust approximation under a material-mass perturbation budget using a Taylor expansion and H{"o}lder's duality. The original penalty weight is identified as a dimensionless norm-bounded perturbation budget relative to the area (2D) or volume (3D) of the design domain. This interpretation explains the suppression of sensitivity hot spots, hinge localization, and stress concentrations by limiting the maximum first-order degradation under budgeted perturbations. It is investigated for compliance minimization and compliant mechanism design. Robustness is assessed using a relaxed worst-case density perturbation and by comparing deterministic and SHoSP designs under equivalent perturbation budgets. Stress-related effects observed on structured meshes are cross-validated by stress-oriented topology optimization and body-fitted finite element analyses. Extensions to porous infill optimization, multiple load cases, and large-scale 3D examples further demonstrate the applicability and superior scalability of the SHoSP framework.

Closest papers

Nearest neighbours by meaning across the whole index.

An open source Python code for three-dimensional topology optimization in single precision on a consumer GPU

cs.CE cs.MS ·2026-11-09 ·Leonilson Toffoli Pedrini, Rodolfo G. M. Andrade, Rafael M. Ferro
code/data similarity 0.60
Abstract · 18 pages, 8 figures. Online Resource 1 is available as an ancillary file. Code and data: https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24050327. Submitted …

Three-dimensional topology optimization solves linear systems with millions of unknowns at every design iteration. Consumer graphics cards run far faster in single than in double precision, and open codes for them mostly address minimum compliance. This educational article presents TOF3D, an open source Python code for density-based topology optimization in single precision on one consumer GPU. It solves four classes of problems: stress constrained minimum compliance, robust minimum compliance against manufacturing errors, compliant mechanisms and bone-like porous infill. The stiffness operator is applied without assembly, and the conjugate gradient method is preconditioned by geometric multigrid. Rounding the element matrix to single precision gave rigid body motions a spurious energy and changed compliances by up to 5.4%. Forming the element products from differences of nodal displacements reduced this error to $1.3\times 10^{-5}$ at no cost in time. Adjoint sensitivities agreed with finite differences to within $1.7\times 10^{-6}$, and the solutions agreed with Ansys Mechanical APDL to within $4.1\times 10^{-10}$ with the same element. On an RTX 3060 with 12 GB, one design iteration of a cantilever took 0.46 s with 0.5 million elements and 15 s with 33.5 million. On the same card and problem, an open GPU code that applies its operator in double precision took 3.7 and 21 s with 0.5 and 4.2 million elements and ran out of memory on larger meshes. Eight cases fixed in a protocol before the runs took 9 to 35 minutes each with 4.2 to 5.2 million elements.

0.49

Multi-Material Topology Optimization for Targeted Structural Dynamic Vibration Attenuation

cs.CE ·2026-10-22 ·Bir Bahadur Chaudhary, Bidhan Pandey, Bin Ouyang, Shiguang Deng
similarity 0.58
Abstract

Resonance-induced excessive vibrations can degrade performance, reduce reliability, and shorten the service life of engineering structures. To reduce the risk of resonance, structural natural frequencies are generally engineered to be shifted away from excitation frequencies. To achieve these frequency shifts, topology optimization provides a systematic approach to tailor structural stiffness and mass as an effective inverse design approach. Multi-material topology optimization exploits the high-dimensional design space of spatially varying material constituents by simultaneously optimizing material selection and spatial distribution over the design domain, offering great flexibility in controlling natural frequencies. This study proposes a multi-material topology optimization that attenuates excessive structural dynamic vibrations in free-vibration scenarios via a novel multivariate weight-based interpolation method. Additionally, to address non-smoothness due to mode switching amid optimization, we employ a bound formulation with an auxiliary scalar design variable to replace the max-min eigenvalue objective with constraints on individual eigenvalues. Furthermore, we study and compare three optimization formulations for multi-material design to attenuate vibrations, including maximizing fundamental eigenfrequency, maximizing the gap between adjacent eigenfrequencies, and excluding frequencies from targeted frequency bands, which are smoothly approximated by a proposed rational polynomial formulation. Numerical examples are presented to demonstrate the effectiveness and applicability of our proposed method.

0.30

Robust topology optimization with non-Gaussian material fields using polygonal finite elements

cs.CE math.NAmath.OCstat.CO+1 ·2026-08-16 ·Nilton Cuellar, Anderson Pereira, Ivan F. M. Menezes, Americo Cunha
published similarity 0.57
Abstract

We present a computational framework for robust topology optimization that integrates polygonal finite-element discretizations, spatially correlated non-Gaussian material modeling, and non-intrusive polynomial-chaos surrogates. Spatial uncertainty in Young's modulus is represented as a homogeneous non-Gaussian random field obtained via a memoryless transformation of a truncated Karhunen-Loève expansion, ensuring physical admissibility through positivity of stiffness while preserving the prescribed autocovariance. Polygonal finite elements provide a stable discretization for density-based optimization on unstructured meshes and mitigate checkerboard artefacts and mesh bias, while the sparse polynomial-chaos expansion enables efficient estimation of low-order statistical moments required by the robust objective at a fraction of the cost of intrusive or Monte Carlo approaches. Numerical studies on a cantilever and a curved beam show that introducing non-Gaussian material variability leads to systematic load-path redistribution and a reallocation of 6-12% of the structural volume, together with a reduction in compliance scatter. The non-intrusive surrogate reproduces intrusive reference results within 3% using an order of magnitude fewer full finite-element analyses. These results demonstrate that the proposed framework offers a physically consistent and computationally efficient route to topology-optimized designs that remain reliable under realistic material uncertainty.

0.27

Topology optimization with buckling constraints: Adaptive eigenvalue aggregation and modality identification

cs.CE ·2026-09-17 ·Badvelu Pranay Prabha, Prabhat Kumar
similarity 0.57
Abstract · 33 pages

This paper presents novel approaches to tackle two key challenges in topology optimization problems with buckling constraints: determining how many eigenvalues to aggregate and identifying the eigenvalue modality at the optimal design. We demonstrate the mathematical inconsistencies that arise when choosing an arbitrary fixed number of eigenvalues for aggregation. Specifically, if the multiplicity of the critical eigenvalues is smaller than the chosen subset size, coalescence with higher-order eigenvalues can occur. Neglecting these during aggregation causes incorrect sensitivities, while simply increasing the preselected eigenvalue count unnecessarily raises computational costs. To resolve this issue, we propose an approach that dynamically determines the exact number of eigenvalues required at each optimization iteration. The proposed approach reduces computation time significantly while maintaining competitive performance relative to the conventional method across the numerical experiments presented. Additionally, accurately predicting modality at the optimal point is crucial for understanding the buckled mode shapes of optimized designs. A new optimization formulation is proposed using the difference between eigenvalues to capture the true eigenvalue modality. This formulation is first validated on a classical 1D clamped column, successfully predicting both the bimodal solution and the optimal eigenvectors. The approach demonstrates that the optimal solutions for the wall reinforcement and shear-loaded hinged plate problems for the given set of parameters are trimodal and tetramodal, respectively.

0.27

Robust Optimization of Spring Design under Variable Manufacturing Tolerances

cs.NE ·2026-10-03 ·Grzegorz Sroka, Slawomir T. Wierzchon
similarity 0.56
Abstract

A reliable assessment of an optimizer robustness requires tracking controlled changes in parameters to identify sources of algorithmic weakness. Such an approach was applied to the problem of designing tension/compression springs with three continuous variables describing the spring geometry. Three additional independent binary parameters reflect material variability, manufacturing-related geometric deviations, and an additional safety margin. Without expanding the decision space, these parameters can be combined in eight ways to generate variants that allow for direct comparison. In this study we distinguish between robustness effects and the dimension of the problem, which allows tracking changes in feasibility while keeping the nominal mass objective constant. Seven optimization methods and eight hybridized their variants are used for the analysis. The hybridization mechanism applies the operator selected by the prediction procedure presented in Section 3. All methods are evaluated under the same experimental conditions. Each method is run thirty times for each variant, with a maximum of 30000 function evaluations permitted per run. The final quality assessment takes into account the geometry of the feasibility region, search trajectories, performance variations across landscapes and the computational cost of fixed objectives. Together, these factors allow us to determine the quality of the solution, reproducibility, feasibility control, and the effectiveness of optimization. An interesting observation was that hybridization can mitigate cost or feasibility losses associated with a specific configuration. While it compensates for a specific weakness in the underlying mechanism, it does not provide universal resilience.

0.45

Elastoplastic inherent strain-based topology optimization for residual stress reduction in metal additive manufacturing

cs.CE ·2026-09-07 ·Takao Miki, Jike Han, Kazuhiro Izui, Shinji Nishiwaki
similarity 0.56
Abstract · 34 pages, 17 figures, 6 tables. v2: Figures 15-17 (three-dimensional results), which were missing in v1, are now included. No other changes

This paper proposes a topology optimization method for reducing the residual stress arising in the building process of metal additive manufacturing. First, a layer-by-layer process analysis model based on an elastoplastic inherent strain method is introduced. In this model, the incremental displacement is solved anew at each layer step, and the stress history is explicitly incorporated into the constitutive equation as the stress accumulated up to the previous step, which guarantees the stress continuity across layer interfaces without introducing activation strains. Next, the design sensitivity of this analysis model is derived based on the adjoint method. Taking the pair of the stress and the equivalent plastic strain as the state variables reduces the dependency between layer steps to a one-step recurrence, and the adjoint fields are constructed as a layer-by-layer reverse sweep that reuses the coefficient tensors obtained in the forward analysis. Consequently, the cost of the sensitivity analysis scales linearly with the number of layers and remains of the same order as that of the forward analysis. An optimization problem is then formulated based on the density method to minimize the P-norm of the residual stress at the completion of the building process under the volume and final-use compliance constraints, and the derived sensitivities are verified by comparison with central finite differences. Finally, the proposed method is demonstrated through two- and three-dimensional examples of residual stress minimization under a compliance constraint. The results clarify that, under the elastoplastic analysis, the maximum residual stress is bounded by the yield surface, and the optimization therefore reduces the extent of the yielded and plastic strain accumulating regions rather than the peak stress value.

0.29

HGTO: A Unified Graph-Based Physics-Informed Formulation for Structural Topology Optimization

cs.LG ·2026-09-14 ·Kangzheng Liu, Uday Kumar Punna, Leixin Ma
similarity 0.55
Abstract

Density-based topology optimization is typically structured as a nested sequence of material updates, structural analyses, and sensitivity assessments. While neural density parameterization and dual-field physics-informed approaches provide data-free alternatives, most existing methods represent density and displacement as coordinate fields and make limited use of the discrete relationships inherent in the finite element mesh. The present study introduces HGTO, a unified graph-based formulation that extends complete neural topology optimization from coordinate space to finite-element graph space. Element densities are parameterized on the element graph derived from the mesh, and the structural state is determined on the corresponding node--element hypergraph. Finite element kinematics, numerical quadrature, constitutive response, and force assembly remain explicitly defined operations within the differentiable computation. The material field and equilibrium state are therefore coupled through a common finite-element incidence structure. Numerical studies show compliance comparable to conventional density-based optimization at substantially lower computational cost than a representative coordinate-based dual-field neural method. The same coupled formulation accommodates high-resolution and irregular meshes, three-dimensional structures, finite deformation, and elastoplastic response.

0.47

Topology optimization of shipboard components for Navy shock certification via the Dynamic Design Analysis Method

cs.CE ·2026-10-19 ·Miguel A. Aguilo
theory similarity 0.53
Abstract · 32 pages, 17 figures, 12 tables

Shipboard equipment must survive the transient loads of underwater explosions. The U.S. Navy certifies such equipment with the Dynamic Design Analysis Method (DDAM), a modal response analysis driven by Navy shock design spectra. DDAM is well established as a verification tool, yet it is rarely used as a design driver in topology optimization. The design spectrum depends on the modal mass, a non-smooth coupling that classical sensitivity formulations do not address. This paper presents a complete differentiable formulation of the DDAM criterion for gradient-based topology optimization. Eigenvalue sensitivities follow the Fox-Kapoor method, and eigenvector sensitivities follow Nelson's method. The chain rule covers a spectral displacement that depends on both the natural frequency and the modal participation factor. Automatic differentiation assembles the sensitivity, and the engineer can certify components inside the optimization loop rather than after design. Three certification problems on a representative shipboard equipment frame demonstrate the workflow. In each, the optimizer removes 43.2% to 46.1% of the design-domain material and holds the certifying NRL Sum within 0.41% of the Navy allowable. Two companion studies follow. A compliance-optimized frame of nearly the same mass has a 5.2 Hz fundamental, outside the range the certification can qualify. Its nominal response also exceeds the allowable by a factor of 2.75. A lower bound on the mean of the two lowest eigenvalues separates the repeated pair that the demonstrations drive onto the frequency floor. The response then stops oscillating across the acceptance boundary. It ends at most 0.5% above the allowable, at a cost of under two percentage points of volume fraction.

0.32